Water services - investing in and paying from 2027-2033: business and regulatory impact assessment

Business and regulatory impact assessment (BRIA) prepared to support the Scottish Government’s development of its statutory inputs into the strategic review of charges for the 2027 to 2033 regulatory period. Namely, the Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging.


Section 7: Options Considered and Recommended

7.1 Options considered initially

In preparing for the 2027-33 regulatory period, a range of options have been considered to determine the most appropriate framework for setting the Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging. These options reflect varying degrees of continuity and change from the current arrangements in place for the 2021-27 regulatory period. The assessment of options has been informed by policy, regulatory, and operational considerations, as well as alignment with the Scottish Government’s Better Regulation principles.

Three options have been considered:

The first option considered was to replicate the Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging for the 2021-27 regulatory period exactly with no changes. While this approach offers simplicity and might have limited impact on stakeholders, it does not reflect the evolving policy landscape, emerging challenges (e.g. climate resilience, affordability), or lessons learned from implementation in the 2021-27 regulatory period. It may also fail to address areas where greater clarity or refinement is needed.

  • Type of action: continuation of current approach
  • Status: considered but not preferred
  • Justification: Better Regulation alignment:

    • Transparent: limited, as it does not reflect updated policy priorities
    • Accountable: weak, as it does not respond to stakeholder feedback
    • Proportionate: potentially disproportionate given changing context
    • Consistent: strong, but risks stagnation
    • Targeted: lacks responsiveness to emerging needs

The second option considered was to evolve the Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging for the 2021-27 regulatory period. This option involves retaining the core structure and intent of the current framework while introducing targeted refinements to improve clarity, responsiveness, and alignment with current Ministerial priorities. These changes may include updates to language, emphasis on specific outputs or outcomes (e.g. asset maintenance, sustainable economic growth, climate adaptation), and adjustments to reflect lessons learned during the current regulatory period. This is the preferred option and balances continuity with adaptability and is consistent with the Scottish Government’s Better Regulation principles.

  • Type of action: evolution of current approach
  • Status: confirmed approach
  • Justification: Better Regulation alignment:

    • Transparent: enhances clarity and stakeholder understanding
    • Accountable: reflects Ministerial direction and stakeholder input
    • Proportionate: adjusts framework without overhauling it
    • Consistent: builds on established regulatory precedent
    • Targeted: focuses on areas of improvement and strategic priority

The third option considered would involve a fundamental redesign of both the Ministerial Objectives (e.g. more prescriptive Ministerial Objectives and consequently a less flexible investment programme) and the Principles of Charging (e.g. redesign of affordability support). This option has not been investigated in detail, as it is inconsistent with the direction set out in the Commissioning Letter from the Scottish Ministers. Pursuing this option would require extensive consultation and a longer lead-in period than is available.

  • Type of action: major change in current approach
  • Status: Not investigated
  • Justification: misaligned with Ministerial intent and commissioning scope
  • Better Regulation alignment:

    • Transparent: would require significant stakeholder engagement
    • Accountable: potentially high, but not feasible within current scope
    • Proportionate: likely disproportionate to current needs
    • Consistent: breaks with established regulatory trajectory
    • Targeted: too narrow and focused (or broad and unfocused) for current commissioning context
Table 1: Summary table of options

Option

Description

Type of Action

Status

Better Regulation Alignment

1

Maintain 2021-27 framework unchanged

Continuation

Considered

Mixed alignment

2

Evolution of 2021-27 framework

Refinement

Confirmed approach

Strong alignment

3

Major overhaul

Redesign

Not investigated

Misaligned

7.2 Recommendations/ preferred options

The preferred option is to evolve the Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging established for the 2021-27 regulatory period. This approach is consistent with the expectations set out in the Ministerial Commissioning Letter and reflects the preparatory work undertaken by WICS and Scottish Water. The focus has been on targeted refinements to improve clarity, ensure responsiveness to emerging challenges, and align with the current priorities of Ministers.

In terms of mitigation, given the likelihood that charges will need to rise, Ministers have, therefore, been mindful of affordability when setting the Ministerial Objectives. The intention is that the Ministerial Objectives provide the framework for a balanced investment programme that enables Scottish Water to continue to provide high-quality services, accommodate growth, and adapt to the challenges presented by climate change, while keeping bills affordable for customers.

7. Declaration

I have read the Business and Regulatory Impact Assessment, and I am satisfied that it represents a fair and reasonable view of the expected costs, benefits and impact of the policy in business, and that these have been taken into account when making the policy decision. I am satisfied that business impact has been assessed with the support of businesses in Scotland.

I am also satisfied that officials have considered the impact on consumers as required by the Consumer Scotland Act 2020 in completion of the Consumer Duty section of this BRIA.

Signed:

Date: 30th September 2026

Minister's name: Gillian Martin

Minister's title: Cabinet Secretary for Climate Action and Rural Affairs

Scottish Government Contact point: Darren Knox

Contact

Email: waterindustry@gov.scot

Back to top