Procurement - use of consultants: guidance

Guidance for public sector organisations on the use of consultancy procedures when procuring professional services.


Introduction

Documentation control

This guidance is owned and maintained by the Scottish Government’s Scottish Procurement and Property Directorate, enquiries should be addressed to scottishprocurement@gov.scot

  

Effective date

Changes made

Version 1.0

Effective from 8 Dec 2008

  • endorsed by the Scottish Government Strategic Board

Version 1.1

Effective from 13 Mar 2009

  • small clarification on definition of IT Consultancy scope (Part 2, Table 1)
  • addition of footnote on Social Research DPA

Version 1.2

Effective from 24 Apr 2009

  • financial Reporting Requirements added (Part 3, Para 21, 22 and 23)
  • post Project Review Template added (Annex B)

Version 1.3

Effective from 14 Oct 2010

  • general Revision in light of:
  • The Public Service Reform (Scotland) Act 2010
  • General update to clarify terms, names etc

Version 1.4

Effective from 30 Sep 2011

  • ministerial portfolio changes and approval controls for Executive Agencies, Non Departmental Public Bodies and Non Ministerial Departments
  • general update to clarify terms, names etc.

Version 1.5

Effective from 21 Sep 2012

  • ministerial portfolio changes

Version 1.6

Effective from 23 Jan 2013

  • enquiry contact details updated

Version 1.7

Effective from 20 Mar 2017

  • update to reflect Ministerial portfolio changes and removal of approvals controls for Non Departmental Public Bodies
  • update to flowchart (Annex B)

Version 1.8

Effective from Mar 2022

  • amended Cab Sec for Finance title on tables
  • small clarification on variance of contract

Version 1.9

Effective from October 2025

  • small clarification on definition of consultancy
  • small clarification on exclusion of legal services for Three Part Test
  • removal of Annex A: Consultancy Categories and Three Part Test
  • update to Approval Controls table to remove overlap of financial thresholds and amended Cab Sec for Finance titles on tables
  • updated to reflect the introduction of Oracle Cloud System
  • updated graphics to Annex B (now A) Process to Buy Consultancy Services within SG, no material change

Scope

We recognise that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to consultancy services. As such, these procedures are mandatory for the Scottish Government (SG) and should be regarded as a useful benchmark for good practice by all organisations. The approval controls to buy consultancy services are mandatory for the SG, Executive Agencies and Non-Ministerial Departments.

Introduction

Consultancy is broadly defined as provision of advice to fill a knowledge gap. This can be to identify options and recommendations, or advice to assist with implementing solutions, and will be time limited. It will usually relate to business change or transformation, but can also focus on more technical, sector-specific expertise. The individuals (consultants) delivering the service (output) will operate outside of your organisation’s structure and staffing establishment. Services that are part of routine operations and where individuals are embedded in the organisation’s structure are typically not classed as consultancy.

Consultancy services should only be purchased in certain essential circumstances. When consultants are necessary, they need to be used sparingly, appropriately and effectively. Therefore, the SG must ensure that consultants are only used when:

  • the work cannot be carried out internally, i.e. we are sure that the required knowledge and expertise is not available in-house or from some other source from which the SG can draw
  • management is determined to take action to bring about change and demonstrate commitment to act upon the outputs
  • you have approval from a delegated purchasing officer (DPO)
  • they can bring relevant knowledge and have proven experience which will add value to the SG objectives
  • there is sufficient in-house capacity to manage the contract effectively

These procedures:

  • clarify when consultancy applies
  • confirm the approval levels required when buying consultancy services
  • set out the procurement and financial processes
  • identify audit and Freedom of Information (FoI) requirements
  • explain the processes for acquiring and managing consultancy services

Contact

Email: scottishprocurement@gov.scot

Back to top