Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill: Business Regulatory Impact Assessment
Business Regulatory Impact Assessment for the Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill 2026
Section 1: Background, aims and options
1.1 Background to policy issue
Council Tax in Scotland currently has eight valuation bands, A to H. Dwellings are placed in those bands by reference to their open-market value at 1 April 1991. Band H covers every dwelling valued at more than £212,000 on that basis. The system therefore does not distinguish between substantial differences in value at the top of the current housing market. Some greatly improved or significantly appreciated dwellings may also remain in lower bands.
The Bill has three principal policy objectives. It seeks to improve fairness and proportionality at the upper end of the Council Tax property distribution; modernise the law relating to people currently described as severely mentally impaired; and enable local authorities to reduce Council Tax liability in response to particular local circumstances.
Sections 1 to 5 create Bands I and J, provide for a targeted valuation exercise and give eligible sole or main residences automatic transitional protection. Around 13,600 dwellings may enter the new bands. Dwellings worth £1 million or less by reference to market conditions at 1 April 2026 will remain in Bands A to H and will not be revalued between those bands as part of this exercise.
Section 7 replaces the existing terminology with 'significant cognitive impairment', modernises the definition and addresses the timing of entitlement where the other qualifying conditions are fulfilled after medical certification. Section 6 gives local authorities an optional power to reduce Council Tax, including to nil, where a locally determined scheme applies.
1.2 Current Position – before proposed changes
The Local Government Finance Act 1992 provides the main Council Tax framework. Independent assessors assign domestic dwellings to valuation bands and maintain valuation lists. Each local authority sets its Band D amount and the amounts for the other bands are calculated through statutory proportions. Billing, collection, discounts, exemptions, Council Tax Reduction, proposals and appeals already operate through established legislation and administrative systems.
The current law provides a disregard or exemption for a person described as severely mentally impaired where the medical and other qualifying conditions are met. It does not provide the proposed timing rule. At present the disregard or exemption will only apply from the date on which the medical and other relevant qualifying conditions are all met.
Local authorities can apply national discounts, exemptions and reductions but do not have the proposed general power to reduce a person's Council Tax in response to local circumstances.
The changes require primary legislation. Guidance cannot create new bands, change liability or confer the local reduction power, and existing order-making powers cannot readily deliver the intended dual valuation system and safeguards. A full revaluation would affect the whole domestic tax base, require substantially more work and could not be delivered by 1 April 2028.
1.3 Types of Business, Economic Sector, Groups or Communities that could be affected by the issue and its proposed solution
The Bill primarily affects people liable for Council Tax, local authorities, assessors and the bodies that determine appeals. Households occupying high-value dwellings may face higher bills, subject to transitional protection and existing discounts, exemptions and reductions.
A landlord, trust, company or charity may be affected where it is already the liable person for a domestic dwelling. The Bill creates a regulation making power to except specific property types from the new Bands I and J.
Estate agents, surveyors, valuers, conveyancers, letting agents, developers and residential investors may see additional enquiries or small changes in high-value market activity. Council Tax software, data, printing and implementation suppliers will undertake work needed for the new bands, transitional protection, billing and reporting.
Advice, welfare-rights, disability and third-sector bodies may receive additional enquiries. Medical practitioners may need to become familiar with the revised terminology, but the Bill creates no new clinical test or recurring reporting requirement. Local communities may benefit from the additional Council Tax receipts retained by local authorities.
Contact
Email: LocalTax@gov.scot