A Study of Medical Negligence Claiming in Scotland

The study examined the current system for medical negligence claiming in Scotland. The study was commissioned to inform the work of the No-fault Compensation Review Group which was established in 2009 to consider the potential benefits to patients of the introduction of a no-fault compensation scheme for medical negligence claims in Scotland.


Adamson, T. E., Tschann. J. M., Gullion, D. S., and Oppenberg, A. A. (1989) "Physician communication skills and malpractice claims: a complex relationship" Western Journal of Medicine, 150(3), 356-360.

Akien, L. H., Clarke, S. P., Sloane, D. M., Sochalski, J. A., Busse, R., Clarke, H., Giovannetti, P., Hunt, J., Rafferty, A. M., and Shamian, J. (2001) "Nurses' report on hospital care in five countries" Health Affairs, May/June, 43-53.

Allsop, J. (1994) "Two sides to every story: complainants' and doctors' perspectives in disputes about medical care in a general practice setting" Law and Policy, 16, 149-184.

Andrews, L. (2004) "Studying medical error in situ: implications for malpractice law and policy" DePaul Law Review, 54, 357-392.

Annandale, E., and Hunt, K. (1998) "Accounts of disagreements and doctors" Social Science and Medicine, 1, 119-129.

Annandale, E. and Cunningham-Burley, S. (1996) "Medical students' perceptions of medical malpractice" Medical Education, 30(4), 253-258.

Ayrshire and Arran Health Board (1993) Ayrshire and Arran Health Board: Survey of Hospital Patients. Peter Gibson Associated.

Baker, T. (2005) "Reconsidering the Harvard Medical Practice Study Conclusions about the validity of medical malpractice claims" Journal of Law, Medical and Ethics, 33(3), 501-514.

Bateman, D. N., Sanders, G. L. S., and Rawlins, M. D. (1992) "Attitudes to adverse drug reaction reporting in the Northern Region" British Journal of Clin. Pharmac, 34, 421-426.

Bebchuk, L. (1984) "Litigation and settlement under imperfect information" RAND Journal of Economics, 15, 404-415.

Belton, K. J., Lewis, S. C., Payne, S., Rawlins, M. D. and Wood, S. (1995) "Attitudinal survey of adverse drug reaction reporting by medical practitioners in the United Kingdom" British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology, 39(3), 223-226.

Berlin, L. (1997) "Consequences of being accused of malpractice" American Journal of Roentgenology, 169, 1219-1223.

Bishop, T. F., Federman, A. D., and Keyhani, S. (2010) "Physicians' views on defensive medicine: a national survey" Archives of Internal Medicine, 170(12), 1081-1083.

Bismark, M. M., Brennan, T. A., Paterson, P. B., Davis, P. B. and Studdert, D. M. (2006) "Relationship between complaints and quality of care in New Zealand: a descriptive analysis of complainants and non-complainants following adverse events" Quality and Safety in Health Care, 15, 17-22.

Black, B. S., Silver, Hyman, D. A. and Sage, W. M. (2005) "Stability, not crisis: medical malpractice claim outcomes in Texas, 1988-2002" Journal of Empirical Legal Studies, 2 (2), 207-259.

Blendon, R. J., Des Roches, C. M., Brodie, M., Benson, J. M., Rosen, A. B., Schneider, E., Altman, D. E., Zapert, K., Herrmann, M. J., and Steffenson, A. E. (2002) "Views of practicing physicians and the public on medical errors" New England Journal of Medicine, 347(24), 1933-1940.

Bovbjerg, R. R., and Bartow, A. (2003) "Understanding Pennsylvania's medical malpractice crisis: facts about liability insurance, the legal system, and health care in Pennsylvania", The Project on Medical Liability in Pennsylvania. Philadelphia: The Pews Charitable Trusts.

Brennan, T. A., Leape, L. L, Laird, N. M., Herbert, L., Localio, A. R., Lawthers, A. G., Newhouse, J. P., Weiler, P. C., and Hiatt, H. H. (1991) "Incidence of adverse events and negligence in hospitalized patients: results of the Harvard medical practice study" New England Journal of Medicine, 324(6), 370-376.

Brennan, T. A., Sox, C. M., and Burstin, H. R. (1996) "Relation between negligent adverse events and the outcomes of medical malpractice litigation" New England Journal of Medicine, 335 (26), 1963-67.

Britain, A., Leslie, A., Beaton, C., and Campbell, M. (2009) Making it Better: Complaints and Feedback from Patients and Carers about NHS Services in Scotland. Scottish Health Council

Chan, D. K., Gallagher, T. H., Reznick, R., and Levinson, W. (2005) "How surgeons disclose medical errors to patients: a study using standardized patients" Surgery, 139(5), 851-585.

Chandra, A., Nundy, S., and Seabury, S. A. (2005), 'The Growth of Physician Medical Malpractice Payments: Evidence from the National Practitioner Data Bank', Health Affairs, 24, 240-50.

Charles, S. C., Wilbert, J., and Kennedy, E. C. (1984) "Physicians' self-reports of reactions to malpractice litigation" American Journal of Psychiatry, 141, 563-565.

Charles, S. C., Wilbert, J. R. and Franke, K. J. (1985) "Sued and nonsued physicians' self-reported reactions to malpractice litigation" American Journal of Psychiatry, 142, 437-440.

Charles, S. C., Pyskoty, C. E. and Nelson, A. (1988) "Physicians on trial - self reported reactions to malpractice trials" Western Journal of Medicine, 148(3), 358-360.

Christie, B. (2003) "Adverse events in surgery in Scotland show a steady fall" British Medical Journal, 327, 1367.

Cohen, J. R. (2004) "Toward candor after medical error: the first apology law" Harvard Health Policy Review, 5, 21-24.

Crawford, R. (1991) "Trauma audit: experience in north-east Scotland" British Journal of Surgery, 78, 1362-1366.

Cunningham, W. (2004a) "The immediate and long-term impact on New Zealand doctors who receive patient complaints" New Zealand Medical Journal, 117(1198),

Cunningham, W. (2004b) "New Zealand doctors' attitudes towards the complaints and disciplinary process" New Zealand Medical Journal, 119(1244),

Cunningham, W. and Dovey (2006) "Defensive changes in medical practice and the complaints process: a qualitative study of New Zealand doctors" New Zealand Medical Journal, 119(1244),

Daniel, A. E., Burn, R. J., and Horarik, S. (1999) "Patients' complaints about medical practice" Medical Journal of Australia, 170, 598-602.

Danzon, P. (1982) The Frequency and Severity of Medical Malpractice Claims. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Institute for Civil Justice.

Danzon, P. (1990) "The "crisis" in medical malpractice: a comparison of trends in the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom and Australia" Law Medicine and Health Care, 18 (1-2), 48-58.

Davis, P., Lay-Yee, R., Briant, R., Ali, W., Scott, A., and Schug, S. (2002) "Adverse events in New Zealand public hospitals I: occurrence and impact" New Zealand Medical Journal, 115(1167),

Davis, P., Lay-Yee, R., Scott, A., Briant, R., and Schug, S. (2003) "Acknowledgement of 'no fault' medical injury: review of patients' hospital records in New Zealand" British Medical Journal, 326(7380), 79-80.

Dillman, D. A. (1978) Mail and Telephone Surveys: The Tailored Design Methods. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Dunn, K. L., Reddy, P., Moulden, A., and Bowes, G. (2006) "Medical record review of deaths, unexpected intensive care unit admissions, and clinician referrals: detection of adverse events and insights into the system" Archives of Disease in Childhood, 91(2), 169-72.

Elmore, J. E., Taplin, S. H., Barlow, W. E., Cutter, G. R., D'Orsi, C. J., Hendrick, R. E., Abraham, L A., Fosse, J. S., and Carney, P. A. (2005) "Does litigation influence medical practice? The influence of community radiologists' medical malpractice perceptions and experience on screening mammongraphy" Radiology, 236, 37-46.

Ennis, M., and Grudzinksas, J. G. (1993) "The effect of accidents and litigation on doctors" in Vincent, C., Ennis, M., and Audley, R. J. (eds) Medical Accidents. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Ennis, M. and Vincent, C. (1994) "The effects of medical accidents and litigation on doctors and patients" Law and Policy, 16(2), 97-121.

Fenn, P. T. (2002) "Counting the cost of clinical negligence" British Medical Journal, 325, 233-34.

Fenn, P. T., Diacon, S. R., Gray, A., Hodges, R., and Rickman, N. (2000) "The current cost of medical negligence in NHS hospitals: analysis of claims database', British Medical Journal, 320, 1567-71.

Fenn, P. T., Gray, A. and Rickman, N (2004), 'The Economics of Clinical Negligence Reform in England', The Economic Journal, 114 (June), F272-F292.

Fenn, P. T., Gray, A., Rickman, N. and Towse, A. (2004), 'Making Amends for Negligence', British Medical Journal, 328, 417-18.

Gallagher, T. H., Waterman, A. D., Ebers, A. G., Fraser, V. J., and Levinson, W. (2003) "Patients' and physicians' attitudes regarding the disclosure of medical errors" JAMA, 289, 1001-1007.

Gallagher, T. H., Waterman, A. D., Garbutt, J. M., Kapp, J. M., Chan, D. K., Dunagan, W. C., Fraser, V. J., Levinson, W., (2006) "Canadian physicians' attitudes and experiences regarding disclosing errors to patients" Archives of Internal Medicine, 166, 1605-1611.

Garbutt, J., Brownstein, D. R., Klein, E. J., Waterman, A., Krauss, M. J., Marcuse, E. J., Hazel, R., Dunagon, C., Fraser, V., and Gallagher, T. H. (2007) "Reporting and disclosing medical errors: paediatricians'' attitudes and behaviours" Archives of Paediatrics' and Adolescent Medicine, 161(2), 179-185.

Genn, H. (1987) Hard Bargaining: Out of Court Settlement in Personal Injury Actions. Clarendon Press: Oxford.

Genn, H., (1999) Paths to Justice: What People Do and Think about Going to Law. Hart Publishing: Oxford.

Genn, H. and Lloyd-Bostock, S. (1995) Medical Negligence Research Project: The Operation of the Tort System in Medical Negligence Cases. Final Report to the Nuffield Foundation. London: Nuffield Foundation.

Genn, H. G. and Paterson, A. (2001) Paths to Justice Scotland: What People in Scotland Do and Think About Going to Law. Hart Publishing: Oxford.

Glassman, P. A., Rolph, J. E., Petersen, L. P., Bradley, M. A., and Kravitz, R. L. (1996) "Physicians' personal malpractice experiences are not related to defensive clinical practices" Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 21(2), 219-241.

Ham, C., Dingwall, R., Fenn, P., and Harris, D. (1988) Medical Negligence: Compensation and Accountability. London and Oxford: King's Fund and Centre for Socio-Legal Studies.

Haslam, C. and Marriott, N. (2006) "Accounting for reform: funding and transformation n the four nation's hospital services" Accounting Forum, 30, 389-405.

Hickson, G., Clayton, E., Gitnens, P. and Sloan, F. (1992) "Factors that prompted families to file medical malpractice claims following perinatal injuries" Journal of the American Medical Association, 267(16): 1359-63.

Hickson, G. B. (2002) "Patients complaints and malpractice risk" Journal of the American Medical Association, 287, 2951-2957.

Hingorani, M., Wong, T., and Vafidis, G. (1999) "Patients' and doctors' attitudes to amount of information given after unintended injury during treatment: cross sectional questionnaire survey" British Medical Journal, 318, 640-641.

Hobgood, C., Peck, C. R., Gilbert, B. et al (2002) "Medical errors: what and when: what do patients want to know?" Academic Emergency Medicine, 9(11), 1156-1161.

Hobgood, C., Tamayo-Sarver, J. H., Elms, A. et al (2005) "Parental preferences for error disclosure, reporting, and legal action after medical error in the care of their children" Pediatrics, 116, 1276-1286.

HMSO (1992) The Patient's Charter - What Users Think. Scotland.

Hunter, R., Genovese, A., Melville, A., and Chrzanowski, A. (2000) Legal Services in Family Law. Justice Research Centre: Sydney.

Huycke, L. I. and Huycke, M. M. (1994) "Characteristics of potential plaintiffs in malpractice litigation" Annals of Internal Medicine, 120, 792; 797.

Jeffe, D. B., Claiborne, D. W., Garbutt, J., Burroughs T., Gallagher, T., Hill, P. R., Harris, C. B. Bommarito, K., and Fraser, B. J. (2004) "Using focus groups to understand physicians' and nurses' perspectives on error reporting in hospitals" Journal on Quality and Patient Safety, 30(8), 471-494.

Jost, T. S., Mulcahy, L., Strasser, S., and Sachs, L. A. (1993) "Consumers, complaints and professional discipline: a look at medical licensure boards" Health Matrix, 3(2), 309-338.

Kaldjian, L. C., Jones, E. W., Wu, B. J., Forman-Hoffman, V. L., Levi, B. H., and Rosenthal, G. E. (2008) "Reporting medical errors to improve patient safety: a survey of physicians in teaching hospitals" Archives of Internal Medicine, 168(1): 40-46.

Katz, D. A., Williams, G. C., Brown, R. L. Aulderheide, T. P., Booner, M. Rahko, P. S., and Selker, H. P. (2005) "Emergency physicians' fear of malpractice in evaluating patients with possible acute cardiac ischemia" Annals of Emergency Medicine, 46(6), 525-533.

Klingman, D., Wagner, J. L., Polishuk, P. T., Wolfe, l., Corrigan, J. A. (1996) "Measuring defensive medicine using clinical scenario surveys" Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 21(2), 185-220.

Kressler, D. P., Summerton, N., and Graham, J. R. (1988) "The physicians' point of view concerning medical malpractice: a sociological perspective on the symbolic importance of tort reform" The Lancet, 368(9531), 240-246.

Kritzer, H. M. (2001) "The fracturing legal profession: the case of plaintiffs personal injury lawyers" International Journal of the Legal Profession, 8(3), 225-250.

Lawthers, A. G., Laird, N. M., Lipsitz, S., Hebert, L., and Brennan, T. A. (1992) "Physicians' perceptions of the risk of being sued" Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 17(3), 463-482.

Lawton, R. and Parker, R. (2002) "Barriers to incident reporting in a healthcare system" Quality and Safety in Health Care, 11, 15-18.

Lester, G. W. and Smith, S. G. (1993) "Listening and talking to patients: a remedy for malpractice suits?" Western Journal of Medicine, 158, 268; 270.

Lister, J. (2008) The NHS After 60: For Patients or Profits? Middlesex University Press: London.

Levinson, W., Roter, D. K., Mullooly, J. P., Dull, V. T., Frankel, R. M. (1997) "Physician-patient communication: the relationship with malpractice claims among primary care physicians and surgeons" JAMA, 277, 553

Lloyd-Bostock, S. and Mulcahy, L. (1994) "The social psychology of making and responding to hospital complaints: an account model of complaint processes" Law and Policy, 16, 123-147.

Lopez, L., Weissman, J. S., Schneider, E. C., Weingart, S. N., Cohen, A. O. and Epstein, A. M. (2009) "Disclosure of hospital adverse events and its association with patients' rating of the quality of care" Archives of Internal Medicine, 169(20), 1888-1894,

Manoj, K., and Renju, J. (2009) "Complaints procedures in the NHS: are they fair and valid?" Clinical Governance, 14(3), 183-188.

Martin, C. A., Wilson, J. F., Fiebelman, N. D., Gurley, D. N., Miller, T. W. (1991) "Physicians' psychologic reactions to malpractice litigation" Southern Medical Journal, 84(11), 1300-1304.

May, M. L. and Stengel, D. B. (1990) "Who sues their doctors? How patients handle medical grievances" Law and Society Review, 24, 103; 110

Mazor, K. M., Simon, S. R. and Gurwitz, J. H. (2004) "Communicating with patients about medical errors: a review of the literature" Archives of Internal Medicine, 164, 1690-1697.

McCord, R. S., Floyd, M. R., Lang, F., and Young, V. K. (2002) "Responding effectively to patient anger directed at the physician" Family Behaviour, 34(5), 331.

McCrindle, J. and Jones, R. K. (1998) "Preliminary evaluation of the efficacy and implementation of the new NHS complaints procedure" International Journal of Health Care, 11(2), 41-44.

Mori Survey (1997) Complaint Handling, 1997 Report, Mori: London.

Mulcahy, L., Allsop, J., and Shirley, C. (1996) The Voices of Complainants and General Practitioners in Complaints about Health Care. Social Science Research Monographs, No. 3, South Bank: London.

Mulcahy, L. and Tritter, J. (1998) "Pyramids, pathways, and iceberg - understanding the relationship between dissatisfaction, complaints and disputes" Sociology of Health and Illness, 20(6), 825-47.

Mulcahy, L. (2001) "Can leopards change their spots? An evaluation of the role of lawyers in medical negligence mediation" International Journal of the legal profession, 8(3), 203-244.

National Audit Office (2001) Handling Clinical Negligence Claims in England. Report by the Comptroller and Auditor General, Session 2000-2001, HC 403.

O'Connor, E., Coates, H. M., Yardley, I. E., Wu. A. W. (2010) "Disclosure of patient safety incidents: a comprehensive review" International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 1-9.

Passmore, K. and Leung, W. C. (2002) "Defensive practice among psychiatrists: a questionnaire survey" Postgraduate Medical Journal, 78, 671-673.

Patients Association, The. (2008) NHS Complaints: Who Cares? Who Can Make it Better?,

Peeples, R., Harris, C. T., and Mertzloff, T. B. (2000) "Settlement has many faces: physicians, attorneys and medical malpractice" Journal of Health and Social Behaviour, 41(3), 333-346.

Penchansky, R. and Macneem C. (1994) "Initiation of medical malpractice suits: a conceptualization and test" Medical Care, 32(8), 813-831.

Pleasence, P., Britain, G., Balmer, N., and Buck, A. (2006) Causes of Action: Civil Law and Social Justice, 2nd edition. Legal Services Commission: London.

Pleasence, P., Genn, H., Balmer, N. J. and Buck, A. (2003) "Causes of action: first findings of the LSRC Periodic Survey" Journal of Law and Society, 30(1), 11-30.

Press, I. (1984) "The predisposition to file claims: the patient's perspective" Law, Medicine and Health Care, 12(2), 53-62.

Rodriguez, R. M., Anglin, D., Hankin, A., Hayden, S. R., Phelps, M., McCollough, L., and Hendey, G. W. (2007) "A longitudinal study of emergency medicine residents' malpractice fear and defensive medicine" Academic Emerg. Medicine, 14(6), 569-573.

Rose, N. and Glendinning, R. (2004) Public Attitudes to the National Health Service in Scotland - 2004 Survey. Scottish Executive: Edinburgh.

Rosenblatt, R. A., Weitkamp, G., Lloyd, M., Schafter, B., Winterscheid, L. C., and Hart, L. L. G., (1990) "Why do physicians stop practicing obstetrics? The impact of malpractice claims" Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 76(2),

Ross, Lord (2003) Report of the Expert Group on Financial and Other Support, Edinburgh: Scottish Executive, March 2003.

Saberi, S. M., Sheikhazadi, A., Johgataei, H., Mohammadi, V., and Fallahian, M. (2009) "A survey of sued physicians' self-reported reactions to malpractice litigation in Iran" Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, 16(6), 301-306.

Schoen, C., Osborn, R., Huynh, P. T., Doty, M., Zapert, K., Peugh, J., and Davis, K. (2005) "Taking the pulse of health care systems: experiences of patients with health problems in six countries" Health Affairs.

Scottish Health Council's (2009) Making it Better: Complaints and Feedback from Patients and Carers about NHS Services in Scotland.

Schwappach, D. L. B. and Koeck, C. M. (2004) "What makes an error unacceptable? A factorial survey on the disclosure of medical errors" International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 16(4), 317-326.

Shapiro, R. S., Simpson, D. E., Lawrence, S. L., Talsky, A. M., Sobocinski, K. A., Schiedermayer, D. L. (1989) "A survey of sued and nonsued physicians and suing patients" Archives of Internal Medicine, 149, 2190-2196.

Shaw, C. and Coles, J. (2001) The Reporting of Adverse Incidences - International Views and Experiences. CASPE Research: London.

Sloan, F. A., Mergenhagen, P. M., Burfield, W. B., Randall, R.., Bovbjerg, J. D., and Hassan, M. (1989) "Medical malpractice experience of physicians: predictable or haphazard?" The Journal of the American Medical Association, 262(23), 3291-97.

Soleymani Lehmann, L., Puopolo, A. L., Shqykevich, S., and Brennan, T. A. (2005) "Iatrogenic events resulting in intensive care admission: frequency, cause and disclosure to patients and institutions" The American Journal of Medicine, 118(4), 409-413.

Spier, K. (1994) "Settlement bargainings and the design of damage awards" Journal of Law, Economics and Organization, 10(1), 84-95.

Studdert, D. M. and Brennan, T. A. (2001) "No-fault compensation for medical injuries: the prospect for error prevention" The Journal of the American Medical Association, 286(2), 217-223.

Studdert, D. M., Mello, M. M., Sage, W. M., DesRoches, C. M., Peugh, J., Zapert, K., and Brennan, T. A., (2005) "Defensive medicine among high-risk specialist physicians in a volatile malpractice environment" The Journal of the American Medical Association, 293(21), 2609-2617.

Studdert, D. M., Mello, M. M., Gawande, A. A., Gandhi, T. J., Kachalia, A., Yoon, C., Puopolo, A. L., Brennan, T. A. (2006) "Claims, errors, and compensation payments in medical malpractice litigation" New England Journal of Medicine, 354(19), 2023-2033.

Symon, A. (1999) "Perinatal litigation in Scotland 1980-1995: its incidence, rate and nature" Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 19(3), 239-247.

Symon, A. "Litigation and defensive clinical practice: quantifying the problem" Midwifery, 16(1), 8-14.

Tancredi, L. R. and Barondess, J. A. (1978) "The problem of defensive medicine" Science, 200, 879-882.

Vidmar, N., Lee, P., MacKillop, K., McCarthy, K., and McGwin, G. (2005) "Seeking the 'invisible' profile of medical malpractice litigation: insights from Florida" DePaul Law Review, 54, 315.

Vincent, C., Phillips, A., and Young, M. (1994) "Why do people sue doctors? A study of patients and relatives taking legal action" Lancet, 343, 1609.

Vincent, C., Neale, G., and Woloshynowych, M. (2001) "Adverse events in British hospitals: preliminary retrospective record review" British Medical Journal, 322, 517-519.

Weiler, P. C. (1991) Medical Malpractice on Trial. Cambridge: Mass: Harvard University Press.

Weisman, C. S., Morlock, L. L., Teitelbaum, M. A., Klassen, A. C. and Celentano, D. D. (1989) "Practice changes in response to the malpractice litigation climate: results of a Maryland Physician Survey" Medical Care, 27, 16-24.

Weissman, J. S., Annas, C. L., Epstein, A. M., Schneider, E. C., Clarridge, B., Kirle, L., Gatsonis, C., Feibelmann, S., and Ridley, N. (2005) "Error reporting and disclosure systems: views from hospital leaders" The Journal of the American Medical Association, 293(11), 1359-1366.

Witman, A. B., Park, D. M., and Hardin, S. B. (1996) "How do patients want physicians to handle mistakes? A survey of internal medicine patients in an academic setting" Archives of Internal Medicine, 156(22), 2562-2569.

Wooldridge, J. E. (2000) Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach, South Western Cooege Publishing.

Woodward, C. A., and Rosser, W. (1989) "Effect of medico legal liability on patterns of general and family practice in Canada" Canadian Medical Association Journal, 141(4), 291-299.

Wu, A. W., Cavanaugh, T. A., McPhee, S. J. et al (1997) "To tell the truth: ethical and practical issues in disclosing medical mistakes to patients" Journal of General Internal Medicine, 12, 770-775.

Zuckerman, S. (1984) "Medical malpractice: claims, legal costs, and the practice of defensive medicine" Health Affairs, 393, 128-134.


Email: Fiona Hodgkiss

Back to top