Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill: Island Communities Impact Assessment Screening

Island Communities Impact Assessment Screening for the Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill 2026


Step Two - Gather data and identify stakeholders

The data that is available about the current situation in the islands

Current modelling identifies 11 potential Band I dwellings and no Band J dwellings across the six local-authority areas containing islands. This is around 0.08% of the approximately 13,600 dwellings expected to enter Bands I or J across Scotland.

The estimate is for whole local-authority areas. It does not establish that all 11 dwellings are physically located on islands; in Argyll and Bute, Highland and North Ayrshire, some or all may be on the mainland. It is therefore an upper-bound proxy for island exposure pending completion of the targeted valuation exercise.

The earlier Institute for Fiscal Studies assessment of wider Council Tax reform estimated average island residential property values at about £203,000, compared with about £211,000 outside islands, and found no systematic disadvantage to island communities across the modelled reform options. That work is contextual: the present Bill is narrower and introduces targeted high-value bands rather than a general revaluation.

Delivery and finance

The Scottish Government intends to provide £10 million for the targeted valuation exercise: £5 million in 2026-27, £4 million in 2027-28 and £1 million in 2028-29. Scotland-wide gross additional Council Tax liability is estimated at £17.1 million in 2028-29; the transitional model reduces this to £13.8 million before collection effects, existing reductions, successful challenges and administration.

Given the very small number of potential island dwellings, island-related receipts and appeal volumes are expected to be minimal. Illustrative one-off local-authority implementation costs across Scotland range from £0.385 million to £2 million, but the evidence does not support an island-specific allocation.

Consideration of further data or consultation

No further consultation is required to support the current determination.

The final number and location of affected dwellings will not be known until assessors complete the targeted valuation exercise. Proportionate engagement with island councils and assessors should continue during implementation to confirm operational arrangements, costs, accessibility and any island-specific issues.

Existing data differ between islands

Island housing markets, transport links, assessor geography, access to services and the prevalence of Gaelic differ substantially. The three wholly island authorities are not directly comparable with the island parts of Argyll and Bute, Highland and North Ayrshire. The current 11-property estimate is too small and insufficiently disaggregated to support reliable comparisons between island groups.

Stakeholders

  • Island residents and community bodies, including any households likely to enter Band I or J.
  • The six local authorities, COSLA, assessors and the relevant Valuation Joint Boards.
  • Advice, housing, disability and carers organisations, and people who may use the significant-cognitive-impairment provisions.
  • Local public, private and third-sector bodies that may be affected indirectly.

Existing design features or mitigations are in place

  • The exercise is targeted: existing Bands A to H and 1991 values continue for most dwellings.
  • Eligible sole or main residences moving from Bands A to H into Band I or J will receive automatic transitional protection. In each year, the increase in gross liability will be limited to the lower of £1,500 or 50% of the relevant previous-year amount until full liability is reached.
  • Separate amendments to the Council Tax Reduction regulations are intended to support eligible lower- to middle-income households.
  • Section 4 enables the Scottish Ministers, by regulations, to exclude specified descriptions of dwelling from Bands I and J where their nature or use makes inclusion inappropriate. Water and sewerage charges are not intended to rise solely because a dwelling enters Band I or J.
  • The discretionary reduction power lets councils tailor support to local circumstances, including island emergencies, rather than relying on a single national scheme.
  • The £10 million Scottish Government funding profile for the targeted valuation exercise is intended to cover the identification and valuation work, notifications, proposals, appeals and list maintenance, including reasonable island-related travel and data work.

Contact

Email: LocalTax@gov.scot

Back to top