Publication - Consultation paper

Extending children's rights guidance: consultation

Published: 25 Aug 2017
Learning Directorate
Part of:
Children and families, Education, Equality and rights

Consultation on non-statutory guidance for education authorities and schools regarding the rights of children aged 12 to 15 years.

24 page PDF

493.7 kB

24 page PDF

493.7 kB

Extending children's rights guidance: consultation
Chapter Five: Assessment of Change in Circumstances

24 page PDF

493.7 kB

Chapter Five: Assessment of Change in Circumstances

Assessing capacity and adverse impact on wellbeing when similar matters have recently been considered

28 Where a child has requested to exercise their rights within a short period of time after an earlier request an education authority will assess whether there has been any significant change in circumstances of the child since the request was made. This assessment will take into account the following factors:

  • time elapsed since request was made, usually there will be little time elapsed between a request to exercise a right and the use of the right, in other instances the time elapsed may be a significant factor
  • consideration of any changes in the child's circumstances in the key barriers to learning:
    • learning environment
    • health and disability
    • social and emotional factors
    • family circumstances
  • ensure active participation of the child in decision-making,
  • personal support from an adult who knows the child well. The assessment of the teacher who knows the child will be based on a wide variety of sources of evidence including observing day-to-day learning, learning conversations and/or planned periodic holistic assessment.
  • involve and inform parents, good communication with parents and carers will lead to everyone being updated about significant changes

Notifying the conclusions of considerations

29 The child and their parents or carers must be informed of the conclusions of these considerations. In the circumstances where the child or their parent does not agree with the outcome of these considerations they may refer this to the Tribunal for consideration. Where it is considered that the child is not considered to have capacity and there is adverse impact on wellbeing the education authority (and the child) may not carry out the right.


Email: Emily McLean,

Phone: 0300 244 4000 – Central Enquiry Unit

The Scottish Government
St Andrew's House
Regent Road