Private rented sector - minimum energy efficiency standard: tenant engagement research report
This research presents the finding of a series of tenants' focus groups carried out as part of the wider Private Rented Sector (PRS) Minimum Energy Efficiency Standard (MEES) Consultation which took place in 2025.
Background and methodology
Research background
The Scottish Government is proposing the introduction of a Minimum Energy Efficiency Standard (MEES) applying to properties in the Private Rented Sector (PRS). The aim of this policy is to improve the quality of PRS homes and reduce the energy demand of heating homes, benefiting the environment and PRS tenants where approximately 44% of dwellings are estimated to be in fuel poverty.
A public consultation[2] into these measures took place between 6th June 2025 and 29th August 2025, but tenant voices were under-represented in this process. Therefore, the Scottish Government commissioned Thinks Insight and Strategy to conduct qualitative research with PRS tenants to support the consultation.
This research was designed to ensure PRS tenant views are thoroughly heard as part of the policy development process and that any potential unintended consequences of the policy’s introduction are identified so they can be guarded against. The Scottish Government wanted to hear from tenants across the PRS, including those who might be most impacted by the changes, for example those living in vulnerable circumstances or who live in areas with low PRS housing stock.
Research objectives:
- Understand tenants’ opinions regarding the proposed MEES across a sample of participants from varying socioeconomic backgrounds and EPC rated properties.
- Identify potential impacts of the MEES to ensure the legislation is effective in its implementation and re-emphasise its expected benefits.
- Explore any concerns regarding the MEES to mitigate negative consequences that may affect tenants and highlight any challenges that may not have been considered previously.
- Understand if there are any groups of tenants that might be more specifically impacted by legislation because of their needs or personal circumstances.
Methodology
In order to explore this topic, we used a qualitative approach:
Five focus groups (each with four to seven participants) with PRS tenants grouped by location, socioeconomic background and EPC rated property.
Eight in-depth interviews conducted remotely to speak to PRS tenants who were older, disabled, living on the islands and/or digitally disengaged.
In total, we spoke to 36 participants. Across the sample, we heard from participants living in a range of properties, which varied by property type, property age and property location. Participants were also recruited across a range of ages, socioeconomic status grades, and protected characteristics. A full sample breakdown can be found in the appendix.
No participants had detailed understanding of the proposed MEES regulations before taking part in the research. A summary of the proposed MEES regulations was shared with participants at the outset of the focus groups and in-depth interviews, to enable an informed discussion of the proposals.
Experiences of energy efficiency in the Private Rented Sector
The most common challenge research participants faced in relation to energy efficiency was keeping a property warm. This was largely due to inadequate and inefficient building infrastructure which did not regulate temperature well. Participants felt this was a particular challenge during colder weather and the winter months; but for some in older or poorly ventilated properties, humid summer months also caused discomfort. While a sample of research participants lived in higher EPC rated properties, they still felt they faced similar challenges with heat retention, particularly if they lived in an older property.
Examples of less efficient infrastructure mentioned by participants included single glazed windows, draughty doors, old heating, and poorly insulated rooms, which often lead to further issues such as damp or mould. Echoing the findings of other research[3], the participants who were most impacted by these challenges were more likely to be living:
In much older buildings which have less efficient infrastructure in place and are more likely to experience more significant challenges with damp and mould
In rural areas, whose buildings often bear the brunt of colder or more extreme weather than those living in urban centres
With dependants (including young children or older relatives), who can be more impacted by colder temperatures
With disabilities or long-term health conditions that are worsened by low temperatures.
“We've had to select times when the property can be heated and it's usually always only when the kids are home. If it's myself and my partner in the house, all the heating is off constantly because instead of having to spend the money, we will wrap up, and we'll sit there with a hot water bottle. We'll put the heating on an hour before they come so the house is warm for them.”
EPC E, SEG C1, Islands, depth
“My flat was so cold, I didn’t even want to be in the house in the winter, I would just avoid being home… I’m paying rent for a property I can’t even enjoy and then things like damp and being able to dry your clothes, I had to get a tumble dryer because the clothes would go mouldy.”
EPC E, SEG C2, Urban, focus group
High energy bills were also a key concern for research participants living in energy inefficient homes, particularly in the context of the rising cost of living. Those with lower EPC rated properties were particularly affected, as they felt that they had to spend more money to keep their homes warm. Participants living in larger properties also mentioned feeling they faced higher energy bills as a result of their property’s size.
In addition to being a significant (often unaffordable) household expense, participants also spoke about the impact of these high energy bills on their mental health, with participants mentioning feeling anxiety and worry about being able to make payments.
“Because I'm ground floor [in] a Victorian tenement flat, it's just constant draught from everywhere and I don't have the skills, the desire or the money to fix that. So, I just tend to be at uni all day and then at the gym or the library at night, and then just come home and go to sleep.”
EPC E, SEG C2, Urban, focus group
“We have to constantly balance and sacrifice [things] because of the financial implication that comes with [managing our home]. We don’t have an expendable income… any time [my partner] has things to worry about, it increases the amount his mental health suffers.”
EPC E, SEG C1, Islands, depth
Many participants said they had raised these challenges with their landlord but had seen little meaningful action as a result. Most participants reported being ignored by their landlords when making requests for improvements. Those who have had a response from their landlord had generally seen partial or low-quality improvements, or temporary solutions such as plug-in heaters.
Where landlords have responded well in the past, participants found that the previous fixes no longer met the current needs of the property (e.g., old window glazing or insulation). Some research participants living in tenements also mentioned landlords citing restrictions or difficulty getting permissions as barriers to making certain improvements. Many participants stated they are reluctant to invest in significant improvements themselves due to the costs and temporary nature of their home.
“I had an accident about three years ago, since then my health has completely deteriorated… When circumstances change, you realise what the person is really like. The landlord showed us his true colours… he kept ignoring everything… It was a complete and utter nightmare.”
EPC D, SEG E, Suburban, LTHC/disability, depth
“I rent a two-bedroom house and my biggest thing is communication with my landlord and if anything goes wrong in the house, it’s just a nightmare to try and get things fixed.”
EPC D, SEG D, Suburban, focus group
In the absence of landlords offering improvements, many participants said they have had to make-do, adopting their own strategies for regulating temperatures and improving their energy efficiency. This included layering up when indoors, only heating certain rooms (for example, the room they spend the most time in, or their children’s bedrooms), covering draughty door gaps, or using heating pads on chairs. Some invested in non-structural strategies to keep warm such as using curtains to keep draughts out, or in the summer months using dehumidifiers. For these non-structural strategies, participants often paid out of pocket themselves, which many considered significant investments. A few obtained permission from their landlords to invest in bigger property changes such as flooring underlays.
“I tend not to try to burn too much [energy] because it’s quite expensive. I tend to put my heating on early and I just drape my clothes over there and then jump into them as soon as I can and save as much heat as I can.”
EPC E, SEG E, Islands, LTHC/disability, aged 60+, focus group
“The hallway is always freezing… There were gaps in the walls and around the door and stuff like that. So, I sealed everything up and then I replaced the flooring. I made sure there was no gaps and everything. I put [a] curtain at the front door in the window. It did help a bit, but it’s still not as warm as the rest of the house.”
EPC D, SEG E, Urban, LTHC/disability, focus group
Contact
Email: PRSMEESConsultation@gov.scot