Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill: Business Regulatory Impact Assessment
Business Regulatory Impact Assessment for the Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill 2026
Section 7: Options Considered and Recommended
7.1 Options considered initially (or so far if this is a Partial BRIA)
High-value dwellings. Existing powers do not readily deliver the intended dual valuation basis and safeguards. A separate owner surcharge would create another billing and ownership regime. A full revaluation would have much wider effects and could not be delivered by April 2028. The preferred approach is therefore to create Bands I and J within the existing Council Tax framework and undertake a targeted valuation exercise. Within the high-value option, consultation tested lower, proposed and higher multipliers. Ministers retained 2.886 and 4.628 after balancing progressivity, affordability and revenue. Transitional protection, and intended Council Tax Reduction changes, are integral safeguards.
Significant cognitive impairment. Guidance and forms could use more respectful language but could not replace the statutory term or create a consistent timing rule. The preferred approach is primary legislation that modernises the terminology and definition while preserving the underlying eligibility conditions.
Local discretionary reductions. Doing nothing would leave gaps in the existing national provisions. Grants outside the Council Tax account would require a separate process and would not alter liability, while further national categories would be less adaptable. The preferred approach is an optional power allowing each authority to reduce liability, including to nil, according to local circumstances.
7.2 Recommendations/ preferred options
The approach taken in the Bill addresses the defined problems through the existing Council Tax framework, avoids a full revaluation and a separate owner-billing system, limits direct private-sector burden and allows implementation from 1 April 2028.
The preferred option is transparent because the thresholds, multipliers and valuation dates are set in legislation and decisions are supported by notices, guidance and appeal rights. It is accountable because Ministers and Parliament set the framework, assessors determine valuations, local authorities administer liability and an independent tribunal determines appeals.
It is proportionate and targeted because it affects fewer than 1% of dwellings, retains existing systems and does not revalue Bands A to H or impose a general business-compliance regime. It is consistent because the same thresholds and multipliers apply throughout Scotland while each authority continues to set its own Band D amount and use the established billing, recovery and redress arrangements.
Contact
Email: LocalTax@gov.scot