Water services - investing in and paying from 2027-2033: business and regulatory impact assessment
Business and regulatory impact assessment (BRIA) prepared to support the Scottish Government’s development of its statutory inputs into the strategic review of charges for the 2027 to 2033 regulatory period. Namely, the Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging.
Section 2: Engagement and information gathering
The Scottish Government has adopted a phased and inclusive approach to engagement throughout the development of the Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging for the 2027-33 regulatory period. Engagement has focused on collaboration with key water industry stakeholders and cross-government policy alignment and public consultation.
Officials have engaged with:
- Scottish Water
- Consumer Scotland
- DWQR
- SEPA
- WICS
- The Convention of Scottish Local Authorities
- Local Authorities
- The Central Market Agency
- All Licensed Providers in the retail market
- The Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator
- The Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
This engagement has been through dedicated working groups - the Future Investment Group and the Future Charging Group. These forums have supported iterative development of the Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging, building on the direction set out in the Commissioning Letter. Engagement has also taken place across Scottish Government policy areas to ensure alignment with broader strategic objectives.
It is also worth reflecting on the engagement that has been undertaken by other water industry stakeholders on various parts of the SRC process.
- WICS’ public consultation on their methodology and the consultation on their draft determination.
- Memorandum of understanding on customer engagement between Scottish Water, WICS, and Consumer Scotland that ensures customer engagement is embedded throughout the SRC process
- Feedback from Consumer Scotland, WICS and the other water industry stakeholders on Scottish Water’s draft and final business plans.
Officials have also drawn on a range of evidence sources including published statistics, stakeholder reports, consultation analyses, and relevant government strategies developed since 2021.
The main public consultation on the draft Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging was published alongside the partial BRIA. The Scottish Government published an analysis of the responses to the public consultation in August 2026. WICS published its draft determination in June 2026 and a consultation which is open for response until September 2026. Feedback from the public consultation and WICS’ draft determination was fully considered in the finalisation of the Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging.
2.1 Business/Third Sector engagement
Engagement with business stakeholders was predominantly conducted through the consultation on the draft Principles of Charging and the Ministerial Objectives. Additional engagement focused on the perspectives of the Central Market Agency, representing the retail market, and representatives of the Licensed Providers. This contributed to the development of the Principles of Charging through the Future Charging Group which has provided insight into the operational and affordability considerations for non-household customers.
In addition, Scottish Water has undertaken research with around 280 non-household customers and 6 Licensed Providers, as part of its customer research programme for the SRC. Participants included businesses of varying sizes, sectors, levels of water dependency and geographical locations, providing a broad evidence base on customer priorities and expectations for the 2027-33 regulatory period. This engagement explored views on the affordability of proposed investment scenarios and identified priority service areas for businesses. The findings of this research were published at the same time as Scottish Water’s final business plan.
The research found that, regardless of business size, businesses were generally very positive about Scottish Water’s current service performance, particularly in relation to drinking water quality and reliability of supply. Businesses consistently identified reliable water and wastewater services, future proofing infrastructure and ongoing asset maintenance as key priorities. Participants highlighted that dependable water and wastewater services are fundamental to their operations and supported investment that would improve resilience and minimise the risk of future service disruptions. Businesses also expressed a desire for greater communication and collaboration with Scottish Water on water efficiency and sustainability.
When evaluating the different investment scenarios, businesses generally recognised the need for increased investment to address ageing assets, improve resilience and respond to future challenges, including climate change. There was broad acceptance that additional investment may require higher charges, provided this delivers tangible improvements and protected service reliability. However, participants also highlighted the importance of affordability and expressed a desire for support and advice to help businesses improve water efficiency and manage costs.
Consumer Scotland also carried out longitudinal deliberative research with household and non-household consumers on Scottish Water’s draft and final business plans. The research found broad support for, and acceptance of, Scottish Water’s final business plan among non-household participants. Although non-household customers on the whole agreed with the priority put on improved drinking water quality, some were surprised that improvements were necessary, given their experience of high water quality in general and suggested that maintaining performance in this area and redirecting investment to other outcomes would be preferred. Certain non-household customers expressed that reliability of supply was more important to their business than other outcomes, and thus they would have preferred more ambition in this area. This feeling was less strong in businesses who had not experienced previous issues with their supply. Non-household customers were more likely than household customers to consider the lowering of carbon reduction targets to be the right decision as it was felt to be a more realistic target. This was underpinned by broader views that net zero targets are costly and/or not a core function of Scottish Water. They ultimately felt that the changes reflected the feedback they had given on the Draft Business Plan.
Non-household customers expressed some concern about cumulative impact of bill increases and inflation as an unknown factor. In particular, hospitality and manufacturing businesses raised concerns about the impact on their sectors. Others thought charges were very affordable and would pay more to enable further investment. Overall, charges were viewed as striking the right balance. Non-household customers were generally accepting of the charges and felt they could afford the increase, even if it was unwelcome; however, this acceptance was conditional on the outcomes being achieved and WICS holding Scottish Water to account.
Additional outreach was made to businesses via the Economy Stakeholder Bulletin encouraging participation in the consultation, however no responses were received.
No specific engagement has been undertaken with businesses outside Scotland.
2.2 Internal SG Engagement
Officials have engaged with relevant Scottish Government policy areas to ensure that the Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging align with wider government strategies and priorities, particularly those introduced or updated since April 2021. This engagement has included discussions with teams responsible for the Infrastructure Strategy, Scottish National Adaptation Plan, National Planning Framework 4, Scotland’s Circular Economy and Waste Route Map to 2030, National Flood Resilience Strategy, and Scotland's Climate Change Plan – 2026-2040. These interactions have helped identify potential synergies and avoid conflicts with concurrent policy activity affecting the water sector.
Officials have also considered possible implications for investment and competitiveness. Engagement was conducted with the Directorate for International Trade and Investment (DITI), including the Investment Unit. This was to ensure that there is alignment with the recommendations of the First Minister’s Investor Panel to position Scotland as a globally competitive investment destination. Feedback from the Investment Unit noted no significant issues for global investors considering investment in infrastructure projects in Scotland.
In addition, the Regulatory Review Group were engaged and no concerns were raised.
2.3 UK/ Devolved Administrations
Officials have not engaged with governments in other parts of the UK, as the SRC process is specific to the water industry and regulatory framework in Scotland. No direct impacts on the water industries in England, Wales, or Northern Ireland are expected.
There may, however, be some indirect impacts arising from the scale of capital investment programmes being delivered in England and Wales alongside that proposed by Scottish Water. As outlined in the WICS methodology for the SRC, these factors will be considered to ensure Scottish Water can deliver its investment programme efficiently and maintain value for customers.[6]
2.4 Wider Public Sector
As previously set out, engagement has taken place with a number of key stakeholders across the wider public sector.
Officials contacted Scotland’s enterprise agencies (Scottish Enterprise, Scottish Development International, Highlands and Islands Enterprise, and South of Scotland Enterprise), the Scottish National Investment Bank, and Scottish Futures Trust and encouraged them to raise awareness of the public consultation and to share their views.
2.5 Other Key Stakeholders
No additional stakeholder groups were identified as requiring specific engagement beyond those described elsewhere in this BRIA.
2.6 Public consultation
The Scottish Government undertook a 12-week public consultation to seek views on the proposed Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging for the 2027-33 regulatory period. The consultation launched on 6 January and closed on 30 March 2026. The consultation received 58 responses from 21 individuals and 37 organisations.
The consultation included eight questions; four on the Ministerial Objectives and four on the Principles of Charging. A full list of the questions can be found in the consultation paper and in the Respondent Information Form. The public consultation document is published on the Scottish Government website and Citizen Space was used to ensure broad public access. The materials were written in clear and accessible language to ensure inclusivity. Statutory consultees and key industry stakeholders were notified and encouraged to participate.
Of the three options presented in this BRIA (see Section 7.1), the preferred option proposed in the consultation is for an evolution of the existing Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging. This approach reflects continuity with previous regulatory periods while incorporating lessons learned and stakeholder feedback. It should be noted that similar Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging were consulted on in 2018 (Investing in and paying for water services: consultation) and 2020 (Investing in and paying for your water services from 2021: consultation)
Overall, respondents were broadly supportive of the proposed Ministerial Objectives. Most (69%) agreed that the Ministerial Objectives identified the type of investment Scottish Water should undertake during the 2027-33 period. Key themes included support for continued investment in infrastructure, strengthening climate resilience and improved accountability and monitoring while ensuring affordability.
Feedback from businesses on the Ministerial Objectives, particularly with relation to a draft standard of services Ministerial Objective, highlighted the reliability and consistency of Scottish Water’s services. It was also noted that it is helpful for businesses to have a sense of future charges.
On the Principles of Charging, there was support for retaining the overall charging framework (42%). Other views expressed by respondents included concerns regarding the continued use of council tax bands to determine charges and the need for greater support for those facing financial hardship. There was broad agreement that a more fundamental review of charging policy is needed to ensure it meets the emerging policy needs and to inform the approach for the next regulatory period from 2033.
Contact
Email: waterindustry@gov.scot