Ascribing sentience to fish: potential policy implications
Report on the potential policy implications of ascribing sentience to fish produced by the Scottish Animal Welfare Commission.
References
1. SAWC statement on animal sentience, 2021
3. Birch, J., Burn, C., Schnell, A., Browning, H. and Crump, A. (2021) Review of the evidence of sentience in cephalopod molluscs and decapod crustaceans
4. Scottish Sea Fisheries Statistics 2022
5. Scottish Government 2023b Scottish Fish Farm Production Survey 2022
6. Scottish Animal Welfare Commission Interim Report – Exotic pets
7. Scottish salmon and sea trout fishery statistics, 2023
9. Cooke, S. J. and Sneddon, L. U. (2007) Animal welfare perspectives on recreational angling. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 104(3):176-198.
10. Holmes, Tim Q. (2020) Impact of UK sport fishing on fish welfare and conservation. Animal Sentience 3(47) DOI: 10.51291/2377-7478.1580
11. EFSA (2009) Scientific Opinion of the Panel on Animal Health and Welfare on a request from European Commission on General approach to fish welfare and to the concept of sentience in fish. The EFSA Journal (2009) 954:1-26.
12. Kotrschal, K., Van Staaden, M. J. and Huber, R. (1998) Fish brains: evolution and environmental relationships. Reviews In Fish Biology and Fisheries 8(4):373-408.
13. Huntingford, F., Adams, C., Braithwaite, V., Kadri, S., Pottinger, T., Sandoe, P. and Turnbull, J. (2006) Current issues in fish welfare. Journal of Fish Biology 68(2):332-372.
14. Rose, J. D. (2002) The Neurobehavioral nature of fishes and the question of awareness and pain. Reviews In Fisheries Science 10(1):1-38.
15. Vogt, B. A., Berger, G. R. and Derbyshire, S. W. G. (2003) Structural and functional dichotomy of human midcingulate cortex. European Journal of Neuroscience 18(11): 3134-3144.
16. Rink, E. and Wullimann, M. F. (2004) Connections of the ventral telencephalon (subpallium) in the zebrafish (Danio rerio). Brain Research 1011(2):206-220
17. Dunlop, R. and Laming, P. (2005) Mechanoreceptive and nociceptive responses in the central nervous system of goldfish (Carassius auratus) and trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Journal Of Pain 6(9):561-568
18. Carter, R. (1998) Mapping the mind. University of California Press, London, 224p
19. Maren, S. (2001) Neurobiology of Pavlovian fear conditioning. Annual Review of Neuroscience 24:897-931
20. Fox, H. E., White, S. A., Kao, M. H. F. and Fernald, R. D. (1997) Stress and Dominance in a Social Fish. Journal of Neuroscience 17(16):6463.
21. Portavella, M., Vargas, J. P., Torres, B. and Salas, C. (2002) The effects of telencephalic pallial lesions on spatial, temporal, and emotional learning in goldfish. Brain Research Bulletin 57(3-4):397-399
22. Chandroo, K. P., Duncan, I. J. H. and Moccia, R. D. (2004) Can fish suffer?: perspectives on sentience, pain, fear and stress. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 86(3-4):225-250.
23. Hodos W. and Butler A.B. (1997) Evolution of sensory pathways in vertebrates. Brain, Behavior and Evolution 50(4):189-197.
24. Walker, M. M., Diebel, C. E., Haugh, C. V., Pankhurst, P. M., Montgomery, J. C. and Green, C. R. (1997) Structure and function of the vertebrate magnetic sense. Nature 390(6658):371.
25. Sneddon, L. U., Braithwaite, V. A. and Gentle, M. J. (2003a) Do fishes have nociceptors? Evidence for the evolution of a vertebrate sensory system. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B, Biological Sciences 270(1520):1115-1121.
26. Sneddon, L. U., Braithwaite, V. A. and Gentle, M. J. (2003b) Novel object test: Examining nociception and fear in the rainbow trout. Journal Of Pain 4(8):431-440.
27. Sneddon, L. U. (2004) Evolution of nociception in vertebrates: comparative analysis of lower vertebrates. Brain Research Reviews 46(2):123-130
28. Bateson, P. (1991) Assessment of pain in animals. Animal Behaviour 42(5):827-839.
29. Broom, D. M. (2001a) The evolution of pain. Vlaams Diergeneeskundig Tijdschrift 70(1):17-21.
30. Broom, D. M. (2001b) Evolution of pain. In: Pain: its nature and management in man and animals. (eds Soulsby, Lord and Morton, D.) Royal Society of Medicine International Congress Symposium Series, pp17-25.
31. Stevens, C. W. (2004) Opioid research in amphibians: an alternative pain model yielding insights on the evolution of opioid receptors. Brain Research Reviews 46(2):204-215.
32. Jansen, G. A. and Greene, N. M. (1970) Morphine metabolism and morphine tolerance in goldfish. Anesthesiology 32 (3): 231-235.
33. Bentley, P. J. (1998) The chemical structure, polymorphism, and evolution of hormones In: Comparative Vertebrate Endocrinology. (Editor P.J. Bentley). Cambridge University Press, pp65-171.
34. Sneddon, L. U. (2006) Ethics and welfare: pain perception in fish. Bulletin of the European Association of Fish Pathologists 26(1):7-10.
35. Beukema, J. (1970a) Acquired hook avoidance in the pike Esox ucius L. fished with artificial and natural baits. Journal of Fish Biology 2:155 -160.
36. Beukema, J. (1970b) Angling experiments with carp (Cyprinus carpio L.) II. Decreased catchability through one trial learning. Netherlands Journal of Zoology 20:81-92.
37. Overmier, J. B. and Hollis, K. L. (1983) The teleostean telencephalon in learning. In: Fish Neurobiology. R. E. N. Davis, R. G. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, pp265 - 283
38. Overmier, J. B. and Hollis, K. L. (1990) Fish in the think tank: learning, memory and integrated behaviour. In: Neurobiology of Comparative Cognition. R. P. O. Kesner, D. S. Hillsdales, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, pp205 - 236
39. Xu, X. and Davis, R. E. (1992) N-Methyl--Aspartate Receptor Antagonist MK-801 Impairs Learning but Not Memory Fixation or Expression of Classical Fear Conditioning in Goldfish (Carassius auratus). Behavioral Neuroscience 106(2):307.
40. Wedemeyer, G. A., Barton, B. A. and McLeay, D. J. (1990) Stress and acclimation. Methods for fish biology. American Fisheries Society, Bethesda, Maryland: 451–489.
41. Wendelaar Bonga, S. E. (1997) The stress response in fish. Physiological Reviews 77(3):591-625.
42. FSBI (2002) Fish welfare, Briefing Report 2. Fisheries Society of the British Isles, Granta Information Centre, Cambridge, UK.
43. Ashley, P. J. (2007) Fish welfare: Current issues in aquaculture. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 104(3-4):199-235.
44. Korte, S. M., Koolhaas, J. M., Wingfield, J. C. and McEwen, B. S. (2005) The Darwinian concept of stress: benefits of allostasis and costs of allostatic load and the trade-offs in health and disease. Neuroscience and Bio-behavioral Reviews 29(1):3-38.
45. Hayashi, K., Locke, N.J.M. and Laudet, V. (2022) Counting Nemo: Anemonefish Amphiprion ocellaris identify species by number of white bars Journal of Experimental Biology 227(2): jeb246357
46. Buston, P. (2004) Territory inheritance in clownfish Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B Biological Sciences 271(Suppl 4): S252-S254.
47. Barlow, G. W. (2000). The cichlid fishes: Nature's grand experiment in evolution. Cambridge, MA: Perseus Publishing
48. Brännäs, E., Alanärä, A., and Magnhagen, C. (2001) The social behaviour of fish. In L. J. Keeling & H. W. Gonyou (Eds.), Social behaviour in farm animals. Wallingford, UK: CABI Publishing pp.275–304.
49. Brandao, M.L., Dorigao-Guimaraes, F., Bolognesi, M.C., Gauy, A.C.D-S., Pereira, A.V.S., Vian, L., Carvalho, T.B. and Goncaalves-de-Freitas, E. (2021) Understanding behaviour to improve the welfare of an ornamental fish. Fish Biology 99:726-739.
50. Barlow, G. W. (1968) Dither: a way to reduce undesirable fright behavior in ethological studies. Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie, 25:313–318
51. McKaye, K. R., and Barlow, G. W. (1976) Competition between color morphs of the Midas cichlid, Cichlasoma citrinellum, in Lake Jiloa, Nicaragua. Investigations of the Ichthyofauna of Nicaraguan lakes, 34:465–475.
52. Galhardo, L., Vitorino, A., and Oliveira, R. F. (2012) Social familiarity modulates personality trait in a cichlid fish. Biology Letters, 8:936–938
53. Brandao, M. L., Braithwaite, V. A., and Gonçalves-de-Freitas, E. (2015) Isolation impairs cognition in a social fish. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 17:204–210.
54. García-Ruiz, I. and Taborsky, M. (2022) Group augmentation on trial: helpers in small groups enhance antipredator defence of eggs. Biology Letters 18(10):20220170. doi: 10.1098/rsbl.2022.0170. Epub 2022 Oct 5. PMID: 36196551; PMCID: PMC9533001.
55. Heg, D., Jutzeler, E., Mitchell, J.S. and Hamilton, I.M. (2009) Helpful female subordinate cichlids are more likely to reproduce. PLoS One. 4(5): e5458. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0005458. Epub 2009 May 6. PMID: 19421320; PMCID: PMC2673683.
56. Bergmüller, R. and Taborsky, M. (2005) Experimental manipulation of helping in a cooperative breeder: helpers ‘pay to stay’ by pre-emptive appeasement. Animal Behaviour 69:19–28
57. Bergmüller, R., Heg, D. and Taborsky, M. (2005) Helpers in a cooperatively breeding cichlid stay and pay or disperse and breed, depending on ecological constraints. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B. 272:325–31.
58. Soares, M.C. (2017) The Neurobiology of Mutualistic Behavior: The Cleanerfish Swims into the Spotlight. Frontiers of Behavioral Neuroscience 11:191. doi: 10.3389/fnbeh.2017.00191. PMID: 29089876; PMCID: PMC5651018.
59. Brandl, S.J. and Bellwood, D.R. (2015) Coordinated vigilance provides evidence for direct reciprocity in coral reef fishes. Scientific Reports 5:14556
60. Helfman, G.S. and Schultz, E.T. (1984) Social transmission of behavioral traditions in a coral reef fish. Animal Behaviour. 32:379–84
61. Laland, K.N. and Williams, K. (1997) Shoaling generates social learning of foraging information in guppies. Animal Behaviour. 53(6):1161–9.
62. Laland, K.N. and Williams, K. (1998) Social transmission of maladaptive information in the guppy. Behavioral Ecology. 9(5):493–9
63. Brown, C. and Laland, K.N. (2011) Social learning in Fishes. In: Brown C, Laland KN, Krause J, editors. Fish cognition and behavior. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Wiley-Blackwell, p. 186–202.
64. Brown, C. and Warburton, K. (1999) Social mechanisms enhance escape responses in shoals of rainbowfish, Melanotaenia duboulayi. Environmetal Biology of Fish. 56(4):455–9.
65. Brown, C. and Laland, K.N. (2002) Social learning of a novel avoidance task in the guppy: conformity and social release. Animal Behaviour. 64:41–7.
66. Brown, C. and Laland, K.N. (2002) Social enhancement and social inhibition of foraging behavior in hatchery-reared Atlantic salmon. Journal of Fish Biology. 61(4):987–98
67. Olsen, K.H. and Jarvi, T. (1997) Effects of kinship on aggression and RNA content in juvenile Arctic charr. Journal of Fish Biology. 51(2):422–35.
68. Griffiths, S.W. and Magurran, A.E. (1997) Familiarity in schooling fish: how long does it take to acquire? Animal Behaviour. 53(5):945–9
69. Frommen, J.G., Luz, C. and Bakker, T.C.M. (2007) Kin discrimination in sticklebacks is mediated by social learning rather than innate recognition. Ethology. 113(3):276–82
70. Brown, C. (2002) Do female rainbowfish (Melanotaenia spp.) prefer to shoal with familiar individuals under predation pressure? Journal of Ethology. 20(2):89–94
71. Laubu, C., Louapre, P. and Dechume-Moncharmont, F-X. (2019) Pair-bonding influences affective state in a monogamous fish species. Proceedings of the Biology Society, 286, 20190760.
72. Faustino, A.I., Tacão-Monteiro, A. and Oliveira, R.F. (2017) Mechanisms of social buffering of fear in zebrafish. Scientific Reports. 7:44329.
73. White, L.J., Thomson, J.S., Pounder, K.C., Coleman, R.C. and Sneddon, L.U. (2017) The impact of social context on behavior and the recovery from welfare challenges in zebrafish, Danio rerio. Animal Behaviour. 132:189–99
74. Bergmann, H.H. (1968) Eine deskriptive Verhaltensanalyse des Segelflossers (Pterophyllum scalare Cuv. & Val., Cichlidae, Pisces). Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie, 25:559–587
75. Chien, A. K., and Salmon, M. (1972) Reproductive behaviour of the angelfish, Pterophyllum scalare. I. A quantitative analysis of spawning and parental behaviour. Forma et Functio, 5:45–74.
76. Aronson, L.R. (1951) Orientation and jumping behavior in the gobiid fish Bathygobius soporator. American Museum Novitates. 1486:1–12.
77. White, G,E. and Brown, C. (2013) Site fidelity and homing behavior in intertidal fishes. Marine Biology. 160 (6):1365–72.
78. Lucon-Xiccato, T. and Bisazza, A. (2017) Complex maze learning by fish, Animal Behaviour, 125:69-75, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anbehav.2016.12.022
79. Jones, A., Brown, C. and Gardener, S. (2011) Tool use in the spotted tuskfish, Choerodon schoenleinii. Coral Reefs 30:865.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anbehav.2019.11.019
81. Vail, A., Manica, A. and Bshary, R. (2013) Referential gestures in fish collaborative hunting. Natural Communications 4, 1765. https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms2781
82. Bshary, R., Hohner, A., Ait-el-Djoudi, K. and Fricke, H. (2006) Interspecific communicative and coordinated hunting between groupers and giant moray eels in the Red Sea. PLoS Biology. 4(12): e431. doi: 10.1371/journal.pbio.0040431. PMID: 17147471; PMCID: PMC1750927.
83. Miletto Petrazzini, M. E., Agrillo, C., Izard, V., and Bisazza, A. (2016) Do humans (Homo sapiens) and fish (Pterophyllum scalare) make similar numerosity judgments? Journal of Comparative Psychology, 130:380–390
84. Dunlop, R., Millsopp, S. and Laming, P. (2006) Avoidance learning in goldfish (Carassius auratus) and trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and implications for pain perception. Applied Animal Behavioral Science. 97(2):255–71.
85. Gorissen, M., Manuel, R., Pelgrim, T.N.M., Mes, W., de Wolf, M.J.S., Zethof, J., Flik, G. and van den Bos, R. (2015) Differences in inhibitory avoidance, cortisol and brain gene expression in TL and AB zebrafish. Genes, Brain and Behavior. 14:428–38.
86. Nathan, F.M., Ogawa, S. and Pahar, I.S. (2015) Kisspeptin1 modulate odorant evoked fear response in two serotonin receptor subtypes (5-HT1A and 5-HT2) in zebrafish. Journal of Neurochemistry. 133 (6):870–8.
87. Perathoner, S., Cordero-Maldonado, M.L. and Crawford, A.D. (2016) Potential of zebrafish as a model for exploring the role of the amygdala in emotional memory and motivational behavior. Journal of Neuroscience Research. 94(6):445–62
88. Rehnberg, B.G., Bates, E.H., Smith, R.J.F., Sloley, B.D. and Richardson, J.S. (1989) Brain benzodiazepine receptors in fathead minnows and the behavioral response to alarm pheromone. Pharmacology Biochemistry and Behavior. 33(2):435–42
89. Grossman, L., Stewart, A., Gaikwad, S., Utterback, E., Wu, N., Dileo, J., Frank, K., Hart, P., Howard, H. and Kalueff, A.V. (2011) Effects of piracetam on behavior and memory in adult zebrafish. Brain Research Bulletin. 85:58–63.
90. Hedayatirad, M., Nematollahi, M.A., Forsatkar, M.N. and Brown, C. (2017) Prozac impacts lateralization of aggression in male Siamese fighting fish. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety. 140:84–8
92. Jarvis, S., Ellis, M.A., Turnbull, J.F., Planellas, S.R. and Wemelsfelder, F. (2019) Qualitative behavioural assessment of juvenile farmed Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar): Potential for on-farm welfare assessment. Frontiers in Veterinary Science, 8, 702783.
93. Wiese, T.R. Planellas, S.R., Betancor, M., Haskell, M., Jarvis, S., Davie, A., Wemelsfelder, F. and Turnbull, J.F. (2023) Qualitative Behavioural Assessment as a welfare indicator for farmed Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) in response to a stressful challenge. Frontiers in Veterinary Science, 10, 1260090.
94. Sneddon, L.U., Lopez-Luna, J., Wolfenden, D.C.C., Leach, M.C., Valentim, A.M., Steenbergen, P.J., Bardine, N., Currie, A.D., Broom, D.M. and Brown, C. (2018) Fish sentience denial: muddying the waters. Animal Sentience. 3(21):1–11.
95. Brown C. (2015) Fish intelligence, sentience and ethics. Animal Cognition. 18:1–17.
96. Bshary, R., Wickler, W. and Fricke, H. (2002) Fish cognition: a primate’s eye view. Animal Cognition. 5 (1):1–13.
97. Sneddon, L.U. (2015) Pain in aquatic animals. Journal of Experimental Biology. 218(7):967–76.
98. Sneddon, L.U. and Leach, M.C. (2016) Anthropomorphic denial of fish pain. Animal Sentience. 1(3):28
100. Nielsen, J., Hedeholm, R.B., Heinemeier, J., Bushnell, P.G., Christiansen, J.S., Olsen, J., Ramsey, C.B., Brill, R.W., Simon, M., Steffensen, K.F. and Steffensen, J.F. (2016) Eye lens radiocarbon reveals centuries of longevity in the Greenland shark (Somniosus microcephalus) Science 353(6300):702-704
101. Das, M. (1994) Age determination and longevity in fishes Gerontology 40:70-96.
102. Scottish Sea Fisheries Statistics 2022
103. Scottish Fish Farm Production Survey 2023
104. Scotland’s Aquaculture, 2024
105. Fish Health Inspectorate: mortality information
106. BVA Policy position on UK sustainable finfish aquaculture, April 2023
107. Technical Note No.22 Transport of Farmed Fish, Humane Slaughter Association April 2018
110. Animal Welfare Committee (AWC): update to the 2014 FAWC opinion on the welfare of farmed fish at the time of killing.
Contact
Email: SAWC.Secretariat@gov.scot