Family law reforms: consultation analysis

Analysis of responses to the public consultation on potential family law reforms in Scotland.


3. The minimum age of marriage and civil partnership

This part of the consultation sought stakeholder views on whether the Scottish

Government should bring forward legislation in the Scottish Parliament to raise the age at which a person becomes eligible to enter into a marriage or civil partnership to 18 from 16, and also on related matters. The consultation document also notes that in Scotland, while the age of majority is 18, children and young people can exercise some rights before then.

Forcing someone into a marriage or civil partnership is a criminal offence in Scotland under section 122(1) of the Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Act 2014. An offence occurs where a person uses violence, threats or other forms of coercion for the purpose of causing another person to enter into a marriage or civil partnership and believes, or ought reasonably to believe that the conduct may cause the other person to enter into the marriage without free and full consent.[4]

Q7. Should the Scottish Government legislate to raise the minimum age of marriage and civil partnership to 18?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes
% No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 57 19 7 16
All answering 104 68 23 9 -

Two thirds (68%) of those answering Q7 agreed that the Scottish Government should legislate to raise the minimum age of marriage and civil partnership to 18, while 23% disagreed, and 9% were unsure. Among individuals who answered, 71% agreed, and 27% disagreed.

Opinions varied considerably by organisation type. Overall, 62% of organisations that answered agreed, 15% disagreed, and 24% were unsure. High levels of support were recorded among children’s rights/protection organisations (100%), women’s rights and protection organisations (80%) and other organisations (100%). Just over half (54%) of religion or belief-based bodies were in favour, with 23% opposed and 23% unsure. However, among legal/judicial bodies that answered, 14% were in favour, 29% opposed, and over half (57%) were unsure.

At Q7a, respondents who wished to do so were presented with a list of potential reasons for and against raising the minimum age of marriage and civil partnership to 18 and asked to select any they felt aligned with their views. Among all consultation respondents, 85% selected at least one answer option or left an ‘other’ comment.

Q7a. If you wish, you can choose a reason (or reasons) for your answer from the list below and/or add your own reasons:

Reason % among all (n=124) % among all answering Q7a (n=105) % among those answering ‘yes’ at Q7 (n=69) % among those answering ‘no’ at Q7 (n=24)
Raising the minimum age would protect some children and young people from harm they would not otherwise suffer 48 58 88 0
Other measures can be taken to protect children from harmful conduct, without increasing the minimum age for marriage or civil partnership 5 6 4 13
In general, people aged 16 or 17 do not have the capacity to understand what it means to marry or enter a civil partnership 31 37 57 0
Raising the minimum age in Scotland would meet our international obligations 39 46 70 0
We should keep the minimum age at 16, as it’s consistent with some other rights that 16-year-olds can also exercise, like leaving home 15 18 1 75
There’s not enough evidence to justify reform 10 11 0 50
Selected ‘other’ or left a comment 55 65 49 92
Not answered 15 N/A N/A N/A

As might be expected, the reasons selected aligned with the responses given by respondents at Q7. Among those who answered ‘yes’ (i.e. in favour of raising the minimum age), respondents most commonly indicated this would protect some children and young people from harm (88%) and that it would help Scotland meet its international obligations (70%). A further 57% indicated they were in favour as they felt that, in general, people aged 16 or 17 do not have the capacity to understand what it means to marry or enter a civil partnership.

Conversely, among those opposed to raising the minimum age, the main reason was to keep it consistent with other rights that 16-year-olds can exercise (75%), as well as the view that there is not enough evidence to justify reform (50%).

Over half of all respondents left an open comment to explain their answers. The most prevalent views were agreement with raising the minimum age as it can avoid harmful practices, disagreement as it was felt alignment with other age-related rights is important, and agreement as the change aligns with human and children’s rights commitments.

To aid readability of this question, reasons for agreement are given first, as such comments were most prevalent, followed by reasons for disagreement.

Reasons for agreement

Can avoid harmful practices

Legislation to raise the minimum age of marriage and civil partnership to 18 was supported by several respondents as it was considered a way to reduce harms arising from early marriage or could improve protection for 16 and 17-year-olds, especially girls. Most of these respondents were from children’s or women’s rights and protection bodies.

Harms that respondents felt could be minimised or prevented included:

  • Coerced or forced marriages.
  • Exploitation or grooming.
  • Long-term disadvantage due to reduced educational opportunities or economic dependence.

Raising the minimum age of marriage and civil partnership was felt to align with relevant domestic and international policies and recommendations aimed at reducing harm, including Goal 5 of the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) to eliminate child, early and forced marriages; the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women safeguarding principles; the Equally Safe Strategy; and a primary prevention approach to violence against women and girls. In addition, it was viewed to clearly signal Scotland’s commitment to safeguarding and protecting children.

“Girls are disproportionately harmed by marriage before 18, both globally and in Scotland. Barnardo’s supports raising the minimum marriage age to 18, as this will help prevent coerced and forced marriage and align Scotland with wider child‑protection law. Evidence from UN bodies, child‑protection organisations and Scottish data consistently shows that early marriage harms children and that legislative reform is essential to ensuring equal protection across the UK. UNICEF identifies child marriage as a major driver of gender inequality, affecting girls six times more often than boys. – Barnardo’s

Aligns with human and children’s rights commitments

Several respondents supported this change as they felt raising the minimum age of marriage and civil partnership aligned with broader commitments to children’s or international human rights. As with the previous theme, the majority of these respondents were children’s or women’s rights and protection bodies. This theme also overlapped with ‘Yes, as under 18s are children’, discussed below.

Most of these respondents noted that raising the minimum age was consistent with obligations under the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC), now adopted in Scots law. For instance, it was noted that the UNCRC has repeatedly called for states to outlaw child marriage (defined as any marriage where at least one of the parties is under 18 years of age) and set a minimum age of marriage of 18 and has highlighted that disabled children are at increased risk of child marriage. Concerns raised by the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child in the 2023 Concluding Observations on the UK’s compliance with the UNCRC regarding marriage under 18 remaining permissible were also highlighted by the Children and Young People's Commissioner Scotland. Barnardo's mentioned that UNICEF classifies child marriage as a human rights violation.

“Raising the minimum age of marriage and civil partnership to 18 would ensure that

Scotland meets obligations set out by the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the

Child (UNCRC), expanded upon in General Comment No. 18 of the Committee on the

Rights of the Child (2019) on harmful practices, as well as being compliant with the United

Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (Incorporation) (Scotland) Act 2024.” – CELCIS

Aligns with other jurisdictions

A view that raising the minimum age of marriage and civil partnerships would bring Scotland in line with the rest of the UK or other countries was mentioned by several respondents. These respondents noted that Scotland was an outlier or out of step with other countries and not aligned with recommendations for UK states made by the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child (noted above).

“In most European countries, the minimum age for marriage and civil partnership is 18 years. While many nations allow exceptions at age 16 with parental or judicial consent, recent legislation - notably in England and Wales - has raised the age to 18 with no exceptions. Scotland needs to catch up with progress and do better to protect our children” - Individual

It is difficult to achieve informed consent

The minimum age of marriage and civil partnership should be raised due to people aged 16 or 17 not having sufficient maturity to make informed decisions about these, according to several respondents. These respondents felt that marriage or civil partnership is a potentially life-long commitment, and therefore requires maturity to make such a decision, and that self-knowledge is required. However, they noted that as 16 and 17-year-olds’ brains are still developing, and because emotional and psychological development is still underway, informed consent was unlikely.

These respondents also felt raising the age would minimise the potential for coercion, such as from parents, as people would be more able to exercise individual agency in deciding whether to marry once they are older. For example, one individual felt that marriage should remain a ‘mature, voluntary choice rooted in genuine commitment’ and that raising the age would send a clear message that Scots law prioritises individual consent and personal development over arrangements that can put young women in unstable or exploitative situations. Another individual cited their personal experience of being in an unhappy marriage at a young age and would have preferred if a ‘cooling off’ period of five months had been possible, to avoid the need for costly marriage and divorce.

“People under 18 are still developing emotionally and psychologically, and marriage or civil partnership is a significant legal and lifelong commitment that requires full maturity and the ability to give free and informed consent.” – Individual

Under-18s are children

Several respondents noted that childhood does not end until age 18, and therefore, raising the minimum age would eradicate child marriage. This was seen to align with rights-based definitions of childhood, as noted in the ‘Yes, it aligns with human and children’s rights commitments’ theme above, as well as being consistent with domestic policies. One individual queried why the term ‘young people’ was used in Scotland when the UNCRC Incorporation Scotland Act 2024 clearly states in Article 1 that everyone under the age of 18 is a child.

Reasons for disagreement

Should align with other age-related rights

The most prevalent theme among several respondents who left comments disagreeing with raising the age of marriage and civil partnership was that age should be similar to other rights of young people in Scotland. Other rights mentioned that are available from the age of 16 included:

  • Leaving education or being in employment and paying taxes.
  • Joining a trade union or the armed forces.
  • Voting in Scottish elections.
  • Sexual intercourse.
  • Instruct a solicitor.
  • Apply for a passport.
  • Determining one's own medical treatment.
  • Choose a place of residence or take up a tenancy agreement.

It was felt that if the above rights are available from age 16, then the option of marriage or civil partnership should also be available. Concerns were expressed that raising the minimum age could reduce the rights available to 16 and 17-year-olds or represent interference by the state. Views were expressed that more, rather than fewer, rights should be given to 16 and 17-year-olds. For example, one individual noted her parents had remained married despite her mother being 17 when they married and queried why this was considered wrong.

“A removal of the right to marry at 16 while they can do all these other things needs to be justified for reasons other than their inability to understand (because many 16- and 17 year-olds understand the concept of marriage just as much as a 22-year-old does).” – Individual

“We respectfully object to the proposal to increase the legal age of marriage from 16 to 18 on the grounds of consistency and fairness within Scots law. At 16, individuals in Scotland are already recognised as having the capacity to make significant life decisions: they may work full time, pay taxes, leave home, join the armed forces, and participate in democratic processes such as voting in Scottish Parliament and local government elections. To deny those same individuals the right to marry creates an inconsistency in how their autonomy and responsibility are recognised.” - Independent Humanist Ceremonies / Community / Charities (IHC)

Additionally, these respondents felt that those aged 16 or 17 did have sufficient maturity to decide whether to marry or enter into a civil partnership. Allowing people to exercise their rights was felt to aid maturity, and these respondents expressed the view that when people are treated responsibly, they behave more responsibly.

Not enough of a problem to justify change

Several respondents felt that there is not enough of a problem to justify legislative change to raise the age of marriage or civil partnerships. These respondents cited evidence from the consultation document that very few marriages took place annually involving a person under the age of 18, that protection to under-18s was available through other routes, or that a change in the law was not proportionate to the size of the issue. Views were also expressed that evidence for change was limited, that it was not justified, or that it restricted individual freedoms. One individual felt that the most relevant and recent research had found very mixed views on raising the age of marriage and that there was no strong evidence in support of doing so.

“The number of young people choosing to marry or enter into a civil partnership under 18 years is minimal... We have the Forced Marriage etc (Protection & Jurisdiction) (Sc) Act 2011, and forced marriage is a ground upon which a child can be referred to a children’s hearing. Therefore, protection is currently available, and this makes it less critical to review the age at which someone can marry outside a more comprehensive review of age and capacity in Scotland.” - Thorntons Law LLP

Scotland does not compare to other places

It was felt by some respondents, mostly individuals, that it is not possible to compare Scotland with other jurisdictions and that there was little research specific to the Scottish context. These respondents thought that just because the age of marriage or civil partnerships was 18 in other countries, this did not mean it should be raised in Scotland.

One individual noted that much of the available research was from jurisdictions in sub-Saharan Africa and the Indian sub-continent, where socio-economic conditions were very different from those in Scotland. This respondent highlighted a journal article that found that in Mexico, while raising the age of marriage had led to a reduction in child marriages, many young women instead had cohabited with their partners, had babies and abandoned formal education. Another individual noted that Scotland does not have a parental consent requirement for those under 18, like in England, and that the change in the law in England was no basis for automatic change in Scots law.

“The international evidence against early marriage is compelling. However, this applies to cultures and jurisdictions outwith Scotland. We do not know enough about early marriage and CP in Scotland to justify taking away an existing right. More importantly, we do not know enough about any potentially positive benefits of early marriage and CP in Scotland - the assumption is that effects will be negative, but this is unclear. It is at least possible that some YP estranged from their parents (e.g. LGBT+ YP) will benefit from marriage or CP and a new legal relationship with someone outside their family.” - Individual

Rights frameworks do not prescribe age

Aligned with the theme above, some respondents felt that there is no need to raise the minimum age of marriage and civil partnership, as this was not prescribed by rights frameworks. It was noted that recommendations by international rights bodies were not binding and that no treaty sets a minimum age for marriage. For instance, it was highlighted that Article 1 of the UNCRC specified that if a state’s laws conferred adulthood at an earlier age, then this would take precedence over a person being deemed a child until age 18. One individual also highlighted that the right to marry is enshrined in human rights law, notably Article 16 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

Other themes

Suggested actions

Ways for the Scottish Government to take forward this agenda were suggested by several respondents, whose support for raising the minimum age varied. These respondents mostly called for a comprehensive or holistic review, or wider discussion, of Scots law in relation to the age of capacity or rights and autonomy of 16 and 17-year-olds. Two respondents felt that such a review was overdue, with one noting the last general review of legal capacity was over 35 years ago. Respondents holding this view were likely to believe that the minimum age of marriage should not be raised without such a review occurring.

For instance, SKO Family Law Specialists Ltd felt such a review should take a consistent and coherent approach to age limits both for protection and for responsibilities across private (age of marriage) and public law domains (age children in care can leave care), and felt such a review should cover:

“Whether and how the forced marriage legislation needs reformed; How the age of marriage and the age of consent to sex interact: One significant concern with raising the age of marriage as a standalone reform is that the age of consent to sex remains at 16. Thus, children can become parents at 16, but boys would not get the benefit of the presumption of parenthood that comes with being married; The age for leaving care, and the extent to which the care system should continue to support young people after this age; The minimum age for military service; The minimum age for entering into a cohabiting relationship in terms of ss25-29 of the Family Law (Scotland) Act 2006.” - SKO Family Law Specialists Ltd

However, the Humanist Society Scotland, which strongly favoured increasing the minimum, suggested that additional research was needed to determine the extent of nonbinding child marriage in Scotland to inform a suite of non-legislative initiatives aimed at prevention and support for children at risk of forced or ceremonial marriage.

Other suggested actions by respondents included:

  • Increasing the voting age to be consistent with the age of marriage and civil partnership, should it be increased.
  • A need to distinguish conceptually between forced marriage and early marriage, with a focus placed on the lack of value accorded to women in patriarchal cultures.
  • Not allowing exemptions should the minimum age be increased.
  • Considering introducing a right for any person under age 18 at the time of their marriage or civil partnership to seek divorce or dissolution on that ground alone, without requiring any other ground and without cost. It should also account for cases where a spouse cannot apply freely due to coercion or control.
  • Strengthening safeguards against coercion and abuse within the existing framework, instead of raising the minimum age, e.g. celebrants could help assess whether there is any evidence of pressure, coercion or lack of consent prior to conducting a marriage or civil partnership.
  • Taking care when drafting legislation on the definition of ‘cohabitant’ to ensure protections under the 2006 Act for a cohabitant or former cohabitant aged 16 or 17, should the minimum age be increased.

Marriage should be encouraged or confers greater protection

Some respondents at Q7 felt that the minimum age of marriage or civil partnership should not be raised, as marriage should be encouraged, or felt that marriage and civil partnership conferred stronger protections. For instance, the Centre for Scots Law, School of Law, University of Aberdeen, which opted for ‘Other’ at Q7a, noted that marriage or civil partnership offered stronger protections than cohabitation, from financial provision on divorce to the existence of automatic occupancy rights during marriage. One individual felt the consultation document had placed less emphasis on protections marriage could provide, and another felt increasing the minimum age could encourage cohabitation rather than marriage, which would reduce protections.

The Free Church of Scotland and the United Free Church of Scotland felt marriage was the appropriate context for sexual relationships and family life, particularly within a Christian context. Both highlighted that the age of consent for sexual relationships was 16 years and opposed the separation of age between marriage and sexual consent.

Other views

One individual highlighted that their organisation had undertaken eight awareness-raising sessions with around 300 pupils in one secondary school. When asked to submit their views on raising the minimum age, 7.1% disagreed, 44.6% held no view either way, and 48.2% agreed that the age should be raised.

Q8. Do you agree or disagree that the Scottish Government should legislate to extend the forced marriage offence? This would be so that any conduct with the intention of causing a person under 18 to marry or enter a civil partnership would be a criminal offence, including where there is no evidence of coercion. If you wish, you can give reasons for your answer.

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Agree % Disagree % Don’t know % No answer
All respondents 124 61 14 3 22
All answering 97 78 18 4 -

Over three quarters (78%) of those answering Q8 agreed that the Scottish Government should legislate to extend the forced marriage offence, while 18% disagreed, and 4% were unsure. Agreement was similar among organisations (83%) and individuals (76%), but disagreement was higher among individuals (22%) than organisations (7%).

Among those answering, high levels of support were recorded among children’s rights/protection organisations (100%), women’s rights/protection organisations (100%), other organisations (100%), and religion or belief-based organisations (78%, with 0% disagreeing and 22% unsure). The highest level of disagreement was recorded by legal/judicial bodies, with 29% disagreeing and 57% agreeing.

Almost two fifths (39%) of all respondents commented at Q8. The most prevalent views were agreement with the Scottish Government legislating the forced marriage offence because it removes prosecution barriers and protects children, disagreement due to existing legislation being sufficient, and areas for improvement or consideration. To aid readability of this question, reasons for agreement are given first, as such comments were most prevalent, followed by reasons for disagreement, and then areas for improvement.

Agree, removes prosecution barriers and protects children

Several respondents agreed that the Scottish Government should legislate to extend the forced marriage offence to protect children and young people under the age of 18. Respondents referenced the UNCRC definition that any individual under the age of 18 is a child, therefore making marriage for those aged 16 or 17 a form of ‘child marriage’. They called for the UNCRC definition of a child to be implemented in Scotland by raising the minimum age of marriage in Scotland to 18. It was felt that this would align with children’s rights and safety protections in England and Wales, where the minimum age of marriage is 18. The UNCRC definition was noted to have already been adopted by some third sector organisations in Scotland.

Respondents expressed that child marriage is a form of forced marriage, that those under 18 are not old enough to make the decision to get married, and that there is no need for those under 18 to get married. Those aged under 18 were considered to still be developing psychologically and physically and were unable to meaningfully consent to marriage. Respondents raised concerns about girls marrying men who are older. They urged for this legislative change to be implemented to better safeguard children aged under 18 from the risks of abuse, coercion, violence, exploitation, pressure and ongoing harm due to such marriages. It was noted that current legislation limits the ability of services to intervene in cases of marriage involving those under age 18.

“Barnardo’s believes that no child should be placed in a position where consent can be manipulated, pressured, or assumed - particularly where cultural, emotional, financial, or familial pressures may be present. We have consistently argued across the UK that childhood should be protected until 18, and that early marriage exposes children to increased risks of domestic abuse and other harms, including those linked to faith or belief.” - Barnardo's

“Expanding the offence is essential to protect children and young people - particularly girls and young women - from all forms of pressure, manipulation, exploitation, and "honour” based abuse, including subtler forms that may not meet the current threshold of overt coercion or threats.” - Women's Rights Network Scotland

“This extension would provide an additional layer of safeguarding for children and ensure that the legislation did not include a loophole for this specific form of child abuse. It also ensures that the legislation is coherent across the ages of transition between children’s and adult services, an area which we know can often be complex and nuanced. Extending this offence sends a clear message that Scotland does not tolerate child abuse or forced marriage in any shape or form.” - CPC Scotland

Support for extending legislation of the forced marriage offence was made by several respondents because it helps to remove barriers to prosecution, namely, current difficulties proving coercion. Respondents detailed the many forms of pressure that can be placed on people to marry, including family, cultural, parental and community expectations. It was felt that this left young, vulnerable individuals with little choice but to marry despite not wanting to or not being ready to. Additionally, respondents noted that pressure could make it difficult to prosecute under existing legislation. Extending the forced marriage offence was hoped to improve the tools to prosecute and support individuals who have been forced to marry. One respondent suggested it could support the prosecution of facilitators of overseas forced child marriages or marriage ceremonies that are not legal or recognised in Scotland.

“Laws permitting under‑18 marriage are routinely exploited by families, communities, or older partners to pressure girls into unions they cannot refuse. Though these forms of coercion are not overt, girls are faced with cultural, emotional, financial or relational pressure, which experts identify as common forms of invisible coercion in cases of child marriage.” - Barnardo's

“Extending the offence to cover arrangements, inducements, or non-binding ceremonies aimed at under-18s closes this gap and provides stronger protection for vulnerable young people, especially girls.” – Individual

“This would also enable steps to be taken to prosecute conduct in connection with nonlegal marriages, or religious marriage ceremonies which are not recognised in Scotland, but which nonetheless take place in Scotland and abroad.” - Brodies LLP

Several respondents felt extending the legislation could actively prevent forced marriage and protect against the harm it can cause. They highlighted the legislative extension would send clear messages to families, communities and wider society that forced child marriage is unlawful. Respondents felt that this legislative extension could also better support prosecution, safeguarding, and early intervention.

“It would send a clear societal message that child marriage is unacceptable, strengthen early intervention and prosecution, and better safeguard vulnerable young people from the serious long-term harms associated with forced marriage, including domestic abuse, interrupted education, and poor health outcomes.” - Women's Rights Network Scotland

“By taking this two-pronged approach to underage marriage, we send a clear message that Scotland does not tolerate child abuse or forced marriage in any shape or form.” - Equally Safe Edinburgh Committee and the Edinburgh Child Protection Committee

Some respondents outlined more general statements of agreement that there should be an extension to the forced marriage offence by the Scottish Government. This included explicit support of the proposal set out in the consultation paper, as well as comments highlighting the importance of this change and a view that it is overdue.

Disagree, existing legislation is sufficient and evidential concerns

The most common reason for disagreement with the legislative extension of the forced marriage offence was that some respondents felt existing legislation is sufficient. This theme includes comments that coercion is already covered within legislation, with a perceived limited additional benefit of an extension. An individual noted that existing legislation would remain sufficient if the minimum age of marriage is increased.

“If coercion, threats, or manipulation are present, current forced marriage laws already make that illegal. Extending the offence to situations without coercion may be unnecessary duplication, rather than a targeted improvement.” - Individual

A few respondents stated concerns with removing the need for evidence of coercion, commenting that it would make prosecution difficult due to the updated definition being too broad. An individual outlined concerns of the legislative extension, including the criminalisation of some behaviours that are not harmful, and removing coercion from forced marriage.

Areas to consider and improve

Several respondents outlined unintended consequences that could occur from this legislative extension despite the best intentions. This includes concerns that extending the legislation could reduce reporting and help-seeking by victims of forced marriage, due to fear of their family members or the person they are in a relationship with being criminally prosecuted. This, in turn, could undermine safeguarding efforts and reduce awareness of the practice of forced marriage in Scotland. Other singular comments included concerns that extending the legislation could result in people getting married abroad instead, or that it may have a disproportionate impact on certain cultures and communities.

“…there is a concern that such changes could discourage individuals from seeking support if doing so might lead to the criminalisation of family members. We would therefore urge careful consideration of the potential impact of any extension of the offence, particularly in relation to safeguarding, reporting, and the proportionality of the legal response.” - The Free Church of Scotland

A few respondents left implementation considerations, which included:

  • Two respondents calling for consultation and engagement with the communities more likely to be impacted by the suggested legislative extension, to obtain their views on support and prevention approaches needed to help avoid forced marriage.
  • Addressing concerns that the offence will be difficult to prove.
  • Using the wording adopted in England and Wales regarding this legislation.
  • Considering concerns of a lack of access to public funds for 16- and 17-year-olds who are brought to Scotland for marriage.

“…people (including 16- and 17-year-olds) who ‘consented’ to a marriage because they didn’t know they could refuse are unlikely to want to take legal action against their family or community members (or anyone responsible for arranging their marriage). It would also risk criminalising family or community members who arranged the marriage of a (young) person on the assumption that the person was free to refuse it but did not – therefore leading them to believe that they freely and fully consented. Therefore, any changes to the law would require sensitive yet proactive engagement with communities who may practice arranged marriage.” - Equally Safe Edinburgh Committee and the Edinburgh Child Protection Committee

A small number of respondents expressed agreement with the potential legislative extension, depending on whether the minimum age of marriage is increased. For instance, some aged 16 and 17 may freely consent to marriage, and therefore no harm or force would be involved.

Calls for greater clarity were made, such as being clear on:

  • Forced marriage protections for people aged 16 and 17 years old, including access to support services.
  • What would count as evidence for a forced marriage conviction.
  • Whether the legislation extension would address marriages that are not legally valid, such as certain religious ceremonies.

Two respondents suggested wider initiatives beyond the suggested legislative extension to address forced marriage in Scotland, including:

  • Training to recognise forced marriages for teachers, health professionals, prosecutors, social workers and police.
  • Funding for victim support and its provision within the criminal justice system.
  • Developing a reporting pathway for victims that does not require prosecution or naming family members who may be involved.
  • Increasing public awareness of the offence of forced marriage with engagement from relevant communities, to support the prevention of offences occurring.

A singular comment from an individual felt it should not be possible to use a lack of understanding as a legal defence.

Q9. Do you have any comments on our draft impact assessments about the minimum age of marriage and civil partnership? We are particularly interested in any evidence about the experience of harm (or other impacts) for parties aged 16 or 17 who are permitted to marry or enter a civil partnership in Scotland, to their children or to others.

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % No Answer
All respondents 124 15 55 31
All answering 86 21 79 -

Among all respondents, 15% indicated at the closed question that they had comments on the draft impact assessments about the minimum age of marriage and civil partnership.

One in six respondents left an open comment at Q9. The most prevalent themes were comments on perceived risk or evidence of harm, comments on the data used to inform the impact assessments, and ensuring the views and rights of children are considered.

Comments on perceived risks or evidence of harm

Some respondents left comments on perceived risks or harms for 16 or 17-year-olds, though it was generally unclear how these related to the draft impact assessments. Harms raised reflected those mentioned under the theme ‘Can avoid harmful practices’ at Q7. Comments specifically related to the impact assessments included that they:

  • Understated the harms for 16- and 17-year-olds. For instance, they did not sufficiently capture the intersection of child marriage and other harmful practices, such as female genital mutilation, removal from education, restriction of movement and exposure to domestic abuse.
  • Should consider the impact on young people leaving care, who may be particularly vulnerable to pressure.
  • Did not adequately consider the impact of unintended consequences, such as the displacement of harms to circumstances with fewer protections, such as cohabitation.

Comments on data used

Comments on the data used to inform the impact assessments were highlighted by some respondents. Generally it was felt the data was limited, for instance, that it did not reflect the real picture on forced or child marriages as these are significantly under-reported, did not fully capture the experiences of the most affected and marginalised groups, or that arguments for harm often relied on global statistics from countries with high rates of coerced or forced marriage, which was unlikely to be the reality for the small number of voluntary marriages in Scotland.

Together (Scottish Alliance for Children's Rights) felt the data used to inform the draft CRWIA was relatively robust and noted the inclusion of the Annex summarising views expressed by members of the Scottish Youth Parliament, which they felt enhanced transparency, allowing readers to better understand the perspectives of children and young people. Conversely, the Law Society of Scotland felt it important that the CRWIA contains up-to-date data, noting that it had relied on statistics on 16 and 17-year-olds’ marriages from 2023.

“The draft Fairer Scotland Duty Assessment concludes that the very low number of registered marriages and civil partnerships involving people aged 16 or 17 means that there is little scope for effecting measurable socio-economic change through the proposed reforms (para 2.73). This reasoning is internally contradictory as the consultation elsewhere acknowledges that we lack reliable data in this area (para 2.38) and forced marriage is generally under-reported (para 2.40). It seems at least questionable to simultaneously acknowledge that the data is unreliable/incomplete while relying on that data to conclude that reform would have a limited impact.” - Centre for Scots Law, School of Law, University of Aberdeen

Ensure the views and rights of children are considered

The need to ensure the views and rights of children are considered within the impact assessments was highlighted by some respondents. This was felt necessary, according to one individual, given that raising the age of marriage or civil partnership would “amount to the removal of a fundamental right in Scottish law”. Suggested ways of engaging children included gathering further evidence on the experiences of 16 and 17-year-olds who marry, including long-term outcomes, consulting widely through schools and colleges or targeted engagement with communities who may be disproportionately affected by the legislation.

While this consultation may have engaged young people or young adults, it is unclear how many responded, though one did note their age in response to this question:

“As an 18-year-old myself, it is inconceivable to me that somebody younger than me could enter into something as big as marriage. It is totally wrong, and the age of consent to marriage should be raised.” - Individual

Two respondents noted the proposal to raise the minimum age of marriage or civil partnership aligned with children’s rights, with one commenting:

“Authors also pinpointed and explained the direct impacts that the proposals may have on children’s rights, with reference to the relevant UNCRC articles. There was also some evidence that indirect and differential impacts were considered; for instance, authors identified that the Gypsy/Traveller communities and those in same-sex relationships could potentially be disproportionately impacted by a change to the legal age of marriage. These examples show an increasing awareness of children’s rights issues and their legal basis, as well as progress in recognising the numerous ways that a policy can impact the lives of children from different backgrounds.” - Together (Scottish Alliance for Children's Rights)

Q10. Do you have any other comments on the minimum age of marriage and civil partnership?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % No Answer
All respondents 124 27 45 27
All answering 90 38 62 -

Among all respondents, 27% indicated at the closed question that they had other comments on the minimum age of marriage and civil partnership.

One in three of all respondents left an open comment at Q10. The most prevalent themes were concerns regarding harms, the need for awareness and support, and alignment with domestic legislation.

Concerns regarding harms

Some respondents left comments on harms, with these being used to reiterate their view as to whether the minimum age should be raised or not, often aligned to issues raised at Q7-9. For instance, raising the minimum age was seen as a way to protect children from arranged or forced marriage or to prevent consensual early marriage in a context of increasingly sexist and misogynistic social media content, which could normalise problematic views around gender roles within a household. One respondent against raising the minimum age suggested extending child protection and vulnerable adult legislation through exploring the potential for statutory reporting of concerns by registrars, celebrants or religious leaders, a suggestion raised by a few others. Suggestions from individuals included:

  • Ensuring overseas marriages involving anyone domiciled in Scotland under 18 are not recognised in Scottish law.
  • Reforming the age of consent to ensure adults over nine years older than someone aged 16 or 17 cannot have sexual relations with someone under age 18.
  • Investigating parties that were married under 18, prior to reform, for coercion and abuse.

Need for awareness and support

The need for awareness-raising, training and adequate support was raised by some respondents. Additionally, this point was made by a few respondents at Q7, Q8 and Q9, with those views incorporated here. Education, outreach and accessible advice were all advocated to help ensure people were aware of any changes in the law, understand their rights and responsibilities, and address cultural beliefs and attitudes among the public that could cause harm to children and young people, such as coercion and control, misogyny or harms associated with early or forced marriage. Additionally, training for those involved in conducting marriages or civil partnerships or working with children and young people was considered important, for instance, to recognise early signs of pressure or abuse.

Suggestions for ways to improve awareness included:

  • Mandatory training, regularly refreshed and co-designed with specialist organisations, such as for registrars, celebrants, teachers and social workers.
  • A proactive, multi-lingual, community-facing awareness campaign developed in partnership with specialist organisations and community leaders.
  • Providing clear, accessible information through schools and community settings.
  • Facilitating community dialogue that includes men, boys and parents to change social norms.

Suggestions of wider support that were felt to be needed included:

  • Addressing inequity in service access, such as challenges in sourcing support in rural areas.
  • Engaging religious, traditional and community leaders to actively support ending the practice of early or forced marriage.
  • Encouraging girls to continue with their schooling, such as providing scholarships, safe transport and flexible learning opportunities.
  • Empowering girls directly, such as through establishing girls’ groups, mentorship programmes and life-skills training where they can learn about their rights and connect with peers.
  • Support for married girls, such as ensuring access to reproductive health services, psychological counselling and opportunities to return to education.
  • Economic support for families, such as implementing conditional cash transfers or livelihood programmes that provide families with financial security, making marriage unnecessary for economic survival.

“Registrars, teachers, GPs, midwives, social workers, police officers, and housing officers must all be equipped to recognise the signs of child marriage, including in the absence of overt coercion. This training must be mandatory, regularly refreshed, and co-designed with specialist organisations that have direct experience of these issues. Many families and communities in Scotland are unaware that the law is changing or that child marriage is unlawful. A proactive, multilingual, community-facing awareness campaign developed in partnership with specialist organisations and community leaders is essential to shift attitudes as well as behaviour. Law changes behaviour most effectively when it is accompanied by cultural messaging that explains why the change matters.” - Individual

Alignment with domestic legislation

The need to ensure alignment with other age-related rights in Scots law or relevant legislation was mentioned by some respondents. Mostly, these commented on legislation relating to cohabitation and the law of consent (see also ‘Should align with other age-related rights’ at Q7). For instance, the Faculty of Advocates highlighted that other aspects of the statutory regime would need to be considered, should the minimum age be raised to 18, such as:

  • The impact on fathers’ ability to obtain parental responsibilities and rights for their child.
  • How those who wished to engage in sexual activity were able to solemnise their relationships.
  • That there would be no protection in terms of financial provision for those aged 16 should their relationship break down if the SLC's recommended definition of the minimum age at which a person could be considered a cohabitant for the purposes of the 2006 Act was also raised to 18.
  • If the recommended definition of ‘cohabitant’ under the SLC’s proposals for reform of cohabitants’ rights on separation is not extended so that it also applies to circumstances where a cohabitant is applying for financial provision from their deceased partner’s intestate estate, then cohabitants aged 16 and 17 would be disadvantaged.
  • That children over 16 have legal capacity to make decisions about whether to claim a portion of a deceased parent's net moveable estate, regardless of the terms of the will.

“BCOS notes that this proposal raises broader questions about consistency within the legal framework relating to young people, including the relationship between the minimum age of marriage and the current age of consent for sexual activity. From the perspective of safeguarding and the wellbeing of young people, BCOS considers it important that any changes in this area are assessed holistically, taking into account how different age-related legal thresholds interact and the potential implications for those under 18. In particular, attention should be given to whether differing age limits may have unintended consequences for vulnerable young people.” - Bishops' Conference of Scotland (BCOS) Alignment with wider requirements

A few respondents commented on wider alignments that they felt should be taken into account. One individual noted that following the increase in the minimum age to 18 in

England and Wales in 2022, there was evidence of families bringing young people to

Scotland to circumvent the higher age threshold. They felt that should the age be raised in Scotland, there would be a risk of families travelling to other jurisdictions, including internationally, to conduct marriages that would be unlawful at home. They recommended the Scottish Government work with the UK Government, the Forced Marriage Unit and international partners to ensure that marriages conducted abroad to circumvent Scottish law are not recognised.

Similarly, the Civil Partnership Act is an Act of the UK Parliament, and an individual felt that the minimum age of marriage should be the same as that for civil partnerships, so section 217 of the Civil Partnership Act 2004 would need to be amended.

Together (Scottish Alliance for Children's Rights) highlighted that differences between Scottish and UK legislative regimes meant that as the ages of marriage and forced marriage were governed by Acts of the UK Parliament, they currently fall outwith the ‘compatibility duty’ enshrined in section 6 of the UNCRC Act. They suggested careful attention during legislative drafting to avoid adverse consequences such as:

“Children and young people and/or their representatives will be barred from using the UNCRC Act to seek remedy where potential rights breaches emerge, leaving them with no option but to resort to more complex and less accessible legal routes, such as judicial review or claims under the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). This would undermine the aim of the UNCRC Act, which sought to make children’s rights legally enforceable in Scots law and provide children with a clear and direct route to remedy when their rights are breached. It would also contradict Scottish Government’s pledge to avoid amending UK Acts and to instead create stand-alone provisions in new Acts of the Scottish Parliament where possible, so that the UNCRC Act would be applicable to a wider range of legislation.” - Together (Scottish Alliance for Children's Rights)

Other views

Some respondents left a disparate range of views at Q10. These included:

  • Approaches that could be taken should the minimum age not be increased, such as:
    • Two respondents who felt there may be a case for requiring judicial consent in Scotland where either party is under 18.
    • Focusing instead on strengthening targeted protections and informed decision-making, such as strengthening safeguards around consent, such as introducing a requirement for independent verification of consent given freely and fully by a registrar or qualified professional.
    • Adopting a case-by-case or conditional approval system, subject to additional safeguards such as a waiting period or independent counselling to balance protection with individual autonomy.
  • A recommendation that Scotland commits to a survivor-led approach to implementation and developing policy, training and communications with survivors of child marriage and forced marriage.

“A more proportionate and evidence-based approach would prioritise consent, safeguarding, and education, while preserving flexibility for young people in different circumstances. This is likely to be more effective than a blanket increase in the minimum age alone.” – Individual

Contact

Email: family.law@gov.scot

Back to top