Private rented sector - minimum energy efficiency standard: tenant engagement research report
This research presents the finding of a series of tenants' focus groups carried out as part of the wider Private Rented Sector (PRS) Minimum Energy Efficiency Standard (MEES) Consultation which took place in 2025.
Concerns about Minimum Energy Efficiency Standards
Concerns around implementation
Research participants were broadly supportive of the introduction of MEES in principle, believing it would address existing challenges and improve standards across the sector as a whole. However, there were significant concerns about the implementation of new regulations based primarily on low trust in landlords to comply without exploiting loopholes, and in local authorities’ ability to enforce regulations effectively.
Compliance
Most concern about the feasibility of the proposals stemmed from a lack of trust in landlords to comply with them. Most participants were pessimistic about landlords’ willingness to comply with the proposed regulations, considering landlords’ perceived current reluctance to make improvements without external pressures. Many had experienced significant challenges trying to secure changes to their properties, and some had experience of disputes with landlords who refused to comply with existing legislation or improve properties. They identified ways in which landlords could avoid complying with the spirit of the legislation, for example by:
Using appeals, extensions, or slow processes to delay improvements indefinitely,
Submitting inaccurate or misleading reports or evidence to disguise substandard conditions,
Claiming unaffordability to avoid improvements, particularly where they own multiple properties that fall below the MEES,
Not registering unsuitable properties with local authorities and letting them unofficially, which would mean fewer protections for tenants,
Accepting fines as a necessity of proceeding with business as usual, rather than financing improvements,
Resorting to token compliance, involving superficial fixes or minimal cosmetic work rather than effective changes,
Withholding information from tenants or carrying out work without their full understanding, so they are unable to monitor compliance.
“I think it should be looked at thoroughly so there are no loopholes for landlords to explore because let’s be real, they are very sneaky… If there is a loophole, they will find it. It has to be looked at thoroughly to make sure every nook and cranny is sealed.”
EPC F, SEG D, Urban, focus group
Case study: Henry[5] lives in a flat with an EPC D rating, and he is currently struggling with poor insulation and a broken radiator which the landlord is not dealing with. Henry found out about grants from Home Energy Scotland which could fund insulation improvements in his home. He called the helpline to get more information and found out his home would be eligible for the scheme, and that the process would be free for his landlord. He passed on this information to his landlord, offering to help manage the process, but his landlord has ignored the information and refuses to make improvements. Henry has little trust in landlords and worries that they wouldn’t take up a scheme. He feels that the proposed MEES scheme would leave tenants with little recourse to follow this up with landlords who refuse to make improvements.
“I've collected loads of things my landlord can do and then tried to pass it over to him. […] I feel like I don't have any insulation in the roof. So, it's really, really cold […] but he's not done it yet.” EPC D, SEG C2, Rural, focus group
Enforcement
Underpinning participants’ concerns about compliance was scepticism that local authorities and the Government would be able to identify noncompliance and enforce regulations consistency. Many doubted local authority capacity to oversee and assess compliance, pointing to existing underfunding and ineffective enforcement of current standards. There was scepticism that local authorities would be able to keep track of landlords who don’t comply with the regulations, especially if this is a large proportion of landlords, as expected. They noted that local authorities could be slow to respond to tenant concerns, were often overwhelmed, and that support was inconsistent across different local authorities. A few recalled perceived collusion with bad landlords, which they worried would continue and undermine any regulations introduced.
As a result, participants doubted local authorities’ ability and willingness to enforce fines incurred by landlords, particularly if enforcement involved a lengthy appeals process that delayed consequences for landlords. Some sought the additional assurance of independent oversight and verification that would not fall under local authorities but broad awareness of local authority underfunding meant they worried this would be unaffordable.
Limited awareness of existing legislation and protections for tenants and low political trust also meant participants couldn’t point to success stories of similar regulations being enforced. Instead, many pointed to news stories or personal experiences of poor-quality housing as an indicator that current regulations were being ignored by landlords and were not being enforced by local authorities. The proposed improvements therefore felt out of reach for many in this context.
“I just wouldn’t trust the local authority for compliance. My parents live next to a short-term let… the local authorities are in charge of compliance for that and they’re having issues with it. The council didn’t do anything, and I can see this being the exact same, but on an even bigger scale.”
EPC D, SEG C2, Rural, focus group
Timescale
Participants were informed that if these regulations were introduced in their current form, they would apply to properties being let to a new tenant from April 2028 and then apply to all properties in the private rented sector by the end of 2033.
The proposed timescales felt achievable and sensible for most, but there were concerns that the long lead-in period could delay or prevent improvements. Most participants recognised the need for time to introduce the changes and prepare landlords and tenants for their implementation. Some questioned beginning with new tenancies, feeling this would mean waiting another eight years for necessary improvements. They suggested it would make more sense to prioritise the most vulnerable tenants or properties with the poorest energy efficiency. Others felt this staging made sense and would be easier for landlords and local authorities to manage.
“Eight years, you know, that you could want the energy efficiency for your little kids and in eight years they’re going to be grown up which is completely pointless.”
EPC D, SEG E, Urban, LTHC/disability, focus group
However, some participants felt the phasing of improvements made them less likely to occur and could give landlords more time to work out evasion tactics and exploit compliance loopholes. Some also feared policy changes during the lead-in period that could waste early investments or mean tenant expectations are ultimately not met if standards for improvements are lowered after being set. This was exacerbated by concerns that some landlords would do their best to delay timelines further, meaning improvements may not materialise till long past the proposed deadlines. Local authority enforcement of regulations was also expected to be a protracted process, suggesting further delays.
“People who are already living in substandard conditions will have to continue doing that for another eight years… and even then, it could be like… they could long it for ten years.”
EPC E, SEG C2, Urban, focus group
Exemptions
Participants were given an overview of proposed exemptions during the discussion and invited to provide feedback on each:
Consent
Participants were informed that it is proposed that a consent exemption would apply if a landlord is unable to get relevant consents for works e.g., if a tenant refused for the improvement to be made or third-party consent could not be obtained.
Though seen as necessary and broadly reasonable, the proposed exemptions around consent were also perceived as easily exploitable, particularly any exemptions hinging on tenant or third-party consent.
Participants worried landlords may pressure or coerce tenants into withholding consent to avoid making improvements to their property. Many suggested this could be done by withholding information from tenants about their rights or misinforming them about the regulations, particularly those who may have limited access to detailed information, such as elderly tenants or tenants with English as a second language.
“I don’t think you would get many [tenants] refusing unless it was someone that’s vulnerable that doesn’t really understand what they’re being asked… they [landlords] could make out all the tenants not agreeing… when the tenant possibly doesn’t really understand what they’re being asked to do.”
EPC D, SEG D, Suburban, focus group
Many participants also warned that tenants may feel cornered into withholding consent by landlords who are aware of limited housing options and may threaten eviction or temporary displacement if works are carried out. Even without landlord pressure, some felt tenants may not consent out of fear of being thrust into housing insecurity. This was particularly a concern for participants with financial constraints or professional/familial/academic ties to their current area, who worried about their lack of options if forced to leave. Other participants were concerned about other tenants who may lack support options (e.g., single parents, care leavers, students in HMO flats) who may be wary of losing their current properties.
“Potentially single mums or single parents with young families that are scared of housing insecurity and homelessness - if there was a scenario as extreme as the landlord threatening them and coercing them, they might be at risk as well.”
EPC D, SEG C1, Urban, focus group
To a lesser extent, some were concerned that landlords who would like to make improvements to their property may be blocked by tenants who refuse them, whether due to fears about disruption or satisfaction with current standards. For those living in tenements, there were concerns that third-party consent may also prevent necessary improvements from being made, despite willingness of other landlords and tenants.
“If there was, say, a tenant who lived in a tenement building and they couldn’t get consent from neighbouring tenants for works to be made… that could be quite frustrating from that tenant’s perspective because they’re trying to make home improvements.”
EPC D, SEG C1, Urban, focus group
Short-term holiday lets
Participants were informed that it is proposed that short-term holiday lets would also not be required to comply with the proposed regulations.
There were widespread concerns around exemptions related to tenancy types, with many participants believing some landlords may opt out of the regulated long-term rental market entirely rather than comply. Participants felt there is little preventing landlords who want to maintain a rental income but do not want to invest in improvements from converting their properties to holiday lets, non-residential properties, or otherwise out of scope to sidestep regulations. This was a particular concern for properties in highly populated urban areas or tourist hotspots, where there is felt to be little risk of loss of rental income for landlords.
“The first thing I picked up on was the holiday lets being exempt, which I think is ridiculous because if I was a landlord and I had to do all of this work for a tenant, then I would just turn my home into a holiday let… which means less housing for people.”
EPC D, SEG C1, Islands, depth
Negative impacts on fabric or structure of property
Participants were informed that it is proposed that this exemption would apply if certain improvements are inappropriate or could negatively impact the property, which would need to be assessed by a relevantly qualified person.
Though seen as necessary for older buildings unsuitable for works, some felt fabric exemptions may be misapplied where possible to avoid investing in upgrades. Some participants worried landlords may exploit listed building status or planning/heritage constraints to secure exemptions or delay works, even where improvements might otherwise be viable. Concerns about enforcement meant some were sceptical about fair and accurate assessment of these exemptions, needing more reassurance that independent inspection will correctly identify false claims.
“It comes down to this listed building thing because, not just rural, but even the cities in Scotland, there’s listed buildings every two, three doors… that needs to be looked at, otherwise every building is going to be exempt.”
EPC E, SEG D, Rural, LTHC/disability, focus group
Cost cap
Participants were informed that it is proposed that this exemption provide a maximum ceiling in terms of the costs a landlord should pay to achieve the standard. If the landlord spends up to a certain amount and is still below EPC C, they can apply this exemption. The current proposed cap is £10,000.
The proposed cost cap was seen as reasonable by most, though some cautioned that £10,000 would be insufficient for some improvements needed and may not result in tangible change to energy efficiency standards. Participants recognised the need for an affordable cost cap to ensure landlord commitment. But they expected that homes with very poor energy efficiency (due to poor insulation, heating, or damp) and larger or older homes that are harder to keep warm need more work than the cost cap would cover. They worried that works would cause disruption and discomfort without paying off in noticeable energy efficiency improvements.
“I’ve got eight windows up the stairs and four downstairs, then two doors and then a boiler and all the radiators to cover… ten grand wouldn’t cover that.”
EPC D, SEG D, Suburban, focus group
Some participants also questioned the effectiveness of the cost cap if it does not include guidelines or cost regulations. They noted landlords may opt to do minimal work within the cost cap rather than more comprehensive improvements that may mean extended disruption or displacement. Inaccurate cost claims were also raised as a concern by many, fearing landlords may claim that needed upgrades exceed the cap through inflated quotes to avoid making them. Some also pointed to inflation and demand increase, which could make improvements unaffordable / out of scope as vendors raise their prices to capitalise on regulations.
“If I look at my property and I think of the amount of work that needs to be done to bring this up to standard, they could just do one thing up to nine grand and then say, ‘Oh, everything else over that is going to take me over the threshold’.”
EPC E, SEG C2, Urban, focus group
Impact on the Private Rented Sector
Housing affordability
The most pressing risk of MEES identified by participants was a potential loss of affordable housing, which could price existing tenants out of local rental markets. Most participants cautioned that landlords could raise rents to recoup the costs of improvements, particularly if grants or loans aren’t available, meaning the financial burden would fall on tenants. There was particular worry that tenants on low incomes, with prepayment meters, or other vulnerable groups such as single parent families, carers, low-income households, students, or elderly or disabled tenants may be disproportionately harmed by indirect cost shifts that they can’t absorb. Many participants expected landlords to use eviction or non‑renewal of leases to allow them to re-let at higher rents, displacing tenants who are unable to cover the upgrade costs.
“The rent increase, I don’t have the money for that… There’s no housing here, I don’t know where I’m going to end up living… I would need something written ironclad saying, ‘We’re not going to kick you out, we’re not going to sell it’.”
EPC E, SEG D, Rural, LTHC/disability, focus group
Loss of affordable housing was expected to be most severe in urban areas or areas with limited housing stock / competitive rental markets, where those unable to afford higher rents could be priced out of the area or pushed into rental insecurity. Participants felt that any improvement in affordability due to reductions in energy bills would be undermined by these increases, and there was scepticism that they would be sufficiently offset any savings on bills.
“It worries me about the young families…. Lots of children and mums and they’ve found their forever flat and they’re happy…. Then suddenly they’re not compliant and [the landlord]’s got to say, ‘Right, I’m sorry, I have to say here’s your notice because I can’t comply and I can’t afford to comply’.”
EPC D, SEG B, Urban, LTHC/disability, focus group
Case study: Arthur[6] lives in the Islands in a flat with an EPC E rating. He struggles to live in his cold, energy inefficient property particularly due to his age, being 70 years old, and living with a disability/LTHC. Financial hardship is a major issue affecting his daily life; therefore, Arthur takes various steps to both save more money and keep warm in his flat. He dries his clothes on the radiator, ‘jumping’ into them as soon as he can to save heat, and sits under his duvet when watching TV instead of heating the home. Despite these efforts, the cost of bills remains high as he recounts paying triple in standing charges than the actual energy used whilst he was away visiting friends. Arthur lacks faith in the Government in keeping to the terms it has set out through the MEES and fears the potential impact of increased rent costs. He is also sceptical of local authorities leading compliance and would much prefer to see external companies ensure high standards.
“If you look at a place that’s got many flats… How protected are those tenants coming back into the place [after MEES improvements]? Are they guaranteed the same rent?... I just don’t know if there seems to be any protection.”
EPC E, SEG E, Islands, LTHC/disability, aged 60+, focus group
Housing availability
Many participants worried the rental market in their area would constrict as landlords choose to sell their properties or otherwise remove them from the long-term rental market. In urban areas, participants expected landlords to switch to short-term lets or sell entirely to avoid compliance, reducing the number of homes available for tenants in the PRS. Participants were acutely aware of the lack of local authority housing available to people who are homeless or temporarily displaced as a result, and anticipated more housing insecurity for those who can’t afford rent increases and can’t find alternative housing.
“If your house is a holiday let then you don’t have to do it. So, the landlords will just go, ‘Okay, I’ll take my property back now’ after how many years, give them a year or two years notice and then just turn it into a holiday [home]. Especially here on the islands, they’ll quite easily make their money through the summer.”
EPC D, SEG C1, Islands, depth
In rural areas, particularly islands, where housing availability is already limited, this concern was more pronounced. Constraints on works due to limited contractors, slower transport, and adverse weather were perceived by participants as likely to cause delays and increase costs of any improvements, making it more likely that properties will be taken off the rental market and local shortages will intensify. Participants feared being entirely pushed/priced out of areas where much of the housing has poor energy performance and landlords are unable or unwilling to make the changes, especially considering the lack of temporary accommodation available. Many participants remained concerned despite assurances that landlords will be able to let properties that do not meet the MEES, provided some improvements have been made.
Participants’ concerns about housing availability in both rural and urban locations focused on households that have limited mobility due to remote locations, caregiving duties that limit their flexibility, or children attending school locally, all of whom would struggle to relocate if pushed out.
“One fear up here in [the island], well it’s the same all over Scotland but it’s especially bad here, is the housing. There’s a severe lack as there is and there’s always in the back of my mind that I’m going to get a letter through the door or he’s [landlord] going to come knock… saying ‘I need to sell’.”
EPC E, SEG D, Islands, LTHC/disability, focus group
Short-term disruption
Improvements to properties were expected to cause disruption and discomfort, with some research participants worrying about the logistics of temporary displacement. All participants acknowledged that works would affect tenants’ day-to-day lives through increased mess and noise, potential time off work, temporary loss of utilities, disruption of routine, and safety concerns about contractors having access to homes. Many participants questioned whether this would also lead to voluntary or involuntary displacement, worrying about loss of income, storage costs, logistical caregiving problems, and school impacts for those with children if forced to temporarily relocate.
“Unless they were doing the insulation from the exterior or pumping the stuff in, if they were doing it on the interior, you wouldn’t be able to live in the place because of the dust… You’d have to move all your stuff out. You’d have to find storage and you wouldn’t be able to live in the place.”
EPC E, SEG E, Islands, digitally disengaged, aged 60+, focus group
Those participants concerned about needing to vacate for works also pointed to a lack of suitable temporary accommodation (especially in small towns or islands) for private sector tenants, particularly if there were to be high demand for it due to widespread displacement, and sought assurances around responsibility for rehousing costs to protect vulnerable tenants. Some participants feared that inadequate arrangements would pressure tenants into moving out of their property or area entirely rather than weather the disruption. There was a risk identified by research participants that tenants who are worried about temporary displacement could be pressured into not consenting to works, even if they’d like them to be made.
“I’ve known people to get houses insulated and essentially, they have to move out while all the walls and floors get ripped out… So obviously that would be a big thing for a tenant, especially if they’ve got a family like ourselves… we’d have to find somewhere to live while the work was being done, or live on a building site which is not the best with a small child.”
EPC D, SEG C1, Islands, depth
Housing quality
To a lesser extent, there were also concerns from research participants that landlords may not carry out works to suitable standards, and that mandated improvements may unintentionally worsen the quality of some properties. Many participants anticipated poor quality or token changes to properties by noncompliant landlords, which would mean little benefit for tenants while still causing displacement or creating enforcement headaches. Some participants recalled their landlords’ reliance on cowboy contractors who created further complications rather than effectively resolving issues in order to save costs, and expected them to continue doing so. Participants also expected that many landlords would do the bare minimum work needed, which may not meaningfully improve energy efficiency but could still be used to justify de‑letting or rent increases.
“I think the idea is great, like making my landlord fix this… I just have distrust of are they going to try and get around that to avoid doing it?”
EPC D, SEG C2, Rural, focus group
Cost-cutting was expected by some research participants to mean ugly external works that could reduce property values or make homes more unpleasant to live in. This was partly the result of a lack of clarity around improvements covered under the new regulations. There was some doubt from research participants about the suitability of certain technologies (e.g. heat pumps, external insulation) for older/stone/listed buildings and the impact on energy efficiency, and limited understanding of what improvements would be covered/allowed under the regulations. Participants feared some works may be inappropriate for many property types and could harm property value or usability, without proper oversight of improvements undertaken by landlords.
“It could also have an effect on selling the property if you’ve got ugly things attached to the outside of the house… So, unless you can find a way to make them more energy efficient without destroying the character.”
EPC D, SEG C1, Rural, LTHC/disability, aged 60+, depth
Contact
Email: PRSMEESConsultation@gov.scot