Publication - Research and analysis

Energy Efficiency Standard for Social Housing: peer review

Published: 22 Oct 2013
Directorate:
Energy and Climate Change Directorate
Part of:
Environment and climate change
ISBN:
9781782569961

Peer review scrutinising the example dwellings in the Energy Efficiency Standard for Social Housing consultation document.

Energy Efficiency Standard for Social Housing: peer review
Appendix I Summary - Upgrade Measures and Outcomes

Appendix I Summary - Upgrade Measures and Outcomes

Property type Sub-archetype Fuel Baseline Rating Post- SHQS Rating Post- EESSH Rating Post 2050 Rating List of Applied Measures
EE EI EE EI EE EI EE EI SHQS EESSH 2050
A: Pre 1919

solid wall dwelling
1: ground floor Gas E (51) E (49) D (56) E (53) C (71) C (72) C (76) C (79) − dbl glazing (pre 2003)

− CLFs
− Boiler / controls − int. wall ins.

− floor ins.

− dbl glazing (post 2003)
Electric E (52) F (33) D (65) E (42) N/A N/A C (74) D (57) − dbl glazing (pre 2003)

− St. heating, controls & HWT

− CLFs
− N/A − int. wall ins

− Floor ins

− dbl glazing (post 2003)
A: Pre 1919

solid wall dwelling
2: mid floor Gas D (59) D (57) D (63) D (62) C (75) C (78) C (80) B (83) − dbl glazing (pre 2003)

− CLFs
− Boiler / controls − int. wall ins

− dbl glazing (post 2003)
Electric D (64) E (43) C (72) E (53) N/A N/A C (80) C (69) − dbl glazing (pre 2003),

− St. heating, controls & HWT

− CLFs
− N/A − int. wall ins

− dbl glazing (post 2003)
A: Pre 1919

solid wall dwelling
3: top floor Gas E (40) F (38) D (62) D (59) C (76) C (78) C (79) B (82) LI (100mm)

− dbl glazing (pre 2003)

− CLFs
LI (250mm)

− boiler / controls
− dbl glazing (post 2003)

− int. wall ins.
Electric F (35) G (18) D (67) E (46) C (74) D (57) C (79) D (66) LI (100mm)

− St. heating, controls & HWT

− CLFs
LI (250mm)

− dbl glazing (post 2003)
− int. wall ins.
B: 1930-49 4: mid-floor flat Gas D (64) D (63) C (71) C (70) B (82) B (86) N/A N/A CWI

− CLFs
− dbl glazing (post 2003)

− boiler / controls
− N/A
Electric D (68) E (50) C (79) D (68) B (81) C (71) B (83) C (74) CWI − dbl glazing (pre 2003) − CLFs − St. heating, controls & HWT − dbl glazing (post 2003)
B: 1930-49 5: mid-terrace Gas E (42) E (39) D (62) D (59) C (76) C (76) B (83) B (84) CWI

LI (100mm)

− dbl glazing (pre 2003)

− CLFs
LI (250mm)

− boiler / controls
− floor ins

− dbl glazing (post 2003)

PV
Electric F (36) G (19) C (73) D (55) N/A N/A C (80) D (63) CWI

LI (250mm)

− dbl glazing (pre 2003)

− St. heating, controls & HWT

− CLFs
− N/A − floor ins

PV
B: 1930-49 6: semi-detached Gas F (36) F (33) D (59) E (54) C (74) C (74) B (81) B (81) CWI

LI (100mm)

− dbl glazing (pre 2003)

− CLFs
LI (250mm)

− boiler / controls
− floor ins

− dbl glazing (post 2003)

PV
Electric F (27) G (11) C (69) E (47) N/A N/A C (76) D (55) CWI

LI (250mm)

− dbl glazing (pre 2003)

− St. heating, controls & HWT

− CLFs
− N/A − floor ins

PV
C: 1930-49 7: Four-in-a-block lower Gas E (50) E (46) D (61) D (56) C (74) C (74) C (78) C (79) CWI

− CLFs
− boiler / controls − floor ins

− dbl glazing (post 2003)
Electric E (47) F (28) C (71) E (51) N/A N/A C (75) D (57) CWI

− dbl glazing (post 2003)

− St. heatIng /controls / HWT

− CLFs
− N/A − floor ins
C: 1930-49 8: Four-in-a-block upper Gas F (34) F (32) D (61) D (57) C (76) C (77) B (89) B (89) CWI

LI (100mm)

− CLFs
LI (250mm)

− boiler /controls
− dbl glazing (post 2003)

PV
Electric F (25) G (9) C (70) E (52) C (74) D (56) B (85) D (66) CWI

LI (250mm)

− dbl glazing (pre 2003)

− CLFs
− St. heater /controls / HWT PV
D: 1950-65 post war 9: mid-floor flat Gas D (67) D (65) C (74) C (73) B (81) B (83) B (84) B (86) CWI

− CLFs
− boiler /controls − dbl glazing (post 2003)
Electric C (69) E (52) C (77) D (64) B (84) C (75) N/A N/A CWI

− CLFs
− dbl glazing (post 2003)

− St. heater /controls / HWT
− N/A
D: 1950-65 post war 10: mid-terrace Gas E (44) E (41) D (60) D (56) C (74) C (75) B (82) B (84) CWI

LI (100mm)

− CLFs
LI (250mm)

− boiler / controls
− floor ins

− dbl glazing (post 2003)

PV
Electric E (40) F (22) C (72) E (54) N/A N/A C (80) D (64) CWI

LI

− Dbl glazing (pre 2003)

− St. heater /controls / HWT

− CLFs
− N/A − floor ins

− dbl glazing (post 2003)

PV
D: 1950-65 post war 11: semi-detached Gas F (33) F (30) E (53) E (48) C (70) C (69) C (79) C (79) CWI

LI (100mm)

− CLFs
LI (250mm)

− boiler / controls
− floor ins

− dbl glazing (post 2003)

PV
Electric F (22) G (7) C (71) E (45) N/A N/A C (73) E (51) CWI

LI

− dbl glazing (post 2003)

− St. heater /controls / HWT

− CLFs

PV
− N/A − floor ins
E: 1976-83 12: mid-floor flat Gas D (66) D (66) C (71) C (71) B (82) B (86) N/A N/A CWI

− CLFs
− dbl glazing (post 2003)

− Boilers / controls
− N/A
Electric C (72) D (58) C (78) D (65) B (84) C (77) N/A N/A CWI

− CLFs
− dbl glazing (post 2003)

− St. heater /controls / HWT
− N/A
E: 1976-83 13: mid-terrace Gas E (47) E (43) D (56) E (51) C (75) C (76) B (81) B (82) CWI

LI (100mm)

− CLFs
LI (250mm)

− dbl glazing (post 2003)

− boiler / controls
− floor ins

PV
Electric E (44) F (25) D (66) E (45) D (68) E (47) C (77) D (58) CWI

LI (100mm)

− dbl glazing (pre 2003)

− St. heater / controls

− CLFs
LI (250mm) − floor ins,

− dbl glazing (post 2003),

HWT

PV
E: 1976-83 14: semi-detached Gas E (47) E (42) D (60) D (55) C (75) C (74) B (82) B (82) CWI

LI (100mm)

− CLFs
LI (250mm)

− boiler / controls
− floor ins

− dbl glazing (post 2003)

PV
Electric E (42) F (24) D (69) E (49) N/A N/A C (77) D (57) CWI

LI (250mm)

− dbl glazing (post 2003)

− St. heater /controls / HWT

− CLFs
− N/A − floor ins

PV
F: 1984-91 15: mid-floor flat Gas C (71) C (73) N/A N/A B (81) B (86) N/A N/A − N/A − dbl glazing (Post 2003)

− boiler / controls

− CLFs
− N/A
Electric C (79) C (69) N/A N/A B (82) C (72) B (85) C (70) − N/A − St. heater/ HWT

− CLFs
− additional wall ins

− dbl glazing (post 2003)
F: 1984-91 16: mid-terrace Gas D (59) D (55) N/A N/A C (76) C (77) C (80) B (81) − N/A LI (250mm)

− dbl glazing (Post 2003)

− boiler / controls
PV
Electric D (63) E (44) C (70) E (49) N/A N/A C (77) D (57) LI (250mm)

− St. heater / HWT

− CLFs
− N/A − dbl glazing (post 2003)

PV
F: 1984-91 17: semi-detached Gas E (52) E (48) N/A N/A C (72) C (72) C (76) C (76) − N/A LI (250mm)

− dbl glazing (Post 2003)

− boiler / controls

− CLFs
PV
Electric E (51) F (32) D (67) E (42) C (69) E (45) C (71) E (48) LI (250mm)

− St. heater /controls / HWT

− CLFs

PV
− dbl glazing (post 2003) SHW
G: 1992-98 18: mid-floor flat Gas C (69) C (69) N/A N/A C (80) B (83) N/A N/A − N/A − dbl glazing (Post 2003)

− boiler / controls

− CLFs
− N/A
Electric C (76) D (64) N/A N/A C (80) C (69) N/A N/A − N/A − St. heater/ HWT

− CLFs
− N/A
G: 1992-98 19: mid-terrace Gas D (65) D (64) N/A N/A C (76) C (77) B (81) B (83) − N/A LI (250mm)

− boiler / controls

− CLFs
− dbl glazing (Post 2003)

PV
Electric D (65) E (47) C (74) E (54) C (78) D (60) N/A N/A LI (100-250mm)

− CLFs

PV
− dbl glazing (post 2003)

− St. heater / HWT
− N/A
G: 1992-98 20: semi-detached Gas D (61) D (58) N/A N/A C (73) C (73) C (78) C (79) − N/A LI (100-250mm)

− boiler / controls

− CLFs
− dbl glazing (Post 2003) − PV
Electric D (59) E (39) D (67) E (45) C (72) E (50) N/A N/A LI (100-250mm)

− CLFs

PV
− dbl glazing (post 2003)

− St. heater / HWT
− N/A
H: 1999-2007 21: mid-floor flat Gas C (79) B (84) N/A N/A B (83) B (87) N/A N/A − N/A − Boiler / controls

− CLFs
− N/A
Electric B (81) C (74) N/A N/A B (84) C (77) N/A N/A − N/A − St. heater / controls / HWT

− CLFs
− N/A
H: 1999-2007 22: mid-terrace Gas C (75) C (76) N/A N/A C (80) B (81) B (85) B (86) − N/A LI (200-250mm top-up)

− boiler / controls

− CLFs
PV
Electric C (73) D (57) N/A N/A C (77) D (60) B (82) D (65) − N/A LI (200-250mm top-up)

− St. heater / HWT

− CLFs
PV
H: 1999-2007 23: semi-detached Gas C (73) C (74) N/A N/A C (77) C (79) B (82) B (84) − N/A LI (200-250mm top-up)

− boiler / controls

− CLFs
PV
Electric C (70) E (53) N/A N/A C (74) D (56) C (79) D (60) − N/A LI (200-250mm top-up)

− St. heater / HWT

− CLFs
PV
HTT-Pre-1919 tenement flat 1: Ground floor, gable end Gas E (49) E (44) E (53) E (47) D (68) D (66) C (77) C (76) - Dbl glazing
(pre-2003)

- CLFs
- Boiler / controls - Int. wall ins.

- Floor ins.

- Dbl. glazing
(post 2003)
Electric E (44) F (25) D (58) F (34) N/A N/A C (72) E (52) - Dbl glazing
(pre-2003)

- St. heating/ controls/ HWT

- CLFs
- N/A - Int. wall ins.

- Floor ins.

- Dbl. glazing
(post 2003)
HTT: Pre-1919 tenement flat 1: Ground floor, gable end (in-situ u-values) Gas F (33) F (31) F (37) F (33) D (57) E (52) C (74) C (73) - Sec. glazing

- CLFs
- Boiler / controls - Int. wall ins.

- Floor ins.
Electric F (23) G (8) E (39) G (18) N/A N/A D (67) E (45) - Sec. glazing

- St. heating, controls & HWT

- CLFs
- N/A - Int. wall ins.

- Floor ins.
HTT: Pre-1919 tenement flat 2: Top floor,

gable end, partial flat roof
Gas F (31) F (28) F (38) F (34) C (70) D (68) C (76) C (75) - LI (100mm)

- Draught proofing

- CLFs
- LI (250mm)

- flat roof ins.

- Boiler /controls

- dbl glazing (post 2003)
- Int. wall ins
Electric G (19) G (5) E (40) G (19) D (60) F (37) C (70) E (50) - LI (100mm)

- St. heating, controls & HWT

- Draught proofing

- CLFs
- LI (250mm)

- flat roof ins

- dbl glazing (post 2003)
- Int. wall ins
HTT: Multi-storey flat 3: Ground floor, gable end Gas E (53) F (33) D (68) D (65) C (75) C (75) C (78) C (79) - communal gas heating (ext.)

- dbl glazing
(pre 2003)

- CLFs
- ext. wall ins (100mm)
  • - floor ins.
  • - dbl glazing (post 2003)
Electric E (53) F (33) D (65) E (43) C (74) D (57) C (79) D (66) - Dbl glazing
(pre 2003)

- St. heating, controls & HWT

- CLFs
- ext. wall ins (100mm)
  • - floor ins.
  • - dbl glazing (post 2003)
HTT: Multi-storey flat 4: Mid-floor,

gable end
Gas D (63) E (44) C (73) C (73) B (81) B (83) B (82) B (85) - communal gas heating (ext.)

- dbl glazing
(pre 2003)

- CLFs
- ext. wall ins (100mm)
  • - dbl glazing (post 2003)
Electric D (63) E (44) C (72) E (54) B (83) C (73) B (84) C (76) - Dbl glazing
(pre 2003) - St. heating, controls & HWT - CLFs
- ext. wall ins (100mm)
  • - dbl glazing (post 2003)
HTT: External deck access flat 5: Ground floor, gable end Gas E (47) E (44) E (51) E (48) C (75) C (77) C (78) B (81) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- CLFs
- Boiler / controls

- ext. wall ins (100mm)
- floor ins

- dbl glazing (post 2003)
Electric E (45) F (26) D (59) F (36) C (72) E (54) C (77) D (63) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- St. heating, controls & HWT

- CLFs
- ext. wall ins (100mm)
  • - floor ins
  • - dbl glazing (post 2003)
HTT: External deck access flat 6: Mid-floor,

gable end
Gas D (58) D (55) D (62) D (60) B (81) B (84) B (82) B (86) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- CLFs
- Boiler/controls

- ext. wall ins (100mm)
- dbl glazing (post 2003)
Electric D (61) E (41) C (70) E (51) B (82) C (72) B (84) C (75) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- St. heating, controls & HWT

- CLFs
- ext. wall ins (100mm)
  • - dbl glazing (post 2003)
HTT: No Fines concrete flat 7: Ground floor, gable end (user defined u-values) Gas E (49) E (46) E (53) E (49) C (72) C (73) C (76) C (78) - Dbl glazing
(pre-2003)

- CLFs
- Boiler / controls

- ext. wall ins.
- Floor ins. - Dbl glazing (post-2003)
Electric E (47) F (28) D (59) F (36) D (67) E (46) C (73) E (54) - Dbl glazing
(pre-2003)

- St. heating, controls, HWT

- CLFs
- ext. wall ins.
  • - Floor ins.
  • - Dbl glazing (post-2003)
HTT: No Fines concrete flat 7: Ground floor, gable end (default u-values) Gas E (45) E (42) E (49) E (45) C (73) C (74) C (76) C (78) - Dbl glazing
(pre-2003)

- CLFs
- Boiler / controls

- ext. wall ins.
- Floor ins.

- Dbl glazing (post-2003)
Electric E (41) F (23) D (56) F (32) D (68) E (48) C (74) D (57) - Dbl glazing
(pre-2003)

- St. heating, controls, HWT

- CLFs
- ext. wall ins.
  • - Floor ins.
  • - Dbl glazing (post-2003)
HTT: No Fines concrete flat 8: Top floor, gable end (user defined u-values) Gas F (37) F (35) D (56) E (53) C (77) C (79) C (77) C (79) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- Loft ins. (100mm)

- CLFs
- loft ins. (250mm)

- Boiler/ controls

Ext. wall ins (75mm)
  • - dbl glazing (post 2003)
Electric F (29) G (13) D (64) E (42) C (74) D (56) C (75) D (59) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- St. heating, controls & HWT

- CLFs
- Loft ins. (250mm)

- Ext. wall ins (75mm)
  • - dbl glazing (post 2003)
HTT: No Fines concrete flat 8: Top floor, gable end (default u-values) Gas F (34) F (32) E (52) E (48) C (76) C (78) C (77) C (80) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- Loft ins. (100mm)

- CLFs
- loft ins. (250mm)

- Boiler/ controls

- Ext. wall ins (default)
- dbl glazing (post 2003)
Electric F (25) G (9) D (59) F (36) C (74) D (57) C (76) D (60) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- St. heating, controls & HWT

- CLFs
- Loft ins. (250mm)

- Ext. wall ins (default)
  • - dbl glazing (post 2003)
HTT: Swedish timber house 9: Semi-detached (user defined u-values) Gas F (37) F (34) E (50) E (45) C (73) C (73) B (82) B (82) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- loft ins. (100mm)

- CLFs
- loft ins. (250mm)

- Boiler/ controls

- Ext. or int. wall ins.
- dbl glazing (post 2003)

- floor ins

- PV
Electric F (29) G (13) D (59) F (36) C (70) E (50) C (79) D (60) - dbl glazing (post 2003)

- Loft ins. (250mm)

- St. heating, controls & HWT

- CLFs
- Ext. or int. wall ins.
  • - floor ins
  • - PV
HTT: Swedish timber house 9: Semi-detached (default u-values) Gas F (32) F (30) E (43) E (39) C (71) C (70) C (79) C (78) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- loft ins. (100mm)

- CLFs
- loft ins. (250mm)

- Boiler/ controls

- Ext. or int. wall ins.
- dbl glazing (post 2003)

- floor ins

- PV
Electric F (22) G (7) E (52) F (28) D (66) E (44) C (73) E (51) - dbl glazing (post 2003)

- Loft ins. (250mm)

- St. heating, controls & HWT

- CLFs
- Ext. or int. wall ins. - floor ins

- PV
HTT: 1950-1982 timber house 10: Semi-detached Gas E (45) E (41) D (56) E (51) C (71) C (71) C (79) C (78) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- loft ins. (100mm)

- CLFs
- loft ins. (250mm)

- Boiler/ controls
- dbl glazing (post 2003)

- floor ins

- PV
Electric E (41) F (22) D (66) E (45) N/A N/A C (74) E (51) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- loft ins. (250mm)

- St. heating, controls & HWT

- CLFs
- N/A - floor ins

- PV
HTT: System-built concrete house 11: Semi-detached Gas F (33) F (31) D (64) D (60) C (75) C (74) B (82) B (82) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- boiler/ controls

- loft ins. (100mm)

- CLFs
- loft ins. (250mm)

- ext. wall ins (100mm)
  • - dbl glazing (post 2003)
  • - floor ins
  • - PV
Electric F (23) G (8) E (54) F (30) C (71) E (51) C (78) D (59) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- loft ins. (250mm)

- St. heating, controls & HWT

- PV

- CLFs
- ext. wall ins (100mm)
  • - floor ins
HTT: BISF steel frame house 12: Semi-detached Gas F (33) F (31) D (63) D (60) C (74) C (74) B (81) B (82) - dbl glazing (pre 2003)

- boiler / controls

- loft ins. (100mm)

- CLFs
- loft ins. (250mm)

- ext. wall ins
- dbl glazing (post 2003)

- floor ins

- (100mm)

- PV
Electric F (23) G (8) E (53) F (30) C (71) E (51) C (78) D (59) - dbl glazing (post 2003)

- loft ins. (250mm)

- St. heating, controls & HWT

- PV

- CLFs
- ext. wall ins (100mm)
  • - floor ins

Contact

Email: Agnes Meany