Cash-First Programme: interim evaluation - updated
Interim findings from a process and impact evaluation of the Scottish Government's Cash-First Programme. The Programme supports new local partnership work to deliver Cash-First interventions across eight delivery partner areas.
Appendix 4: Data Collection and Research Questions
RQ1. Process: Has the Programme been implemented and delivered as intended?
Governance and collaborative working sub-questions |
Data Collection Methods |
Cohort |
|---|---|---|
In what ways has partnership working between different organisations been facilitated? |
Interviews |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders Learning Partner |
How were interventions decided on? |
Interviews |
Delivery Partners |
How were resources and responsibilities allocated/divided? |
Interviews |
Delivery Partners |
Do Partnerships have the resources and information they need to deliver cash-first solutions? How has this changed over the life of the project? |
Interviews |
Delivery Partners |
What are the differences in delivery approach between different areas? |
Interviews Desk research Document review |
Delivery Partners Learning Partner Stakeholders |
To what extent does local context affect delivery? |
Interviews |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders |
Engagement sub-questions |
Data Collection Methods |
Cohort |
|---|---|---|
To what extent, and how, have people with direct experience of food insecurity been involved in the development and delivery of activities? |
Interviews |
Delivery Partners Service Beneficiaries Stakeholders |
How has the Learning Partner contributed to the development and delivery of activities? |
Interviews Document review |
Delivery Partners Learning Partner |
Do all partners understand and agree with the aims of the Programme? |
Interviews |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders |
Do wider stakeholders support the activities delivered? (this might include people and organisations who are not core Partnership members, but have an interest – for example, professionals who refer people to food banks or other third sector food aid providers) |
Interviews |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders |
Targeting sub-questions |
Data Collection Methods |
Cohort |
|---|---|---|
What groups, or people, have activities been designed to target, and how was this decided? |
Interviews Document review |
Delivery Partners Learning Partner Stakeholders |
What measures have been taken to reach groups of people for whom there may be barriers to accessing support? |
Interviews Focus groups Survey |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders Service beneficiaries |
Did the activities succeed in reaching those targeted? What were the barriers/enablers encountered? |
Interviews Survey Quarterly data returns |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders Service beneficiaries Non-users of the service |
Use of data and knowledge sub-questions |
Data Collection Methods |
Cohort |
|---|---|---|
To what extent do Partnerships use data and evidence to inform their cash-first activities? |
Interviews Document review |
Delivery Partners Learning Partner |
Are there appropriate monitoring and evaluation processes in place, and how have data sources and measurement methods been determined? |
Interviews Document review |
Delivery Partners Learning Partner |
RQ2. Outputs: What has been produced as a result of the Programme?
Outputs produced sub-questions |
Data Collection Methods |
Cohort |
|---|---|---|
What cash-first initiatives are being developed or improved as part of the Programme? |
Interviews |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders |
What are the strengths and limitations of different cash-first initiatives? |
Interviews Survey Document review |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders Service beneficiaries Learning Partner |
What new or improved processes have been implemented? For example – processes for involving those with direct experience, or processes that enable partnership working? |
Interviews Document review |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders Service beneficiaries Learning Partner |
What resources have been produced to enable learning across the Programme? |
Interviews |
Delivery Partners |
RQ3. Impact/outcomes: What difference has the Programme made and for whom?
Collaborative working sub-questions |
Data Collection Methods |
Cohort |
|---|---|---|
What effect has the Programme had on ways of working between partners? |
Interviews Document review Quarterly data returns |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders Learning Partner |
To what extent has the work of the Learning Partner informed approaches to partnership working? |
Interviews Document review |
Delivery Partners Learning Partner |
What are the long-term prospects for relationships between partners? |
Interviews |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders |
Accessing Support sub-questions |
Data Collection Methods |
Cohort |
|---|---|---|
To what extent has the Programme improved access to cash-first responses? |
Interviews Document review Longitudinal research Survey Quarterly data returns |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders Service beneficiaries |
To what extent have people taken up cash-first responses? (Are there factors that inhibit take-up?) |
Interviews Survey Quarterly data returns |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders Service beneficiaries |
To what extent have people taken up wider support (e.g. money advice or employment services)? |
Interviews Survey Quarterly data returns |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders Service beneficiaries |
To what extent have these activities impacted on food bank referrals? |
Interviews Survey Longitudinal research Quarterly data returns Focus group |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders Service beneficiaries Non-users of cash-first services |
To what extent have outcomes varied for different groups of people and why? |
Interviews Survey Longitudinal research |
Delivery Partners Service beneficiaries |
Wellbeing sub-questions |
Data Collection Methods |
Cohort |
|---|---|---|
To what extent are people satisfied with the support they have received? (greater dignity, increased choice etc.) |
Interviews Consultation |
Service beneficiaries |
Are there other wellbeing benefits that can be attributed to the provision of cash-first support? |
Interviews Consultation Longitudinal research Focus groups |
Service beneficiaries Non-users of Cash-First services |
Objectives and Sustainability sub-questions |
Data Collection Methods |
Cohort |
|---|---|---|
To what extent were the activities appropriately designed? |
Interviews |
Service beneficiaries Stakeholders Delivery Partners |
Is there evidence that the activities increased the food security of those supported? |
Interviews Quarterly data returns Longitudinal research |
Service beneficiaries Delivery partners |
Can the actions undertaken as part of the Programme be sustained beyond the timeframe of the Programme? |
Interviews Document review |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders Learning Partner |
Can the outcomes be sustained in the longer-term? |
Interviews Document review |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders Learning Partner |
Were there any unintended consequences (positive or negative)? |
Interviews Survey Longitudinal research Document review |
Delivery Partners Stakeholders Service beneficiaries Learning Partner |
Contact
Email: socialresearch@gov.scot