Family law reforms: consultation analysis

Analysis of responses to the public consultation on potential family law reforms in Scotland.


5. Extending simplified divorce and dissolution

This part of the consultation is about potential changes to court procedures for divorce and dissolution of a civil partnership. The Scottish Government sought stakeholder views on whether to extend simplified court procedures for obtaining a divorce or dissolution and related matters. The proposal is for simplified court procedures to be extended to cases where there are children in the family under 16, and the spouses or civil partners have agreed on the arrangements for the upbringing of each child.

Readers are advised to refer to the consultation document for further information on arrangements for simplified divorce and dissolution procedures and potential changes. The document also sets out the necessary legislative changes should the proposals be adopted.

Q17. The Scottish Government is considering making simplified divorce and dissolution procedures available in cases where:

  • there are children (one or more of the family under 16), and
  • the spouses or civil partners have agreed about the upbringing of the children and so neither applies for an order under section 11 of the 1995 Act in relation to the children.

Do you agree or disagree with making the simplified procedures available in these cases?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Agree % Disagree % Don’t know % No answer
All respondents 124 32 10 5 53
All answering 58 69 21 10 -

Of those answering Q17, 69% agreed with making the simplified procedures available in the specified cases, 21% disagreed, and 10% were unsure. Among individuals who answered, 71% agreed, 23% disagreed, and 6% were unsure.

Overall, two thirds (65%) of organisations that answered agreed, while 17% disagreed and

17% were unsure. However, opinions varied considerably by type of organisation, from all (100%) of legal/judicial bodies that answered in agreement, compared to 38% of religion or belief-based organisations, while one children’s rights/protection organisation answered in disagreement.

A quarter of all respondents left an open comment at Q17. Comments did not necessarily align with the answers given to the closed question. For instance, comments were often left by those who did not answer the closed question, and concerns were sometimes raised by those who answered, ‘don’t know’. The most prevalent themes were that this approach could benefit applicants, that safeguards were needed, and that it could reduce court involvement.

Benefits for applicants

Several respondents, two thirds of whom were organisations, felt that making the simplified procedure available in the suggested circumstances would benefit applicants. Most commonly, it was felt that it could save time, including reducing delays and costs for applicants. As noted in the quote below, this could therefore benefit those with less access to resources. Additionally, it was felt that it could reduce stress and strain on applicants due to being simpler and quicker.

“It takes up a lot of time and resources to divorce through non-simplified procedures, possibly limiting access to those with more money and resources.” - University of Glasgow Class Adult Relationships & Law 2026

A few other respondents felt a simplified procedure could reduce conflict among applicants, for instance, as it prevents children from witnessing adversarial processes operating between parents and avoids an acrimonious procedure.

Safeguards would be needed

The need for adequate safeguards was raised by several respondents. These were felt to be necessary to protect children and vulnerable adults or to ensure coercion is not being applied to one of the parties. It was felt important to recognise that decision-making within relationships is not always equal due to power imbalances. While the nature of such safeguards was rarely specified by these respondents, suggested actions included:

  • Ensuring the new procedure did not lower the evidential bar regarding child welfare.
  • Providing guidance relating to changes to the rules of court or a national Practice Note issued by the Sheriffs Principal as to the information that must be provided to enable the court to decide whether the arrangements are satisfactory, such that a decree of divorce may be granted.
  • Considering what enforcement action could be taken if arrangements fail.

Could reduce court involvement

Another benefit identified by some respondents was that simplified procedures for these cases could reduce bureaucracy or complexity, such as reducing the courts’ workload and streamlining processes. For instance, it was highlighted that this approach could reduce the need for affidavits and undefended ordinary family actions in sheriff courts or allow court time to be used for situations in which parties are unable to reach an agreement.

“This respects autonomy, reduces conflict, and avoids unnecessary court involvement.” - The Humanist Society Scotland

Concerns about child welfare

Some respondents raised concerns regarding child welfare. These included the need to properly consider the welfare of any children involved when a marriage or civil partnership ends. For instance, it was felt that ‘quick’ divorce risks rushed decisions, that coercion could occur when agreements are being made, or that, should agreed arrangements break down, children should receive ‘all relevant statutory support and care to protect their needs and interests’. SKO Family Law Specialists Ltd expressed the view that they were ‘not aware that section 12 operates to flush out child welfare issues’. They highlighted that across the combined time in practice of the solicitors in the firm, they had never had a situation where a child welfare issue required the intervention of the court as a result of section 12, suggesting section 12 is not considered effective in addressing child welfare concerns.

Two respondents noted that there is already a two-fold safety net in place, comprising the option for an interested party who is concerned about the child’s welfare to take the matter to a court, and the child protection system. Shared Parenting Scotland noted that other countries require parents to undertake a parenting course after separation before it is signed off in court. The option for a parent to seek a section 11 order if there was any dispute or disagreement was noted by one legal/judicial body.

The extent of judicial oversight into the care of children was questioned by a few respondents and was considered challenging, with concerns raised about invasion of privacy, either family privacy or the privacy of children. For instance, one legal/judicial body felt that the level of detail to be provided to the court posed a risk to the privacy of children. In addition, they were unclear whether disclosure complies with data protection legislation, particularly whether the requirement would meet the first three principles of lawful data processing. This organisation suggested an alternative approach:

“Under a modified version of the proposed simplified procedure, the parties could be required to confirm to the court (in a form to be sworn on oath): whether there are appropriate arrangements in place for the children; whether either party seeks a s11 order; and whether there are any s67 grounds for referral. This would be in keeping with the current simplified procedure, which accepts the responses of parties in a form sworn on oath as evidence sufficient to satisfy the court on other legal tests, including jurisdiction and the irretrievable breakdown of the marriage.” - SKO Family Law Specialists Ltd

Childcare arrangements

Some respondents discussed the process for determining that an agreed arrangement is in place for childcare. Concerns were raised over what would happen should the agreement break down, with two respondents noting that this was likely. Views were also noted that this was not equivalent to other similar situations, for instance, separating cohabiting couples. Other issues included:

  • That the lack of a formal agreement would disproportionately impact women more than men due to their likelihood of remaining the primary caregiver for children.
  • The importance of ensuring that raising an action by ordinary procedure remains an easily accessible option in appropriate cases.
  • That parents may be living separately already, and what they have determined as a workable arrangement may be all that is on offer.
  • That both parents should be entitled to seek and receive advice on the importance of a range of parenting issues before signing.

Views of the child

The need to consider the views of the child was raised by some respondents. A few noted requirements of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995, that children should be given an opportunity to express their views, and to have those views taken into account for major decisions that impact them. One respondent thought it seemed anomalous that the views of children were not central to the simple procedure, given the increasing role given to this in contested cases.

However, Brodies LLP suggested children’s views need not be obtained as this is not required in ordinary divorce applications (see quote below). They suggested that if children’s views were to be considered in a new simplified divorce procedure, it would also be necessary to introduce this as a requirement for undefended ordinary divorce actions.

“Given that children in family law proceedings do not have automatic legal standing in proceedings concerning their family relationships, residence and contact, we are concerned that they are not afforded the right to meaningfully participate in proceedings, or to challenge decisions made (by contrast, children in the Children’s Hearings System have legal standing and rights to participate, have advocacy support, challenge and appeal decisions, and seek reviews.). Any changes to the rights of adults in dissolution and divorce should also consider whether improvements could be made in the rights of children affected.” - Law Society of Scotland

“We appreciate the impact of the United Nation Convention on the Rights of the Child and the terms of the Children (Scotland) Act 2020 (albeit not yet in force), however we do not consider that it is necessary or desirable for children's views to be canvassed in the course of a simplified application, nor in an ordinary action which is undefended and no s11 orders are sought. We also expressed concern in the SCJC consultation about the suggestion that the parties to a simplified divorce application would be responsible for obtaining and reporting (via the amended simplified divorce form) the views of the child/children in connection with their care arrangements. Again, we anticipate that this may have been included in an attempt to align with the provision of the UNCRC and the 2020 Act, however this is not a requirement of the ordinary procedure and indeed the taking of children’s views is usually done by a third party (child welfare reporter, psychologist, etc) as appropriate and not by the parents directly.” - Brodies LLP

General positive or negative views

Some respondents left positive views of the proposal to extend the simplified procedure in these cases, while a few left general negative views. Positive views included agreement in principle that a case could be made for this approach and general supportive comments. University of Glasgow Class Adult Relationships & Law 2026 felt the approach could encourage people to marry if they know that, in the case of potential divorce, the proceedings would not be difficult and adversarial.

One religion/belief-based organisation felt more support and resources should be given to couples for mediation rather than focusing on simplifying divorce and dissolution, whilst Burness Paull LLP felt it should be a matter for parents to decide whether orders are necessary or not, and that the present ordinary procedure was easy to navigate. Two legal/judicial bodies felt the simplified procedure would still require legal fees, with one noting expense may not be reduced by much if there are more forms to complete.

Shared Parenting Scotland felt the consultation document had been overly optimistic about the delivery of advice and assistance through the Scottish Legal Aid Board, with access limitations caused by a lack of availability or eligibility being underestimated. They also stressed the need to address inequity caused by one parent receiving advice and the other not, potentially by broadening out sources of information and support to help formulate a sustainable parenting plan.

Other views

Brodies LLP noted they had previously responded to the Scottish Civil Justice Council’s consultation setting out their concerns about the proposed changes to the court rules and forms should the simplified procedures be extended. The Church of Scotland called for greater involvement with expert groups before introducing legislation. The Faculty of Advocates felt Section 12 of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 may need reviewed. That section provides that when dealing with divorce and dissolution cases the court has to consider whether to make orders under s11 of the 1995 Act or under s62 of the Children’s Hearing (Scotland) Act 2011.

Q18. Should Ministers amend the Orders which helped establish the simplified divorce and dissolution procedures to remove the references to “mental disorder” and instead exclude only cases where one of the parties actually “lacks capacity”?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes [the Orders should be amended] % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 28 7 9 56
All answering 55 64 16 20 -

Almost two thirds (64%) of those answering Q18 felt that Ministers should amend the

Orders which helped establish the simplified divorce and dissolution procedures, while 16% disagreed and 20% were unsure. Views were more polarised among the individuals who answered, with 68% in favour, 21% opposed and 12% unsure.

Among organisations that answered, there was slightly less support (57%), but also less opposition (10%) and greater uncertainty (33%). A similar pattern was evident among most types of organisation, though only legal/judicial bodies recorded opposition (20%).

Almost one in five of all respondents left an open comment to explain their answer at Q18. The main theme was the reasons for supporting the amendment of Orders. Although not directly answering the question, comments on determining capacity were also an identified theme.

Reasons for agreement

Several respondents provided comments explaining why they support amending the Orders to remove references to ‘mental disorder’ and instead exclude only cases where one of the parties actually ‘lacks capacity’. Reasons for support included that it aligned with other legislation such as the Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Act 2000, and that it was more modern, principled and appropriate to focus on ‘capacity’ rather than ‘mental disorder’. Amending the Orders was felt by these respondents to reduce the use of stigmatising language and enable a more respectful approach. It was also seen as a way to ensure that those who have a mental disorder, but who retain legal capacity, are still able to access simplified divorce and dissolution procedures.

“As the consultation notes, replacing the current reference to “mental disorder” with an approach based on capacity aligns with the terminology used in the Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Act 2000. Replacing the current wording would widen access to the simplified divorce procedure for parties who may meet the wide Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003 definition of “mental disorder” but do not meet the 2000 Act definition of incapacity. We consider this appropriate. A capacious person should not be discriminated against or preclude from consenting to or engaging in simplified proceedings simply because they have a mental disorder.” - Law Society of Scotland

Reasons for disagreement

Two respondents left comments explaining why they did not support amending the orders. Morton Fraser MacRoberts did not answer the closed question but disagreed in their open comment, with their rationale being that it was not straightforward to determine capacity and often had to be done by a medical professional, which would still mean the application would need to determine whether the respondent had capacity or not. An individual felt that the current wording already provides protection and changing it would risk weakening safeguards for vulnerable adults in divorce proceedings.

Other views, comments on determining capacity

Views on how capacity is determined were given by some respondents. These respondents varied in their opinion of whether the Orders should be amended or not. While it was acknowledged that it should not be assumed that having a ‘mental disorder’ meant capacity to make decisions was necessarily lacking, it was also highlighted that challenges around assessing capacity (such as noted by Morton Fraser MacRoberts in the theme above) could impact the efficacy of simplified divorce and dissolution procedures. These respondents were likely to take a cautious approach, such as emphasising the need for nuance or expressing uncertainty about whether to amend the Orders.

“While the current requirement in the rules of court is that neither party to the marriage suffered from a mental disorder, the relevant form asks only whether the other spouse has such a disorder. No guidance is provided. In practice, the courts have taken a robust approach to the capacity of parties to divorce, holding that mental disorder short of insanity should not disqualify a person from raising an action of divorce. If simplified procedure were unavailable because of mental disorder despite grounds for divorce being clear, then an applicant would be required to bring an ordinary action to which there would be no defence. The court would then take no interest in whether the pursuer had a mental disorder, if there was nothing to suggest that they lacked the capacity to seek divorce.

Reference is made to JM v RM [2025] SC HAM 30, Sheriff Mungo Bovey KC.” – The Faculty of Advocates

“In particular, we would emphasise that the term “mental disorder” encompasses a wide range of conditions, many of which do not affect an individual’s capacity to understand and consent to marriage or divorce. It is therefore important that any legal provisions in this area are carefully framed so as not to assume incapacity solely on the basis of a diagnosis. The key issue should be whether an individual has the capacity to understand the nature of marriage / divorce and to give free and informed consent. Any approach which does not sufficiently distinguish between different conditions or levels of capacity risks being overly broad and may have unintended consequences. We would therefore encourage a nuanced approach which focuses on capacity in practice, rather than relying on general categories.” - The Free Church of Scotland

Q19. Considering these points, do consultees think any changes are required to the procedures for withholding addresses in simplified divorce and dissolution cases?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 21 12 15 52
All answering 60 43 25 32 -

Mixed views were recorded by those answering Q19. Over two fifths (43%) felt that changes are required to the procedures for withholding addresses in simplified divorce and dissolution cases, while 25% felt they are not, and 32% were unsure. Among individuals, 36% were in favour, 22% against and 42% unsure.

While just over half (54%) of all organisations that answered supported changes, views varied by type of organisation. All (100%) women’s rights/protection organisations that answered were in favour, while the one children’s rights/protection body that answered was opposed. Religion or belief-based organisations were more likely to be in favour (50%) than opposed (17%), whereas views were evenly split among legal/judicial bodies, with 45% in favour and 45% opposed.

One in three of all respondents left an open comment to explain their answer at Q19. The most prevalent theme was suggested approaches that could operate, that protection or safeguarding should be priorities within procedures, and agreement that procedures should allow for withholding addresses in simplified divorce and dissolution cases.

Suggested approaches

Several respondents made comments regarding changes to procedures for withholding addresses in simplified divorce and dissolution cases. It was generally recognised by these respondents that courts would need to know the applicant's address while withholding addresses more widely. Suggested ways to withhold addresses included, in order of prevalence:

  • Using solicitors’ addresses as a correspondence address, though one respondent noted this could disadvantage those acting without a solicitor.
  • Being able to use a correspondence address that does not have to be where the applicant resides.
  • Systems where applicants opt in, or opt out, of address disclosure. For instance, one respondent suggested a system like that operating within the electoral roll, where it is possible to opt out of the open register.
  • Not changing the Ordinary Cause Rules, but rather governing arrangements through a national Practice Note, setting out circumstances and processes by which non-disclosure will be acceptable.

Other implementation considerations included ensuring adherence to privacy laws and consistency between ordinary and simplified procedures.

Views varied on whether the non-disclosure of the address should be available in all cases or not. Suggestions on this included:

  • Allowing address withholding by default in sensitive cases or where there is a valid justification for not doing so.
  • Parties should disclose their address, but a clearer and more consistent system for a party seeking to withhold an address should be put in place.
  • Parties being able to withhold their address without the need for further explanation.

“We support that as long as a correspondence address is provided, then it should not be necessary for either partner to disclose their current address. We would further add that where this is the case, there should be a responsibility on the Court to recognise that this is likely due to concerns around abuse within the relationship, concerns about the safety of the partner who has opted not to disclose their address, or concern about any child(ren) in the relationship.” - Equally Safe Edinburgh Committee and the Edinburgh Child Protection Committee

Prioritise protection and safeguarding

The need to protect people by withholding their addresses as part of the simplified proceedings was raised by several respondents, over two thirds of whom were women’s rights and protection organisations.

It was noted that the current situation, where addresses must be shared between parties, increased risk to safety and wellbeing, and could cause anxiety, fear, distress and trauma. Scottish Women's Aid also felt the problem was a recurring, wider issue in relation to actions for contact and residence where domestic abuse is an issue and a particular safety issue where someone is residing with her children in a refuge, which is intended to be a safe, secure place of accommodation.

Risks identified by these respondents included harassment, stalking, breaking and entering, honour-based pressure and abuse. One individual also highlighted that in cases where there is adultery, forcing disclosure of an address can escalate issues. This respondent had responded to the consultation specifically to comment on this question and felt that if a person did not wish the other party to know her/his whereabouts, there would always be a reason for this, which should be respected by the law.

Ensuring alignment with trauma-informed practice was recommended, with one respondent noting provisions of the trauma-based practice principles in sections 26 and 28, related to civil proceedings, in the Victims, Witnesses and Justice Reform (Scotland)

Act 2025 and the obligation that will be placed on civil courts, once commenced. Scottish Women's Convention noted their reports consistently stress the importance of safety, confidentiality and trauma-informed approaches within legal processes and felt individuals may be deterred from engaging with the system without these.

“Withholding addresses is essential in protecting victims of domestic abuse from ongoing abuse from perpetrators. [This is] particularly [relevant] when women are residing in refuges for the safety of themselves and their children, not to mention other residents and staff of the refuge.” – Individual

Agreement that procedures should be changed

Support or agreement was given by several respondents for changing procedures to make it easier to withhold addresses. Comments included that this seemed reasonable, that arrangements should be simplified, that strengthened protections were needed and that it was common sense. It was felt that simplifying arrangements could reduce costs involved, as an ordinary action would not need to be raised, or that it could mean a solicitor would not need to be involved.

“We believe procedures in this area should be reformed where necessary to ensure that individuals are adequately protected, particularly in cases involving abuse.” - The Free Church of Scotland

Current arrangement is sufficient

Some respondents, mostly legal or judicial organisations, felt the current arrangement was sufficient. Reasons for retaining the current arrangements included:

  • It was consistent with other civil court actions.
  • That current arrangements worked satisfactorily.
  • It may be necessary to establish why the court has jurisdiction to deal with the application at all.
  • That address disclosure was necessary to inform both parties that the divorce is granted and to receive the extract decree.
  • That changes could undermine the principle of parties being properly designed in court documents.
  • That a reason for withholding addresses could be to cut the other parent out of their child’s life.

“We consider that if a person wishes to withhold their address from the respondent in simplified divorce and dissolution cases then they should be required to apply to the court for permission and to set out to the court their reasons for doing so. It is then for the court to determine whether or not the address should continue to be withheld. That is consistent with other civil court actions. Divorce changes an individual’s status, and we consider it is only in certain circumstances that remedies should be granted by the court without full identification of the applicant.” - The Faculty of Advocates

Should not have to give detailed reasons

Some respondents highlighted that parties should not have to justify why they want to withhold their address. Reasons given for this were that it could risk re-traumatising that party, that it was an ‘archaic law’ or that it was unacceptable.

“As paragraph 4.56 of the consultation document acknowledges, requiring a party to explain in detail the reasons why they wish to withhold their address risks, inter alia, retraumatising that party.” - Centre for Scots Law, School of Law, University of Aberdeen

Q20. Do you have any comments on our draft impact assessments about extending the simplified divorce and dissolution procedures?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % No Answer
All respondents 124 9 31 60
All answering 49 22 78 -

Among all respondents, 9% indicated that they had comments on the draft impact assessments about extending the simplified divorce and dissolution procedures.

One in ten respondents left an open comment at Q20. The most prevalent themes were that the draft impact assessments should better reflect risks to women and children, and comments on financial impacts.

Better reflect risks to women and children

Some respondents raised concerns about ensuring the draft impact assessments adequately reflect the risks to children and vulnerable women. Two individuals expressed the view that it was important for children to be protected and their welfare prioritised, with one of these noting care was needed to ensure extending the simplified divorce and dissolution procedures did not disproportionately adversely affect women and children.

Scottish Women's Convention and Scottish Women’s Aid felt the impact assessments should better reflect risks for women. For instance, it was noted that the draft CRWIA did not reference domestic abuse or violence against women. The Centre for Scots Law, School of Law, University of Aberdeen felt the draft CRWIA could be more thorough.

Shared Parenting Scotland stated that children’s rights are individual and should not be subsumed within groups. Scottish Women’s Aid noted that while reference was made to UNCRC Article 19 (Protection from violence, abuse and neglect) this was simply to say that the potential extension of the simplified procedure does not affect the requirements on a court dealing with a divorce or dissolution to consider an order under s11 of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 on parental responsibilities and rights and that: “The revised process would allow an abusive applicant to use the process to mask any domestic abuse and prevent the court both considering the need for a section 11 order and seeking further evidence on the application”. They also observed there was no reported engagement with children and young people in the draft impact assessments, particularly those experiencing domestic abuse.

Comments on financial impacts

A few respondents raised a range of views on the need for a greater focus in the draft impact assessments on the financial impacts for parties involved. This included noting that divorce or dissolution could be expensive, that barriers to legal aid should be addressed, that the impact on child maintenance provisions was not mentioned and that there should be clearer consideration of how access to mechanisms such as LSPOs might mitigate short-term affordability barriers in these cases, especially for those not eligible for legal aid.

“While the draft impact assessments anticipate that extending simplified divorce and dissolution procedures will deliver cost savings for couples and the public purse, there is limited consideration of circumstances in which those savings may not be fully realised in practice. In particular, where applications involve children under 16, there is a risk that unanticipated hearings or transfer to ordinary procedure may generate additional legal costs for parties.” – Individual

Other views

Shared Parenting Scotland felt insufficient attention was paid to ensure the full involvement of both parents and their wider families after divorce or separation, noting that parents most adversely affected when post separation conflict occurs are fathers, with the term ‘non-resident parent’ carrying negative connotations and can be an active barrier embedded in policies and practices among agencies.

The Humanist Society Scotland encouraged the Scottish Government to assess the impact on low-income families, who may rely on simplified procedures, and to ensure that digital processes are accessible and do not exclude those without digital literacy or private internet access.

One individual felt the draft impact assessments should be based on more recent cases.

Q21. Do you have any comments on our draft impact assessments about extending the simplified divorce and dissolution procedures?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % No Answer
All respondents 124 11 31 57
All answering 53 26 74 -

Among all respondents, 11% indicated at the closed question that they had other comments on extending the simplified divorce and dissolution procedures.

One in ten of all respondents left an open comment at Q21. The most prevalent themes were suggested changes or general comments, calls to further update policy, and to prioritise marriage.

Suggested changes or general comments

A range of comments were left by some respondents, most notably around the need for access to appropriate information, such as:

  • For the parties involved, on legal advice, financial provision and child contact or residence.
  • The judiciary to have a clear understanding of the dynamics, tactics and impact of domestic abuse on women and children.
  • The civil courts being able to access information around criminal proceedings relating to domestic abuse.

Other views included that evidence-led approaches should prevail, such as evidence based assessment of welfare arrangements and financial fairness and ensuring access to justice. An individual felt it should be possible to submit documents electronically to avoid having to take time off work to physically hand them in.

“We encourage the Government to adopt a human rights-based, evidence-led, and inclusive approach throughout the reform process.” - The Humanist Society Scotland

Further update policy

A few respondents called for further policy changes. The Law Society of Scotland and an individual suggested further streamlining the process for divorce and dissolution, namely removing the need for judicial involvement for couples without children and no outstanding property disputes. Two individuals felt policy should be further modernised, such as aligning with reforms in England and Wales in the Divorce, Dissolution and Separation Act 2020, which introduced a ‘no fault’ divorce system. One of these individuals felt that detailed research into the operation of the Divorce (Scotland) Act 1976 was needed:

“Very little is known in Scotland about how divorce law works in practice and what impact it has on individuals and families. The high proportion of undefended and simplified divorce tends to suggest there are few problems, but occasional judgments indicate there may be underlying issues (e.g. Hafthorsdotir v Eyvindsson [2025] CSOH 6; Douglas v Douglas 2018 11 WLUK). Detailed research into the operation of the 1976 Act is long overdue, and wider review of divorce law should be considered, particularly in light of the significant change in divorce law in England & Wales.” - Individual

Prioritise marriage

A few respondents at Q21, and singular respondents at Q17 and Q20 incorporated here, raised the need to prioritise marriage. These views were raised by individuals and one religious or belief-based organisation. Comments included that marriage was a lifelong commitment and should attract stronger support, and that divorce should be not treated as ‘routine’ or made easier / quicker.

“In general, we would emphasise the importance of marriage as a lifelong commitment and would be concerned about any approach which may, even indirectly, contribute to divorce being seen as routine or easily entered into. Marriage breakdown has significant consequences for individuals, families, and particularly for children, and should not be encouraged.” - The Free Church of Scotland

Other views

Two respondents raised the need for safeguards, primarily to protect children involved, such as avoiding unnecessary expense and delay or to ensure parties are not being coerced.

One legal/judicial body felt that, overall, there would be savings for the public purse from making the suggested changes. However, Scottish Women’s Aid felt that cost savings appeared to be a driver for the reform and provided a detailed explanation as to why they did not support extending the simplified divorce and dissolution procedures. For instance, they identified multiple problems with requiring the applicant spouse / civil partner to complete a form giving certain information relating to a child. Readers are advised to refer to the full published response for further details regarding their opposition.

Contact

Email: family.law@gov.scot

Back to top