Small Hive Beetle and Tropilaelaps mite: contingency plan
This plan sets out the role of the Scottish Government in response to a suspected or confirmed outbreak of Small Hive Beetle (SHB) or Tropilaelaps mite in Scotland: the actions to be taken as well as governance, roles and responsibilities.
Official Action on Confirmation
Establishment of Statutory Infected Areas (SIAs) and Movement Restrictions
27. If Scottish Ministers are satisfied that SHB or Tropilaelaps mite (as notifiable pests) are present, they may issue a notice under article 10 of the Bee Disease and Pest Control (Scotland) Order 2007 declaring an infected area. The notice may state that some or all of the rules listed in the Schedule to the Order will apply to all or part of the infected area (including movement restrictions), if the Scottish Ministers consider this is necessary to stop the notifiable pest from spreading.
28. The notice(s) will define precise boundaries and will be published on the Scottish Government’s website, BeeBase and elsewhere as appropriate.
29. To enable the efficient and timely issuing of an SIA, a template has been agreed with Legal.
Small Hive Beetle:
30. Based on current knowledge of the dispersal of SHB, it is anticipated that a SIA will initially cover a minimum 16km radius around the location of the initial credible sighting on the grounds that the SHB is likely to be present in this area. The infected area may be altered and enlarged as circumstances change, or new infected areas may be declared.
Tropilaelaps mite:
31. For Tropilaelaps mites, it is also anticipated that the SIA will initially cover a minimum radius of 16km, but inspections will initially be prioritised within a radius of 5km. All apiaries within the designated SIA will be subject to movement restrictions, which will be clearly detailed in the statutory notice declaring the infected area.
Operational activity
32. This next section of the Contingency Plan sets out an overview of the processes and governance of the search, identification, confirmation, co-ordination and response, and post-incident management.
33. It is triggered by either official confirmation from Science & Advice for Scottish Agriculture (“SASA”) (a division of the Scottish Government’s Agriculture and Rural Economy Directorate), of the presence of SHB or Tropilaelaps mite or an assessment that the information provided constitutes credible evidence of the presence of SHB or Tropilaelaps mite and requires further investigation.
34. SG Honey Bee Health Team will follow Standard Operating Procedures (“SOPs”) to ensure that operational activities are undertaken consistently and in line with agreed process.
35. Immediately on confirmation from SASA or agreement that the information or evidence confirms or strongly suggests a SHB or Tropilaelaps mite outbreak in Scotland, the following governance procedures will be implemented to manage and respond to the incident.
36. A flowchart summarising the actions taken is provided in Annex A.
Strategic
Pest-Specific Strategic Oversight Group
37. On confirmation of finding SHB or Tropilaelaps mite in Scotland, the SG Honey Bee Health Policy Team will convene the Pest-Specific Strategic Oversight Group (Oversight Group) and arrange an urgent meeting.
38. The Oversight Group will be chaired by the Senior Responsible Officer (SRO), in this case the Chief Veterinary Officer. Membership will include:
- Honey Bee Health Senior Veterinary Advisor.
- SG Honey Bee Health Policy Lead in their capacity as Incident Management Lead.
- Operational Response Team Leader
- SG Comms.
- Senior Entomologist at SASA.
- SG Animal Disease lead.
- SG Head of Area Office in the area concerned.
- others deemed appropriate.
39. The Honey Bee Health Policy Lead (hereafter the Incident Management Lead (IML) shall be responsible for the preparation of documentation for Oversight Group meetings, the execution of agreed recommendations, and the management of all strategic functions associated with the outbreak. The SRO, Incident Management Lead, Operational Response Team Lead, and Senior Veterinary Advisor for the outbreak will attend any ministerial meetings required.
Specific activities for the Oversight Group will include:
- Immediate actions: An Oversight Group meeting will be convened by the IML within 24 hours to agree the strategic approach and identify issues. The meeting will be chaired by the SRO for the incident.
- Determining a “battle rhythm” for the outbreak including frequency of Oversight Group meetings.
- Developing recommendations as necessary for Ministers on the strategic direction of response and control policies based on the advice of the Incident Management Team and scientific advice from SASA.
- Consider and provide sign off on the recommended action plan for the outbreak presented to the Group by the Incident Management Team, which will include whether eradication or containment should be pursued and agreeing priorities and when to establish/remove any Statutory Infected Areas (SIA’s)
- Considering the impacts of the outbreak, including on bumble bee and feral bees in the vicinity, and whether suspending exports is necessary.
- Agreeing communication and stakeholder engagement plans.
- Agreeing an official spokesperson for interviews with the media.
Planning
Pest-Specific Incident Management Team
40. A Pest-Specific Incident Management Team (Incident Management Team) will be established, led by the Honey Bee Health Policy Lead acting as Incident Management Lead.
The Incident Management Team will comprise:
- Scottish Chief Veterinary Officer (or Deputy).
- Honey Bee Health Veterinary Advisor.
- Honey Bee Health Delivery Lead.
- Honey Bee Health Team Deputy Lead Inspector
- SASA Senior Entomologist.
- SASA Entomology Manager.
- Deputy Head of Office in the area concerned.
- National Bee Unit representative.
41. The Incident Management Team is responsible for developing specific actions to deal with the outbreak, as directed by the Oversight Group.
The functions of the Incident Management Team include:
- Immediate actions: The Incident Management Lead will draw up the SIA with the help of the SG legal team. Dissemination of information to the public, beekeeping associations, and other stakeholders per the Communications Plan.
- Set up and providing secretariat to the Oversight Group meetings.
- Maintaining outbreak records/documents (e.g. action list, core briefing, event briefing, lessons identified).
- Gathering intelligence about the outbreak and providing advice and options on management and recommended actions to the Oversight Group.
- Identifying and securing additional resources as required to manage the incident.
- Applying for any necessary and additional funding required for the duration of the emergency, upon senior management request.
- establish and/or remove any SIAs.
- Liaising and communicating with SRUC, SG Bee Health Inspectors, beekeeping associations, and other relevant stakeholders, as appropriate, to ensure clarity of roles and responsibilities following activation of the contingency plan
42. The Incident Management Team will be convened immediately when a credible report has been confirmed to initiate the initial actions as set out in the Operational section of this Plan.
43. The Incident Management Team will convene daily or at such other frequency as is determined by the Oversight Group.
44. The Incident Management Team will note and distribute agreed actions from each Incident Management Team meeting allowing attendees to prepare appropriate comms and plan for next steps.
45. Using the templates in the Communications Plan, the Incident Management Team will notify Ministers that a finding of SHB or Tropilaelaps mite in Scotland is being investigated and that pre-agreed press lines will be issued.
46. The Incident Management Team will liaise with other Devolved Administrations to apprise of the outbreak and actions being taken.
Operational
Pest-Specific Operational Response Team
47. The Honey Bee Health Delivery Lead/Deputy will take on the role of Operational Response Team Lead in the event of any confirmed outbreak and will initiate actions appropriate to whether the incursion is isolated (e.g. Pest confirmed in two geographically separate apiaries that have been linked to known movement of bees, but no or very limited findings in surrounding apiaries – eradication is likely to be successful) or widespread (e.g. Pest confirmed in more than one geographically separate location and pest is present in multiple apiaries in each SIA. Especially if no known links between locations – eradication is unlikely to be successful) and to establish a Pest-Specific Operational Response Team (Operational Response Team).
48. The Operational Response Team Lead will set out specific actions for the outbreak, considering the ‘battle rhythm’ set by Oversight Group. The actions will be agreed by the Incident Management Team and signed off by the Oversight Group.
49. Specific activities of the Operational Response Team Lead will include:
- Directing and co-ordinating response measures, including determining areas and apiaries on which to concentrate surveillance, allocation of apiary searches and use of appropriate pest controls in line with Incident Management Team decision making.
- Providing regular local contact and support for personnel working in the field.
- Maintaining contact with, attend and provide reports on outcome of searches and incident progress information to the Incident Management Team.
- Providing information to local beekeeping associations and liaise with local associations who may be able to contact beekeepers to facilitate inspection arrangements.
50. Specific activities of the Operational Response Team will include:
- Conducting surveillance and apiary searches where SHB/Tropilaelaps mite was found.
- Providing daily sit reps and the outcome of searches to the Operational Response Team Lead.
- Use of pest controls as directed.
51. Based on the advice from the Operational Response Team Lead, the Incident Management Team will agree whether the outbreak is isolated (i.e., eradication is likely to be successful) and will develop a recommendation and action plan to present to the Oversight Group, where authorisation to proceed with eradication efforts will be sought.
Emergency Searches and Inspections
52. Based on intelligence from the Operational Response Team to establish the extent of the outbreak and, if possible, its source, the Operational Response Team Lead will recommend the size of the surveillance areas and priorities to the Incident Management Team for confirmation from the Oversight Group.
53. The NBU’s BeeBase database and Geographic Information Systems (GIS) will be used to enable searches to be targeted at all known apiaries initially within a 5km radius of the outbreak and subsequently widened out to cover the 16km radius of the SIA. This would also include apiaries that are identified through subsequent tracings e.g. any bee movements or sales of honey bees, hive products, and beekeeping equipment from the designated premises within the SIA.
54. The Operational Response Team Lead will arrange for teams of SG Bee Health Inspectors to be deployed to the outbreak area(s). They will seek to rapidly establish the extent of the outbreak and, if possible, its source. They will also establish if there are further primary infestations in the SIA or any secondary infestations further afield. Details of the inspection protocols are given in the SG’s SOPs.
55. The Oversight Group will confirm the appropriate policy on bumblebees and feral honey bee colonies, including whether suspending exports are necessary based on the circumstances of the outbreak. If colonies are found in close proximity to an infested hive this should be noted in the inspection report.
56. Follow-up inspections will be completed based on any information gathered by this process. Risk analysis will be an integral component of the emergency searches to predict potential spread from the point of entry and assist with targeted inspections.
57. An inspection report should be submitted by the field inspectors to the Operational Response Team Lead after each inspection; the forms are contained within the SOPs. The Operational Response Team Lead will update the Incident Management Team meeting.
Trace forward/backwards
58. SHB/ Tropilaelaps mites are likely to spread within the UK from movements of bees during the beekeeping season. The Operational Response Team will arrange inspections of bees which were moved from the SIA prior to discovery of the pest. Other countries will be notified of exports from the UK prior to the discovery of the pest. The SG will contact the CIT to establish if any exports have taken place.
Laboratory Diagnosis
59. Suspect samples sent by beekeepers or SG Bee Health Inspectors to SASA will undergo a confirmatory diagnosis. A report will be sent to affected beekeepers (copied to the Operational Response Team Lead) as soon as possible. Turnaround times and reporting will be reviewed if large numbers of samples are submitted. Any positive samples will be immediately reported to the Operational Response Team, and the Incident Management Team.
Isolated Outbreaks
60. After completion of the initial search, if the Incident Management Team considers that the outbreak is an isolated incident and eradication will be practicable, this may be attempted following consultation with the Oversight Group.
Widespread outbreak
61. If Bee Health Inspectors find several outbreaks across a large geographical area, the Operational Response Team Lead, in consultation with the Senior Responsible Officer, will make a recommendation to the Oversight Group regarding the likelihood of eradication and whether a policy of eradication or containment should be pursued. The Oversight Group will decide the outbreak strategy, where necessary consulting Ministers.
Decontamination/disposal
62. Whilst an eradication policy remains in place, all colonies that are infested or have been exposed to infestation and contain contaminated hive products in the affected area will be humanely euthanised and subsequently destroyed, normally by burning, in accordance with the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) for Decontamination and Disposal.
Emergency Pest Control: Product Treatment Availability
63. Currently, most medicaments available overseas to control many of the exotic pests and diseases of bees are not approved or available in the UK for general use in apiculture. This is due to the apiculture sector, particularly in the UK, being a relatively small market. In the event of an outbreak of SHB or Tropilaelaps mite, SG policy, on advice from Operational Management Lead, will apply to the HSE to use treatment considered appropriate to control or treat affected colonies and the surrounding area.
64. Integrated Pest Management (IPM) techniques will also be advocated as the best approach to control the pest. Details of current methods are available in advisory leaflets on the BeeBase website.
Treatment Schedules
65. As SHB has only been subjected to intensive scientific study for a comparatively short time, there are still significant gaps in the understanding of many aspects of its biology and habits. So far, chemical measures to control SHB have not been fully effective and are considered short-term measures. The use of nematodes as a soil treatment is being studied.
66. Tropilaelaps mite can be controlled using miticides (which have been registered by the Veterinary Medicines Directorate) combined with IPM methods.
67. Appropriate precautions as defined in the Special Treatment Certificates will be taken with any medicaments approved by the VMD to control SHB or Tropilaelaps mites in the hive. This is to prevent the risk of possible contamination of honey and other hive products. In such cases, it may be necessary in an emergency to place storage restrictions on the use of harvested honey or other hive products from treated colonies, to allow time for residues to break down before consumption or sale. In such instances, SG will inform Food Standards Scotland (FSS) of any additional controls placed on harvested honey or hive products subsequently intended for human consumption.
68. Operational instructions to carry out the detailed requirements of this contingency plan are set out in the SG’s SOPs. Parallel and separate Control of Substances Hazardous to Health (COSHH) and health and safety assessments will be produced where appropriate. The SG reviews and revises SOPs as a minimum bi-annually.
Contact
Email: Bees_mailbox@gov.scot