Publication - Progress report

Scottish Marine and Freshwater Science Volume 5 Number 16:The Avoidance Rates of Collision Between Birds and Offshore Turbines

Published: 3 Dec 2014
Part of:
Marine and fisheries

This study reviewed data that have been collected from offshore windfarms and considers how they can be used to derive appropriate avoidance rates for use in the offshore environment.

Scottish Marine and Freshwater Science Volume 5 Number 16:The Avoidance Rates of Collision Between Birds and Offshore Turbines


Able, K.P. 1982. Skylight polarization patterns at dusk influence migratory orientation in birds. Nature 299, 550-551.

Alerstam, T., Rosén, M., Bäckman, J., Ericson, P.G.P. & Hellgren, O. 2007. Flight Speeds among Bird Species: Allometric and Phylogenetic Effects. PLoS Biol 5, e197. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.0050197

Alexander, D.E. 2004. Nature's flyers: Birds, Insects and the biomechanics of flight. JHU Press, Baltimore.

Arnqvist, G. & Wooster, D. 1995. Meta-analysis: synthesizing research findings in ecology and evolution. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 10, 236-240.

Band, W. 2000. Guidance WINDFARMS AND BIRDS: calculating a theoretical collision risk assuming no avoidance action. Guidance notes series 2000. Scottish Natural Heritage, Battleby.

Band, W., Madders, M., & Whitfield, D.P. 2007. Developing field and analytical methods to assess avian collision risk at wind farms. In: de Lucas, M., Janss, G.F.E. & Ferrer, M. (eds.) Birds and Wind farms: Risk Assessment and Mitigation, pp. 259-275. Quercus, Madrid

Band, W. 2012. Using a collision risk to assess bird collision risk for offshore wind farms. Report to SOSS. .

Banks, A.N., Burton, N.H.K., Austin, G.E., Carter, N., Chamberlain, D.E., Holt, C., Rehfisch, M.M., Wakefield, E. & Gill, P. 2005. The potential effects on birds of the Greater Gabbard Offshore Wind farm Report for February 2004 to March 2005, BTO Research Report No. 419.

Barrios, L. & Rodríguez, A. 2004. Behavioural and environmental correlates of soaring-bird mortality at on-shore wind turbines. Journal of Applied Ecology 41, 72-81.

Batschelet, E. 1976. Introduction to Mathematics for Life Scientists. Springer-Verlag, Berlin.

Beatrice Offshore Wind farm Ltd. 2012. Beatrice Offshore Wind farm Environmental Statement.

Bernardino, J., Bispo, R., Torres, P., Rebelo, R., Mascarenhas, M., & Costa, H. 2011. Enhancing carcass removal trials at three wind energy facilities in Portugal. Wildlife Biology in Practice, 7, 1-14.

Bevanger, K. 1994. Bird interactions with utility structures: collision and electrocution, causes and mitigating measures. Ibis 136, 412-425.

Blew, J., Hoffmann, M., Nehls, G. & Hennig, V. 2008. Investigations of the bird collision risk and the response of harbour porpoises in the offshore wind farms Horns Rev, North Sea and Nysted, Baltic Sea, in Denmark. Part 1: Birds.

Bodey, T. W., Jessopp, M. J., Votier, S. C., Gerritsen, H. D., Cleasby, I. R., Hamer, K. C., Patrick, S. C., Wakefield, E. D. & Bearhop, S. 2014. Seabird movement reveals the ecological footprint of fishing vessels. Current Biology, 24, R514-R515.

Brooke, M. D. L., Hanley, S., & Laughlin, S. B. 1999. The scaling of eye size with body mass in birds. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences 266, 405-412.

Brown, W.K. & B.L. Hamilton. 2004. Bird and bat monitoring at the McBride Lake Wind farm, Alberta, 2003-2004. Unpublished report prepared for Vision Quest Windelectric, Calgary, AB.

Brown, W.K. & B.L. Hamilton. 2006. Bird and bat interactions with wind turbines, Castle River Wind farm, Alberta, 2003-2004. Unpublished report prepared for Vision Quest Windelectric, Calgary, AB.

Buckland, S.T., Anderson, D.R., Burnham, K.P., Laake, J.L., Borchers, D.L. & Thomas, L. 2001. Introduction to Distance Sampling. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Buckland, S.T., Burt, M.L., Rexstad, E.A., Mellor, M., Williams, A.E. & Woodward, R. 2012. Aerial surveys of seabirds: the advent of digital methods. Journal of Applied Ecology 49, 960-967.

Bundesamt fur Seeschiffart und Hydrographie ( BSH). 2011. Okologische Begleitforshung bei alha ventus erste Ergebnisse (Environmental research at alpha ventus - first results). Contributions from the Event of 10 May 2010, Katholische Akademie Hamburg.

Burton, N.H.K., Thaxter, C.B., Cook, A.S.C.P., Austin, G.E., Humphreys, E.M., Johnston, A., Morrison, C.A., Wright, L.J. 2013. Ornithology Technical Report for the Proposed Dogger Bank Creyke Beck Offshore Wind farm Projects, BTO Research Report 630, Thetford.

Camphuysen, C.J., Calvo, B., Durinck, J., Ensor, K., Follestad, A., Furness, R. W., Garthe, S., Leaper, G., Skov, H., Tasker, M. L. & Winter, C. J. N., 1995. Consumption of discards by seabirds in the North Sea. Final Report of EC DG XIV Research Contract BIOECO/93/10. NIOZ-Report 1995-5, Netherlands Institute for Sea Research, Texel. 202 pp.

Camphuysen, C.J. & Garthe, S. 2004. Recording foraging seabirds at sea. Standardised recording and coding of foraging behaviour and multi-species foraging associations. Atlantic Seabirds 6, 1-32.

Camphuysen, C.J., Fox, A.D., Leopold, M.F., & Petersen, I.K. 2004. Towards standardised seabirds at sea census techniques in connection with environmental impact assessments for offshore wind farms in the UK A comparison of ship and aerial sampling methods for marine birds, and their applicability to offshore wind farm assessments. Koninklijk Nederlands Instituut voor Onderzoek der Zee Report commissioned by COWRIE.

Centrica Energy. 2007. Lincs Offshore Wind farm Environmental Statement. Centrica Energy, Uxbridge.

Centrica Energy. 2009. Race Bank Offshore Wind farm Environmental Statement.

Centrica Energy. 2012. Irish Sea Zone: Zonal Appraisal and Planning ( ZAP) Report. A strategic approach to the identification of Potential Areas for Development within the Irish Sea Zone.

Chamberlain, D., Freeman, S., Rehfisch, M., Fox, T. & Desholm, M. 2005. Appraisal of Scottish Natural Heritage's wind farm collision risk model and its application. BTO Research Report 401. British Trust for Ornithology, Thetford.

Chamberlain, D.E., Rehfisch, M.R., Fox. T., Desholm, M. & Anthony, S.J. 2006. The effect of avoidance rates on bird mortality predictions made by wind turbine collision risk models. Ibis 148 (Suppl. 1), 198-202.

Channel Energy Ltd. 2013. Atlantic Array Offshore Wind farm Environmental Statement. .

Christensen, T.K., Clausager, I. & Petersen, I.K. 2003. Base-line investigations of birds in relation to an offshore wind farm at Horns Rev, and results from the year of construction. Commissioned report to Tech-wise A/S. National Environmental Research Institute.

Christensen, T.K., Hounisen, J.P., Clausager, I. & Petersen, I.K. 2004 . Visual and radar observations of birds in relation to collision risk at the Horns Rev offshore wind farm. Annual status report 2003. Commissioned report to Elsam Engineering A/S. National Environmental Research Institute.

Cochran, W.G. 1977. Sampling Techniques, 3 rd Edition. John Wiley New York.

Collier, M.P., Dirksen, S. & Krijgsveld, K.L. 2011a. A review of methods to monitor collisions or micro-avoidance of birds with offshore wind turbines: Part 1 Review. Strategic Ornithological Support Services Project SOSS-03A, Bureau Waardenburg, Culemborg, the Netherlands.

Collier, M.P., Dirksen, S. & Krijgsveld, K.L. 2011b. A review of methods to monitor collisions or micro-avoidance of birds with offshore wind turbines: Part 2 Feasibility study of systems to monitor collisions. Strategic Ornithological Support Services Project SOSS-03A, Bureau Waardenburg, Culemborg, the Netherlands.

Cook, A.S.C.P., Johnston, A., Wright, L.J. & Burton, N.H.K. 2012. A review of flight heights and avoidance rates of birds in relation to offshore wind farms. Strategic Ornithological Support Services Project SOSS-02. BTO Research Report Number 618. BTO, Thetford.

Cook, A.S.C.P., Ross-Smith, V.H., Roos, S., Burton, N.H.K., Beale, N., Coleman, C., Daniel, H., Fitzpatrick, S., Rankin, E., Norman, K. & Martin, G. 2011. Identifying a range of options to prevent or reduce avian collision with offshore wind farms, using a UK-based case study. BTO Research Report No. 580 to Defra. British Trust for Ornithology, Thetford.

Corman, A. M., & Garthe, S. 2014. What flight heights tell us about foraging and potential conflicts with wind farms: a case study in Lesser Black-backed Gulls (Larus fuscus). Journal of Ornithology, 155, 1037-1043.

Crawford, R.I. 1981. Weather, migration and autumn bird kills at a north Florida TV tower. Wilson Bulletin 93, 189-195.

Davies, I., Finlay, A., Cole, E. & Alcock, P. 2013. Avoidance behaviour at offshore wind farms: a new joint industry approach. BOU Proceedings - Marine Renewables and Birds.

de Lucas, M., Ferrer, M. & Janss, G. F. E. 2012. Using wind tunnels to predict bird mortality in wind farms: The case of griffon vultures. PLoS ONE 7, e48092. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0048092.

Desholm, M. 2005. TADS investigations of avian collision risk at Nysted offshore wind farm, autumn 2004. NERI, Denmark

Desholm, M. 2006. Wind farm related mortality among avian migrants - a remote sensing study and model analysis. PhD University of Copenhagen.

Desholm, M., Fox, A.D., Beasley, P.D.L., Kahlert, J. 2006. Remote techniques for counting and estimating the number of bird-wind turbine collisions at sea: a review. Ibis 148, 76-89.

Desholm, M. & Kahlert, J. 2005. Avian collision risk at an offshore wind farm. Biology Letters 1: 296-298.

Devereux, C. L., Denny, M. J. H. & Whittingham, M. J. 2008. Minimal effects of wind turbines on the distribution of wintering farmland birds. Journal of Applied Ecology 45, 1689-1694.

Dokter, A. M., Liechti, F., Stark, H., Delobbe, L., Tabary, P., & Holleman, I. 2011. Bird migration flight altitudes studied by a network of operational weather radars. Journal of the Royal Society Interface, 8, 30-43.

DONG Energy. 2009. Westernmost Rough Offshore Windfarm, DONG Energy, Copenhagen

DONG Energy. 2013. Walney Extension Offshore Wind Farm Environmental Statement. .

DONG Energy. 2013. Burbo Bank Extension Offshore Wind Farm Environmental Statement, .

Douglas, D.J.T., Follestad, A., Langston, R.H.W. & Pearce-Higgins, J.W. 2012. Modelled sensitivity of avian collision rate at wind turbines varies with number of hours of flight activity input data. Ibis 154, 858-861.

Dulac, P. 2008. Evaluation de l'impact du parc eolian de Bouin (Vendee) sur l'avifaune et les chauves-souris. Bilan de 5 anness de suivi. Ligue pour la Protection des Oiseaux, Nantes.

East Anglia Wind. 2012. East Anglia One Offshore Wind farm .

ECON. 2009. Ornithological assessment of the Dudgeon Offshore Wind farm: Technical Report, ECON Ecology, Norwich.

EDF Energy (Northern Offshore Wind) Ltd. 2004. Teesside Offshore Wind farm Environmental Statement. EDF Energy - NOWL, Sunderland .

Eichhorn, M., Johst, K., Seppelt, R. & Drechsler, M. 2012. Model-based estimation of collision risks of predatory birds with wind turbines. Ecology & Society 17: 1.

EON. 2012. Rampion Offshore Wind farm Environmental Statement. .

Everaert, J. 2003. Windturbines en vogels in Vlaanderen: voorlopige onderzoeksresultaten en aanbevelingen. Natuur Oriolus 69, 145-155.

Everaert, J. 2008. Effecten van windturbines op de fauna in Vlaanderen. Onderzoeks resultaten, discussie en aanbevelingen. Rapporten van het Instituut voor Natuur- en Bosonderzoek, Brussels. Rapport INBO.R.2008.44.

Everaert, J. 2014. Collision risk and micro-avoidance rates of birds with wind turbines in Flanders. Bird Study 61, 220-230.

Everaert, J., Devos, K. & Kuijken, E. 2002. Windturbines en vogels in Vlaanderen: Voorlopige onderzoeksreultaten en buitenlandse bevindingen [Wind turbines and birds in Flanders (Belgium): Preliminary study results in a European context]. Instituut voor Natuurbehoud, Report R. 2002.03, Brussels.

Everaert, J. & Kuijken, E. 2007. Wind turbines and birds in Flanders (Belgium). Preliminary summary of the mortality research results. Research Institute for Nature and Forest, Brussels.

Everaert, J. & Stienen, E.W.M. 2006. Impact of wind turbines on birds in Zeebrugge (Belgium). Significant effect on breeding tern colony due to collisions. Biodiversity Conservation 16, 3345-3359.

Everaert, J. & Stienen, E.W.M. 2007. Impact of wind turbines on birds in Zeebrugge (Belgium) Significant effect on breeding tern colony due to collisions. Biodiversity and Conservation 16, 3345-3359.

Fernley, J., Lowther, S. & Whitfield, P. 2006. A review of goose collisions at operating wind farms and estimation of the goose avoidance rate. Natural Research Ltd.

Furness, R.W. Wade, H.M., Masden, E.A. 2013. Assessing vulnerability of marine bird populations to offshore wind farms. Journal of Environmental Management 119, 56-66

Garthe, S. & Hüppop, O. 1994. Distribution of ship-following seabirds and their utilization of discards in the North Sea in summer. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 106, 1-9

Garthe, S. & Hüppop, O. 2004. Scaling possible adverse effects of marine wind farms on seabirds: developing and applying a vulnerability index. Journal of Applied Ecology 41, 724-734.

Garvin, J.C., Jennelle, C.S., Drake, D. & Grodsky, S.M. 2011. Response of raptors to a windfarm. Journal of Applied Ecology, 48, 199-209.

Gauthreaux, S.A., Jr. 1991. The flight behavior of migrating birds in changing wind fields: Radar and visual analyses. American Zoologist 31, 187-204.

GoBe Consultants Ltd. 2012. Gunfleet Sands Offshore Wind farm I & II - Post Construction Year 2 - Marine Licence Environmental Monitoring Report. Prepared for DONG Energy.

Global Renewable Energy Partners. 2002. Kentish Flats Offshore Wind farm. Global Renewable Energy Partners, Egham

Grünkorn, T. , Diederichs, A., Poszig, D., Diederichs, B. & Nehls, G. 2009. Wie viele Vögel kollidieren mit Windenergieanlagen? Natur und Landschaft 7, 309-314.

Gurevitch, J. & Hedges, L.V.1999. Statistical issues in ecological meta-analyses. Ecology 80, 1142-1149.

Hamer, K.C., Humphreys, E.M., Magalhaes, M.C., Garthe, S., Hennicke, J., Peters, G., Grémillet, D., & Wanless, S. 2009. Fine-scale foraging behaviour of a medium-ranging marine predator. Journal of Animal Ecology 78, 880-889.

Hamer, K.C., Monaghan, P., Uttley, J.D., Walton, P. & Burns, M.D. 1993. The influence of food supply on the breeding ecology of kittiwakes Rissa tridactyla in Shetland. Ibis 135, 255-263

Hartman, J,C., Krijgsveld. K.L., Poot, M.J.M., Fijn. R.C., Leopold, M.F., and Dirksen, S. 2012. Effects of birds of Offshore Wind farm Egmond aan Zee ( OWEZ)- An overview and intergration of insights obtained. Bureau Waardenburg BV.

Henderson, I.G., Langston, R.H.W. & Clark, N.A. 1996. The response of Common Terns Sterna hirundo to power lines: an assessment of risk in relation to breeding commitment, age and wind speed. Biological Conservation 77, 185-192.

Holmstrom, L. , Hamer, T. E., Colclazier, E., Denis, N., Ruché, D. & Verschuyl, J. 2011. Assessing avian-turbine collision risk: an approach angle dependent model. Wind Engineering 35, 289-312.

Howe, R.W., Evans, W. & Wolf, A.T. 2002. Effects of wind turbines on birds and bats in northeastern Wisconsin. Report to Wisconsin Public Service Corporation and Madison Gas and Electric Company.

Howell, J.A. 1997. Avian Mortality at Rotor Swept Area Equivalents, Altamont Pass and Montezuma Hills, California. Transactions of the Western Section of the Wildlife Society 33, 24-29.

Hull Innogy. 2002. North Hoyle Offshore Wind farm Environmental Statement.

IECS. 2007 Collision Risk Assessment: Humber Gateway Offshore Wind farm, IECS.

Inger, R., Attrill, M.J., Bearhop, S., Broderick, A.C., Grecian, W.J., Hodgson, D.J., Mills, C., Sheehan, E., Votier, S.C., Witt, M.J. & Godley, B.J. 2009. Marine renewable energy: potential benefits to biodiversity? An urgent call for research. Journal of Applied Ecology 46, 1145-1153.

Jackson, D. & Whitfield, P. 2011. Guidance on survey and monitoring in relation to marine renewables deployments in Scotland, volume 4. birds. Technical report, Scottish Natural Heritage and Marine Scotland.

Janoska, F. 2012. Investigations of Bird Collisions in 2 Wind farms. International Scientific Conference on Sustainable Development & Ecological Footprint, Sopron, Hungary, March 26-27 2012.

Johnson, G.D., Erickson, W.P., Strickland, M.D., Shepherd, M.F., Shepherd, D.A. 2000. Avian Monitoring Studies at The Buffalo Ridge, Minnesota Wind Resource Area: Results of a 4-year study. Western EcoSystems Technology Inc., Wyoming.

Johnston, A., Cook, A.S.C.P., Wright, L.J., Humphreys, E.M. & Burton, N.H.K. 2014a. Modelling flight heights of marine birds to more accurately assess collision risk with offshore wind turbines. Journal of Applied Ecology 51, 31-41.

Johnston, A., Cook, A.S.C.P., Wright, L.J., Humphreys, E.M. & Burton, N.H.K. 2014b. Corrigendum. Journal of Applied Ecology doi: 10.1111/1365-2664.12260

Kahlert, J., Petersen, I. K., Fox, A. D., Desholm, M. & Clausager, I. 2004. Investigations of birds during construction and operation of Nysted offshore wind farm at Rødsand. Annual status report 2003. National Environmental Research Institute ( NERI) Kalø, Denmark.

Kolios, S. 2009. Quantification of the movement characteristics of Lesser Black-backed Gull (Larus fuscus), using high resolution GPS measurements. MSc. Thesis, University of Amsterdam

Komdeur, J., Bertelsen, J. & Cracknell, G. (eds) 1992. Manual for aeroplane and ship surveys of waterfowl and seabirds. IWRB Special Publ. No. 19, National Environmental Research Institute Kalø.

Krijgsveld, K.L., Akershoek, K., Schenk, F., Dijk, F. & Dirksen, S. 2009. Collision risk of birds with modern large wind turbines. Ardea 97: 357-366.

Krijgsveld, K.L., Fijn, R.C., Japink, M., van Horssen, P.W., Heunks, C., Collier, M.P., Poot, M.J.M., Beuker, D. & Dirksen, S. 2011. Effect Studies Offshore Wind farm Egmond aan Zee. Final report on fluxes, flight altitudes and behaviour of flying bird. Bureau Waardenburg report 10-219, NZW-ReportR_231_T1_flu&flight. Bureau Waardenburg, Culemborg, Netherlands.

Kubetzki, U., & Garthe, S. 2003. Distribution, diet and habitat selection by four sympatrically breeding gull species in the south-eastern North Sea. Marine Biology, 143, 199-207.

Larkin, G.P. & Thompson, D. 1980. Flight speeds of birds observed with radar: evidence for two phases of migratory flight. Behavioral Ecology & Sociobiology 7: 301-317.

Lawrence, E.S., Painter, S. & Little, B. 2007. Responses of birds to the wind farm at Blyth Harbour, Northumberland, UK. In: de Lucas, M., Janss, G.F.E., Ferrer, M. 2007. Birds and Wind farms Risk Assessment and Mitigation, Quercus, Madrid.

Leopold, M.F., Camphuysen, C.J., van Lieshout, S.M.J., ter Braak, C.J.F. & Dijkman, E.M. 2004. Baseline studies North Sea wind farms: Lot 5 marine birds in and around the future site Nearshore Windfarm (NSW). Alterra-rapport 1047.

Leopold, M.F., Dijkman, E.M. & Teal, L. 2011. Local birds in and around the Offshore Wind farm Egmond aan Zee ( OWEZ) (T-0 & T-1, 2002-2010). NoordzeeWind report OWEZ_R_221_T1_20110915_localbirds_final. Imares / NoordzeeWind, Wageningen / IJmuiden.

Lincs Wind farm Ltd. 2010. LID6 Environmental Statement, Lincs Wind farm Ltd.

Lindeboom, H.J., Kouwenhoven, H.J., Bergman, M J.N., Bouma, S., Brasseur, S. Daan, R., Fijn, R.C., de Haan, D., Dirksen, S., van Hal, R., Hille Ris Lambers, R., ter Hofstede, R., Krijgsveld, K.L., Leopold, M. & Scheidat, M. 2011. Short-term ecological effects of an offshore windfarm in the Dutch coastal zone; a compilation. Environmental Research Letters 6: .

Maar, M., Bolding, K., Petersen, J.K., Hansen, J.L.S. & Timmermann, K. 2009. Local effects of blue mussels around turbine foundations in an ecosystem model of Nysted off-shore wind farm, Denmark. Journal of Sea Research 62, 159-174.

MacArthur Green. 2012. Note to support the use of a 99% avoidance rate for the Beatrice Offshore Wind farm collision risk modelling, MacArthur Green Ltd., Glasgow.

Mackenzie, M.L, Scott-Hayward, L.A.S., Oedekoven, C.S., Skov, H., Humphreys, E. & Rexstad E. 2013. Statistical modelling of seabird and cetacean data: guidance document. University of St. Andrews contract for Marine Scotland.

MacLean, I.M.D., Wright, L.J., Showler, D.A. & Rehfisch, M.M. 2009. A review of assessment methodologies for offshore wind farms. Report commissioned by COWRIE Ltd.

Maclean, I.M.D., Rehfisch, M.M., Skov, H. & Thaxter, C.B. 2013. Evaluating the statistical power of detecting changes in the abundance of seabirds at sea. Ibis 155, 113-126.

Madsen, J., & Boertmann, D. 2008. Animal behavioral adaptation to changing landscapes: spring-staging geese habituate to wind farms. Landscape ecology 23, 1007-1011.

Mainstream Renewable Power. 2012. Neart na Gaoithe Environmental Statement.

Martin, G. R. 2010. Bird collisions: a visual or perceptual problem? BOU Proceedings - Climate Change and Birds.

Martin, G.R. 2011. Understanding bird collisions with man-made objects: a sensory ecology approach. Ibis 153, 239-254.

Martin, G.R. & Shaw, J.M. 2010. Bird collisions with power lines: Failing to see the way ahead? Biological Conservation 143, 2695-2702.

Masden, E. A., Fox, A. D., Furness, R. W., Bullman, R. & Haydon, D. T. 2010. Cumulative impact assessments and bird/wind farm interactions: Developing a conceptual framework. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 30, 1-7.

Masden, E.A., Haydon, D.T., Fox, A.D., Furness, R.W., Bullman, R. & Desholm, M. 2009. Barriers to movement: impacts of wind farms on migrating birds. ICES Journal of Marine Science 66, 746-753.

Masden, E. A., McCluskie, A., Owen, E., Langston, R. H. W. 2014. Renewable energy developments in an uncertain world: The case of offshore wind and birds in the UK. Marine Policy 51, 169-172.

Mateos, M., Arroyo, G. M., Rodríguez, A., Cuenca, D. and de la Cruz, A. 2010. Calibration of visually estimated distances to migrating seabirds with radar measurements. Journal of Field Ornithology, 81, 302-309.

May, R., Hoel, P.L., Langston, R., Dahl, E.L., Bevanger, K., Reitan, O., Nygård, T., Peder-sen, H.C., Røskaft, E. & Stokke, B.G. 2010. Collision risk in white-tailed eagles. Modelling collision risk using vantage point observations in Smøla wind-power plant. - NINA Report 639. 25 pp.

May, R., Nygard, T., Lie Dahl, E., Bevanger, K. 2013. Habitat utilization in white-tailed eagles ( Haliaeetus albicilla) and the displacement impact of the Smola wind-power plant. Wildlife Society Bulletin 37, 75-83.

McAdam, B.J., 2005. A Monte-Carlo model for bird / wind turbine collisions. MSc Ecology. University of Aberdeen.

MMO. 2014. Review of post-consent offshore wind farm monitoring data associated with licence conditions. A report produced for the Marine Management Organisation, pp 194. MMO Project No: 1031. ISBN: 978-1-909452-24-4.

Mendel, B., Kotzerka, J., Sommerfeld, J., Schwemmer, H., Sonntag, N. & Garthe, S. 2014. Effects of the alpha ventus offshore test site on distribution patterns, behaviour and flight heights of seabirds. In Ecological Research at the Offshore Windfarm Alpha Ventus: Challenges, Results and Perspectives. Editors Federal Maritime and Hydrographic Agency, Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety. Springer Spektrum.

Meyers, J. & Meneveau, C. 2012. Optimal turbine spacing in fully developed wind farm boundary layers. Wind Energy 15, 305-317.

Moray Offshore Renewables Ltd ( MORL). 2012. Environmental Statement: Telford, Stevenson, MacColl Wind farms and Associated Transmission Infrastructure. .

Morecambe Wind Ltd. 2006. West of Duddon Sands Offshore Wind farm Environmental Statement. Morecambe Wind Ltd., Helsby.

Munsters, C.J.M., Noordervliet, M.A.W. & Ter Keurs, W.J. 1996. Bird casualties caused by a wind energy project in an estuary. Bird Study 43, 124-126.

Natural Power Consultants. 2012. Analysis of Marine Environmental Monitoring Plan Data from the Robin Rigg Offshore Wind farm, Scotland (Operational Year 1). Natural Power, Castle Douglas.

Natural Power. 2013 . Responses to the Examining Authority's Second Written Questions - Question 22 Appendix 9 - Moray Offshore Wind farm. Avoidance Rate Study Telford, Stevenson, MacColl Windfarms and Associated Transmission Infrastructure. Ornithology Avoidance Rate Calculations. Report written for Moray Offshore Renewables Ltd ( MORL).

Natural Power. 2014 . Analysis of Marine Ecology Monitoring Plan Data from the Robin Rigg Offshore Windfarm, Scotland (Post-construction Year 3). Draft Technical Report. E.ON Climate & Renewables.

NIRAS. 2011. Gunfleet Sands 2 Offshore Wind farms. Year 1 Post-construction Ornithological monitoring. NIRAS, Cambridge

Norman, J.F., Crabtree, C.E., Clayton, A.M. & Norman, H.F. 2005. The perception of distances and spatial relationships in natural outdoor environments. Perception 34, 1315-1324.

Orloff, S. & Flannery, A. 1992. Wind Turbine Effects on Avian Activity, Habitat Use, and Mortality in Altamont Pass and Solano County Wind Resource Areas. Prepared by BioSystems Analysis, Inc., Tiburon, CA, for the California Energy Commission, Sacramento.

Painter, S., Little, B. & Lawrence, S. 1999. Continuation of birds studies at Blyth Harbour Wind farm and the implications for offshore wind farms. ETSU Report.

Pearce-Higgins, J.W., Leigh, S., Douse, A. & Langston, R.H.W. 2012. Greater impacts of windfarms on bird populations during construction than subsequent operation: results of a multi-site and multi-species analysis. Journal of Applied Ecology 49, 386-394.

Pendlebury, C. 2006. An appraisal of 'A review of goose collisions at operating wind farms and estimation of the goose avoidance rate' by Fernley, J., Lowther, S. and Whitfield, P. BTO Research Report No. 455, Thetford.

Pennycuick, C.J. 1997. Actual and ''optimum'' flight speeds: field data reassessed. Journal of Experimental Biology 200, 2355-2361.

Percival, S.M., 1998. Birds and wind turbines: managing potential planning issues. Proceedings of the 20th British Wind Energy Association Conference, 1998. pp. 345-350.

Percival, S.M. 2001. Assessment of the effects of offshore wind farms on birds. Consultancy Report to UK Department of Technology and Industry. Ecology Consulting. University of Sunderland, Sunderland.

Percival, S. 2012. Hellrigg Wind farm: Goose Refuge Monitoring Report Winter 2011-12, Ecology Consulting, Durham

Percival, S. 2013. Hellrigg Wind farm: Goose Refuge Monitoring Report Winter 2012-13, Ecology Consulting, Durham

Pérez Lapeña, B., Wijnberg, K.M., Hulscher, S.J.M.H. & Stein, A. 2010. Environmental impact assessment of offshore wind farms: a simulation-based approach. Journal of Applied Ecology 47: 1110-1118.

Petersen, I.K., Christensen, T.K., Kahlert, J., Desholm, M. & Fox, A.D. 2006. Final results of bird studies at the offshore wind farms at Nysted and Horns Rev, Denmark. National Environmental Research Institute, Denmark.

Petterson, J. 2005. The impact of offshore wind farms on bird life in Southern Kalmar Sound, Sweden: A final report based on studies 1999-2003. Swedish Energy Agency.

Pettex, E., Bonadonna, F., Enstipp, M., Siorat, F. & Grémillet, D. 2010. Northern gannets anticipate the spatio-temporal occurrence of their prey. Journal of Experimental Biology 213, 2365-2371.

Pinder, J. M. 1989. Kittiwakes Rissa tridactyla inland in Yorkshire 1981-1985. Ringing & Migration, 10, 113-118.

Plonczkier, P. & Simms, I.C. 2012. Radar monitoring of migrating pink-footed geese: behavioural responses to offshore wind farm development. Journal of Applied Ecology 49, 1187-1194.

Powell, L. A. 2007. Approximating variance of demographic parameters using the delta method: A reference for avian biologists. Condor 109, 949-954.

Robinson, R.A. (2005) BirdFacts: profiles of birds occurring in Britain & Ireland. BTO Research Report 407. BTO, Thetford (, accessed on 12/06/2014)

Rothery, P., Newton, I. & Little, B. 2009. Observations of seabirds at offshore wind turbines near Blyth in northeast England. Bird Study 56, 1-14.

Richardson, W.J. 1990. Timing of bird migration in relation to weather: updated review. In: Bird Migration: the Physiology and Ecophysiology (ed. Gwinner, E.), pp. 78-101. Springer-Verlag, Berlin.

RPS. 2005. London Array Environmental Statement, London Array Ltd., Coventry.

RPS. 2008. Gunfleet Sands Monitoring Report, RPS, London.

RPS. 2011. Galloper Wind farm Project Environmental Statement - Technical Appendices 2: Appendix 4: Greater Gabbard post-construction vantage point surveys, RPS, Glasgow.

RPS 2013. Inch Cape Offshore Wind farm Environmental Statement, RPS, Edinburgh.

RWE Npower Renewables. 2005. Gwynt Y Mor Offshore Wind farm Environmental Statement.

RWE Npower Renewables. 2011. Galloper Wind farm Project Environmental Statement, Galloper Wind farm Ltd.

Rexstad, E. 2011. DSM: density surface modelling of distance sampling data. R package version 1.0.5.

Safi, K., Kranstauber, B., Weinzierl, R., Griffin, L., Rees, E., Cabot, D., Cruz, S., Proaño, C., Takekawa, J. Y., Waldenström, J., Bengtsson, D., Kays, R., Wikelski, M. & Bohrer, G. 2013. Flying with the wind: scale dependency of speed and direction measurements in modelling wind support in avian flight. Movement Ecology 1: 4 doi:10.1186/2051-3933-1-4.

Scira Offshore Energy Ltd. 2006. Sheringham Shoal Offshore Wind farm Environmental Statement.

Seascape Energy Ltd. 2002. Burbo Bank Offshore Wind farm Environmental Statement. Seascape Energy Ltd., Lancashire,

Scottish Natural Heritage ( SNH). 2010. Use of avoidance rates in the SNH wind farm collision risk model. SNH Avoidance Rate Information & Guidance Note. Scottish Natural Heritage, Inverness, UK.

Scottish Natural Heritage ( SNH). 2013. Avoidance Rates for wintering species of geese in Scotland at onshore wind farms. Scottish Natural Heritage, Inverness, UK. .

Schwemmer, P., & Garthe, S. 2005. At-sea distribution and behaviour of a surface-feeding seabird, the lesser black-backed gull Larus fuscus, and its association with different prey. Marine Ecology Progress Series 285, 245-258.

Shamoun-Baranes, J. & van Loon, E. 2006. Energetic influence on gull flight strategy selection. Journal of Experimental Biology 209, 3489-3498.

Shamoun-Baranes, J., van Gasteren, H., van Belle, J. van Loon, E., Bouten, W. & Buurma, L. 2006. A comparative analysis of the influence of weather on the flight altitudes of birds. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society 87, 47-61.

Skov, H., & Durinck, J. (2001). Seabird attraction to fishing vessels is a local process. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 214, 289-298.

Skov H., Leonhard, S.B., Heinänen, S., Zydelis, R., Jensen, N.E., Durinck, J., Johansen, T.W., Jensen, B.P., Hansen, B.L., Piper, W. & Grøn, P.N. 2012. Horns Rev 2 Monitoring 2010-2012. Migrating Birds. Orbicon, DHI, Marine Observers and Biola. Report commissioned by DONG Energy.

Smales, I., Muir, S., Meredith, C., Baird, R., 2013. A Description of the Biosis Model to Assess Risk of Bird Collisions with Wind Turbines. Wildlife Society Bulletin 37, 59-65.

Smallwood, K.S. & Thelander, C. 2008. Bird mortality in the Altamont Pass wind resource area, California. Journal of Wildlife Management 72, 215-223.

Smartwind. 2013. Hornsea Offshore Wind farm Environmental Statement, Smartwind Ltd., London .

Spear, L.B. & Ainley D.G. 1997. Flight speed of seabirds in relation to wind speed and direction . Ibis 139, 234-251.

Stephens, D.W. & Krebs, J. R. 1986. Foraging theory. Princeton University Press.

Stewart, G. 2010. Meta-analysis in applied ecology. Biology Letters 6, 78-81.

Stewart-Oaten, A., Murdoch, W.M. & Parker, K.R. 1986. Environmental impact assessment: 'pseudoreplication' in time? Ecology 67, 929-940.

Stienen, E. W., Van Beers, P. W., Brenninkmeijer, A., Habraken, J. M., Raaijmakers, M. H., & Van Tienen, P. G. 2000. Reflections of a specialist: patterns in food provisioning and foraging conditions in Sandwich Terns Sterna sandvicensis. Ardea, 88, 33-49

Still, D., Little, B., Lawrence, S. 1996. The effect of wind turbines on the bird population at Blyth Harbour. ETSU Report

Talisman Energy ( UK) Ltd. 2006. Beatrice Wind farm Demonstrator Project Environmental Statement, Talisman Energy ( UK) Ltd., Aberdeen

Tasker, M.L., Jones, P.H., Dixon, T.J. & Blake, B.F. 1984. Counting seabirds at sea from ships: a review of methods employed and a suggestion for a standardized approach. Auk 101, 567-577.

Technip UK Ltd. 2012. Aberdeen Offshore Wind farm Ornithological Baseline and Impact Assessment Addendum. .

Thanet Offshore Wind farm Ltd. 2005. Thanet Offshore Wind farm Environmental Statement. Thanet Offshore Wind farm Ltd., Warwickshire.

Thelander, C.G., Smallwood, K.S. & Rugge, L. 2003. Bird risk behaviours and fatalities at the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area. National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Colorado.

Trinder, M. (2012) Note to support the use of a 99% avoidance rate for the Beatrice Offshore Wind farm collision risk modelling, MacArthur Green Ltd., Glasgow

Triton Knoll Offshore Wind farm Ltd. 2011. Triton Knoll Environmental Statement. Triton Knoll Offshore Wind farm Ltd., Swindon.

Tucker, V.A. 1996. A mathematical model of bird collisions with wind turbine rotors. Journal of Solar Energy Engineering 253-262.

Tucker, V.A. & Schmidt-Koenig, K. 1971. Flight speeds of birds in relation to energetics and wind directions. Auk 88, 97-107.

Vanermen, N., Stienen, E.W.M., Courtens, W., Onkelinx, T., Van de walle, M. & Verstraete, H. 2013. Bird monitoring at offshore wind farms in the Belgian part of the North Sea - Assessing seabird displacement effects. Rapporten van het Instituut voor Natuur- en Bosonderzoek 2013 ( INBO.R.2013.755887). Instituut voor Natuur- en Bosonderzoek, Brussel.

Vanermen, N., Stienen, E.W.M., Onkelinx, T., Courtens, W., Van de walle, M., Verschelde, P. & Verstraete, H. 2012. Seabirds & Offshore Wind Farms: Monitoring Results 2011. pp. 85-109. In: Degraer, S., Brabant, R. & Rumes, B., (Eds.) Offshore wind farms in the Belgian part of The North Sea: Heading for an understanding of environmental impacts. Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences, Management Unit of the North Sea Mathematical Models, Marine Ecosystem Management Unit.

Votier, S.C., Bicknell, A., Cox, S.L., Scales, K.L., Patrick, S.C. 2013. A bird's eye view of discard reforms: bird-borne cameras reveal seabird/fishery interactions. PLoS One 8, e57376.

Wakeling, J. M., & Hodgson, J. 1992. Optimisation of the Flight Speed of the Little, Common And Sandwich Tern. Journal of experimental biology, 169, 261-266.

Whitfield, D.P. (2008). Review of evidence presented to support conclusions drawn during offshore wind farm application process: Appropriate Assessment for Sheringham Shoal proposed wind farm. Consultants' Report by Natural Research Ltd., Banchory, Aberdeen to Marine and Fisheries Agency

Whitfield, D.P. 2009. Collision avoidance of golden eagles at wind farms under the 'Band' collision risk model. Report from Natural Research to Scottish Natural Heritage, Banchory, UK.

Whitfield, D.P. & Madders, M. 2006a. A review of the impacts of wind farms on hen harriers Circus cyaneus and an estimation of collision avoidance rates. Unpublished report, Natural Research Ltd, Banchory, Aberdeenshire, Scotland.

Wild Frontier Ecology. 2013. Kessingland Wind farm Annual Post-construction Monitoring Report Year 2. Wild Frontier Ecology, Norfolk.

Williams, T.C., Williams, J.M. & Klonowski, T.J. 1974. Flight patterns of birds studied with an Ornithar. In: Proc. A Conf. on the Biol. Aspects of the Bird/Aircraft Collision Problem. S. Gauthreaux (ed.), p. 477-490. Washington, DC, U.S.A.F. Office of Scientific Research.

Wilson, J. C. & Elliot, M. 2009. The habitat-creation potential of offshore wind farms. Wind Energy 12, 203-212.

Winkelman, J.E. 1990. Nocturnal collision risks for and behaviour of birds approaching a rotor in operation in the experimental wind park near Oosterbierum, Friesland, The Netherlands; English summary. Rijksinstituut voor Natuurbeheer, Arnheim. RINRapport 90/17.

Winkelman, J.E. 1992. The impact of the Sep Wind Park near Oosterbierum (Fr.). The Netherlands, on birds, 1: Collision victims. RIN Rep. 92/2. Rijksinstituut voor Natuurbeheer, Arnhem, The Netherlands (Dutch, English summary).

Zehnder, S., Åkesson, S., Liechti, F. & Bruderer, B. 2001. Nocturnal autumn bird migration at Falsterbo, South Sweden. Journal of Avian Biology 32, 239-248.

Zielinski, P., Bela, G. & Marchlewski, A. 2008. Report on monitoring of the wind farm impact on birds in the vicinity of Gniezdzewo (gmina Puck, pomorskie voivodeship).

Zielinski, P., Bela, G. & Marchlewski, A. 2010. Report on monitoring of the wind farm impact on birds in the vicinity of Gniezdzewo (gmina Puck, pomorskie voivodeship).

Zielinski, P., Bela, G. & Marchlewski, A. 2011. Report on monitoring of the wind farm near Gniezdzewo impact on birds (gmina Puck, pomorskie voivodeship).

Zielinski, P., Bela, G. & Marchlewski, A. 2012. Report on monitoring of the wind farm near Gniezdzewo impact on birds (gmina Puck, pomorskie voivodeship).