This report provides a summary of the discussion from the Care Home Data Review Workshop, held online on 14 March 2023. The aim of the workshop was to discuss the experiences of providers and users of care home data, looking across all national care home data collections.
The majority of the workshop consisted of interactive sessions intended to capture data uses, issues, potential improvements and prioritisation. The topics covered in these sessions were:
Session 1 - How can we improve the accessibility and insight from the care home data currently available?
Session 2 - What are the most important questions that need to be answered relating to care homes and do we have the data to answer these?
Session 3 - How do we prioritise changes/improvements to both reduce the number of collections & ensure maximum benefit for data users & providers?
Session 4 - What are the needs of care homes/service providers with regard to data for planning and delivering good quality care?
The workshop had over 110 people in attendance, both data providers and users, from a range of organisations:
- of the 94 participants who answered the question “What type of organisation do you work for or represent?”, 35 (37%) worked for a Health and Social Care Partnership (HSCP); 19 (20%) worked for one of the following 3 main public sector organisations in Scotland (Scottish Government, Care Inspectorate and Public Health Scotland), while 16 (17%) worked for a care home or care home organisation
- of the 126 people who signed up, 31% were data users, 20% data providers, and 46% both provided and used data. (3% did not answer this question)
- a majority of participants came from the Central Belt, although there were a few from Aberdeenshire, Dumfries and Galloway and the Highlands and Islands
This document summarises the comments provided & issues raised in the workshop, together with possible solutions suggested by participants. These issues and suggested solutions are quotes or paraphrases of workshop participants’ views, so do not necessarily reflect the views of the Scottish Government or our delivery partners, nor are they an indication of practicality. Please note that this list of issues and solutions may not be complete, but simply reflects the views we heard on the day.
In summarising, we have pulled comments together under eight key themes. In some cases, a comment may cover a number of themes, but to avoid duplication will only be listed once.
We have mostly not indicated who made each comment, so the issues discussed below are a reflection of the collective challenges faced by a number of different data providers and users. It should be noted, however, that there will be variation of experience even among data providers & users (e.g. the issues faced by a care home may be very different to those faced by an HSCP).
Finally, by its very nature, the document only focusses on challenges and possible solutions; it does not reflect areas where the systems currently work well for data providers and users.
If you have any questions about the contents of this document, please contact the Care Home Data Review team at SWStat@gov.scot
There is a problem
Thanks for your feedback