Tourism and Hospitality Industry Leadership Group minutes: 17 June 2026

Tourism and Hospitality Industry Leadership Group minutes: 17 June 2026


Attendees and apologies

ILG members attending:
Aileen Crawford, Glasgow Life
Amanda Wrathall, Edinburgh International Conference Centre (EICC)
Benjamin Carey, Carey Tourism
Carron Tobin, Rural Dimensions
Chris Greenwood, Moffat Centre
Debbie Johnson, IHG Hotels & Resorts
Franck Bruyere, The Royal Yacht Britannia Trust
Hannah Schlesinger Brodie (Online), Edinburgh New Town Cookery School
Joshua Ryan-Saha, Travel Tech Scotland
Judy Rae, Industry Expert
Kat Brogan, Mercat Tours
Leon Thompson, UK Hospitality
Patrick Colquhoun (Online), Scottish Land & Estates and Luss Estates Company
Sarah Allanson, British Holiday & Home Parks Association
Stephen Duncan (Online), Historic Environment Scotland
Anna Miller, Highlands and Islands Enterprise
Gary Cox, Scottish Government
Karen Jackson, South of Scotland Enterprise
Marc Crothall, Scottish Tourism Alliance
Rob Dickson, VisitScotland
Lawrence Durden, Skills Development Scotland
Mark Rowley (Online), South of Scotland Enterprise

Attending:
Caitlin McLoed, VisitScotland
Beth Thoms, VisitScotland
Caroline Cantin, Scottish Government
John Telfer, Scottish Government
Laura Fegan (Online), Scottish Government
Lucy Kenny, Scottish Government
Graham Morrison, VisitScotland
Gwen Raez, VisitScotland

Apologies:
Victoria Erasmus, Glen Mhor Hotel
Derek Shaw, Scottish Enterprise
Brian Simpson, Unite the Union
Barbara Smith, Industry expert
Calum Ross (Online), Loch Melfort Hotel
Kelly Johnstone (Online), The Springboard Charity
Chris Brodie, Skills Development Scotland
James Fowlie, COSLA

Items and actions

Key notes and actions: 

Co-Chair welcome    

Welcome: 

  • Marc Crothall opened by highlighting his recent introductory meeting with the new Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Tourism and Transport. Noting his engagement with the sector and understanding of our strategy. Noted Mr Flynn has also met with VisitScotland and other stakeholders
  • MC welcomed Caitlin McLeod, Strategy Manager at VisitScotland to the meeting and indicated that she will be contributing to today’s discussions on the Rail & Visitor Economy strategy
  • MC provided an update on the Cross Party Group on Tourism (CPG), noting that a number of ILG members have attended previously

February THILG Meeting

  • No amends, February meeting minutes approved by the group.

Updates / actions from February meeting: 

  • The Secretariat was asked to make a connection between Lynne Ward and Josh Ryan-Saha. Both are now in touch. Members should flag if they would also like to connect with Lynne Ward and the Scottish Futures Trust, and the Secretariat is happy to facilitate introductions
  • VisitScotland was asked to incorporate feedback from ILG members into its Infrastructure Strategy consultation response. This has now been completed, with the discussion at the previous ILG meeting proving particularly useful
  • Members were invited to contribute examples or insights on what good practice looks like in relation to the Sustainable Transport Mission. There is an opportunity to discuss this further during today's meeting.
  • A deep dive on Sustainable Transport was proposed for the June 2026 ILG meeting. This item is included on today's agenda
  • The new Minister was encouraged to engage with key stakeholders at an early stage of the new term. Early meetings have already been taking place
  • A VisitScotland representative was asked to hold regular meetings with the Community-Led Tourism Mission Lead. VisitScotland Senior Strategy and Sustainable Growth Manager is meeting regularly with the Mission Group
  • Community-Led Tourism case studies were to be considered as part of upcoming visitor economy activity through VisitScotland. Mission Lead is in contact with Head of Corporate Affairs and Senior Corporate Communications Manager from VisitScotland on this work
  • VisitScotland was asked to prepare a video for launch during Scottish Tourism Month, highlighting the work and priority areas of the ILG. This has been completed
  • VisitScotland was asked to share a communications plan before the next ILG meeting. The plan was shared alongside the papers for today's meeting

 

Sustainable Transport Deep Dive – Rail & Visitor Economy Strategy

Caitlin McLeod from VisitScotland joined the meeting to present on the ongoing development of a new Rail & Visitor Economy Strategy, highlighting the collaborative nature of the project across both tourism and rail industry stakeholders.

The strategy has been informed by extensive engagement across the rail, tourism and events sectors, including ScotRail, Network Rail, Caledonian Sleeper, Community Rail Partnerships, Regional Transport Partnerships, destinations and visitor economy stakeholders.

A consistent theme emerging from engagement is that there is no shortage of ambition, willingness or activity across the sector. The challenge is achieving better alignment, stronger shared understanding, and more informed decision-making.

The strategy is focused less on identifying new actions and more on agreeing what success looks like, ensuring future activity is sequenced across the short, medium and long term, supported by meaningful measurement of impact.

The proposed vision is for more people to choose rail travel with confidence for experience-led purposes, helping sustain public transport provision, connect communities and places, manage peak visitor pressures and generate year-round economic benefit across Scotland.

The strategy is designed to align with wider national frameworks, including Scotland Outlook 2030, Scotland the Perfect Stage, the National Transport Strategy, Net Zero Scotland, the National Performance Framework and wider economic transformation ambitions.

Four strategic pillars have been identified:

  • Improving accessibility and connectivity
  • Supporting the transition to Net Zero
  • Delivering economic benefit across regions and sectors
  • Providing quality and memorable visitor experiences

The strategy is underpinned by three key enablers

  1. Long-term partnerships
  2. Data and insights to support decision-making
  3. Programmed investment to deliver long-term ambitions

Members heard that the strategy has the potential to bring together rail, tourism, events and wider transport activity to:

  • Attract higher-value visitors
  • Support investment prioritisation
  • Encourage integrated transport systems
  • Drive innovation through improved use of data

Seven initial delivery areas have been identified:

  1. Adopting a strategic corridor approach
  2. Visitor economy input into station prioritisation
  3. Integrating tourism and event demand into rail planning
  4. Embedding practical tools to support sustainable journey planning and booking
  5. Improving B2C and B2B communications
  6. Addressing fragmented data and insight sharing
  7. Prioritising high-impact visitor experience improvements

The immediate focus over the next six months will be on establishing strong governance arrangements, including:

  • Creation of a Programme Board
  • Appointment of a coordination role
  • Alignment of rail investment and visitor economy priorities
  • Clear mechanisms for structured visitor economy input
  • Short-term priorities (0-2 years) will focus on moving from engagement into coordinated delivery through:
    • Strategic corridor development
    • Better station investment planning
    • Shared data and insight plans
    • Enhanced visitor-facing tools
    • Stronger collaborative marketing and communications

A strategic corridor approach was proposed as a framework for bringing rail and visitor economy planning together, enabling partners to identify investment opportunities, map existing projects, identify gaps and establish measures of success. Medium-term ambitions (3-5 years) include:

  • Demonstrable visitor experience improvements
  • Enhanced station environments
  • Better use of data and insights
  • Stronger commercial opportunities
  • More effective demand management
  • Longer-term ambitions (5+ years) focus on embedding rail and visitor economy priorities into mainstream decision-making processes, resulting in more integrated planning and greater long-term impact
  • Importance on ensuring the strategy remains practical and deliverable, with a clear emphasis on measuring outcomes and impact rather than simply tracking activity

Members were asked to consider where ultimate ownership of the strategy should sit, how long-term governance should be structured, and how momentum can be maintained once the development phase is complete.

Next steps include continued stakeholder engagement, refinement of the strategy and delivery plan, formal approvals through partner organisations and agreement on future governance and ownership arrangements.

 

The meeting then opened for further discussion as a group:

 

  • Kat Brogan commended the process, describing it as evidence-led, thorough and impressive
  • Judy Rae congratulated the team on producing a strategy that is both ambitious and intuitive. She stressed that ownership will be critical to successful delivery and asked who will ultimately be responsible for the strategy?
  • Caitlin McLeod responded that the strategy will need to command the confidence and support of all stakeholders if it is to succeed
  • Benjamin Carey welcomed the work overall and raised three points. He described integrated ticketing as one of the biggest barriers to modal shift, highlighted the need for increased capacity for bicycles on trains, and asked whether there would be future investment in electrification of rail lines in the far north of Scotland
  • CM noted that some of those questions fall beyond the scope of the strategy itself but advised that dedicated working groups are looking at issues such as integrated ticketing. She highlighted work on fleet standardisation, ensuring rolling stock meets future requirements, improving luggage provision on routes such as the Highland Main Line, and exploring electrification through wider network planning and rail decarbonisation programmes
  • BC expressed concern that Scottish Government may be stepping back from some Net Zero ambitions and stressed the importance of maintaining a clear vision for a just transition
  • CM responded that the aim is ultimately to encourage more people to travel by rail, recognising wider benefits beyond carbon reduction alone
  • Aileen Crawford suggested using localised examples to demonstrate where standardisation and consistency are needed and offered to provide additional examples
  • Joshua Ryan-Saha highlighted the difficulty of the data challenge, noting work underway through Smart Data Foundry on events and festival data. He pointed out that demand spikes are often difficult to predict and that useful insights may already exist within datasets such as card transactions
  • An action was agreed to connect JRS with Caitlin to ensure data opportunities are explored further
  • CM acknowledged that Network Rail can be insular with data, which remains a barrier
  • JRS noted efforts to encourage wider government recognition of tourism data opportunities and suggested possible collaboration with providers such as Trainline. He also raised the growing role of AI-powered trip planning and questioned whether ScotRail could better connect its services into journey-planning platforms
  • JRS emphasised the importance of understanding how the vision will ultimately be used and how it can influence behaviour across multiple stakeholders
  • CM observed that private cars remain the dominant mode of transport and therefore represent the principal challenge
  • MC reflected that the audience for rail is extremely broad and that there are multiple stakeholders seeking to encourage greater rail use. He noted there can be a disconnect between industry perspectives and those of the general public
  • Debbie Johnson, speaking as a regular rail user, highlighted challenges around integrated ticketing, ticket pricing, consistency of customer experience, workforce shortages and live journey information. She suggested that more people would choose rail if journeys were cheaper, easier, and more reliable
  • Carron Tobin referenced Edinburgh’s bus network as an example of clear, affordable transport with live information and wider connectivity. Noting the need for a focus across all modes of transport.
  • Franck Bruyere suggested rail should be considered as part of a complementary transport system rather than in isolation
  • MC agreed that maintaining choice is important
  • Karen Jackson stressed that modal shift can only occur if viable alternatives are available and noted that rail does not currently serve all parts of Scotland. She emphasised the need to begin planning now if future behavioural change is to be achieved

 

Discussion on Best Practice and International Comparisons

  • MC asked what “best in class” looks like internationally and what lessons Scotland can draw from elsewhere
  • CM is engaging with other destinations to understand international approaches, noting that planning and management practices appear to be areas where Scotland has room for improvement
  • Amanda Wrathall stressed that the challenge is not just journeys within Scotland but also journeys to Scotland, both of which need consideration
  • FB highlighted international examples where transport is simpler due to integrated systems and stronger cultural expectations around public transport use. He suggested Scotland should learn from that experience
  • FB also pointed to examples such as Dubai Airport’s AI-powered concierge services, which integrate travel information and onward connections into a seamless customer experience. He also touched on rail capacity, infrastructure constraints, and the importance of encouraging sustainable travel without necessarily assuming rail is the answer for every journey

 

Workforce and Visitor Experience

  • Lawrence Durden highlighted the success of the Welcome Host programme for rail staff but questioned whether wider rail staff fully understand their role within the visitor economy
  • CM agreed that workforce development and onboard catering are issues that require further consideration
  • AC encouraged the group to identify quick wins that can demonstrate success and maintain momentum, suggesting that early actions should be reflected clearly in delivery plans
  • CM agreed and referenced opportunities along key strategic corridors

 

Regional Connectivity and Rural Considerations

  • CM also cited examples such as rail itineraries and highlighted wider challenges around onward connectivity, including taxis in rural locations such as Aberdeenshire
  • Anna Miller stressed the importance of ensuring rural Scotland has an equal voice, noting mixed experiences on services from Inverness and the likely long-running disruption to be caused by A9 dualling.
  • MC highlighted opportunities to better utilise major events when planning transport provision
  • CM noted the appeal of routes such as the Kyle Line and Far North Line, and observed that the industry has traditionally focused heavily on commuter rail rather than visitor experiences. She believes stakeholders are now ready for a significant mindset shift
  • CM also suggested that stronger rail connectivity could encourage visitors to stay longer in destinations such as Fort William and take day trips rather than passing through

 

Delivery and Governance

  • MC noted that ultimately the discussion comes back to prioritisation, infrastructure, and cost
  • Rob Dickson said the conversation around rail is now well ahead of where it was previously. He believes stakeholders recognise the scale of the challenge and that some elements—particularly intercity connectivity—can be fixed
  • RD reflected that he is confident about progress, and credited constructive discussions with the Cabinet Secretary and officials for moving the agenda forward. He called for the same level of commitment and ambition that has been achieved elsewhere in the visitor economy
  • RD proposed that a Programme Board should keep the ILG informed, using members as a critical friend and source of expertise
  • He emphasised the strategic significance of continued collaboration between ScotRail, SRH and the ILG, and expected the group to remain closely connected to the work
  • RD said the vision successfully captures the essence of what the group is trying to achieve, recognising that the transport experience is a core part of the visitor experience in Scotland
  • He pointed to examples such as the Borders Railway and station environments, arguing that infrastructure quality must better reflect the quality Scotland wants visitors to associate with the destination

 

Closing Reflections

  • MC observed that the discussion had generated significant support and very little opposition. He noted encouraging alignment across government, opposition parties and stakeholders and encouraged the group to continue pressing ahead
  • BC welcomed the focus on economic growth but questioned who benefits from that growth, noting that the vision did not sufficiently reference communities. He cited housing pressures along the Borders Railway corridor and argued that the strategy should be clearer about what economic growth means in practice
  • Gwen Raez responded that these themes are already contained within the strategy but acknowledged they may need to be made more visible.
  • RD noted that the work is rooted in supporting rail corridors and the communities connected to them
  • CM agreed, stressing that improving rail services should help sustain communities while encouraging greater use of sustainable transport
  • RD concluded by proposing that the key themes from the discussion be converted into an agenda for the 29th June, after which a final strategy and delivery plan can be prepared. He emphasised that the ILG should continue to provide challenge and oversight from the visitor economy perspective

 

Action: Connect CM with JRS, to inform approach to data and tech.

 

Updates from Mission Leads

Net Zero

  • BC noted that the group remains open to new members and reflected on recent political signals, suggesting there has been a noticeable shift in the conversation around Net Zero. He expressed concern that Scottish Government may be stepping back from previous commitments and questioned whether Scotland will achieve the ambitions it has set for green tourism
  • BC highlighted what he sees as a misunderstanding around North Sea oil, noting that the issue is more complex than simply “turning on/off” production in the UK
  • He acknowledged positive collaboration with VisitScotland, Scottish Government and other partners, but reported disappointment that estimates for the carbon footprint of Scottish tourism are not expected until the autumn at the earliest
  • BC also raised concerns around the growth of data centres, citing examples of the scale of future energy demand and stressing that greater investment in sustainable energy infrastructure will be required.
  • He referenced the National Planning Framework, noting concerns that potential changes could weaken or dilute existing Net Zero commitments
  • BC commented on recent communications material produced by VisitScotland covering the ILG missions, suggesting that it lacked ambition and stronger policy cohesion. He argued that the way the missions are presented should be significantly strengthened

 

A short discussion followed the update:

 

  • Sarah Allanson noted comments from Malcolm Offord, Leader of Reform UK in Scotland suggesting that Net Zero ambitions may be delayed or deprioritised
  • BC agreed that there is a risk of Net Zero being pushed further into the future. While recognising positive news around visitor growth and route development, he questioned whether this alone represents progress if wider sustainability ambitions are not being achieved
  • BC noted that there may be value in engaging directly with political stakeholders, including discussions with senior politicians, to ensure better alignment between policy priorities and the work of the sector. He stressed the importance of understanding how different initiatives connect and support one another
  • He also suggested a role for the visitor levy in implementing and learning from examples of best practice in Net Zero delivery
  • KB highlighted that Edinburgh City Council visitor levy forum currently includes representatives from both business and communities, with projects ultimately subject to council approval and budget decisions. She noted that Net Zero projects continue to receive priority consideration and advised that the next meeting was scheduled soon
  • KB also referenced the VisitScotland Climate Action Accelerator Programme, noting that businesses such as Mercat are participating and that VisitScotland is doing significant work to support businesses on their climate journeys. She was surprised that the programme had not featured more prominently in the discussion
  • GR noted that there are already a number of forums and opportunities where these issues are being discussed
  • KB clarified that responsibility for much of this activity sits with the Net Zero Mission Group
  • BC questioned whether current priorities sufficiently reflect the scale of the challenge and encouraged continued scrutiny of government-agency approaches
  • AM provided an update on the Green Grant Fund, noting that uptake remains lower than anticipated
  • AM questioned whether the challenge stems from a lack of confidence from government or from businesses themselves
  • BC suggested that one barrier may be the absence of requirements or stronger incentives linked to grant funding, reducing motivation for businesses to take action

 

Community Led Tourism

  • CT provided an update on the mission, noting that the part two of the planned deep dive session at the previous meeting had been postponed. The group continues to focus on the measurement agenda and securing dedicated resource to take the work forward
  • CT highlighted that the mission group currently lacks a clear understanding of what data already exists and had requested a meeting with VisitScotland’s Head of Data & Insights to explore available datasets and potential opportunities
  • She noted that activity to date has largely been piecemeal and ad hoc, with a need to move towards a more coordinated programme approach
  • JR asked for views from the group on the mission’s request for additional support and invited further explanation
  • CT referenced the three regional “Press Pause” programmes and similar proof-of-concept activity, highlighting these as examples of work underway but not yet brought together under a coherent framework.
  • SA recognised the challenge of progressing the agenda without dedicated resource, noting that much of the work has been undertaken by a small number of individuals. She suggested that activity is happening across the sector but has not yet been effectively captured or connected
  • When asked how this could be addressed, SA suggested that additional funding and resource would likely be required
  • AC noted that community-led tourism is already reflected within the wider tourism strategy and that similar conversations are taking place elsewhere
  • GR highlighted ongoing work around visitor management and stressed the importance of knowing who the right contacts are within VisitScotland. She also referenced the contribution that Gaelic language and culture can make to community tourism
  • GR emphasised the need to ensure that community-led tourism activity is genuinely delivering impact rather than simply existing as a concept
  • CT updated the group on discussions with the Regional Economic Partnership (REP) team within Scottish Government and noted that VisitScotland’s Head of Data & Insight is exploring opportunities through the Visitor Economy Barometer
  • She acknowledged that there are currently no tangible outputs that can yet be shared but confirmed that conversations and component parts are progressing
  • JR asked whether a timeline could be developed to show how this work might progress and what outputs could be expected, suggesting that this would help build confidence and understanding
  • KJ observed that significant investment is already being directed towards community tourism and questioned what unique value the mission itself brings. She stressed the importance of demonstrating how the mission links to organisations such as SCOTO and ensuring there is not a perception that nothing is happening in this space
  • CT responded that the challenge is not a lack of activity but rather the fact that nobody is currently bringing together the various strands of work, identifying gaps, and joining the dots across the system
  • KB agreed, suggesting there is no clear oversight of what happens if action is not taken. She highlighted the amount of innovative work emerging from grassroots organisations but argued that it remains fragmented
  • KB described community-led tourism as being “under the radar”, with no obvious leadership, ownership, or funding mechanism, and questioned whether organisations such as SCOTO might be best placed to coordinate future activity
  • JR suggested that there may be value in formally articulating these challenges and opportunities with Scottish Government
  • CT agreed and shared that a new symbol is being developed for Community Owned Scotland, with backing from 16 organisations. She encouraged the tourism industry to support and align behind the initiative

 

Action: Carron Tobin to meet with John Quinn to discuss existing data sets.

 

Proud & Valued People

  • LD highlighted continued challenges around the reduction in entry-level jobs within the sector, alongside businesses investing more heavily in training and a decline in apprenticeship opportunities
  • LD noted that the Tourism & Hospitality Toolkit continues to be a valuable resource and will remain hosted by the Fraser of Allander Institute. Work is also underway to showcase best practice through events, with Franck Bruyere recently contributing as a panel member
  • Through partnership working with EVET and ETAG, activity continues to promote skills development and knowledge sharing across the sector
  • LD reported ongoing engagement with the Renfrewshire Tourism Network and highlighted collaboration between Historic Environment Scotland (HES) and SDS on digital innovation, thanking JRS for support in sharing innovations across sectors
  • Concern was raised that the findings of the Fair Work Inquiry have still not been fully implemented. LD suggested there may be a potential role for the Cross Party Group (CPG) in helping progress the agenda.
  • Positive examples of skills activity were highlighted, including the Tay Cities hospitality skills project and other regional training initiatives
  • LD encouraged continued support for Springboard's school leavers campaign, recognising its role in attracting new entrants into the visitor economy workforce
  • The group discussed the potential role of Graduate Apprenticeships, including whether the ILG could help support and promote opportunities that allow people already working in the sector to gain degree-level qualifications
  • LD highlighted work with Edinburgh Napier University around a tourism and hospitality business management pathway and noted ongoing discussions with the Scottish Funding Council about the benefits such a programme could bring to the sector
  • Developing the Young Workforce (DYW) recently invited the Tourism Skills Group to present at its national forum. Feedback was positive, with strong interest shown in the work of the ILG and the wider skills agenda. LD noted the importance of sharing this work with employers and local DYW leads
  • An update was provided on the Tourism Skills Group, with Minister for Innovation, Technology & Tertiary Education, invited to attend future discussions

 

Technology to Enable

  • JRS provided an update on the Scotland Tourism Data Partnership (STDP), noting that work continues across four project areas. Discussions with Mastercard are ongoing and three working groups remain active, progressing project development and funding opportunities
  • JRS reported that a recent funding bid was unsuccessful, however work is already underway on future applications. He stressed the importance of maintaining momentum and securing funding to move projects into delivery
  • Several research grant bids are being developed across different themes. JRS noted that goodwill and voluntary contributions can only sustain progress for so long and highlighted the need for tangible investment to support delivery
  • He thanked Director of Strategy & Competitive Intelligence and Head of Data & Insights from VisitScotland for their continued support and engagement in the programme
  • Data sharing remains a significant challenge, with contractual and legal barriers making collaboration difficult. JRS described this as a collective action problem, suggesting that new approaches to legal and data-sharing frameworks may be required. Academic partnerships are currently seen as the most practical route for accessing and sharing data
  • JRS advised that three or four funding bids are being developed across different topics and suggested there may be opportunities to connect these workstreams more effectively
  • On technology adoption, JRS confirmed funding has been secured for a series of AI Adoption Roadshows in Oban, Edinburgh, Inverness and Dundee. The aim is to help small businesses better understand the practical applications of AI and how it can support business growth and discoverability
  • He noted that the roadshows will also encourage peer learning and sharing of experiences between businesses
  • JRS highlighted continuing engagement with the Tay Cities Test Bed Forum, which is exploring innovation and technology adoption opportunities
  • An update was provided on the development of Scotland's AI Strategy, with JRS expressing disappointment that tourism and hospitality were initially absent from the conversation. He was subsequently asked to draft the tourism contribution, albeit at a very late stage in the process
  • JRS emphasised the importance of ensuring tourism and hospitality are recognised as key sectors within national AI policy and adoption programmes
  • He noted that many businesses continue to struggle with financial pressures and that adoption of AI among SMEs remains behind where it could be
  • However, there has been significant interest from businesses keen to learn more, with strong engagement through initiatives such as the Policy Lab and other support programmes
  • Positive examples are emerging from visitor attractions and tourism businesses experimenting with innovation and new technologies
  • JRS concluded by suggesting that greater ambition, momentum and investment are needed if Scotland is serious about becoming a global leader in tourism innovation. He challenged the group to consider what major actions could realistically be delivered in the coming years rather than focusing solely on incremental change

 

Following the updates, Judy Rae, ILG Vice-Chair opened a discussion:

 

  • JR reflected that it is now 2026 and noted a recurring frustration across several mission groups. She asked what the ILG should do differently and how the next 12–18 months can be used to create a meaningful legacy for the group
  • JR highlighted the Rail and Visitor Economy Strategy (RAVE) as a groundbreaking and strategically significant piece of work and suggested it would be beneficial for the group to discuss what lessons can be learned from that approach. She encouraged members to think differently about how the ILG delivers impact moving forward
  • KB observed that too much activity remains fragmented and funding-driven. She suggested the group should think more horizontally across missions and draw on expertise from outside the ILG where required
  • KB noted that if some missions, such as Net Zero, are struggling for momentum or resource, the wider group should do more to support them collectively. She also reminded members that the ILG exists as a strategic Scottish Government group and should use that position more effectively
  • RD agreed that this feels like an important moment to take stock, citing the new Government, the transition into the final third of the ten-year national tourism strategy, and the wider Public Service Reform agenda
  • RD noted that Scottish Government has moved quickly since the election, with a strong focus on economic growth and public sector reform. He suggested there may be some misalignment between the pace of government priorities and the current focus of the missions
  • He described the wider operating environment as challenging and proposed that the period between now and September should be used to refocus and recalibrate the work of the ILG.
  • RD also identified that the work of the missions is not currently being considered or communicated in the round
  • JR reflected that the ILG has established a trailblazing benchmark and built considerable trust and respect across the sector. She emphasised the need for the group to continue adding value to national conversations
  • KJ observed that the language and priorities of government have shifted following the election, noting that previous frameworks such as NSET are potentially to be replaced. She highlighted the need for the ILG to respond to this changing policy environment
  • RD stated that both STA and VisitScotland benefit from the direction and challenge provided by the ILG. He noted that agencies are likely to face a difficult operating environment and that continued clarity and alignment from the group will be valuable
  • Hannah Schlesinger Brodie suggested the group should frame its ideas and recommendations around solving government priorities and economic challenges. Demonstrating how tourism solutions contribute to economic growth may help strengthen influence and support
  • KB proposed that future conversations should clearly set out both:
    • What action the sector is recommending
    • What the consequences of inaction would be
  • She noted that different politicians will respond to different types of evidence and messaging
  • JR felt that some momentum had been lost and suggested there is broad recognition that the ILG is entering a period of reset. She encouraged the group to identify clear priorities for the next 12–18 months
  • MC called for greater pace and ambition, arguing that the sector needs to make bolder statements, be more vocal, and continue punching above its weight. He stressed the importance of securing collective support behind a renewed direction of travel and avoiding any sense of drift
  • MC questioned whether some of the group's priorities need to change to better align with the priorities of the new Cabinet Secretary and the stronger government focus on economic growth
  • Members discussed whether the ILG should undertake more regular reviews to ensure it is focusing on the right areas and influencing the right agendas. There was recognition that some priorities have progressed well, such as rail, while others are facing barriers
  • MC encouraged members to complete and return the Self-Assessment survey issued to the group, noting that it will help inform future discussions on effectiveness, priorities, and structure
  • He suggested the summer period provides an opportunity to consider whether:
    • The group remains fit for purpose
    • The right people are around the table
    • The current structure remains the best way of working
  • JRS suggested that future engagement should take account of ministerial interests and focus on working with those who are genuinely willing and able to drive change. He argued that tourism should continue to be positioned as a key export sector and that strong political champions are important
  • MC reflected on potential future engagement with Ministers and MSPs, including cross-party involvement where appropriate, while recognising the need to avoid making the group too large or difficult to manage
  • MC concluded by encouraging the group to maintain a strong level of ambition, continue advocating for the sector, and “keep beating the drum” on behalf of the visitor economy

 

Action: ILG Members to complete and return the feedback survey to inform future priorities, membership, and ways of working.

Action: ILG Members to use the September meeting to review, refocus and recalibrate mission priorities in light of the new Government's priorities and economic agenda.

Action: Mission Leads to consider whether current priorities remain the right ones and identify areas requiring greater pace, ambition and impact.

 

Aviation

Gwen Raez, Head of Business Development and Intermediary Marketing at VisitScotland, Stuart Strachan, Head of Aviation for Transport Scotland, Jamie Carson, Aviation Policy Advisor for Transport Scotland and Keith Campbell, Market Connectivity Manager at VisitScotland provided an overview of Scotland’s route development activity, highlighting the importance of aviation in supporting inbound tourism, international connectivity, trade, investment and economic growth.

 

  • Members were reminded that Scotland’s five busiest airports handled almost 29 million passengers in 2025, with Edinburgh continuing to outperform pre-pandemic levels while recovery at other airports remains mixed
  • The group heard that Scotland is currently served by more than 40 airlines, providing a broad mix of short-haul, long-haul, low-cost and full-service connectivity
  • It was noted that route development remains fundamentally a commercial activity, with airports leading negotiations with airlines. The role of Scottish Government and VisitScotland is to provide supporting intelligence, marketing and advocacy through a "Team Scotland" approach
  • The importance of maintaining and growing international connectivity was emphasised, particularly in priority markets such as:
    • North America
    • Canada
    • Germany
    • France
    • China
    • India
    • Australia and Asia-Pacific
  • The group reviewed recent route development successes, including:
    • United Airlines Newark-Glasgow
    • American Airlines New York JFK-Edinburgh
    • WestJet Toronto-Glasgow
    • Eurowings Hannover-Glasgow
    • Continued growth across North American routes
  • Examples were shared of collaborative work between VisitScotland, Scottish Government, airports and airlines, including route launch campaigns, travel trade engagement, Air Lines partnerships, golf tourism promotions and destination marketing activity
  • Members heard how targeted marketing support is increasingly being used not only to secure new routes but also to:
    • Extend seasonality
    • Increase autumn and winter visitation
    • Support year-round connectivity
    • Strengthen route sustainability
  • Additional international connectivity campaigns are targeting the United States, France and Germany through channels such as:
    • Skyscanner
    • Connected TV
    • Social media
    • Travel trade partnerships
  • Discussion highlighted the importance of continuing to focus on both new route opportunities and extending existing services into shoulder and winter seasons
  • The emergence of new aircraft technologies, such as the Airbus A321XLR, was identified as creating opportunities for Scotland to attract routes that may previously have been commercially unviable
  • The role of data and market intelligence was discussed, with recognition that understanding visitor demand patterns and market opportunities will become increasingly important in supporting future connectivity ambitions
  • The group agreed that future route development should continue to focus on markets with strong potential for inbound tourism growth while remaining flexible enough to respond to emerging opportunities

 

A discussion followed the presentation:

 

  • MC asked what passenger numbers are required for an air route to be commercially viable
  • SS explained that there is no single threshold, as viability varies by airline and route. While some operators target load factors of around 80–85%, profitability is influenced by the mix of passengers, premium cabin demand, and revenue generated across the aircraft. SS stressed the importance of demonstrating demand in both directions and the ability of Scottish travellers to utilise the service
  • MC asked about progress on US pre-clearance facilities at Edinburgh Airport
  • SS confirmed that pre-clearance remains an ambition and has broad support. However, a number of challenges remain, most of which are reserved matters. Key issues include the transfer of control within parts of the airport to US immigration authorities, including questions around security arrangements and sovereignty. SS noted that Dublin demonstrates the potential benefits and remains a strong example of the model working successfully
  • KJ asked whether there are opportunities to engage with Newcastle Airport as an alternative route-development option
  • SS said direct intervention would be difficult given the competitive nature of route development. He noted that Newcastle continues to have an interest in the Air Departure Tax debate and that competitiveness remains a significant consideration, although there are no direct discussions currently underway
  • KC highlighted that many inbound tour operators are increasingly promoting twin-destination itineraries, with visitors arriving through one airport and departing from another. Product development activity around these opportunities is ongoing
  • RD stressed the importance of not becoming constrained by administrative boundaries, noting that visitors do not recognise borders in the same way organisations do. He highlighted partnership working with VisitBritain, destination development organisations in the South of Scotland and North East, and the potential opportunities created by investment around Newcastle Airport. He also suggested there may be softer, non-aviation opportunities to improve connectivity and visitor flows
  • SA referenced ongoing rumours around the potential return of the Rosyth ferry service
  • GR noted that the primary challenge remains achieving year-round commercial viability, with operators seeking significant financial support to sustain services
  • KB highlighted the success of DFDS services from Hull and Newcastle and noted that DFDS receives support from the Flemish Government
  • Chris Greenwood observed that the US continues to account for around a third of Scotland’s inbound visitor expenditure and asked which markets beyond Scotland’s traditional top markets offer the best opportunities for diversification and growth
  • GR identified India, Canada, Spain and Italy as areas of opportunity. Spain and Italy are currently showing growth, while India remains a longer-term opportunity. He noted that the Indian market continues to be highly price-sensitive
  • Discussion touched on historic transport links, including the former sleeper train car-carrying service to Scotland, though no active proposals are currently being considered
  • SS confirmed plans to continue working with CWG and partners on opportunities relating to India and said efforts to develop connectivity in that market would continue
  • MC highlighted continued growth in international students, particularly within Glasgow’s university sector, and referenced the economic impact of overseas student markets. He suggested there may be opportunities for additional connectivity with China
  • SS confirmed that further connectivity remains an aspiration and that discussions continue with airports on future possibilities
  • GR emphasised the importance of ensuring the success of the existing Hainan Airlines service to help strengthen the case for future Chinese routes
  • Gary Cox highlighted the role of diplomacy and “soft power” in route development. He noted that engagement at First Minister level had played an important role in supporting discussions with Hainan and suggested that understanding wider political contexts can be critical in developing international connectivity
  • GC also stressed the importance of identifying airline fleet developments early, understanding which carriers are taking delivery of new aircraft, and targeting opportunities accordingly. He cited examples where route opportunities had emerged quickly, including discussions around Calgary services
  • JC explained that advances in aircraft technology are making thinner routes increasingly viable. The arrival of successive generations of new aircraft is creating opportunities that previously would not have been commercially feasible
  • SS highlighted the significance of the Airbus A321XLR, noting that demand currently exceeds supply. He suggested stakeholders should begin considering what opportunities these aircraft could create for Scotland, including services from Southern Europe and other emerging markets
  • SS also referenced recent route-development discussions involving Inverness, where genuine airline interest has been identified. He noted that subsidy-control rules continue to create challenges regarding the type of support that can be offered. He also highlighted recent developments in the Cardiff/Bristol case as an interesting reference point for future route-development policy considerations
  • RD emphasised the importance of aligning aviation, destination development, product development and events activity. He argued that strengthening destinations and events creates stronger route-development propositions
  • Using the North East as an example, RD noted that major events such as the World Rally Championship have the potential to place destinations on the international map, increasing route opportunities and strengthening wider economic benefits
  • He added that many parts of Scotland already have strong international credentials, but improved connectivity could unlock further growth
  • GC concluded by highlighting the potential for existing successful routes, such as Boston, to increase frequency in future, including the possibility of progressing towards double-daily services

 

Close:

 

  • MC reflected on the achievements of the ILG to date, noting that the group has delivered a number of positive outcomes and continues to influence important areas of policy and industry development. He highlighted the aviation discussion as particularly valuable, helping members better understand the opportunities and complexities involved in route development and connectivity
  • MC encouraged all Mission Leads to be candid in their feedback and assessments of progress. He noted that it is entirely natural for the group to pause, refresh and rethink its approach where necessary
  • MC stressed that if mission groups feel they have become stagnant or have reached a brick wall, there should be no hesitation in saying so. He encouraged members to think strategically and honestly about whether priorities need to evolve or change direction
  • Looking beyond Scotland Outlook 2030, MC noted that some members may wish to focus increasingly on longer-term challenges and opportunities. He observed that the ILG is already more advanced than many comparable groups and should continue to build on that position
  • The meeting closed with reference to Kat's recent article on positivity, reinforcing the importance of maintaining confidence, ambition and momentum as the sector navigates future challenges and opportunities
Back to top