We use cookies to collect anonymous data to help us improve your site browsing experience.

Click 'Accept all cookies' to agree to all cookies that collect anonymous data. To only allow the cookies that make the site work, click 'Use essential cookies only.' Visit 'Set cookie preferences' to control specific cookies.

Set cookie preferences

Your cookie preferences have been saved. You can change your cookie settings at any time.

Publication - Research and analysis

Education and Skills Impact Framework (ESIF) - college provision: contextual summary report 2022

Published
2 December 2022
Part of
Economy, Education, Work and skills
ISBN
9781805252511

This analysis uses longitudinal education outcomes data to estimate labour market outcomes and returns to investment associated with post-school qualifications. A technical report describes the methodology and findings in detail. This summary report covers some college qualifications.

View supporting documents Supporting documents

Appendix 1: Samples used for Regression Analysis (University Qualifications)

Earnings Men Women
<=21 22-30 31+ <=21 22-30 31+
Other Treatment 18,984 14,964 5,166 27,407 17,877 12,945
undergraduate, Counterfactual 2,808 1,247 3,633 2,188 1,500 5,414
including HNC
and HND
SCQF Full Vocational Treatment
Counterfactual 		1,348
243 		377
175 		1,273
791 		268
82 		361
175 		5,414
2,534
Level 7
SCQF Full Vocational Treatment
Counterfactual 		2,808
1,348 		1,247
467 		3,633
1,361 		2,188
1,040 		1,500
656 		5,414
2,534
Level 6
SCQF Full Vocational Treatment
Counterfactual 		6,334
3,056 		1,935
784 		5,429
1,958 		4,445
2,395 		2,069
866 		7,675
3,256
Level 5
SCQF Full Vocational Treatment
Counterfactual 		3,317
1,200 		1,014
295 		3,418
705 		2,037
761 		950
309 		4,703
1,260
Level 4
Employment Men Women
<=21 22-30 31+ <=21 22-30 31+
Other Treatment 19,103 8,364 9,542 19,503 10,844 20,894
undergraduate, Counterfactual 5,304 2,011 5,359 3,449 2,432 7,765
including HNC
and HND
SCQF Full Vocational Treatment
Counterfactual 		2,474
483 		774
309 		1,802
1,269 		392
130 		513
255 		2,404
1,081
Level 7
SCQF Full Vocational Treatment
Counterfactual 		5,304
2,935 		2,011
850 		5,359
2,152 		3,449
1,790 		2,432
1,194 		7,765
3,844
Level 6
SCQF Full Vocational Treatment
Counterfactual 		10,652
6,369 		3,466
1,758 		8,628
3,689 		7,679
5,208 		3,718
1,996 		11,732
5,363
Level 5
SCQF Full Vocational Treatment
Counterfactual 		5,980
2,905 		1,833
724 		5,793
1,550 		3,929
1,904 		1,683
677 		7,287
2,191
Level 4
Welfare Dependency Men Women
<=21 22-30 31+ <=21 22-30 31+
Other Treatment 19,053 8,290 9,496 19,461 10,787 20,876
undergraduate, Counterfactual 5,297 1,991 5,305 3,441 2,406 7,763
including HNC
and HND
SCQF Full Vocational Treatment
Counterfactual 		2,450
479 		582
236 		1,664
1,158 		259
101 		419
216 		2,276
1,016
Level 7
SCQF Full Vocational Treatment
Counterfactual 		5,285
2,929 		1,936
819 		5,224
2,114 		3,419
1,773 		2,353
1,176 		7,741
3,838
Level 6
SCQF Full Vocational Treatment
Counterfactual 		10,652
6,369 		3,418
1,741 		8,602
3,681 		7,671
5,199 		3,666
1,966 		11,683
5,343
Level 5
SCQF Full Vocational Treatment
Counterfactual 		5,978
2,904 		1,786
717 		5,721
1,533 		3,919
1,896 		1,633
656 		7,207
2,176
Level 4

Contact

Email: stuart.king@gov.scot

Back to top