Business Appointment Rules advice: Dr Alasdair Allan
Advice given to the former Acting Minister for Climate Action.
Former minister: Dr Alasdair Allan, Acting Minister for Climate Action
Left office: June 2025
Appointment: International Elections Observer, Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR)
Advice provided: October 2026
Appointment start date: October 2026
Thank you for your application, submitted on 7 October 2026, seeking advice under the Business Appointment Rules in relation to potential future work as an international election observer with the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR). Your application relates to occasional, speculative and largely unpaid assignments as part of international election observation missions.
I have considered the information you provided, including that no specific appointment has yet been offered, that any work would be undertaken only periodically, that your role would be limited to observing and reporting on electoral processes overseas, and that you do not expect the role to involve contact with the Scottish Government or other UK Government departments.
Having considered the nature of the proposed role and the information you have provided, I am satisfied that the risks associated with this appointment are limited. The role is unrelated to your former ministerial responsibilities as Acting Minister for Climate Action and does not appear to create any significant risk that knowledge, contacts or influence acquired during your time in office could be used to provide an unfair advantage to another party.
Accordingly, I am content for you to undertake this work, subject to the standard conditions that apply under the Business Appointment Rules for the remainder of the two-year period following your departure from ministerial office:
- privileged information condition - You may draw upon the skills and experience gained during your time in office. However, you must not, at any time, draw upon or disclose privileged information obtained while serving as a Minister
- lobbying condition - Any contact with the Scottish Government, the UK Government or other public bodies must not be such that it could reasonably be perceived as lobbying. This includes direct and indirect lobbying on behalf of any organisation or individual connected with your election observation activities
- contracts and bids condition - You must not work on, advise on, or assist with any bids for government contracts, grants or funding
In reaching this view, I have taken account of the fact that:
- the application is speculative and no firm offer of work has been made
- the work is expected to be infrequent and limited in duration
- the role appears to be independent and observational in nature rather than commercial
- you stated that the role would not involve dealings with government in the UK
- you confirmed that you were not responsible for regulatory, funding or other decisions affecting the prospective organisation while in ministerial office
Should the nature of the role change materially, or should you receive an offer involving additional responsibilities beyond those described in your application, you should seek further advice before accepting or undertaking that work.
Yours sincerely,
Ashleigh Gray
Deputy Director, Propriety and Ethics Directorat