Health Board Elections and Alternative Pilots: Literature Review

This report presents the findings of a literature review which explored evidence on methods to enhance public representation on Health Boards. It was undertaken alongside an evaluation of NHS Scotland health board electoral and alternative pilot projects arising from the Health Boards (Membership and Elections) (Scotland) Act 2009. The Act follows several other measures in Scotland which have aimed to increase public involvement and accountability in NHS decision making.


Abelson, J., & Eyles, J. (2004). Public participation and citizen governance in the Canadian Health System. In P.-G. Forest, G. P. Marchildon & T. A. McIntosh (Eds.), Romanow papers: Changing health care in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

Abelson, J., Forest, P.-G., Eyles, J., Smith, P., Martin, E., & Gauvin, F.-P. (2002). Obtaining public input for health-systems decision-making: past experiences and future prospects. Canadian Public Administration, 45(1), 70-97.

Allen, P., Keen, J., Wright, J., Dempster, P., Townsend, J., Hutchings, A., et al. (2012). Investigating the governance of autonomous public hospitals in England: multi-site case study of NHS foundation trusts. Journal of Health Services Research & Policy, 17(suppl 1).

Allen, P., Townsend, J., Dempster, P., Wright, J., Hutchings, A., & Keen, J. (2011). Organizational form as a mechanism to involve staff, public and users in public services: a study of the governance of NHS Foundation Trusts. Social Policy & Administration, 46(3)239-257.

Alliston, L., & Cossar, D. (2006). The participation and engagement of Maori in decision-making processes and other government initiatives. Wellington, NZ: The Electoral Commission.

Appointments Commission. (2009). Are there any women on board? A review of recruiting and retaining women in public appointments in 2009. Retrieved August 28th 2010.

Appointments Commission. (2010a). Annual Report 2009/10. London: Appointments Commission.

Appointments Commission. (2010b). Government Diversity Targets. Retrieved August 28th, 2010.

Appointments Commission, & Department of Health. (2010). Improving the diversity of public appointments in health and social care: 2010/11 action plan. London: Appointments Commission.

Arnstein, S. R. (1969). A ladder of citizen participation. Journal of the American Institute of Planners, 35(4), 216-224.

Ashton, T. (2001). The rocky road to health reform: some lessons from New Zealand. Australian Health Review, 24, 151 - 156.

Ashton, T. (2005). Recent developments in the funding and organisation of the New Zealand health system. Australia and New Zealand Health Policy, 2(1), 9.

Ashton, T., Mays, N., & Devlin, N. (2005). Continuity through change; the rhetoric and reality of health reform in New Zealand. Social Science and Medicine, 61, 253-262.

Audit Commission. (2009). Taking it on trust: a review of how boards of NHS trusts and foundation trusts get their assurance. London: Audit Commission.

Barnett, P., & Clayden, C. (2007). Governance in District Health Boards. Wellington, NZ: Health Services Research Centre.

Boulton, A., Simonsen, K., Walker, T., Cumming, J., & Cunningham, C. (2004). Indigenous participation in the 'new' New Zealand health structure. Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 9(suppl 2), 35-40.

Charles, C., & Di Maio, S. (1993). Lay participation in health care decision making: A conceptual framework. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 18(4), 881-904.

Church, J., Saunders, D., Wanke, M., Pong, R., Spooner, C., & Dorgan, M. (2002). Citizen Participation in Health Decision-Making: Past Experience and Future Prospects. Journal of Public Health Policy, 23(1), 12-32.

Coulter, A. (2002). The autonomous patient: ending paternalism in medical care. London: Stationery Office.

Davies, C., Wetherell, M., & Barnett, E. (2006). Citizens at the centre : deliberative participation in healthcare decisions. Bristol: Policy.

Day, P., & Klein, R. (2005). Governance of foundation trusts: dilemmas of diversity. London: Nuffield Trust.

Department of Internal Affairs. (2011). Local Authority Election Statistics 2010. Wellington, NZ: NZ Department of Internal Affairs.

Dixon, A., Storey, J., & Rosete, A. A. (2010). Accountability of foundation trusts in the English NHS: views of directors and governors. Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 15(2), 82-89.

Dorfman, P., Batty, C., Campbell, F., Chapman, R., & Newman, I. (2010). Local Involvement Networks: Research Project Report. Warwick: Warwick University Local Authorities Research Consortium.

Eakin, J. M. (1984). Hospital power structure and the democratization of hospital administration in Quebec. Social Science & Medicine, 18(3), 221-228.

Elections Prince Edward Island. (2009). Health Board Elections. Retrieved 17th September, 2010.

FMR Consulting. (2008). Public Partnership Forums: what direction and support is needed for the future? Glasgow: Scottish Health Council.

Forbat, L., Hubbard, G., & Kearney, N. (2009). Patient and public involvement: models and muddles. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 18(18), 2547-2554.

Forest, P.-G., Gagnon, D., Abelson, J., Turgeon, J., & Lamarche, P. A. (1999). Issues in the governance of integrated health systems (Executive Summary). Ottawa, Canada: Canadian Health Services Research Foundation.

Frankish, C. J., Kwan, B., Ratner, P. A., Wharf Higgins, J., & Larsen, C. (2002). Challenges of citizen participation in regional health authorities. Social Science & Medicine, 54(10), 1471-1480.

Gauld, R. (2005). Delivering democracy? An analysis of New Zealand's District Health Board elections, 2001 and 2004. Australian health review: a publication of the Australian Hospital Association, 29(3), 345.

Gauld, R. (2011). Are elected health boards an effective mechanism for public participation in health service governance? Health Expectations 13(4), 369-378.

Government of Alberta. (2004). Regional Health Authority Membership Regulations. Retrieved from

Great Britain Ministry of Health and Social Security. (1970). The administrative structure of the medical and related services in England and Wales. London: The Stationery Office.

Haarmann, A., Klenk, T., & Weyrauch, P. (2010). Exit, choice - and what about voice? Public Management Review, 12(2), 213-231.

Ham, C. (1980). Community Heath Council Participation in the NHS Planning System. Social Policy & Administration, 14(3), 221-232.

Ham, C., & Hunt, P. (2008). Membership governance in NHS Foundation Trusts: a review for the Department of Health. London: Department of Health.

Healthcare Commission. (2005). The Healthcare Commission's review of NHS foundation trusts. London: Commission for Healthcare Audit and Inspection.

Hirschman, A. O. (1970). Exit, voice, and loyalty: responses to decline in firms, organizations, and States. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press.

House of Commons - Health Committee. (2007). Public and Patient Involvement in the NHS: Third Report of Session 2006-7 (No. HC 278-I). London: The Stationery Office.

House of Commons - Health Committee. (2008). Foundation Trusts and Monitor: Sixth Report of Session 2007-08 (No. HC 833-I). London: The Stationery Office.

Ipsos MORI. (2008). Survey of Foundation Trust Governors. London: Monitor.

Klein, R. (2003). Governance for NHS foundation trusts. British Medical Journal, 326, 174-175.

Klein, R., & Lewis, J. (1976). The politics of consumer representation : a study of community health councils. London, Centre for Studies in Social Policy.

Learmonth, M., Martin, G. P., & Warwick, P. (2009). Ordinary and effective: the Catch-22 in managing the public voice in health care? Health Expectations, 12(1), 106-115.

Lewis, R., & Hinton, L. (2008). Citizen and staff involvement in health service decision-making: have National Health Service foundation trusts in England given stakeholders a louder voice? Journal of Health Services Research & Policy, 13(1), 19-25.

Lewis, S. J., Kouri, D., Eastbrooks, C. A., Dickinson, H., Dutchak, J. J., Williams, J. I., et al. (2001). Devolution to democratic health authorities in Saskatchewan: an interim report. Canadian Medical Affairs Journal, 164(3), 343-347.

Litva, A., Canvin, K., Shepherd, M., Jacoby, A., & Gabbay, M. (2009). Lay perceptions of the desired role and type of user involvement in clinical governance. Health Expectations, 12(1), 81-91.

Litva, A., Coast, J., Donovan, J., Eyles, J., Shepherd, M., Tacchi, J., et al. (2002). 'The public is too subjective': public involvement at different levels of health-care decision making. Social Science and Medicine, 54(12), 1825-1837(1813).

Lomas, J. (2001). Past concerns and future roles for regional health boards. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 164(3), 356-357.

Lupton, C., Buckland, S., & Moon, G. (1995). Consumer involvement in health care purchasing: the role and influence of the community health councils. Health and Social Care in the Community, 3(4), 215-226.

Maddalena, V. (2006). Governance, public participation and accountability: To whom are regional health authorities accountable? Healthcare Management Forum, 19(3), 32-37.

Martin, G. P. (2008). 'Ordinary people only': knowledge, representativeness, and the publics of public participation in healthcare. Sociology of Health & Illness, 30(1).

Martin, S. (2009). Engaging with citizens and other stakeholders. In T. Bovaird & E. Loffler (Eds.), Public Management and Governance (2nd ed.). Abingdon: Routledge.

Maxwell, J., Rosell, S., & Forest, P.-G. (2003). Giving citizens a voice in healthcare policy in Canada. British Medical Journal, 326, 1031-1033.

Mitton, C., Smith, N., Peacock, S., Evoy, B., & Abelson, J. (2009). Public participation in health care priority setting: a scoping review. Health Policy, 91, 219-228.

Monitor, Electoral Reform Research, & Member Engagement Services. (2011). Current practice in NHS Foundation Trust member recruitment and engagement. London: Monitor.

Mullen, C., Hughes, D., & Vincent-Jones, P. (2011). The Democratic Potential of Public Participation: Healthcare Governance in England. Social & Legal Studies, 20(1), 21-38.

NHS National Centre for Involvement. (2007). Local Involvement Networks: learning from the Early Adopters Programme: interim report. Warwick: NHS National Centre for Involvement.

Office of the Municipal Electoral Officer. (2004). Report of the Municipal Electoral Officer on the Regional Health Authority Elections May 10, 2004. Retrieved from

PEI Health Governance Advisory Council. (2009). Health Governance Advisory Council (Final Report). Charlottetown, Canada.

Pickard, S. (1997). The Future Organization of Community Health Councils. Social Policy & Administration, 31(3), 247-289.

Pitkin, H. F. (1967). The concept of representation. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Province of New Brunswick. (2008). Transforming New Brunswick's Health-care System: the Provincial Health Plan 2008-2012. Retrieved from

Rowe, G., & Frewer, L. J. (2005). A Typology of Public Engagement Mechanisms. Science, Technology & Human Values, 30(2), 251-290.

Saskatchewan Health. (2001). Healthy people, a healthy province. The action plan for Saskatchewan health care. Retrieved from

Scottish Executive. (2004). Community Health Partnerships Statutory Guidance. Retrieved from

Statistics New Zealand. (2006). 2006 Census Data. Retrieved 23rd August, 2010, from

Taylor, J., & Tritter, J. Q. (2007). Local Involvement Networks: learning from the Early Adopters Programme: final report. Warwick: NHS National Centre for Involvement.

Tenbensel, T., Mays, N., & Cumming, J. (2011). A successful mix of hierarchy and collaboration? Interpreting the 2011 reform of the governance of the New Zealand public health system. Policy & Politics, 39(2), 239-255.

Tensenbel, T., Cumming, J., Ashton, T., & Barnett, P. (2008). Where there's a will, is there a way? Is New Zealand's publicly funded health sector able to steer towards population health? Social Science & Medicine, 67, 1143-1152.

The Scottish Government. (2007). Better Health, Better Care. Retrieved from

Thompson, A. (2007). The meaning of patient involvement and participation in health care consultations: A taxonomy. Social Science & Medicine, 64(6), 1297-1310.

Tritter, J. Q., & McCallum, A. (2006). The snakes and ladders of user involvement: moving beyond Arnstein. Health Policy, 76(2), 156-168.

Wise, J. (2011). NHS reforms do little to empower patients, charities say. British Medical Journal, 342.

Wright, J., Dempster, P., Keen, J., Allen, P., & Hutchings, A. (2011). The new governance arrangements for NHS Foundation Trust hospitals: reframing governors as meta-regulators. Public Administration,90(2)351-369..


Email: Fiona Hodgkiss

Back to top