Private rented sector - minimum energy efficiency standard: tenant engagement research report

This research presents the finding of a series of tenants' focus groups carried out as part of the wider Private Rented Sector (PRS) Minimum Energy Efficiency Standard (MEES) Consultation which took place in 2025.


Potential benefits of Minimum Energy Efficiency Standards

Better living standards

Most research participants expected the proposed MEES to improve the experience of living in their property. Participants expected warmer, more comfortable living environments. This was particularly exciting for participants who were having to ration their energy use as a result of poor energy insulation.

Beyond the physical benefits, participants also mentioned the emotional and mental benefits of living in a more comfortable property, especially during colder periods. For those who felt unable to move to a different property because of school or family commitments, improved energy efficiency standards were perceived to have a particularly important impact on quality of life.

Lower energy bills

Participants hoped improvements would lower their energy bills, particularly in the context of high living costs. They saw that energy efficiency measures would mean their homes would require less energy to heat, which would likely reduce their bills. Participants welcomed this as it would alleviate some financial strain and allow them to spend more money on other essentials such as food.

Those using pre-paid meters for energy payments felt that meeting EPC C standards would also reduce and make their energy costs more consistent, making it easier for them to plan their finances.

Participants felt that lower energy bills would allow them to keep their homes warmer and temperatures more consistent without being overly cautious about their energy use. For example, by heating more rooms in their property or running heating more consistently during the day. This was a particularly important benefit for parents with young children who felt it would give them the ability to heat all the areas of the home they needed to in order to keep their family comfortable.

Some participants also suggested that older people living alone who might not think it’s “worth it” to keep their home warm for one person, or single parents living on one income, might feel more able to keep their homes warm.

“I think it’s [MEES] to save people money. I think it’s a good idea. It’s to keep more heat in the house rather than going through the walls and the windows and the doors.”

EPC D, SEG B, Suburban, LTHC/disability, depth

Better health

Participants also expected to see mental and physical health benefits as a result of better living conditions. Participants regularly stated that warmer homes would limit the spread of damp and mould, reducing the risks of respiratory illness such as asthma and pneumonia, particularly for young children. They also felt that reducing people’s anxiety about warmth and rationing heating (closely linked to concerns around bills or health impacts) would lead to improved mental health.

Disabled or chronically ill participants (or those with dependants who are) agreed that improved living standards would have a positive impact on their health through better temperature conditions. Similarly, parents with young children felt health benefits would more positively impact their families by providing consistent warmth.

Most non-disabled participants also agreed that for people who have conditions worsened by cold, this would be a strong benefit. A small number of participants linked a widespread roll-out of MEES to reduced strain on the health service, as people would be less likely to fall ill or see their conditions worsen due to cold.

“Not have to struggle and affect your mental health… Where you're going to get the money to extra heat. You've got kids. That pressure on your mind that am I heating up the property enough? Am I keeping them safe enough? Am I keeping them well enough?”

EPC D, SEG E, LTHC/disability, Suburban, depth

“If you're not dealing with as much damp and mould issues, it being a warmer property that makes people be happier and healthier as well. Especially in the first example that disabilities and stuff like that, that's going to deteriorate people's health.”

EPC D, SEG C1, Urban, focus group

Improving the private rented sector

Participants saw the proposed regulations as a move towards improving the housing standards in the Scottish PRS. This was because they felt they would:

Address disparities between different locations and types of properties, ensuring all renters, including those living in vulnerable circumstances, have access to the same warm and energy efficient homes.

Help new tenants signing onto contracts be more informed about what energy efficiency means, whilst also having reassurance that their new home will be to the same standard as all others in their area.

Guarantee improvements to current properties. This is particularly important in areas with low housing availability as it removes the need to move away to find ‘better’ quality homes.

Benefits for landlords

Participants also saw the proposed regulations as having the potential to benefit landlords by improving the value and long-term appeal of their properties. They felt that improvements would lead to increased tenant satisfaction, and to longer tenancies. More efficient properties were also felt to be more attractive for future tenants signing onto homes.

Environmental benefits

There was some recognition of better energy efficiency contributing to a more sustainable private rented sector and benefitting Scotland as a whole. However, direct benefits to individuals, such as more comfortable homes and cheaper bills were more front of mind to participants.

Case study: Amelia[4] lives in an old house in the Islands with her partner and young children. Her current EPC rating is ‘E’ and she struggles to keep out draughts and maintain a good temperature, which she has tried but failed to get support for. Living in the Islands, bad weather makes it difficult to get contractors over. Amelia’s family also has a tight monthly budget so she makes the choice to mainly heat her children’s rooms, who have sensory induced autism and require warm temperatures. The key benefits Amelia sees from the regulations include the financial relief of not having to be selective of how she heats her property, better mental health and lower stress, and meeting her children’s specific needs.

“If the landlord is told to improve the property to a certain standard… it's going to be warmer, it's going to be dry, it's going to be less of a stress to balance it. Mentally that takes a lot of stress out of having to worry about the financial implications or even just emotional impact of being in a freezing cold house all the time."

EPC E, SEG C1, Islands, depth

Contact

Email: PRSMEESConsultation@gov.scot

Back to top