Scottish Crime and Justice Survey 2023-24: Pilot report
A report detailing a pilot exercise conducted prior to the start of the Scottish Crime and Justice Survey 2023/24 fieldwork.
Summary of pilot fieldwork
In total, 102 pilot interviews were conducted by Ipsos and ScotCen interviewers.
In line with the main survey approach for 2023-24, addresses were randomly pre-selected within each sample point area and sample addresses were allocated to interviewers using the iField survey management system. This allowed both organisations’ field teams to carry out tests on their systems to ensure that everything was working correctly.
However, some elements of the pilot differed from the approach employed for the main stage fieldwork. For example, Ipsos interviewers did not send SCJS letters or leaflets to sampled households in advance of their visits. The random adult selection element of the survey also differed slightly, with interviewers advised for the pilot that if the random adult was unable / unwilling to participate, they could carry out the survey with another willing member of the household.
A quota sampling approach was used for the pilot, with targets set to ensure a broadly representative mix of respondents by gender and age. To allow testing of the new fraud and cyber-crime victim form, interviewers were asked to achieve at least one interview with someone who had been a victim of this type of crime in the last year. Sample points were purposively selected in postcode areas within close travelling distance of interviewers. Thirty-two sample points were created – fifteen of these were worked by interviewers while the remainder were used for systems testing.
| Number of crimes | Quota Breakdown | Achieved |
|---|---|---|
| Gender | Male | 48 |
| Gender | Female | 54 |
| Age | 16-24 | 19 |
| Age | 25-54 | 55 |
| Age | 55+ | 28 |
| Mode of interview | Face to face | 100 |
| Mode of interview | Phone | 2 |
| Victim forms | Any | 57 |
| Victim forms | Traditional | 32 |
| Victim forms | Fraud and cyber-crime | 25 |
| Self-completion mode | CAPI – without interviewer assistance | 80 |
| Self-completion mode | CAPI – with interviewer assistance | 4 |
| Self-completion mode | CAWI | 8 |
| Self-completion mode | Refused | 10 |
| Total interviews | Total | 102 |
In total, 57 victim forms were completed, in 39 different interviews. Twenty-five fraud and cyber-crime victim forms were completed – these comprised 19 interviews where one victim form was completed, and three interviews where two victim forms were completed.
Eighty-four respondents agreed to participate in the self-completion component of the survey on the interviewer’s CAPI tablet, with all but four of them completing it independently, without interviewer assistance. Eight participants who refused the self-completion section opted to receive the online version of the survey. Those who refused the self-completion component did so mainly due to time constraints.
Upon completion of their interviews, interviewers were asked to provide feedback on the changes made to the survey script for 2023-24 (mainly the fraud and cyber-crime victim form and the partner abuse section), along with feedback on any other issues experienced with the survey questionnaire, script or survey management systems. Their feedback was discussed in detail at the pilot debriefing on 1 June 2023, which was attended by members of the SCJS teams from the Scottish Government, Ipsos and ScotCen, together with five interviewers from Ipsos and three from ScotCen.
The remainder of this document sets out the findings from the pilot debrief in detail for three main areas: questionnaire design and content; questionnaire timings; and survey management systems and script performance.
Contact
Email: scjs@gov.scot