Business Appointment Rules advice: Dr Alasdair Allan

Advice given to the former Acting Minister for Climate Action.


First Minister’s Independent Advisers Correspondence with Dr Allan

06 October 2026

Dear Dr Allan

Business Appointment Rules: The National and Growth for Good

Thank you for your applications under the Business Appointment Rules in respect of your work with The National and your proposed consultancy role with Growth for Good, and for your subsequent correspondence explaining the circumstances in which these roles were commenced or announced.

As the First Minister's Independent Advisers, we have considered the information you have provided about both applications and your explanation of the circumstances surrounding them.

The Business Appointment Rules apply to former Ministers for two years after leaving ministerial office. Their purpose is to protect the integrity of government by addressing the real and perceived propriety risks that may arise when former Ministers take up outside appointments. The Rules require former Ministers to seek advice in advance. The published Rules also make clear that retrospective applications will not normally be accepted.

Having considered your representations, we acknowledge the challenges you have faced since the Parliamentary elections, and your approach to the secretariat in July for advice on the application process. However, we have concluded that there has been a breach of the Rules in respect of each role. The nature and consequence of the breach are different in each case.

The National - level 1 application

In relation to your level 1 application concerning your work with The National, we note that you commenced the role before submitting a formal application and receiving advice under the Business Appointment Rules.

We acknowledge that you contacted the secretariat in July and provided information about your intention to undertake journalism work. That contact was, however, a request for guidance on the appropriate application process rather than a formal application seeking advice under the Rules. Your formal application was subsequently received after you had commenced the role.

We therefore acknowledge that, by commencing the role before formally seeking and receiving advice, there has been a breach of the Business Appointment Rules.

Under the delegated arrangements, the Scottish Government Secretariat considers Level 1 applications. It is therefore for the Secretariat to consider the substance of your application and provide the appropriate advice under the Rules. Accordingly, we offer no view on the merits or acceptability of either the application or the appointment.

Growth for Good - level 2 application

The position in relation to your level 2 application concerning Growth for Good is different.

We understand that you have not commenced this role. However, your appointment to Growth for Good was publicly announced before advice had been provided under the Business Appointment Rules. We therefore regard this as a breach of the Rules, albeit one of a different character.

The requirement to seek and await advice is intended to ensure that propriety risks can be considered before an appointment is either taken up or publicly announced. We therefore consider the premature public announcement to constitute a breach of the Rules. We distinguish this from the position arising in relation to The National because the consultancy has not commenced and the opportunity remains for us to assess the associated propriety risks before you undertake the work.

We have consequently decided to continue our consideration of your application in respect of Growth for Good. Our decision to consider the merits of that application should not be interpreted as endorsing, or retrospectively regularising, the earlier breach. The finding that the Rules were breached and our consideration of the substantive application are separate matters.

In reaching our advice on your application in respect of Growth for Good, we will consider the application against the relevant tests in the Rules, including whether there is any reasonable concern about access to privileged information, any relationship between your former ministerial responsibilities and the proposed work, and any potential for improper access to or influence within government. We will also consider what conditions, if any, may be required to mitigate any identified risks.

We note in that context the safeguards concerning lobbying which you have identified in your application. Those will form part of our substantive consideration of the proposed role; our consideration of those safeguards should not be taken to affect our conclusion concerning the earlier announcement.

Conclusion

To be clear, our conclusions at this stage are therefore that:

  • The National, Level 1- you commenced the role before formally seeking and receiving advice under the Business Appointment Rules. We acknowledge that this constitutes a breach of the Rules. The Scottish Government Secretariat considers level 1 applications. We therefore offer no view on the substance or acceptability of the application or appointment. The Secretariat will consider your application and provide its advice separately
  • Growth for Good, Level 2 - the appointment has not commenced, but it was publicly announced before advice was received. This constituted a breach of the Rules. As the role has not commenced, we will proceed to consider the substantive application and provide advice on the propriety risks and any conditions that should apply. You should not commence any paid consultancy work with Growth for Good until you have received our final advice

Former Ministers have a personal responsibility to understand and comply with the Business Appointment Rules. It is important that advice is sought sufficiently in advance to allow the process to be completed before an appointment is announced or taken up. This protects not only the integrity of government, but the former Minister and prospective employer from reasonable concerns about the propriety of an appointment.

In the interests of transparency, our correspondence concerning these matters, including your explanations and this letter, will form part of the public record concerning your applications.

We will write to you separately with our substantive advice on your proposed role with Growth for Good once our consideration of that application is complete.

Yours sincerely
Claire Loftus, Sir Ernest Ryder, Sir John Manzoni
The First Minister's Independent Advisers

Dr Allan’s Correspondence with the Secretariat

From: Alasdair Allan
To: Propriety and Ethics team mailbox
Subject: Re National column
Date: 06 October 2026 11:06:24

Thank you for this. This continues to be a matter of great regret to me.

I will of course now contract no work under Growth for Good while this matter is under consideration and will direct any enquiries I receive from now on to others. I have sought to minimise all reference to me and will trawl my social media further this weekend. I have not gained any income from this source.

With regards to the National column, only the first of these articles been paid to me. If it is your advice that I should repay this, I will.

I have also, in recent days, sent on a level 1 speculative application for proposed work by way of a programme for the BBC which I am asking them to consider. This has neither been commissioned, as yet, nor announced in any way, so it is a speculative application. I would be grateful if you could confirm that this is being considered please.

Sadly, anyone who knows me will say that I am both absent minded generally and mindful of the importance of rules. This bad combination of traits may account for how badly I now feel about this matter.

Yours sincerely,
Alasdair Allan

On Tuesday, 6 October 2026 at 10:33:12 BST, PandETeam@gov.scot wrote:

Dr Allan,

Thank you for the below assurances.

Please see attached correspondence from the First Minister’s Independent Advisers (IAs) on the Ministerial Code.

As previously noted, you should not take on any activities for Growth for Good in advance of finalised advice from the IAs on this application. The attached, the IAs early correspondence alongside your mitigations, excluding any commercially sensitive or personal information, will be published at the point finalised advice on the Growth for Good application is available. The IAs aim to respond to applications within 20 days of receipt of a complete application, this timeline commences today given they have now agreed to consider this application on its merits.

Your application re the National is with the secretariat under the IAs delegation, I will write to you under separate cover regarding this application.

If you have any queries, please do get back in touch.

Kind regards
REDACTED

Business Appointment Secretariat
Propriety and Ethics Directorate
Scottish Government
From: Alasdair Allan
Sent: 01 October 2026 17:38
To: Propriety and Ethics team mailbox
Subject: Re: National column

Thank you for this REDACTED

I have let growth for good know that they should put on hold all activities involving me for the moment. Although I had this as a starting date, I do not as yet have any actual consultees and will not bill or contract any should I receive enquiries while this matter is being considered.

I have no income as yet from this area of work and am, for the moment, no longer actively mentioning it in the public sphere. It would be helpful to have a rough idea of likely timescales involved please.

Thanks for your help
Alasdair Allan

On Thursday, October 1, 2026, 5:13 PM, PandETeam@gov.scot wrote:

Dr Allan,

Thank you again for your below representations, which are with the Advisers for their consideration and response.
As secretariat to the Advisers, I’m conscious your application to join Growth for Good had a start date of today included and wanted to remind you that you may not commence this role until you have received a view on this from the Advisers. 
Kind regards
REDACTED

Business Appointment Secretariat
Propriety and Ethics Directorate
Scottish Government
From: Alasdair Allan
Sent: 24 September 2026 12:45
To: Propriety and Ethics team mailbox
Subject: Re: National column

Thank you for this.

Regarding growth for good, to be clear, I have received no income as yet from this proposed area of work as I have not yet taken on any paying consultees.

Again, I can only apologise if I have misinterpreted the rules here - I would not intend to take on any paid client via growth for good until and unless I have received permissions from you. I did advise, through the form, of my efforts in this area and thought this was sufficient to allow me then to investigate the options for finding clients to see if this area of work might be viable.

All I would add is that this is a genuine error on my part and I have sought to draw your attention to these work proposals (if belatedly) rather than keep any information from you.

The last few months of my life have been pretty upsetting and dislocating at a personal level and have involved as yet no paid work beyond the newspaper articles. I take the code of conduct seriously and can only apologise if I have misinterpreted its requirements. 

Yours sincerely
Alasdair Allan

On Thursday, September 24, 2026, 12:09 PM, PandETeam@gov.scot wrote:

Dr Allan,

Thank you for your correspondence below, which will be conveyed to the Advisers for consideration.

Please confirm if it is your intention to make a separate representation regarding the public announcement of your role with Growth for Good in advance of receiving advice under the Rules.

The deadline for any further representations is 30th September.

Kind regards
REDACTED

Business Appointment Secretariat
Propriety and Ethics Directorate
Scottish Government
From: Alasdair Allan
Sent: 23 September 2026 15:29
To: Propriety and Ethics team mailbox
Subject: National column

Thank you for your letter of 23 sept in which you ask me why my seeking your permission for my National newspaper column came after the initial column’s appearance rather than before it.

I can only apologise for this and no discourtesy was intended. I would offer the following by way of mitigation. The columns are on cultural issues and not related to my former role as a minister.

I had misread the situation and thought that my original correspondence around 15 July was sufficient as initial notification of my intentions. Clearly it was not, I now realise, and I later sought to put this right by making the application to which we are now referring.

The payment for the columns is REDACTED each and I think as yet I have only received the first such payment. I will give the payment back if you feel that I should.

The months since losing my seat have represented a major upheaval in every aspect of my life, including a search for new employment and I therefore initially fell behind in some correspondence.

I accept this means I was late seeking permission and can only again apologise.

Yours faithfully,
Alasdair Allan

First Minister’s Independent Adviser’s Initial correspondence with Applicant

23 September 2026

Dear Dr Allan,

Business Appointment Rules: The National and Growth for Good.

Thank you for your applications under the Business Appointment Rules for Former Ministers ("the Rules") in relation to your journalism and consultancy opportunities.

The purpose of the Rules is to protect the integrity of government by considering the real and perceived risks that can arise when former Ministers take up outside appointments. The Rules require former Ministers to seek advice in relation to appointments and employment they wish to take up during the two-year period after leaving ministerial office. The Rules also provide that retrospective applications will not normally be accepted.

You submitted your applications in respect of the above appointments on 15th September 2026. The information available to us indicates that you had already commenced the role at the National with your first piece being published on the 14th August 2026, before you had sought and received our advice. Similarly your planned appointment to Growth for Good was publicly announced in advance of you receiving our advice on the appointment in line with the Rules.

We note that the Secretariat corresponded with you on 15 July 2026 about the timing of applications under the Rules. You were advised:

"Application timing is up to you, you can put in speculative applications to the IAs or await a substantive employment offer following recruitment activity, however advice must be agreed prior to any acceptance of a role or public announcement of an appointment. The IAs welcome early engagement on BARs from former Ministers to support compliance with the Rules."

You were therefore specifically advised that our advice must be agreed before accepting a role or making a public announcement of an appointment.

The requirement to obtain advice in advance is an important part of the Rules. The process enables us to consider the risks associated with an appointment and any conditions that may be necessary to protect the integrity of government before an individual commits to or announces the appointment. Retrospective consideration cannot provide that same protection.

On the information currently available to us, it therefore appears that you did not follow the requirements of the Rules in relation to these appointments.

Before we consider these matters further, we invite you to provide an explanation of the circumstances in which you progressed the appointments before seeking and receiving our advice.

In particular, you may wish to explain any circumstances that you consider relevant to our assessment, including the earlier advice provided to you by the Secretariat on 15 July.

Please provide any response by 30th September 2026 via our secretariat at pandeteam@gov.scot.

Following consideration of your response, we will determine how these applications should be handled under the Rules, including whether any substantive consideration of the appointments is appropriate.

In accordance with the transparency arrangements applying to the Business Appointment Rules, our final advice and relevant correspondence may be published. We will take account of any response you provide before reaching our conclusions.

Yours sincerely,

Claire Loftus, Sir Ernest Ryder and Sir John Manzoni,
The First Minister’s Independent Advisers on the Ministerial Code

Back to top