Family law reforms: consultation analysis

Analysis of responses to the public consultation on potential family law reforms in Scotland.


4. Qualifying requirements for religious and belief bodies

In Scotland, a couple who meet the eligibility criteria can enter into a marriage or a civil partnership. A marriage may be solemnised, and a civil partnership registered, by a civil registrar (working as an employee of a local authority under the direction of the Registrar General) or by an authorised religious or belief celebrant.

The qualifying requirements were introduced under the Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Act 2014 and were also contained in the Civil Partnership (Scotland) Act 2020, which introduced mixed sex civil partnerships. The qualifying requirements are intended to ensure that a religious or belief body is genuine, and such bodies need to demonstrate that they are genuine, active organisations with publicly stated beliefs, regular meetings and marriage or civil partnership ceremonies that form part of their faith or philosophy and not primarily a commercial enterprise. The qualifying requirements are set out in detail in the consultation document.

The consultation proposes that the Scottish Government would make regulations to lay down qualifying requirements in certain areas and not others. Stakeholder views were sought on whether the Scottish Government should lay down qualifying requirements for religious and belief bodies to meet when they are solemnising a marriage or registering a civil partnership, and if so, whether the qualifying requirements set out in the consultation document are the right ones.

Q11. Should the Scottish Government lay down qualifying requirements for religious or belief bodies to meet when they solemnise marriage or register civil partnership? If you wish, you can give reasons for your answer.

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 37 6 8 49
All answering 63 73 11 16 -

Among those answering Q11, 73% agreed that the Scottish Government should lay down qualifying requirements for religion or belief-based organisations to meet when they solemnise marriage or register a civil partnership. Of the remainder, 11% disagreed, and 16% were unsure. The same pattern of results was recorded by both individuals and organisations, with 73% of both groups agreeing.

All women’s rights/protection bodies and other organisations that answered agreed. A higher percentage of legal/judicial bodies agreed (80%) compared to religion or belief based organisations (60%), though legal/judicial organisations had higher levels of disagreement (20%, compared to 13% in religion or belief-based organisations).

One third of all respondents commented to explain their answer to Q11. The most prevalent views were agreement with laying down qualifying requirements to support standards and safeguarding, considerations for their implementation, and wider views.

Reasons for agreement

Various reasons for agreement were raised by respondents regarding the proposal for the Scottish Government to lay down qualifying requirements for religious or belief bodies to meet when they solemnise marriage or register a civil partnership.

Most commonly, several respondents agreed as they felt laying down qualifying requirements supports rights and standards. According to these respondents, introducing these could provide greater transparency, clarity, coherence, structure, and consistency across practitioners. For example, current requirements allow celebrants to practice across Scotland without geographic restrictions, compared to registrars or religious bodies who have to practice within specific boundaries. Respondents also highlighted the importance of clarifying responsibilities, accountability, and consistently upholding standards across practitioners. It was felt that this could improve fairness, support the rights of celebrants and couples getting married or entering civil partnership, and minimise any illegal or unfair practice, such as individual practitioners or bodies profiting from ceremonies.

“Clear qualifying requirements protect the public, uphold standards, and ensure that all celebrants - religious or belief - operate with professionalism and respect for human rights.” - The Humanist Society Scotland

“Although this area is already subject to extensive regulation, there appear to be gaps in the current framework. Setting out a comprehensive and consolidated list of relevant requirements would therefore be beneficial, improving clarity, accessibility, and the overall coherence of the law.” - Law Society of Scotland

Several respondents supported introducing qualifying requirements as they felt it could support public confidence in the authorisation of religious or belief bodies. They expressed the view that qualifying requirements could ensure that ceremonies are carried out ethically and performed by those with the required authorisation, safeguarding, and governance, and who have sufficient training, qualifications and skills. For example, concerns were raised that some ceremonies are performed by unauthorised or unskilled practitioners, or that ceremonies are being performed for profit with a focus on quantity over quality. One respondent commented on the need for celebrants to demonstrate or evidence adherence to the beliefs of the organisation they represent.

“Religious or belief bodies should also be able to demonstrate that they do in fact represent the beliefs of a group of people, to ensure that there is legitimacy in their undertaking of this responsibility.” - Equally Safe Edinburgh Committee and the Edinburgh Child Protection Committee

“[We agree that the purpose of the qualifying requirements should be] to ensure that marriage or civil partnership ceremonies which are carried out in Scotland by religious or belief bodies meet baseline standards in terms of training, ethical considerations, and the general duties and functions of the bodies/individuals performing these ceremonies.” - Brodies LLP

Another theme, raised by some respondents, was that qualifying requirements could safeguard vulnerable individuals by supporting consistency, awareness, and adherence to the law across religious or belief bodies in solemnising marriage or registering civil partnership. Respondents noted that this could particularly support women and girls from coercion into marriage and prevent sham marriages and child marriages.

Equally Safe Edinburgh Committee and the Edinburgh Child Protection Committee added that the requirements could act as an additional safeguard to the potential increase in the minimum age of marriage. They also noted that requirements could support the proposed process of mandatory abuse reporting through the National Child Sexual Abuse and Exploitation workstreams.

Some other respondents expressed general agreement with the proposal, describing it as reasoned, comprehensive, careful and thoughtful.

Considerations for implementation

Singular concerns and considerations included:

  • The Free Church of Scotland requested that spiritual independence be respected in regulatory frameworks. They supported the Scottish Government in addressing issues such as forced marriage but expressed concerns with the state assessing religious beliefs and practices.
  • The Church of Scotland detailed reservations around the requirement ‘To lay down that when seeking authorisation, bodies should confirm they will not denigrate marriage ceremonies and civil partnership registrations carried out by other bodies or by registrars. They felt this is a disproportionate requirement, restricting free speech.
  • Caledonian Humanist Association raised concerns that the qualifying requirements ‘would not apply to bodies that are prescribed before the qualifying requirements are laid down’. They felt this could result in a two-tier system with variation in standards based on date of prescribed status, suggesting instead proportionate or phased compliance.
  • An individual commented on the potential for standardised requirements to lead to discrimination against certain belief groups.

Singular suggestions for implementing the suggested qualifying requirements included:

  • Ensuring qualifying requirements accommodate the variety of Scottish religious or belief bodies.
  • Focusing on celebrants’ legal compliance and developing a code of practice.
  • Including age verification by religious and belief bodies prior to marriage solemnisation as an enforceable requirement.
  • Including safeguard training, covering topics such as coercion, child marriage, and forced marriage.
  • Ensuring qualifying requirements are clear, proportionate, workable, do not disadvantage small organisations and support safeguarding.

Calls for greater clarity on the qualifying requirements were made by a few respondents. This included requests for more details on what the qualifying requirements would include, the purpose behind their introduction, and how they would benefit existing processes.

Wider views

One anonymous organisation felt that current legislation needs updating to legislate celebrants’ practice, as well as that of religious and belief bodies. United Free Church of Scotland disagreed with the proposal as they felt that the current legislation is sufficient.

Q12. Should the qualifying requirements outlined in this consultation be laid down? Please outline what modifications you think are needed or which requirements you think should not be laid down.

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 26 11 6 56
All answering 54 59 26 15 -

Over half (59%) of those answering Q12 agreed that the qualifying requirements outlined in this consultation should be laid down. This is lower than the proportion who agreed at Q11 that qualifying requirements more generally should be laid down (73%). Agreement was higher among individuals (69%) than organisations (45%), with higher disagreement recorded by organisations (41%) than individuals (16%). Among the small number answering, 50% of legal/judicial bodies and 42% of religion or belief-based bodies agreed with the proposal, while 50% of religion or belief-based organisations disagreed.

If you answered No, please confirm whether you think this is because:

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % The requirements should generally be laid down as outlined, but with modification(s) % Only some of the requirements outlined should be laid down % No answer
All respondents 124 8 4 88
All answering 15 67 33 -

Among the small number answering, two thirds (67%) indicated they selected ‘no’ at Q12 because they felt the requirements should generally be laid down as outlined, but with modifications. Individuals were more likely to select this option than organisations (86% compared to 50%, respectively). The remaining one third (33%) indicated they selected ‘no’ at Q12 because they felt only some of the requirements outlined should be laid down.

One fifth of respondents commented at Q12. The most prevalent views were alternative suggestions and considerations, agreement for qualifying requirements to support good practice, and that qualifying requirements are not needed.

Alternative suggestions and considerations

Most commonly, several respondents raised alternative suggestions and modifications to the qualifying requirements. Respondents called for them to be proportionate, without introducing overly burdensome administration, and to focus on freedom of beliefs, accountability, competence and safeguarding.

Views relating to the specific qualifying requirements outlined in the consultation paper, in order of prevalence, included:

‘To lay down that when nominating persons to the Registrar General to act as celebrants, the religious or belief body should confirm that each proposed celebrant will carry out no more than 3 marriage or civil partnership ceremonies per day and no more than 14 marriage or civil partnership ceremonies per week.’ There were mixed views on alternatives to this qualifying requirement. Most commonly, a few respondents thought the suggested limits are still too high and should be lower. One respondent felt that while this limit may be reasonable for registrars who perform ceremonies in the same building, it may not be suitable for celebrants who may risk being overworked or facing travel difficulties to go between ceremonies, risking couples being let down. The same respondent suggested a maximum of two ceremonies per day and a maximum of eight per week. One respondent suggested adding an annual limit, such as a maximum of 75 yearly ceremonies conducted by each celebrant, to support non-commercialisation and ensure practice based on belief. OneSpirit Interfaith Foundation suggested lowering the limit, with exemptions for registrars for busy periods. Alternatively, one respondent suggested a limit may not be required as there may be fluctuations in the number of ceremonies depending on the time of year.

‘To require bodies seeking authorisation to provide information to the Scottish Government or NRS (National Registers of Scotland) on how often the body meets for religious worship or to uphold or promote philosophical beliefs and what these meetings are about’. Two respondents raised concerns with the wording ‘how often the body meets for religious worship’, with one calling for a broad definition and another feeling it was not a reliable or proportionate indicator of beliefs. They noted the variability in how different belief bodies function, with some being decentralised, and raised a concern that this requirement could discriminate against certain organisations. Another respondent queried the wording ‘what these meetings are about’, suggesting this requirement is intrusive, and to instead consider alternative indicators of organisation legitimacy, such as community engagement and membership. The National Records of Scotland supported this qualifying requirement and requested an expansion. They called for religious or belief bodies to provide evidence of worship and beliefs, and information on guest speakers, samples of service orders or documentation, and how body members are notified of meetings.

‘To lay down that when a body seeks authorisation to solemnise marriage or register civil partnership in Scotland, it should provide information on what training its celebrants have’. Two respondents suggested strengthening this requirement by auditing or reviewing celebrants’ training and professional development. A further two respondents called for training on coercion, and forced and sham marriages, with one suggesting this could be conducted by the Scottish Government.

‘To lay down that when seeking authorisation bodies should confirm they will not denigrate marriage ceremonies and civil partnership registrations carried out by other bodies or by registrars.’ One respondent emphasised the need to not place restrictions on free speech or beliefs. Another respondent felt this should not prevent complaints against other bodies in cases of genuine concern, while another respondent called for more details on the potential impacts of this qualifying requirement.

‘To lay down that when seeking to be authorised, bodies should confirm that they publicise (either at local or national level) the fees they charge for marriage ceremonies and civil partnership registrations.’ OneSpirit Interfaith Foundation felt that body-level fee publication was not practical as fees are set by individual celebrants in their organisation, and instead supported individual celebrants publishing their own fees, which could offer couples greater transparency.

‘To lay down that when seeking to be authorised a body should confirm that solemnising marriage and registering civil partnership is integral to the body’s religious or philosophical beliefs and any income accruing as a result is either to meet legitimate costs and expenses or is incidental to a body’s aims.’ The National Records of Scotland supported this requirement but felt it could be strengthened by requiring religious or belief bodies to provide a statement confirming that the solemnisation of marriages or registration of civil partnerships is integral to their belief practice, when requesting registrar general authorisation. They also requested confirmation of income accruing for legitimate reasons, and to consider requesting ongoing evidence of religious beliefs or activities from these bodies. The Bishops’ Conference of Scotland noted that fees can be used to cover service costs and charitable support work.

Other singular suggested changes or areas to strengthen included:

  • Addressing a concern that the Church of Scotland would be exempt from the qualifying requirements, as this was viewed as preferential treatment and could signal that some beliefs carry greater civic value than others.
  • Reviewing the proposed prohibition on the acceptance of awards or recognition to acknowledge that awards can celebrate good practice, innovation, community contributions or long-standing service.
  • Suggesting having a code of conduct in place instead of qualifying requirements.
  • Considering expanding the first four requirements outlined in the consultation paper, to clarify that coercion is not allowed.
  • Considering organisation-specific requests, such as for The Bishops’ Conference of

Scotland. They commented that they have implicit marriage declarations in the

Catholic rite, and an implicit process instead of training for identifying instances of

sham marriages or coercion, which they requested to be considered in the qualifying requirements.

  • Strengthening requirements on belief promotion, meeting frequency, and organisation details, which were felt to not adequately safeguard against commercial use of authorisations that are belief-based.
  • Expanding on requirements to address unauthorised celebrants.

“In a modern Scotland that increasingly defines itself as diverse, inclusive, and largely secular, it is reasonable to question why the Church of Scotland should continue to receive preferential recognition within government legislation. When many citizens identify with different faiths—or with none at all—granting a single religious institution a privileged legal status risks undermining the principle of equality before the law.” - Independent Humanist Ceremonies/Community/Charities (IHC)

“Religious and belief organisations vary significantly in how they are structured and how they manifest their beliefs. Some may meet regularly in formal settings, while others operate in a more decentralised or occasional way, particularly in relation to life events such as marriages. A requirement framed around frequency and content of meetings risks favouring certain models of religious practice over others.” - Caledonian Humanist Association

Some respondents identified requirements they felt needed more clarity, including what constitutes ‘commercial activities’, and what would be defined as legitimate forms of cost recovery. An individual requested that the Scottish Government provide examples using accessible language to support this definition. Other singular comments included calls for greater clarity on:

  • The definition of ‘effective disciplinary procedures’.
  • The wording ‘meeting regularly’ and the type of meetings this would include.
  • How self-employed celebrants and ministers would have the requirements applied when they work for organisations.
  • Track record requirements and how that would be implemented.
  • What forms of advertisements or promotions would be acceptable.
  • How religious or belief bodies could have a marriage solemnisation track record when they may not yet be authorised.
  • The process of monitoring and evaluation, how religious or belief bodies state their beliefs publicly, such as on websites, and the approach that will be taken for small religious or belief bodies.

The implementation of the qualifying requirements and possible issues was commented on by some respondents. This included:

  • A concern about having standard qualifying requirements and a request for flexibility in requirements to ensure they are applicable across all religious or belief bodies, noting their diversity in structure and operation.
  • Providing support to transition to qualifying requirements being in place, such as through guidance and examples.
  • Suggesting religious or belief bodies should make their statement of belief available on their websites, supporting couples to decide on which celebrant they would like.
  • Calling for fees to be published online, and where religious or belief bodies do not have websites, they should be available for request.
  • Suggesting that authorised celebrants should not be able to advertise as independent celebrants but require a clear linkage to religious or belief bodies.
  • Requesting that the qualifying requirements be a legal requirement, with compliance reviews conducted by the National Records of Scotland.
  • Ensuring human rights, governance, accessibility, inclusion, and transparency are upheld.
  • Supporting all beliefs to be equally treated.
  • Considering unintended consequences on small religious or belief bodies.

Yes, qualifying requirements support good practice and are reasonable

Some respondents broadly supported the suggested qualifying requirements. This included comments that the qualifying requirements are appropriate, support accountability, and align with existing organisational values and practices. Statements of support for specific qualifying requirements were also made, particularly relating to marriage solemnisation not being for profit. Support was also expressed for requirements on providing belief of constitution statements, satisfaction statements of religious or belief body track records, celebrant training, and demonstration of disciplinary processes. National Records of Scotland agreed that certain qualifying requirements, namely a prohibition on paid advertisement or geographical limitations of celebrants, had not been suggested.

Support for qualifying requirements was expressed by some respondents who described them as comprehensive, reasonable and proportionate. Comments related to all or specific qualifying requirements outlined that they are essential, support transparency, are appropriate, aid public confidence, and protect against shams or profits.

Some respondents suggested that qualifying requirements would aid good practice across those solemnising marriages and registering civil partnerships in Scotland. Training, disciplinary procedures, and statements of belief were felt by respondents to support accountability, transparency, and safeguarding. One respondent commented that fee transparency and limits on the number of ceremonies help to address concerns around profits and commercialisation. Another respondent noted that the qualifying requirements set out in the consultation aligned with current good practice.

No, qualifying requirements are not needed

A few respondents expressed general negative views, outlining disagreement with some or all of the suggested qualifying requirements. The Free Church of Scotland noted concerns of spiritual independence and felt that some of the proposed requirements were disproportionate. An individual raised concerns around assumptions that celebrants are salaried and noted that there can be good reasoning for different celebrant fees.

Two respondents raised concerns of unintended negative consequences that could result from the qualifying requirement to publish the beliefs of religious or belief bodies. They felt that this information should not be for the state to assess as a mandatory process, and that it could disproportionately affect small, non-traditional or new organisations. Conversely, United Free Church of Scotland stated that most religious bodies are registered charities that publicly state their constitution.

“…mandatory publication could expose some groups—particularly minority belief communities—to increased risk of scrutiny or harassment.” - Caledonian Humanist Association

Q13. Should any further qualifying requirements be laid down? If so, please outline what should be laid down and why.

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 13 21 13 53
All answering 58 28 45 28 -

Among those answering Q13, just under half (45%) felt there should not be any further qualifying requirements laid down, while 28% indicated there should be, and 28% were unsure. Individuals responded similarly to the overall results, with 41% against any further qualifying requirements, 26% in favour, and 32% unsure. Among organisations that answered, half (50%) disagreed that further qualifying requirements should be laid down, with 29% agreeing there should be, and 21% unsure. Similar views were recorded by religion or belief-based organisations and legal/judicial bodies.

One sixth of all respondents commented at Q13. The most prevalent views were suggestions for additional qualifying requirements and modifications, the need for more effective training, and strengthening protections against abuse and forced marriage.

Suggested modifications and additional qualifying requirements

Several respondents outlined additions or modifications to the suggested qualifying requirements. A range of singular suggestions included:

  • Requiring religious or belief bodies to keep a record of all celebrants’ civil partnerships or marriages solemnised, including details of names, dates, fees, and celebrants. It was felt that this could be helpful in instances where an investigation is undertaken or an issue is identified. The same respondent, Brodies LLP, suggested consideration of the need for probationary periods or to implement routine reviews of whether the qualifying requirements are being upheld after authorisation.
  • Providing proof that those conducting marriage ceremonies do not have a family connection to the people getting married.
  • Implementing a requirement for celebrants to inform prospective civil partners and spouses about their legal marriage rights and marriage dissolution information.
  • Adding a requirement for celebrants to report to authorities where suspected coercion, pressure or forced marriage is identified, with disciplinary action if this is not done.
  • Designating geographical areas where ceremonies can be performed by each celebrant, with another respondent suggesting belief bodies should be restricted to conducting ceremonies within their local boundary or postcode.
  • Supporting consistency across those conducting ceremonies, ensuring that prescribed bodies do not imply their ceremonies are preferable to others.
  • Strengthening requirements to determine genuine belief of organisations, with a suggestion to focus on relationships between celebrants and bodies.
  • Prohibiting temporary celebrant authorisation where their services are marketed without a belief reference, when the authorisation is given through religious or belief bodies.
  • Considering an alternative approach to qualifying requirements altogether, such as having a code of conduct, governance templates, and for guidance to be optional.
  • Strengthening requirements to prevent commercialisation, such as through the prohibition of civil partnership and marriage services having paid advertisements.

“We would also like to see a responsibility placed on celebrants to inform the prospective spouses/civil partners of their legal rights within the marriage and on the dissolution of a marriage. This is particularly important as people’s legal rights are often not the same as the rights and responsibilities placed on them by their religion/belief system.” - Equally Safe Edinburgh Committee and the Edinburgh Child Protection Committee

“We would suggest that greater emphasis be placed instead on the relationship between authorised celebrants and the nominating body, including the extent to which the body exercises oversight, ensures adherence to its beliefs or values, and is able to take action where those standards are not met.” - Caledonian Humanist Association

Need for strengthened training

Some respondents called for strengthened training and accountability to support consistency across bodies and celebrants solemnising marriages and registering civil partnerships. This included suggestions for performance reviews, shared training resources, and regular, mandatory training on relevant laws and recognition of signs of coercion. Respondents noted this could support consistency in competence and accountability. One respondent called for proof that the standards are being met for those receiving temporary authorisation.

Strengthening protections against abuse and forced marriage

A few respondents called for qualifying requirements to strengthen protections against forced marriage and abuse. They urged for greater inclusion of the safeguarding of children, vulnerable adults, and women. They suggested celebrants should support couples intending to enter a civil partnership or marriage to understand how to achieve healthy relationships, and for bodies to confirm that people under 18 are not entering a civil partnership or marriage. One individual suggested the National Records of Scotland should monitor compliance to ensure coercion and forced marriage do not occur.

“From the perspective of protecting children and vulnerable adults from forced marriage and other forms of abuse, we would be keen to see additional considerations on the role of celebrants in supporting the prospective couple to fully understand what it means to enter a marriage or civil partnership. We would also be keen to see how they will support prospective spouses to understand a healthy marriage/civil partner relationship, domestic abuse and coercive control.” - Equally Safe Edinburgh Committee and the Edinburgh Child Protection Committee

Positive comments on the suggested qualifying requirements

A few respondents expressed the view that the current proposed qualifying requirements are sufficient, reasonable and proportionate, without the need for further qualifying requirements or modifications. In addition, it was suggested that further qualifying requirements could create an unnecessary burden for small religious and belief bodies. Two respondents agreed with the outlined qualifying requirements supporting authorisation and public confidence.

“We believe the consultation proposals are comprehensive and sufficient. Additional qualifying requirements do not appear necessary at this time and may risk becoming disproportionate or overly burdensome without clear benefit.” - Independent Humanist Ceremonies/Community/Charities (IHC)

Other views

Wider considerations were made by a few respondents, which included:

  • Urging for greater consultation with celebrants from a range of bodies.
  • Requesting greater clarity on the process of authorisation of standards for religious and belief bodies, including who authorises these bodies.
  • Calling for qualifying requirements overall to be more proportionate, considering freedom in beliefs, preventing overly administrative burdens on bodies, and ensuring that small or minority religious and belief bodies are not disadvantaged.

Q14. Should the Scottish Government and NRS draw up a Code of Conduct for celebrants instead of laying down qualifying requirements? If you wish, you can give reasons for your answer.

One option being considered by the Scottish Government is to draw up a Code of Conduct for celebrants instead of laying down qualifying requirements. This would be voluntary, and there would be no obligation on religious or belief bodies to sign up to it.

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 15 19 11 54
All answering 57 33 42 25 -

Among those answering Q14, there were mixed views on whether there should be a Code of Conduct for celebrants instead of laying down qualifying requirements, with one third

(33%) in favour of this approach, two fifths (42%) opposed, and one quarter (25%) unsure. Support for a Code of Conduct was higher among individuals, with two fifths (41%) agreeing compared to one fifth (22%) of organisations. Opposition was higher among organisations, with three fifths (61%) of organisations selecting ‘no’ compared to three in ten (29%) individuals. All other organisations, four fifths (80%) of legal/judicial bodies, and half (50%) of religion or belief-based organisations answered ‘no’.

Three in ten of all respondents commented at Q14. The most prevalent views were disagreement due to needing legally enforceable standards, that a Code of Conduct should be drawn up in addition to enforceable qualifying requirements, and agreement that a Code of Conduct would support good practice without over-governance.

No, need enforcement and a stronger approach

Several respondents disagreed with introducing a Code of Conduct for celebrants instead of laying down qualifying requirements, due to concerns about a lack of enforceability and accountability if the Code of Conduct is voluntary. These respondents instead supported the qualifying requirements as it was felt these were more enforceable, backed by the law, were clearer, and had consequences for non-compliance. For instance, one respondent felt it could be challenging to evidence organisational compliance with the Code.

Respondents felt the lack of a legally enforceable Code of Conduct may lead to it being ineffective or inconsistently applied across bodies and celebrants. Difficulties in ensuring safeguarding or preventing forced marriages, coercion and sham marriages due to the Code of Conduct being voluntary were also raised. Other singular comments included concerns that the Code of Conduct would:

  • Not support a change in practice or behaviour from religious or belief bodies whose views differ from the Code of Conduct.
  • Not support public confidence or protection of couples seeking to get married or undergo a civil partnership, compared to more formal regulations.

“…a voluntary Code of Conduct on its own would not provide the level of consistency, safeguarding, or public protection that couples are entitled to expect.” - Celebrate People “While a Code of Conduct would be less burdensome for both the Government and the bodies responsible for solemnising marriages, it is unlikely to be as effective as legislation in addressing the risks of forced or sham marriages.” - Bishops' Conference of Scotland

“In the absence of robust qualifying requirements, a code of conduct would not ensure effective oversight, accountability, or the ability of bodies to withdraw authorisation where standards are not met.” - Caledonian Humanist Association

A few respondents suggested that introducing a Code of Conduct would be unnecessary, overcomplicated, burdensome and create duplication in the regulatory landscape.

Yes, supports good practice

Several respondents supported introducing a Code of Conduct if it was additional to enforceable standards, namely the potential qualifying requirements. Respondents suggested it could be complementary, support best practice guidance for celebrants, and align with qualifying requirements to aid their implementation. Introducing qualifying requirements (in addition to a voluntary Code) was felt necessary to reinforce accountability, authorisation, and training.

Some respondents supported a Code of Conduct, suggesting it would aid good practice among bodies and celebrants without over-governance of religious or belief bodies by the Scottish Government. Respondents noted a Code of Conduct would help to provide shared benchmarks for professional standards and training, support understanding of expectations for new bodies and aid consistency. One respondent hoped it would address concerns such as the commercialisation of marriage and civil partnership ceremonies. It was also felt that a Code of Conduct would be a proportionate, balanced, flexible and helpful approach without being overly prescriptive or with rigid requirements, encouraging a state and religious body partnership approach.

Three respondents expressed broad support for introducing a Code of Conduct instead of qualifying requirements, stating it is a more feasible approach.

“A voluntary Code of Conduct would provide a more proportionate and flexible means of promoting good practice, while avoiding unnecessary state involvement in the internal life, doctrine, and governance of religious bodies. It would allow for appropriate guidance in areas such as safeguarding, transparency, and professional standards, without imposing rigid statutory requirements.” - The Free Church of Scotland

Suggestions for implementation and wider comments

Some respondents highlighted implementation considerations and potential issues with a Code of Conduct. Singular considerations included:

  • Ensuring a Code has requirements to outline transparent ceremony pricing, sets professional behaviour standards, and establishes complaints procedures.
  • Outlining processes for the Code of Conduct not being met.
  • Suggesting the Code of Conduct is voluntary for celebrants.
  • Clarifying the proposal’s policy aims.

Other views

One anonymous organisation noted if a Code of Conduct was agreed upon by their organisation, they would require it to be compulsory for their celebrants to follow. Independent Humanist Ceremonies/Community/Charities (IHC) stated they had no preference for either a Code of Conduct or the implementation of qualifying requirements, suggesting they meet to the same objective, and that they would follow either approach.

Q15. Do you have any comments on the draft Impact Assessments about the Qualifying Requirements? If yes, please outline these comments and/or evidence.

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % No Answer
All respondents 124 5 39 56
All answering 54 11 89 -

Among all respondents, 5% indicated at the closed question that they had comments on the draft Impact Assessments about the Qualifying Requirements.

Fewer than one in ten of all respondents commented at Q15. The most prevalent views were positive comments on the draft Impact Assessments about the qualifying requirements and areas for greater consideration.

Positive comments

A small number of respondents agreed with the draft Impact Assessments about the qualifying requirements. Comments included:

  • Agreeing with suggestions in the Business and Regulatory Impact Assessment that there would be minimal costs to religious and belief bodies due to alignment of the qualifying requirements with existing requirements.
  • Supporting the view in the draft Equality Impact Assessment that the Scottish Government has no intention to assess belief systems.

The Faculty of Advocates felt the draft Impact Assessments were aligned with UNCRC rights requirements, as outlined in the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (Incorporation) (Scotland) Act 2024.

Areas for greater consideration

A few respondents called for greater consideration of the impacts of the qualifying requirements on small, volunteer-led or new belief bodies. Respondents raised concerns of disproportionate administrative burdens on these organisations, which may lack the required infrastructure to show compliance, impacting their ability to become authorised. “…we would ask the Scottish Government to consider the potential impact on smaller or newer belief bodies that may not yet have the administrative infrastructure to demonstrate compliance. Proportionality in the application of these requirements will be important to ensure they do not inadvertently create barriers to legitimate belief bodies seeking authorisation.” - OneSpirit Interfaith Foundation

Two respondents urged that the draft Impact Assessments have greater consideration of impacts on vulnerable groups and called for a stronger approach to safeguarding within the qualifying requirements. Scottish Women's Convention requested equality and intersectionality to be considered further, including for marginalised groups, low-income households and women. An individual felt that safeguarding, including forced marriage and coercion training, was not sufficiently considered in the draft Impact Assessment.

Calls for greater consistency across all types of celebrants were made by two respondents, as opposed to focusing on belief. Other singular comments included:

  • Considering diverse organisational models and belief structures within the Equalities Impact Assessment.
  • Ensuring proportionate transition support is provided.

Q16. Do you have any other comments on the Qualifying Requirements? If yes, please outline these comments.

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % No Answer
All respondents 124 13 32 55
All answering 56 29 71 -

Among all respondents, 13% indicated at the closed question that they had other comments on the Qualifying Requirements.

Further comments on qualifying requirements were made by one in six of all respondents at Q16. The most prevalent views were positive comments on the qualifying requirements and suggested amendments to support their implementation.

Positive comments on the qualifying requirements

Some respondents welcomed the introduction of qualifying requirements, particularly as they felt they could enhance public confidence in marriage solemnisation and civil partnership registration processes. One respondent felt the requirements could help couples make informed decisions. Respondents also indicated their willingness to meet the suggested qualifying requirements if they are put into place.

Two respondents commented on the consultation paper’s aim to address concerns about commercialism and profiting among celebrants. One respondent supported this aim; the other felt this meant there was insufficient focus on meaningfully shaping celebrant conduct.

“We note that there are some celebrants who appear to be conducting marriage celebrations for profit or gain, as evidenced by individuals seeking nomination (and winning) commercial awards for their services, and by anecdotal reports which requires parties to a marriage or civil partnership to become a member of a belief organisation. We support the attention that the consultation paper gives to this important matter.” - The Church of Scotland

“The central regulatory challenge is not belief or organisational legitimacy, but the risk that belief-based authorisation can become a commercially flexible licensing route with limited substantive constraints on celebrant conduct.” - Caledonian Humanist Association

Implementation suggestions

A few respondents highlighted the ongoing need to prevent forced marriage, abuse, sham marriages, and support safeguarding, such as through training. Two respondents requested consultation and collaboration on future development of these proposals. Singular comments on areas to improve included:

  • Providing more clarity for couples on authorisation processes and belief framework impact on ceremonies.
  • Ensuring accessibility of the system and support for small and diversely structured belief bodies. The same respondent called for proportionality, transparency in monitoring, clearly defined terms, and relevant guidance.
  • Providing greater engagement and openness about the process to meet qualifying requirements.

Concerns and considerations

Some respondents emphasised the need for enforcement to support compliance with the qualifying requirement. Respondents called for inspections, reviews, and policing by National Records of Scotland to ensure legal compliance of the requirements and reporting of non-compliance.

“It's all very well setting requirements, but there needs to be means of ensuring compliance. There should be a requirement to evidence ongoing compliance, perhaps by annual inspection or internal review of practice.” - Individual

A small number of respondents requested greater freedom of religious and belief bodies. This included recognising the diversity in these bodies, respect for their role, maintenance of church spiritual independence, and a request for little state involvement.

Other comments

A range of comments non-specific to this question were made, including:

  • Regarding the current 1977 Marriage Act as out of date, given changes in Scotland’s religious belief prevalence, and the current roles of celebrants. The same respondent requested that celebrants receive salaries that cover relevant training and insurance as part of the profession, which they wanted to be regulated.

They referenced Australia’s regulatory approach as an example of this.

  • Considering a requirement for universal civil marriage as the only legal form of Scottish marriage, which is regulated by the government. The respondent noted its implementation in European countries to separate marriage from religious or belief based bodies. They felt it would support better consistency, legal standards being upheld, protections, and address unregulated for-profit ceremonies occurring.
  • Ensuring qualifying requirements adequately safeguard through authorisation of bodies that implement Scottish law, and support equality, consent, and minimum age limits for marriage.
  • One respondent called for standards that are enforceable, allow for clear commercial practices, and allow the removal of authorisations for not meeting the standards.

Contact

Email: family.law@gov.scot

Back to top