Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill: Island Communities Impact Assessment Screening

Island Communities Impact Assessment Screening for the Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill 2026


Step Three - Consultation

Consultation

This assessment has drawn on the two national consultations, responses from island local-authority areas, engagement with COSLA and local government, and delivery work with assessors and Valuation Joint Boards.

The six island local authorities, island residents and community bodies, and representative housing, disability, carers and advice organisations remain relevant to implementation and monitoring.

Timescales of Consultation Activity:

  • General consultation. The Future of Council Tax consultation ran from 27 October 2025 to 30 January 2026. It tested broad reform options and transition measures but did not test the specific Band I and J proposal.
  • Focused consultation. The high-value-bands consultation ran from 6 July to 24 August 2026. It sought views on the proposed multipliers and expressly invited evidence about effects on island communities and respondents' local areas. It received 1,231 responses, including 38 organisational responses.
  • Engagement. COSLA and local government have been consulted during policy development, and assessors are delivery partners for the targeted valuation exercise. The significant-cognitive-impairment provisions have also been informed by disability, dementia and advice-sector evidence.
  • Island evidence. The focused consultation received responses from people or organisations identifying with every local-authority area except Comhairle nan Eilean Siar, including a small number from Orkney and Shetland. It did not produce sufficient island-specific evidence to identify a significantly different effect. That evidence has been considered alongside modelling and engagement with relevant authorities and assessors.

Information that has been gathered:

The earlier assessment of wider Council Tax reform found that island communities were not systematically disadvantaged relative to comparable mainland communities under the options modelled, although effects differed between island regions.

The final focused-consultation analysis records responses from almost every local-authority area but did not produce sufficient island-specific evidence to identify a materially different island effect.

No significant island-specific concern emerged from the consultation evidence. The current conclusion therefore also relies on the very small modelled exposure, the targeted nature of the Bill and engagement with delivery bodies.

For the purpose of this screening determination, the national consultations included an express invitation for island evidence, local government and assessors have been engaged, and the assessment uses the best available modelling.

The small number of potential island dwellings and the absence of evidence of a significant differential effect support the conclusion.

Contact

Email: LocalTax@gov.scot

Back to top