Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill: Island Communities Impact Assessment Screening

Island Communities Impact Assessment Screening for the Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill 2026


Step One - Develop a clear understanding of the objectives

Objectives of the legislation:

  • Introduce Band I for dwellings worth more than £1 million and up to £2 million, and Band J for dwellings worth more than £2 million, using market conditions at 1 April 2026. The bands are intended to apply from 1 April 2028 at multipliers of 2.886 and 4.628. Bands A to H remain based on 1 April 1991 values.
  • Replace the term "severe mental impairment" with "significant cognitive impairment", modernise the statutory definition and allow entitlement to be determined by reference to the period covered by medical certification even where the other prescribed conditions are fulfilled later. The underlying eligibility conditions otherwise remain unchanged.
  • Give each local authority an optional power to reduce Council Tax liability, including to nil, through a locally determined scheme responding to particular circumstances. No ministerial approval is required and the Bill does not create new statutory consultation, publication or review requirements for a scheme.

The wider Future of Council Tax consultation and the focused consultation on the high-value bands have been completed. The focused consultation expressly invited evidence about effects on island communities. The assessment also draws on modelling and engagement with local government and assessors.

How islands are identified for the purpose of the legislation:

The assessment uses the statutory concept of an island community and the six local authorities identified as representing island communities. For mixed authorities, the analysis must distinguish people and properties physically on islands from those in the mainland part of the same council area.

Island local authority areas in scope:

Local authority

Area type

Island Communities

Shetland Islands Council

Wholly island

Mainland Shetland, Unst and Fair Isle

Orkney Islands Council

Wholly island

Mainland Orkney, Sanday and South Ronaldsay

Comhairle nan Eilean Siar

Wholly island

Lewis, Harris, the Uists and Barra

Argyll and Bute Council

Mixed

Bute, Mull, Islay, Jura, Tiree and Coll

Highland Council

Mixed

Skye, Raasay, Eigg, Muck, Rum and Canna

North Ayrshire Council

Mixed

Arran and Great Cumbrae

What the intended impacts are and how they may differ in the islands

The high-value bands are intended to improve progressivity at the top of the property distribution and generate additional receipts which local authorities will retain.

Current modelling suggests that very few island dwellings will enter Bands I or J, so direct taxpayer, revenue and appeal effects are expected to be very small. The discretionary reduction power may be particularly useful where an island community is affected by severe weather, flooding or another local event.

The significant-cognitive-impairment provisions apply nationally and are expected to have the same beneficial effect, although remote access to medical certification, qualifying benefits, advice and council services remains relevant to delivery.

New Legislation

This Legislation is new and makes targeted changes within the established Council Tax system. It does not introduce a full revaluation or change the treatment of the overwhelming majority of dwellings.

Contact

Email: LocalTax@gov.scot

Back to top