Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill: Island Communities Impact Assessment Screening
Island Communities Impact Assessment Screening for the Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill 2026
Step Four - Assessment
The assessment identifies markedly lower direct exposure to the high-value bands, possible higher unit costs for physical valuation or inspection work on remote islands, and a potentially greater practical benefit from locally tailored reductions following severe weather or other local events. These are differences in context and scale, but the available evidence does not show an effect on an island community which is significantly different from the effect on other communities.
Further Monitoring required:
- The 11 property estimate is not confirmed address-level island data and cannot support reliable comparisons between island groups. A further review will undertaken once property level information is available.
- Island authorities may receive additional revenue however this is subject to decisions on revenue distribution.
- The optional local reduction power may result in different support between council areas. That variation is inherent in local discretion and will operate within existing equality, public-law, audit, complaints and governance duties. Local authorities are independent democratic bodies that are accountable to their own electorate. Importantly, local authorities are relevant authorities under the Islands (Scotland) Act 2018. Where a local authority decides to a apply a discount in its area, it is for that authority to consider whether its decision requires an Island Communities Impact Assessment.
Assessment by Bill component
|
Bill component |
Likely island effect |
Assessment |
|---|---|---|
|
Bands I and J |
Current modelling identifies 11 potential Band I dwellings and no Band J dwellings across the six whole local-authority areas, within a Scotland total of around 13,600. The actual island count may be lower. |
No significant differential effect identified. |
|
Targeted valuation and appeals |
Potentially higher travel or evidence costs per case, but exceptionally low volumes. Existing assessor arrangements and the £10 million Scottish Government funding profile apply. |
No significant differential effect identified. |
|
Transitional protection and Council Tax Reduction |
Automatic protection applies on the same basis across Scotland to eligible sole or main residences. Accessible information, advice and intended income-related support matter in remote communities. |
Monitor access and take-up. |
|
Significant cognitive impairment |
Respectful terminology and the timing provision benefit island and mainland residents alike. Remote access to certification, qualifying benefits or advice may affect delivery. |
Reach out to Local Authorities to encourage accessible delivery. |
|
Local discretionary reductions |
The optional power may be particularly useful following severe weather, flooding, fire or another local event. Schemes are locally designed and locally funded. |
Potential positive effect. For Local Authorities to assess. |
|
Exclusion power |
Regulations may exclude specified descriptions of dwelling where their nature or use makes inclusion in Bands I and J inappropriate, helping avoid unintended effects on services. |
Screen any potential regulations when developed. |
Statutory determination
Decision:
The Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill is not likely to have an effect on an island community which is significantly different from its effect on other communities, including other island communities, in Scotland.
A full ICIA under section 13 is not required.
The principal reasons are the extremely small number of potentially affected high-value dwellings in the six local-authority areas, the absence of any estimated Band J dwellings, the retention of existing treatment for other dwellings, automatic transitional protection and intended income-related support, and the locally enabling nature of the discretionary reduction power. The final consultation analysis did not identify a significant island-specific effect, and no island community is expected to lose an existing entitlement as a direct consequence of the Bill.
Contact
Email: LocalTax@gov.scot