Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill: Business Regulatory Impact Assessment

Business Regulatory Impact Assessment for the Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill 2026


Section 2: Engagement and information gathering

The assessment draws on the focused consultation on the Band I and J multipliers, the wider Future of Council Tax consultation, engagement with local government and delivery bodies, early implementation cost information from billing-system interests, the petition and stakeholder evidence concerning significant cognitive impairment, and the suite of Bill impact assessments.

Engagement has been proportionate to the measures’ limited direct effect on private business. The principal delivery engagement has been with local authorities, assessors, valuation bodies, tribunal interests and Council Tax system suppliers. The public consultations also enabled businesses, representative bodies and third-sector organisations to provide evidence about property-market, affordability, rural and administrative effects.

2.1 Business/Third Sector engagement

The focused consultation ran from 6 July to 24 August 2026 and expressly invited evidence about effects on businesses and bodies in the private and third sectors. It received 38 organisational responses. Published responses included views from rural land and farming interests, property professionals, taxation bodies, trade unions, policy organisations, local authorities and valuation interests.

Business and representative submissions raised several recurring points: property value does not necessarily indicate income or liquidity; a farmhouse can form part of a productive rural business; the cumulative effect of property and other taxes could influence high-value residential decisions; new bands could affect property transactions, values or rents; and valuation, system and appeal costs should not erode the policy benefit. Other organisations considered that the bands would improve progressivity and raise appropriate revenue for local services.

Implementation costing has also drawn on early information relating to two Council Tax billing platforms and one authority's internal information-technology, communications and temporary staffing requirements. These were approximate planning indications rather than firm supplier quotations. They informed the broad £0.385 million to £2.0 million local-authority implementation range in the Financial Memorandum.

The significant-cognitive-impairment provisions have been informed by disability, dementia and advice-sector evidence, including stakeholder support for modern terminology and for entitlement to cover the period from medical certification where the remaining prescribed conditions are fulfilled later. Because the Bill creates no new private-business compliance regime, the combined consultation, representative-body and supplier evidence is considered proportionate to the anticipated direct business impact.

2.2 Internal SG Engagement

Policy development has involved the local taxation unit and colleagues across the local government directorate, local government finance, analysts, the Scottish Government Legal Directorate.

Equality, Fairer Scotland Duty, child-rights, island-community and Consumer Duty considerations have informed the assessment of affordability, access to information and vulnerable consumers.

Analytical work has used to estimate the revenue raised, and impact of the proposal.

Internal consideration has also covered public-finance and costs, including of the valuation exercise and appeal arrangements.

2.3 UK/ Devolved Administrations

Domestic property taxation is devolved and the Bill applies only to Scotland. Other UK nations operate different domestic tax structures. The UK Government's planned high-value residential surcharge for England was considered as an alternative design, but it would use a separate owner-based charge rather than additional bands within the established occupier-liability framework. The Scottish approach avoids creating a second billing structure and preserves the connection with existing discounts, reductions, billing and collection.

The significant-cognitive-impairment terminology reflects the approach adopted in Wales and assists consistency in respectful language, although the Scottish statutory and administrative arrangements remain distinct. No requirement for operational alignment with the UK Government or other devolved administrations has been identified. Cross-border property and software businesses may nevertheless need to understand the different regimes.

2.4 Wider Public Sector

COSLA and local government have been consulted during development. Local authorities will retain the additional receipts and will implement billing, transitional protection and communications. The discretionary reduction power responds to local-authority experience of circumstances, including flooding and subsidence, in which existing national provisions did not offer a suitable route to reduce liability.

Scottish assessors and the Scottish Assessors Association have informed the targeted valuation approach and delivery planning. The £10 million funding profile for assessors was agreed on an expected-caseload basis. Engagement has also considered the potential additional workload for the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service, the need for data transfer and system testing, and the policy that unmetered water and sewerage charges should not increase solely because a dwelling enters Band I or J.

Local-authority and supplier information has been used to develop the broad one-off implementation-cost range. The Financial Memorandum keeps those costs separate from the assessor funding, revenue forgone through transitional protection, tribunal costs and continuing business-as-usual Council Tax administration.

2.5 Other Key Stakeholder Discussion

Scottish Parliament petition PE1976, published in September 2022 and closed in November 2025, called for the Council Tax discount associated with severe mental impairment to be backdated to the date of medical certification where entitlement to a qualifying benefit was established later. Evidence was sought from the Scottish Government and disability and dementia organisations. The Bill addresses the timing issue while preserving the substantive qualifying conditions.

Taxpayers, advice bodies and professional organisations also emphasised the need for transparent valuation evidence, straightforward proposal and appeal routes, accessible explanations of support, and alternatives to digital-only communication. These considerations inform the implementation and Consumer Duty sections below.

2.6 Public Consultation

The wider Future of Council Tax consultation ran from 27 October 2025 to 30 January 2026. It received 1,291 validated responses, including from 72 organisations, and involved 115 participants at five public engagement events. Of those answering the relevant questions, 79% supported transitional relief, 59% preferred the lower of the two transitional options presented, and 51% supported extending Council Tax Reduction, rising to 85% among organisations.

The focused high-value-bands consultation received 1,231 responses: 1,193 from individuals and 38 from organisations. Of those answering, 55% preferred a Band I multiplier below 2.886, 14% preferred 2.886 and 25% preferred a higher multiplier. For Band J, 55% preferred a multiplier below 4.628, 13% preferred 4.628 and 25% preferred a higher multiplier. Organisations were more likely than individuals to select the proposed or a higher multiplier. These questions measured preferences about the multipliers rather than support for or opposition to introducing the bands.

The most prevalent qualitative concern was affordability, particularly for people with substantial housing wealth but limited current income. Other themes included calls for a full revaluation, concerns about the dual valuation dates and threshold effects, possible housing-market and wider economic effects, unequal geographical distribution of revenue, valuation and system costs, and the need for clear appeals and accessible support. Other respondents supported the bands as a fair means of making high-value dwellings contribute more to local services.

After considering the consultation evidence, modelling and impact assessments, Ministers retained the multipliers of 2.886 and 4.628, confirmed local retention of the additional receipts and provided automatic transitional protection..

Contact

Email: LocalTax@gov.scot

Back to top