Local authority general power of competence: consultation analysis

Analysis and reporting

Consultation themes

Given the open nature of the consultation questions, the analysis of the answers has been grouped within the following themes:

1. Current legislative barriers/limitations.

2. Amendments to existing legislative powers.

3. A General Power of Competence – aspirations for use and limitations.

4. Legislative controls/ financial risk mitigation

Analysis

Quantitative analysis of individual question responses is provided where a question was relatively closed, for example where a question asked whether a specific piece of legislation should be amended and therefore responses could readily be analysed between being either supportive or unsupportive of a proposal. This analysis is on the basis of a simple arithmetic calculation with no attempt to weight responses.

The analysis of subjective questions with a wider range of comments and views is qualitative. If a point was more frequently made this will be indicated, but otherwise the focus is on setting out the range of views expressed. This approach reflects not only the relatively small number of respondents, but also the nature of qualitative data of this type. For example, comments varied considerably in both length, focus and precision. Some addressed the question directly; others made more general observations. Given this diversity, it is often the case that specific points have been made by only one or a small number of respondents. It is also important to note that an analysis of this type reflects the comments made and does not seek to verify the accuracy of those comments or make any judgment on the views expressed.

As with any public consultation exercise, it should be noted that those responding generally have a particular interest in the subject area. Therefore, the views they express cannot necessarily be seen as representative of wider public and professional opinion.