Fintry Primary School closure decision: letter to Aberdeenshire Council

Letter from Education Directorate to Aberdeenshire Council, with decision to call-in the closure proposal for Fintry Primary School closure.


To: Laurence Findlay, Aberdeenshire Council
From: Alison Taylor, Governance, Digital and Infrastructure 

18 November 2026

Dear Laurence,

Call-In Notice Under Section 15(3) Of The Schools (Consultation) (Scotland) Act 2010: Aberdeenshire Council – Proposed Closure of Fintry Primary School

I refer to Rachael Goldring’s email of 25 September 2026 notifying the Scottish Ministers of Aberdeenshire Council’s decision of 24 September 2026 to implement the proposal to merge Fintry and King Edward Primary Schools and permanently close Fintry Primary School. The Scottish Ministers have considered this proposal in line with the requirements set out in the Schools (Consultation) (Scotland) Act 2010 (“the 2010 Act”).

Under section 17 of the 2010 Act, the Scottish Ministers may only issue a call-in notice if it appears to them that the education authority may have failed:

  1. in a significant regard to comply with the requirements imposed on it by (or under) the Act so far as they are relevant in relation to the closure proposal, or
  2. to take proper account of a material consideration relevant to its decision to implement the proposal.

After consideration of Aberdeenshire Council’s notification dated 25 September 2026, proposal paper and consultation report with all appendices (including the Options Appraisal and HMIE’s report), the further information provided by the Council on 29 October 2026, and the representation received, the Scottish Ministers have concluded that there are grounds on which to call-in this closure proposal with reference to section 17(2)(a) of the 2010 Act. Accordingly, this letter is a call-in notice under section 15(3) of the 2010 Act.

Reasons for the proposal, steps taken to address those and reasonable alternatives in response

Sections 12A(2)(a) and (b) of the 2010 Act require an education authority to identify the reasons for formulating the proposal and consider reasonable alternatives in response to those reasons. Section 13(2) requires the Proposal Paper to explain those reasons, the steps taken to address them before formulating the proposal and the reasonable alternatives.

In this case the proposal paper describes the background of the proposal, including the Turriff Cluster engagement, declining pupil rolls and the options considered. However, it does not clearly explain the reasons for the proposal, the steps taken to address those reasons and the reasonable alternatives considered in response to those reasons.

While Aberdeenshire Council have since provided additional information in response to a request from Scottish Government officials this was not made available during the statutory consultation period limiting consultees’ ability to assess the impact of the closure and respond meaningfully.

After careful consideration the Scottish Ministers conclude that the Proposal Paper does not clearly set out the reasons for the proposal, the steps taken to address those reasons before the proposal was formulated and the reasonable alternatives considered in response to those reasons as is required by section 13(2). Ministers consider this potential failure to be significant because these requirements are intended to ensure that consultees can understand why closure is being proposed, what steps have already been taken to address the reasons for closure and what alternatives to closure have been considered. The absence of a clear explanation in the Proposal Paper limited the information available to consultees on which to consider and respond to the proposal and reasonable alternatives.

The Scottish Ministers consider that not setting out these matters at this early stage fed through to the subsequent consultation, undermining the consultation process and purposes of the 2010 Act as regards rural schools. The Scottish Ministers therefore consider that the Council may have failed in a significant regard to comply with section 13(2) and accordingly there are grounds for call-in under section 17(2)(a) of the 2010 Act.

Assessment of reasonable alternatives

Section 12A(2) requires an education authority, when formulating a closure proposal in respect of a rural school, to identify its reasons for the proposal and any reasonable alternatives that might address the reasons for formulating the proposal. The authority must assess the proposal and each reasonable alternative in relation to educational benefit, community impact and travel arrangements. The authority may only proceed to consultation where it is satisfied that the closure proposal is the most appropriate response to the reasons identified.

Aberdeenshire Council’s Options Appraisal considered three options: maintaining the status quo, merging Fintry Primary School into King Edward Primary School and merging King Edward Primary School into Fintry Primary School. The Options Appraisal contains information relevant to educational benefits, community impact and travelling arrangements. However, it does not clearly demonstrate that the proposal and each reasonable alternative were assessed against each of the three matters required by section 12A(2)(c).

Following our review of the Council’s documentation, we sought clarification from the Council on this point. The Council has subsequently acknowledged that the three statutory considerations were not expressly mapped against each reasonable alternative. Its position is that these considerations were embedded throughout the Options Appraisal and supporting evidence and were developed further in the Proposal Paper.

Ministers recognise that information relevant to each of the statutory considerations can be identified across the Council’s documentation. However, this does not clearly demonstrate that the assessment required by section 12A(2)(c) was undertaken for the proposal and each reasonable alternative before the Council decided to proceed to statutory consultation. In particular, it remains unclear how the likely educational benefits of each reasonable alternative were assessed.

After careful consideration, Ministers conclude that the Council has not clearly demonstrated that the proposal and each reasonable alternative were assessed against the likely educational benefits, likely effect on the local community and likely effect of different travelling arrangements, as required by section 12A(2)(c). The Scottish Ministers consider this potential failure to be significant because this assessment is an additional statutory safeguard applying specifically to rural school closure proposals and is required before an education authority decides that implementation of the closure proposal is the most appropriate response to the reasons identified. The absence of a clear assessment makes it difficult to establish how the Council satisfied itself that the closure proposal was the most appropriate response when compared with the reasonable alternatives.

The Scottish Ministers consider that the absence of a clear assessment at this early stage fed through to the subsequent consultation, undermining the consultation process and purposes of the 2010 Act as regards rural schools. The Scottish Ministers therefore consider that the Council may have failed in a significant regard to comply with section 12A(2)(c) of the 2010 Act and accordingly there are grounds for call-in under section 17(2)(a) of the 2010 Act.

Re-assessment of rural factors in Consultation Report

Sections 13(5) and 13(6) of the 2010 Act require the Council, following consultation, to undertake a further assessment of the proposal by reference to the matters in section 12A(2)(c), namely the likely educational benefits, the likely effect on the local community and the likely effect of different travelling arrangements. The Consultation Report must explain that further assessment and how it differs from the assessment undertaken before consultation.

The Consultation Report does not contain a clear further assessment of the likely effect on the local community or the likely effect of different travelling arrangements in respect of the proposal. While community and travel related matters are referred to elsewhere in the report, these are not brought together and assessed as part of the further rural school assessment required under section 13(5). Nor does the report explain how the Council’s further assessment of these matters differed from its original assessment.

We sought clarification from the Council on this point. The Council acknowledged that the Consultation Report could have more clearly drawn together the further assessment undertaken following consultation. Its position is that community, travel, environmental and educational considerations were considered across the options appraisal, Proposal Paper and in the decision-making process.

While this provides further context, we do not consider that this resolves the concern. Section 13(6) requires the Consultation Report itself to explain the further assessment and how it differed from the original assessment.

After careful consideration, Ministers conclude that the Council has not clearly demonstrated that it undertook the required further assessment of the likely effect on the local community and different travelling arrangements following consultation, or adequately explained that further assessment in the Consultation Report, as required by sections 13(5) and 13(6). The Scottish Ministers consider this potential failure to be significant because the further assessment is an important safeguard within the statutory process, requiring the Council to reconsider the relevant rural factors in light of the consultation before reaching its final decision. The absence of a clear further assessment and explanation in the Consultation Report makes it difficult to establish how the representations received during consultation informed the Council's assessment of these matters and its final decision.

The Scottish Ministers therefore consider that the Council may have failed in a significant regard to comply with section 13(5) and 13(6) and accordingly there are grounds for call-in undersection 17(2)(a) of the 2010 Act.

Conclusion

Taking the above considerations together, the Scottish Ministers consider that Aberdeenshire Council may have failed in a significant regard to comply with the requirements imposed on it by (or under) the Act so far as they are relevant in relation to the closure proposal, and that these warrants further independent scrutiny. Therefore, the Scottish Ministers are calling in the proposal under section 15(3) of the 2010 Act for the reasons set out above.

As required under section 17A(2) of the 2010 Act following call in, the Scottish Ministers are referring the proposal to the Convener of the School Closure Review Panel. The Convener is required to constitute a School Closure Review Panel which will review the proposal and reach a decision in terms of sections 17B and 17C, respectively, of the 2010 Act.

Aberdeenshire Council may not implement the proposal (either in whole or in part) unless the School Closure Review Panel grants consent to the proposal (either with conditions or unconditionally) and either the period for making an appeal to the Sheriff has expired without any appeal being made, or, if an appeal is made, it is abandoned or the Sheriff has confirmed the Panel’s decision (in terms of section 17A(4) of the 2010 Act).

Yours sincerely,

Alison Taylor

Deputy Director, Governance, Digital and Infrastructure

Education Directorate

Back to top