Justice Social Work: national practice standards and outcomes
This is an over-arching document which provides a clear framework of professional accountability that will stand up to scrutiny and provide assurance of the agreed principles of practice and is intended to complement current practice guidance.
Part of
4. Justice Social Work Practice
This section outlines the standards of practice that are expected of JSW and services. It also provides guidance on how the standards relate to the core functions of the justice social work role, and the key stages of a person’s involvement in the justice system.
What works literature has been reviewed and updated and the standards, and these evidence-based practice principles that underpin them should apply to all justice social work interventions. This is whether: a limited number of appointments for a court report; a short term piece of work prior to conviction; or working with someone for a number of years who is subject to community supervision; or progressing through a custodial sentence and preparing for release.
Ensuring that practice is evidence-based and meets standards is vital for ensuring a good outcome for the person, and the wider community in terms of creating stability and reducing the risk of further offending behaviour. By taking a ‘trauma informed’ approach this means being able to recognise when someone may be affected by trauma, collaboratively adjusting how we work to take this into account and responding in a way that supports recovery, does no harm and recognises and supports people's resilience. The key principles of a trauma informed approach are:
- safety
- trustworthiness
- empowerment
- choice
- collaboration
Practice Standard 1: People in contact with JSW have their rights and responsibilities explained to them in a way that is clear and understandable.
4.1 Establish communication needs
Research has shown that many people in the justice system have literacy issues or other communication needs. Service providers estimate that neurodiversity is three times more common in the criminal justice system than in the general population. There is limited data on this in terms of the Scottish population and the general view from support organisations are these figures are an under representation and the real figure is much higher due to a lack of screening.
Establishing communication preferences and styles at this early stage can assist in promoting compliance and engagement. Workers should also consider how interventions (e.g. groupwork, supervision, support planning) can be flexibly adapted to suit how people best process and apply information, leading to more effective engagement and understanding from those with whom they are working.
4.2 Expectation setting
The initial contact is the opportunity to set out expectations and ensure an understanding of obligations. There is often a lot of information to absorb prior to an initial meeting following a court appearance or on release from prison so it is important to ensure that there is a clear understanding of the current situation and then routinely follow up to confirm continued understanding during contact. At the initial meeting the worker should clearly explain the elements of the contact including roles, responsibilities and rights of all parties. By adopting a human rights-based approach it will help to build trust in the relationship from the outset. For people who have experienced trauma, predictable and reliable interactions help counter past experiences of unpredictability or betrayal. Giving people the opportunity to feed back their understanding of their situation and demonstrate that they have the right to participate in decisions relating to their contact with JSW at this stage establishes that this is an integral part of the working relationship and normalises this process going forward.
4.3 Boundary setting
Boundary setting around acceptable behaviour and language should be discussed at an early stage, along with expectations regarding attendance for appointments. Boundaries are essential because they protect both the individual and the worker, provide predictability and safety, build trust, and help people develop skills to manage challenges and make positive choices. Consideration should be given to how to explain the person’s right to be treated fairly and if they are unhappy with anything that they know how to raise this. Workers should confirm that there is an expectation they are also accountable for the development of the working relationship. They will listen to concerns, provide explanation and take any necessary action in a transparent manner. This is particularly important when working with people where there will be an inevitable degree of scrutiny and verification of information provided due to management of risk. Methods of keeping in contact should be agreed, with contact details recorded of anyone else in their life that they are happy for the worker to make contact with in case they cannot be reached.
4.4 Establishing trust
It is recognised that there is an inherent power imbalance in the working relationship with a person subject to social work involvement. Thought should be given to how this initial stage of involvement is structured, particularly if there is a need to gather a lot of information from the person. Workers need to be mindful of this by explaining why they need the information they are asking for, what it will be used for, who will have access to it and how long it will be kept for. Dialogue involving the use of negotiation can help to address some of that power imbalance and lead to better levels of engagement.
The use of checklists or pro-forma at these initial meetings can help to keep the contacts focussed and ensure all the required information is collected, for example to undertake unpaid work or get ready for group work. Workers must balance the information required for the successful implementation of a statutory order with the needs of the person they are building a supportive working relationship with, and this should be reviewed continuously.
The skill of the worker is to gather required information sensitively without it feeling overwhelming, overly intrusive or impersonal. Delivering services in a trauma informed way means understanding that individuals may have a history of traumatic experiences which may impact on their ability to feel safe and develop trusting relationships with services and professionals. Sometimes this can lead to interactions that are defensive or guarded until trust is developed.
However, taking a trauma informed approach can help to strengthen the working relationship and support engagement. Ensuring physical and emotional safety, being transparent and consistent to build trust, and actively collaborating with the person can create an environment where they feel secure and respected. Offering meaningful choices where appropriate, such as how sessions are structured, what topics to focus on, or which support options to access, helps restore a sense of control that may have been lost through early trauma. Supporting empowerment by validating experiences, building on individual strengths, and encouraging active participation in decision-making strengthens confidence and resilience.
4.5 Development of Working Relationship
Unless it is a brief contact, for preparation of a court report for example, this initial phase will be characterised by frequent meetings. Intensity of contact thereafter will be proportionate to the assessed likelihood and impact of reoffending.
Appointments should give sufficient time to address any statutory requirements of the contact whilst also addressing immediate practical issues such as housing or health concerns.
At this stage, consideration of how best to address any identified needs should be undertaken which could include referral to third sector organisations. They can offer a different approach and provide a more specialist intervention around addictions or mental health and wellbeing, for example, which would complement planned interventions set out in the management plan.
Contact with JSW in the community may involve a mix of face-to-face, office or locality based appointments, virtual meetings using video calls and announced and, where appropriate, unannounced home visits.
Having a space where people can have safe, confidential discussions on sensitive subjects is crucial to the development of the working relationship.
Home visits are considered essential to building a picture of the person’s life, their local community and those involved with them to provide a more holistic view of the person’s risks and needs. Unless there are defensible and documented reasons for not doing so, meeting people in their home should be an integral and consistent part of supervision. Establishing from the outset that some appointments will take place at home, and the reasons for this, normalises this type of contact thus reducing any potential anxiety the person may have related to home visits.
Practice Standard 2: All contacts and decisions are recorded in accordance with local information systems and recording procedures.
4.6 Case Recording
Case recording is integral to social work practice as it provides an account of contacts and any decisions taken. It is a crucial aspect of practice, particularly if there is a decision to do something or not to do something which deviates from the agreed plan or practice guidance. This provides an explanation of reasons for decisions being taken such as a reduction in contact frequency or extending the period to produce a management plan for particular reasons. Consideration should be given to which decisions require a line manager’s endorsement and local case recording policies will reflect this.
Practice Standard 3: Planned interventions are evidence based and proportionate to the risk and need analysis
4.7 Assessing Risks and Needs
Assessing and responding to a person’s needs and risks is a core and on-going element of the JSW role. Practice should be guided by the principles contained within the Framework for Risk Assessment Management and Evaluation (FRAME) which outlines an agreed risk assessment and management framework that supports multi-agency practice through a shared understanding of roles, responsibilities, process and language of risk in Scotland. Interventions should therefore be evidence based and proportionate to the assessed risk.
Overview of FRAME:
FRAME outlines the five practice standards that set out the required elements of risk assessment and management practice.
Guiding Principles in FRAME:
FRAME advocates for risk practice to be underpinned by the four guiding principles which are the following; balancing rights, proportionality, collaboration and evidence-based practice. As such, JSW should be guided by these principles, for further detail on these see Chapter 4 – Guiding Principles within FRAME (2011).
Risk Assessment Process within FRAME:
The purpose of risk assessment is to estimate the likelihood and impact of further offending in order to inform decision making. Standard 1 of FRAME proposes that the risk assessment process should involve the following steps:
- Identification of key pieces of information, this element of assessment can be assisted by the application of appropriate risk assessment tools to help identify relevant risk and protective factors.
- Analysis of the relevant information to produce a formulation or understanding of individual risk. Addressing imminence in cases where a further risk of serious harm assessment indicates the need for contingency measures.
- Evaluation against the appropriate decision making criteria, and the context and purpose of the assessment e.g. to inform release decisions from custody or supervision intensity levels.
- Meaningful communication of the assessment to inform decision making and action, risk will be communicated in terms of the pattern, nature, seriousness and likelihood of offending.
Tiered Approach to risk practice & the Level of Service Method
FRAME proposes a tiered and proportionate approach which supports practice at minimal, comprehensive and intensive levels, which is fundamentally built around the principles of risk, needs and responsivity[1]
The Level of Service/ Case Management Inventory (LS/CMI)[2] method in use within Scotland enables an evaluation of the pattern, nature, seriousness and likelihood of offending and, providing a structure for professional decision making that is consistent and comprehensible regardless of the nature or complexity of the case.
The process for administering the LS/CMI follows a tiered approach as outlined in FRAME, which enables three different levels or depths of assessment of risk in terms of likelihood and impact. Essentially a process of risk scanning, and proportionately greater levels of assessment and intervention are applied dependent on the features of the individual case. This approach promotes proportionality and evidence-based practice - fundamentals of defensible, responsible and ethical practice.
The three levels/depths of assessment are as follows:
- Tier 1: A Scan Level or Initial Assessment: Applied at pre-sentence stage. The purpose of this risk scan is to ground the initial assessment in a brief actuarial tool (LSIR:SV)[3] and to provide a structured consideration of the pattern, nature, seriousness and likelihood of offending. This then allows an evaluation of the decision making options based on the initial assessment of offending, against knowledge of the suitability of community disposals. The advice to courts offered in Justice Social Work reports is informed by this evaluation.
- Tier 2: An Examination Level: This is an assessment using the LS/CMI 1-8 and is undertaken on the occasions where fuller assessment is required pre-disposal, and in all cases where a sentence involves statutory social work supervision. For example: via community order; during a period of imprisonment (if the individual will be subject to a release license); and for the duration of the supervision period of the licence after release from custody. This depth of assessment is used to inform decisions about the management plan for the individual whilst subject to social work intervention.
- Tier 3: A Scrutiny of Risk: is completed for those individuals where there are indicators of a risk of serious harm and is used, amongst other things, to inform decisions on what type of plan is required to manage the risks the individual presents. Risk of serious harm is defined as:
“The likelihood of harmful behaviour, of a violent or sexual nature, which is life threatening and/or traumatic, and from which recovery, whether physical or psychological, may reasonably be expected to be difficult or impossible.”[4]
As part of this depth of assessment the assessor is required to make a judgement on the risk of serious harm level posed (outlined within the MAPPA Guidance 2022).
Judgements about the risk of serious harm level posed should consider the likelihood and imminence of further seriously harmful offending. The assessor should also consider what is then required to manage/mitigate these risk(s) and if the individual requires active and alert, multi-agency risk management or single agency, routine case management to manage the risk(s) posed. Standards and Guidelines for Risk Management (RMA, 2025) are the standards of practice in relation to the management of individuals who present a risk of serious harm that requires active and alert, multi-agency risk management planning and also apply to the management of those who are subject to an Order for Lifelong Restriction.
It is critical that the worker takes time to help the person understand the outcome of any risk assessment process and the implications of this. Whilst the person may not agree with every aspect of the assessment itself, the primary objective is always the protection of the public.
4.8 Development of a management plan
The management plan is developed from the use of the LS/CMI method which provides the foundation of any plan being applied. Practitioners should have completed relevant training before undertaking the use of any risk assessment tools. The assessment will help inform management planning decisions - including identifying which factors to target during any period of intervention. Information on all relevant risk assessment tools in use in Scotland are contained on the Risk Management Authority’s website: Rated - RMA - Risk Management Authority.
The full LS/CMI will be applied in all instances where the individual is subject to statutory social work supervision (via a community order) or will be subject to social work supervision on release from custody. This method has a structure to analyse offending and consider criminogenic needs which is then used to help inform decisions on whether more assessment is required (a full risk of serious harm assessment) and what type of plan is required to manage the risk e.g. a case management plan or a risk management plan. The additional use of specialised risk assessment tools for offences of domestic abuse or sexual offending will ensure that the plan focusses on the factors most relevant to reducing risks of further offending.
To develop an action or support plan for diversion from prosecution, supervised bail, and structured deferred sentence, workers should use alternative tools which have a greater focus on meeting need rather than managing risk. The RMA has recently published a report on Risk Assessment without Convictions which offers an opportunity to consider the benefits and drawbacks to adopting a risk based approach prior to conviction.
Any plan should be collaborative in nature and evidence that the person who is the subject has been involved in its development and has had sight of the plan. It can also establish if there are any other people; family or friends, support workers or agencies involved that would benefit from inclusion in meetings or more formal reviews to support the plan. This holistic approach provides the best outcomes, particularly when considering desistance from further offending and developing more pro-social attitudes - key factors in reducing risk.
It is recognised that the development of the plan can be an evolving process as more becomes know about the person. However, an initial plan should be devised within the first four weeks of supervision. Thereafter, the plan should be refined and developed as work progresses.
There is strong evidence that the interventions that are most effective in addressing offending behaviour are based on The Risk Need Responsivity Model (RNR). The RNR principle states the level of intervention should be matched to the risk of reoffending and the person’s criminogenic needs. Support should be delivered in a way that is tailored to maximise their specific responsivity. This typically involves cognitive elements, and therefore often uses Cognitive Behavioural Therapy or other evidence-based psycho-social treatments.
The three core RNR principles are:
- Risk is about whom to target, based upon a person’s likelihood of reoffending. This is important because interventions should match the likelihood of reoffending – rehabilitative interventions should be offered to moderate and high-risk cases, with low-risk cases receiving minimal intervention
- Need is about what should be done – identified criminogenic needs should be the focus of targeted interventions, rather than other needs which are not related to offending behaviour. These can be addressed by referrals to third sector providers or be focussed on in alternative sessions delivered by paraprofessional staff, for example.
- Responsivity is about how the work should be delivered, covering both general and specific responsivity. While general responsivity promotes the use of cognitive social learning methods to influence behaviour, specific responsivity provides that interventions should be tailored to, amongst other things, the strengths of the individual.
Adherence to these principles, in addition to assessment and consideration of the likelihood and potential impact of any further offending, determines the development of the management plan.
Practice Standard 4: Frequency of contact must be determined by considering the pattern, nature and seriousness of offending to date along with an assessment of the likelihood and impact of further offending.
4.9 Intensity of Contact Levels
Consideration of the likelihood and impact of further offending, as part of the completion of the risk assessment, should inform defensible decisions on frequency of contact/intensity levels.
The following guidelines should therefore apply:
Intensity level: Very High Intensity
Contact level: Once a week with case manager and can be up to seven contacts per week with other staff or partner agencies.
To include planned and unannounced home visits.
Review Frequency: Contact frequency should be formally reviewed at least every three months but can be sooner if circumstances require it.
Compliance: Failure to attend for appointments followed up by a home visit on the day.
Intensity level: High intensity
Contact level: Once a week with case manager and can be up to three contacts per week with other staff or partner agencies. To include planned and unannounced home visits.
Review Frequency: Reviewed at least every three months.
Compliance: Failure to attend for appointments followed up by a home visit on the day.
Intensity level: Medium intensity
Contact level: Once a week with case manager for initial 3 months. If the situation is reviewed as stable contact may be reduced to once a fortnight thereafter. To include planned and unannounced home visits.
Review Frequency: Reviewed after the initial three months. If circumstances and level of risk is assessed as stable, reviews can be conducted every six months thereafter.
Compliance: Failure to attend for appointment followed up by telephone or in person within two working days.
Intensity level: Low intensity
Contact level: Once a month with case manager to include planned home visits.
Review Frequency: Reviewed every six months.
Compliance: Failure to attend for appointment followed up by telephone or in person within two working days.
4.10 Ongoing Case Management
Depending on the nature of the person’s involvement with JSW the period of case management could be a matter of weeks or many months. This period is an opportunity to build on the progress established in the initial contact phase. It can present challenges in terms of maintaining engagement, particularly if the person is subject to community based supervision for a lengthy period of time. Interventions should focus on the behaviours that resulted in the person being in contact with JSW.
Supervision sessions should include specific consideration of the offence, the circumstances, thoughts and behaviours that led up to it, the patterns of behaviour that might perpetuate offending, and the skills and techniques needed to support people to move away from it. It should be noted that whenever required, additional time should be set aside to address personal issues or circumstances so as not to distract from offence-focussed work.
Interventions should be evidence based which can broadly be described as having certain characteristics:
- draws on a critical and impartial review of the best available research evidence
- values the knowledge base and experience of the practitioner
- is concerned with the engagement and values of the individual service user
- measures and reports on outcomes to encourage transparency and learning.
Work to address the risks and needs associated with offending behaviour may involve support and interventions from other agencies, such as health and third sector services. The case manager should maintain oversight of the levels of engagement linked to the actions within the plan to ensure that they remain effective and manageable.
Where there are concerns of disengagement, or elements of the plan are becoming overwhelming or ineffective, it may be necessary to call an early review to consider priority actions, and whether the management plan requires amendment. Where levels of contact deviate from the management plan, the rationale for this should be discussed and agreed with a manager and recorded in case records.
Practice Standard 5: For those subject to statutory supervision there are regular meetings to formally review the effectiveness of the management plan and any changes required. These involve all key people relevant to the case management at a frequency determined by the intensity of supervision contact.
4.11 Case Management Reviews
All people subject to statutory community based supervision will have a review of their case management plan within three months.
The frequency of subsequent reviews will be determined by the assessment of risk - see section 3.8. Reviews are an opportunity to gauge progress and measure this against agreed intended outcomes. They should be independently chaired, usually by a senior social worker or team manager, and offer an opportunity to record the views of all involved in the case management plan, review the quality of service delivery, discuss what is working well, identify any changes needed and offer feedback on progress.
If the Progress Record held within LS/CMI is being used to measure progress, this will be updated and presented at the review. Management plans will be updated to reflect any changes in the assessed risk or identified areas of need and agreed contact frequency. It should be noted if there has been a significant event then a re-assessment of LS/CMI will be required as it may have a bearing on the management plan. The RMA define a significant event as:
“…something which might result in a significant change to the conclusion of the current assessment and/or management plan for the individual.”
This review process supports defensible decision making in case management. It provides a record of the reasons for contact frequency and the key areas to be addressed within the next period. The Progress Record generated from the LS/CMI is also a source of evidence of the person’s engagement with supervision and a measure of the effectiveness of interventions on achieving a reduced risk of re-offending. This will be used in all relevant cases to record progress in the key areas outlined in the management plan. It will provide evidence of the outcome of interventions and determine any changes needed to the management plan.
In relevant cases, the review will provide an opportunity to consider whether an application to the court for early discharge should be considered.
Listening to feedback from the person they are working with or others involved in the case management, can help the worker to engage most effectively. Consideration should be given to the best way to obtain that feedback as formal reviews can be daunting for the person being supervised. However, taking a person-centred approach, considering whether obtaining views in advance or being given the opportunity to contribute through an agreed supporter or advocacy worker can ensure all views are heard and recorded.
If the person’s progress has been good this can be validated by the chair of the review to positively reinforce efforts and record positive outcomes.
If there are areas of concern, the review presents an opportunity to address these directly. It can identify any gaps in risk or need that aren’t being addressed and put a plan in place that everyone agrees with which will assist in reducing potential risk This ensures a clear line of decision making and, given the person’s agreement with the plan, can assist with any potential compliance issues that require further action.
Practice Standard 6: When reaching the end of contact with JSW a final meeting to establish any further support required and how this can be accessed will be convened.
4.12 Planning for next steps after JSW involvement
This should have been a feature of discussions throughout the period of supervision and people involved in services should be prepared for what happens when this comes to an end. Just as it is important to set the scene and let people know what to expect at the outset of their contact with JSW, it is as important that they are able to prepare for what happens when their contact with JSW comes to an end. Planning should therefore begin in good time, approximately two to three months prior to the expected end of contact.
Workers should check relevant practice guidance for timescales for final reviews and when formal completion reports or post-involvement questionnaires are required, so that they can provide the person with clear guidance about end dates.
From a risk management perspective it is the time that planning should be considered for agencies that will continue to be involved beyond the period of JSW supervision (e.g. those subject to sex offender notification requirements or where there are child protection measures in place or agencies supporting domestic abuse survivors). Statutory supervision can often be viewed as a protective factor in reducing risk. If it is recognised that the person is not yet in a position to self-manage their own risk(s), the end of the support and monitoring could be a change that results in increased risk. Therefore, the completion of the supervision period may lead other agencies to increase contact frequency for a period to establish if there are any on-going risk related issues. Good communication between JSW and all other relevant agencies is therefore crucial during this period.
4.13 Follow up support
By this stage, the worker will have established whether areas of need have been addressed and resolved or whether there are outstanding issues that would benefit from on-going support. In instances where there is already the involvement of, for example, a third sector support organisation which will continue beyond the period of the statutory supervision, the identification of post-supervision support will be relatively straightforward. However, discussions about any other follow up supports needed should take place several weeks (and in some cases months) before the end of JSW involvement to ensure that any referrals or handover meetings required can take place in good time.
Endings can be difficult for people, particularly if their contact with JSW has been lengthy and represents a period of positive change in their life. There can be concerns about the loss of support and feelings of not coping and this can, at times, lead to disengagement or challenging behaviours. The interpersonal skills of the worker and the strength of the working relationship are key at these times in order to address these issues and concerns as they arise. Understanding what lies beneath the behaviours helps to find ways to match the person to the relevant supports to help them build sustainable coping strategies for the future.
This is the stage when it will become most evident if the person continues to require a network of family, friends and other support services to ensure they sustain the progress made whilst involved with JSW. Use of a strengths based approach, reminding them of the goals that they have set and the ways they intended achieving them to help reset a sense of empowerment will be a useful approach at this time.
The worker’s role will therefore be to work alongside the person to develop a plan for how this might work beyond the scope of statutory community supervision so that there are supports in place to deal with any potential crises and action that can be taken in an effective way.
The final meeting or review will therefore be an opportunity to bring together all involved to present and agree the final plan, ensuring that it is clear, where, if needed, sources of support can be obtained. Feedback at this stage on what has changed for the person, what has worked well during their period of supervision and what presented challenges should be obtained either in person or through digital means in order to support service development which is reflective of the service user experience.
Contact
Email: CPO@gov.scot