Business Appointment Rules advice: Dr Alasdair Allan
Advice given to the former Acting Minister for Climate Action.
Former minister: Dr Alasdair Allan, Acting Minister for Climate Action
Left office: June 2025
Appointment: Consultant, Growth for Good
Advice provided: October 2026
Appointment start date: September 2026
Thank you for your application under the Business Appointment Rules for Former Ministers (“the Rules”) for advice on undertaking paid consultancy work with Growth for Good.
You propose to work on an ad hoc basis with Drew Hendry, providing strategic advice to clients on government, parliamentary and public-sector decision-making and helping clients prepare for their own engagement with public bodies. You have stated that you will not undertake engagement with the Scottish Government on behalf of clients, make representations or seek decisions or commitments for them, or use personal or political relationships to secure access or influence.
As set out in our letter of 6 October 2026, your association with Growth for Good was publicly announced before advice had been provided under the Rules. We concluded that this constituted a breach of the Rules. As you have not commenced work with Growth for Good, we agreed to proceed with consideration of the substantive application. Our decision to provide advice on the appointment does not alter or retrospectively regularise our finding that the Rules were breached.
The purpose of the Rules is to protect the integrity of government and to avoid any suspicion that those who have served in government might profit improperly from that experience or that an employer or client might gain unfair advantage through privileged access to government. Given the nature of the proposed consultancy, there is a risk that knowledge, insights or contacts acquired during your time in office could be perceived as providing an unfair advantage to Growth for Good or its clients.
We consider that these risks can be appropriately managed by the following standard conditions:
- privileged information condition - You should not draw on (disclose or use for the benefit of yourself, Growth for Good or its clients) any privileged information available to you from your time in ministerial office. This is an ongoing duty irrespective of the time elapsed since you left office
- lobbying condition - For two years from your last day in office, you should not become personally involved in lobbying the Scottish Government or its arm’s-length bodies on behalf of Growth for Good or its clients; nor should you make use, directly or indirectly, of your contacts in government and/or ministerial office to influence policy, secure business or funding or otherwise unfairly advantage Growth for Good or its clients
- contracts and bids condition - For two years from your last day in office, you should not undertake any work with Growth for Good or its clients that involves providing advice on the terms of, or with regard to the subject matter of, a bid with, or contract relating directly to the work of, the Scottish Government or its arm’s-length bodies
In particular, although your proposed role involves advising clients on how to prepare for engagement with government, you should ensure that you do not become directly or indirectly involved in lobbying government on their behalf. The safeguards described in your application, including that clients themselves will undertake any engagement with government, should therefore be observed in practice.
Please note the following points:
- this advice is not an endorsement of the appointment
- the advice relates solely to your previous role in government and is separate from rules administered by other relevant bodies. It is your personal responsibility to understand any other rules and regulations to which you may be subject
- by 'privileged information', we mean official information to which you had access as a consequence of holding ministerial office and which is not publicly available. You are also reminded that you may be subject to other duties of confidentiality
- the lobbying restriction means that former Ministers should not engage in communication with government, including Ministers, civil servants, special advisers and other relevant officials or public office holders, with a view to influencing a government decision, policy, contract award or grant in relation to their own interests or those of an organisation or client for which they work
Subject to these conditions, we are content for you to undertake the proposed consultancy work with Growth for Good as described in your application. Should the nature or scope of the consultancy change or expand from that described in your application, you should contact the Business Appointments Secretariat before undertaking that work, as a further application under the Rules may be required.
In accordance with the Rules, this advice will be published.
Yours sincerely
Claire Loftus, Sir Ernest Ryder and Sir John Manzoni,
The First Minister’s Independent Advisers