Publication - Consultation analysis

Consultation on proposed safe staffing laws for nursing and midwifery: independent analysis of responses

Published: 15 January 2018
Directorate: Health Workforce Directorate
Topic: Health and social care, Law and order
ISBN: 9781788514675

Independent analysis of responses to the consultation on enshrining safe staffing in nursing and midwifery in law.

Supporting documents

Annex 2 – Discussion group results at quantitative questions

Table 1: Question 1 – Responses by location of discussion group.

	Yes	No	Mixed view	Not answered	Total
Aberdeen	3	1	1		5
Edinburgh	3			1	4
Glasgow	6		1		7
Inverness	4				4
Orkney	1	1			2
Shetland	1				1
Stornoway	2				2
All groups	20	2	2	1	25

Table 2: Question 2 – Responses by location of discussion group.

	Yes	No	Mixed view	Not answered	Total
Aberdeen	5				5
Edinburgh	3			1	4
Glasgow	7				7
Inverness	4				4
Orkney	2				2
Shetland	1				1
Stornoway	1			1	2
All groups	23			2	25

Table 3: Question 3a – Responses by location of discussion group.

	Yes	No	Mixed view	Not answered	Total
Aberdeen	4		1		5
Edinburgh	2			2	4
Glasgow	7				7
Inverness	3	1			4
Orkney	2				2
Shetland	1				1
Stornoway	2				2
All groups	21	1	1	2	25

Table 4: Question 3b – Responses by location of discussion group.

	Yes	No	Mixed view	Not answered	Total
Aberdeen	2	3			5
Edinburgh	3			1	4
Glasgow	6		1		7
Inverness	3	1			4
Orkney	1			1	2
Shetland	1				1
Stornoway	1	1			2
All groups	17	5	1	2	25

Table 5: Question 5 – Responses by location of discussion group.

	Yes	No	Mixed view	Not answered	Total
Aberdeen	5				5
Edinburgh	4				4
Glasgow	6			1	7
Inverness	4				4
Orkney	2				2
Shetland	1				1
Stornoway	2				2
All groups	24			1	25

Table 6: Question 6 – Responses by location of discussion group.

	Yes	No	Mixed view	Not answered	Total
Aberdeen	4			1	5
Edinburgh	3			1	4
Glasgow	5			2	7
Inverness	4				4
Orkney	2				2
Shetland	1				1
Stornoway	2				2
All groups	21			4	25

Table 7: Question 7 – Responses by location of discussion group.

	Yes	No	Mixed view	Not answered	Total
Aberdeen	4			1	5
Edinburgh	3	1			4
Glasgow	1	3	1	2	7
Inverness	1	2	1		4
Orkney	1	1			2
Shetland	1				1
Stornoway	2				2
All groups	13	7	2	3	25

Table 8: Question 9 – Responses by location of discussion group.

	Yes	No	Mixed view	Not answered	Total
Aberdeen	5				5
Edinburgh	4				4
Glasgow	7				7
Inverness	4				4
Orkney	2				2
Shetland	1				1
Stornoway	2				2
All groups	25				25

Table 9: Question 10 – Responses by location of discussion group..

	Yes	No	Mixed view	Not answered	Total
Aberdeen	5				5
Edinburgh	3			1	4
Glasgow	6	1			7
Inverness	3			1	4
Orkney	2				2
Shetland	1				1
Stornoway	2				2
All groups	22	1		2	25

Table 10: Question 11 – Responses by location of discussion group.

	Yes	No	Mixed view	Not answered	Total
Aberdeen	4	1			5
Edinburgh	3			1	4
Glasgow	6			1	7
Inverness	4				4
Orkney	2				2
Shetland	1				1
Stornoway	2				2
All groups	22	1		2	25

Table 11: Question 12 – Responses by location of discussion group.

	Yes	No	Mixed view	Not answered	Total
Aberdeen	5				5
Edinburgh	4				4
Glasgow	4			3	7
Inverness	4				4
Orkney	2				2
Shetland	1				1
Stornoway	1			1	2
All groups	21			4	25

Table 12: Question 14 – Responses by location of discussion group.

	Yes	No	Mixed view	Not answered	Total
Aberdeen	2	2		1	5
Edinburgh	3			1	4
Glasgow	4	2		1	7
Inverness	3			1	4
Orkney	2				2
Shetland	1				1
Stornoway		1		1	2
All groups	15	5		5	25

Table 13: Question 17 – Responses by location of discussion group.

	Yes	No	Mixed view	Not answered	Total
Aberdeen		5			5
Edinburgh		1		3	4
Glasgow	3	3		1	7
Inverness	1	3			4
Orkney	1	1			2
Shetland	1				1
Stornoway		2			2
All groups	6	15		4	25

Contact

Dawn Sungu

Thanks for your feedback