Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill: Business Regulatory Impact Assessment

Business Regulatory Impact Assessment for the Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill 2026


Section 3: Assessment of Impact on Business, Investment and the Economy

3. Costs to businesses

The Bill does not impose a new regulatory compliance cost on businesses as businesses. There is no new licence, registration, recurring return, inspection, conformity assessment or product requirement. Additional Council Tax is a transfer from liable taxpayers to local government rather than a resource cost to the economy. The available modelling does not identify the proportion of Band I and J dwellings for which a company, charity, trust or landlord will be the liable person, so no defensible business-only share of the £17.1 million estimated gross additional liability can be calculated.

Where a business, charity, trust or landlord is already liable for Council Tax on a domestic dwelling, any increase will depend on the dwelling's band, the local Band D rate, existing discounts and exemptions and any premium. Further, if a business is using a domestic property, they would face no additional costs compared to if they were not using it for business. They may be able to have their property apportioned for the part used for commercial purposes and the portion added to the non-domestic rates valuation roll. Non-main residences will not receive transitional protection. This is a tax effect in a limited set of cases, not a new business compliance regime, and it cannot be separately quantified from the available data.

Property, tax and advice professionals may need to understand the new thresholds, valuation basis, transitional protection and appeal route. They may also receive additional client enquiries or requests for valuation, conveyancing or investment advice. These effects are expected to be limited and mainly one-off, and the available evidence does not support monetisation.

Software suppliers will undertake development work through their existing relationships with billing authorities. Medical certification already forms part of the significant-cognitive-impairment rules and no new clinical test or recurring report is created. Any evidence requested under a local discretionary scheme will depend on the scheme chosen by the authority and should be proportionate to the award being considered.

The Bill-specific public-sector costs are addressed under section 3.9. No separate private-sector net-present-value calculation has been produced because direct business costs are expected to be limited and the available evidence does not support a reliable affected-business population or unit cost.

3.1 Other potential impacts on business or the wider economy

Higher recurring liabilities could be reflected to some extent in high-value residential sale prices, rents or transaction timing. The direction, scale and timing will depend on market conditions, the incidence of Council Tax, landlord and purchaser behaviour, and the circumstances of individual properties. Some bunching around the £1 million and £2 million thresholds is possible. The Scottish Fiscal Commission considered the potential behavioural impact on Land and Buildings Transaction Tax and made no adjustment to its forecast because any effect was below its materiality threshold.

Rural respondents noted that the value of a farmhouse may be connected to a wider productive holding and may not indicate liquid income. Landlords and residential investors may consider the effect on yields where they are liable or where market expectations change. Conversely, the small number of affected dwellings and the use of the existing Council Tax structure limit the likelihood of a material Scotland-wide effect.

The Bill has no significant direct climate-change or circular-economy effect. It does not regulate the production, use, import or disposal of goods. The policy that water and sewerage charges will not increase solely because a dwelling enters Band I or J avoids an unrelated increase in household utility charges.

3.2 Benefits to business

The principal economic benefit is additional locally retained revenue for local services. Gross additional liability is estimated at £17.1 million in 2028-29, rising with assumed Council Tax growth. After the upper-bound estimate of transitional protection, approximately £13.9 million of additional liability remains in 2028-29 before collection, existing reductions, successful challenges and administration are taken into account. Well-delivered local services can benefit businesses, employees and communities, although the benefit cannot be attributed to individual firms in advance.

Billing, software, data, printing, valuation and professional-service suppliers may benefit from implementation contracts. Property and advice professionals may receive additional client work. The exclusion power can prevent inappropriate liabilities for specified forms of institutional accommodation and avoid unintended effects on services. The significant-cognitive-impairment and local discretionary-reduction provisions may also support household stability, reduce avoidable hardship and provide a clearer local response after disruptive events.

3.3 Specific Small business impacts

A self-employed person or small-business owner may be affected in a personal capacity because they occupy a high-value dwelling. Small landlords may be affected where existing Council Tax law makes them liable for a dwelling, however Scottish Ministers will have the power except specific property types from Bands I or J.

A business-size exemption would not be appropriate because the measure is based on the value and use of a domestic dwelling, not the turnover or headcount of a firm. Such an exemption could create unequal treatment between otherwise comparable dwellings and opportunities for avoidance.

Proportionate mitigation is instead provided through the narrow thresholds, such the exception power.

Further, there exist protections through exemptions and reductions.

3.4 Impact on Scottish firms’ competitiveness

This change will affect high value domestic properties in Scotland and there is no anticipated impact on Scottish firms’ competitiveness.

Council Tax may form one factor in a high-value housing purchase decision, but every comparable dwelling is subject to the same nationally defined thresholds and local Band D base within its council area. No material restriction or distortion of competition has been identified.

3.5 Impact on Scottish firms’ ability to Trade Internationally

The Bill does not regulate imports or exports, prescribe technical requirements for goods, authorise service providers or distinguish firms according to nationality or location. It therefore does not directly affect the ability of Scottish firms to trade internationally and does not create a World Trade Organisation notification issue on the current assessment.

3.6 Impact on Investment opportunities for Scotland and Scottish Firms

The most plausible investment effect is confined to the high-value residential market. A higher recurring charge may marginally affect expected rental yield, purchaser demand or the capital value of some dwellings, particularly close to the thresholds. The small affected population, transitional protection for qualifying main residences and retention of the existing tax framework limit the likely scale.

No evidence indicates a material effect on investment in Scotland's productive sectors, inward investment or access to capital. Consultation respondents expressed opposing views about investor and migration sentiment, but did not provide evidence from which the direction or scale could be quantified.

The position will be monitored using high-value transaction, price, rent and development data after implementation.

3.7 Impact on Employees

The Bill does not regulate employment, pay, recruitment, working conditions or workforce representation and is neutral in relation to the Fair Work First principles. Implementation may create temporary work for assessors, local authorities, tribunal staff and system suppliers. Any additional posts will be governed by the employment arrangements of the relevant body or supplier.

3.8 Impact on Consumers – The Consumer Duty

The Consumer Duty has been considered.

The principal consumers are individuals liable for Council Tax, people who use valuation, billing and appeal services.

The main benefit is a fairer relationship between liability and current value at the top of the property distribution, together with additional local revenue, more respectful significant-cognitive-impairment provisions and a new route for locally tailored support.

Affordability. Property value may not reflect income or access to cash, particularly for older long-standing occupiers, disabled people, carers. The main safeguards are automatic transitional protection, existing Council Tax Reduction measures and intended Council Tax Reduction changes, existing discounts and exemptions, the local discretionary power and normal payment and recovery arrangements.

Information and accessibility. Complexity, digital exclusion or lack of awareness could prevent consumers from understanding their bill or obtaining support. Communications should use plain language, accessible formats and non-digital channels and should be available early enough for households to prepare.

Housing-market and local effects. The bands could affect some property, rent or transaction decisions, while locally designed discretionary schemes may differ between council areas

The available matched property data do not provide a sufficiently reliable Bill-specific profile by household income, tenure, deprivation or protected characteristic. That uncertainty has been treated as a reason for mitigation and monitoring rather than as evidence that no harm will occur. The overall Consumer Duty conclusion is that the policy can improve consumer outcomes, provided the affordability, accessibility and redress safeguards are implemented as planned.

3.9 Impact on Regulators

The Bill uses existing regulators and administrative bodies and does not create a new regulator.

The following tables reproduce the principal Bill-specific estimates from the Financial Memorandum. The figures are indicative planning assumptions, not forecasts of final expenditure or cash receipts.

Targeted valuation exercise:

The Scottish Government expects to provide £10 million to Scottish assessors. The funding covers the identification and valuation of potentially affected dwellings, statutory notifications, proposals, assessor participation in appeals and list maintenance.

Financial year

Funding for Scottish assessors

2026-27

£5 million

2027-28

£4 million

2028-29

£1 million

Total

£10 million

Additional revenue and transitional protection The estimates are nominal and assume 4% annual Council Tax growth. The transitional figures are an upper-bound scenario in which every modelled dwelling is treated as a sole or main residence. They exclude other discounts, reductions, premiums and collection effects.

£ million

2028-29

2029-30

2030-31

2031-32

Estimated additional revenue before transitional protection

17.1

17.8

18.5

19.3

Estimated additional revenue after transitional protection

13.9

16.9

18.4

19.3

Revenue forgone (may not sum due to rounding)

3.2

1.0

0.2

-

On this upper-bound basis, cumulative revenue forgone is approximately £4.4 million. Actual revenue forgone is expected to be lower because transitional protection applies only to sole or main residences. The figures describe liability rather than cash collected. The effect of second-home and long-term-empty premiums may add approximately £0.3 million to £0.6 million in 2028-29, depending on local policies and property status.

Local-authority implementation The estimates below are illustrative one-off costs across Scotland. They draw on early information relating to two billing platforms and one authority and are not firm quotations or estimates for individual councils.

Cost category

Low estimate

High estimate

Software development and supplier charges

£200,000

£1,600,000

Local ICT, testing, training and implementation

£100,000

£200,000

Printing and communications

£15,000

£30,000

Temporary additional staffing

£70,000

£170,000

Total

£385,000

£2,000,000

Appeal

Actual costs will depend on supplier charging, existing contracts, the final technical design and the extent to which developments can be shared. The temporary-staffing range does not assume that every authority will recruit staff. The estimates exclude the separately funded valuation exercise, revenue forgone through transitional protection, tribunal expenditure and continuing business-as-usual administration.

Early cost indications assume an appeal rate of 2% to 6%, with 70% of appeals proceeding to a hearing and two appeals completed on each hearing day.

Planning assumption

Indicative range

Additional appeals

300-900

Appeals proceeding to a hearing

210-630

Additional hearing days

105-315

Additional staff resource

4-12

Indicative additional cost

Approximately £0.5 million-£1.4 million

These figures represent the potential cost of a full year of additional tribunal activity rather than a forecast for 2028-29. Some appeals may arise in 2029-30 or later. Successful proposals and appeals are estimated to reduce annual additional Council Tax revenue by approximately £30,000 to £100,000 under the Financial Memorandum's illustrative assumptions, which is expected to be de minimis relative to the overall revenue.

Significant cognitive impairment

A robust forecast is not possible because national data do not identify the number of delayed cases or the interval between medical certification and fulfilment of the other qualifying conditions. The sensitivity below is for scale only and is not a best estimate.

Illustrative case

Estimated cases

Assumed interval

Illustrative gross Band D effect in 2028-29

25% discount

400-600

10 months

£0.1 million-£0.2 million

100% exemption

400-600

10 months

£0.6 million-£0.9 million

Applying awards back to the start of the period covered by the certificate of significant cognitive impairment are transfers to eligible households and may reduce local Council Tax receipts or require credits and refunds. The local discretionary-reduction power cannot be costed nationally because use is optional and scheme design is for each authority. An authority choosing to use the power will meet both its administrative costs and the revenue forgone.

Contact

Email: LocalTax@gov.scot

Back to top