Retail Industry Leadership Group meeting minutes: September 2026

Minutes from the meeting of the group on 23 September 2026.


Attendees and apologies

ILG members attending

  • Tom Arthur (TA), Minister for Business and Fair Work, and Retail ILG co-Chair

  • Lucy Brown (LB), Central Operations Director, John Lewis Partnership, and Retail ILG co-Chair

  • David Lonsdale (DL), Director, Scottish Retail Consortium (SRC)

  • Kelly O’Sullivan (KO’S), Head of Communications and Devolved Government Relations, Tesco

  • Garry Fenton (GF), Head of Retail, Greggs

  • Luke McGarty (LMcG), Head of Policy, Public Affairs and Communications, Scottish Grocers’ Federation

  • Mark Millar (MM), Director of Stores – Scotland, Boots

  • Gillian Frew (GFr), Serving Member – Volunteer Member's Council, Federation of Small Business (FSB)

  • Colin Smith (CS), Chief Executive, Scottish Wholesale Association

  • Grace O’Keeffe (GO), Corporate Affairs Manager, Asda

Guests

  • Kirsten Oswald (KO), Minister for Victims and Community Safety

  • ACC Phil Davison (PD), Police Scotland

  • DCI Jordan Low (JL), Police Scotland

  • DSU David MacGregor (DM), Police Scotland

  • Andrew Murphy (AM), Consumer Scotland

Apologies

  • Tony Doonan (TD), Regional Secretary (Scotland), Union of Shop, Distributive and Allied Workers (USDAW)

  • Laura McCormack (LMcC), Head of Policy & Public Affairs, Booksellers Association

  • Mo Razzaq (MR), Chair of Political Engagement - National Federation of Independent Retailers

  • Sonya Harper (SH), Chief Operating Officer, CJ Lang & Son

  • Graeme Thomson (GT), Retail Commercial Director, One O One Convenience Store

Scottish Government

  • James Johnston (JJ), Head of Tourism, Hospitality and Retail Unit

  • John Combe (JC), Retail Policy Officer

  • Fiona Dill (FD), Team Leader, Tobacco & Gambling Unit

  • Derek Moore (DMo) Policy Officer, Police Powers, Strategy & Sponsorship team

Secretariat

  • Ross Sayers (RS), Retail Policy Advisor

Items and actions

Welcome and actions from previous meeting

  • LB welcomed members to the meeting, and noted how pleased she was to welcome back TA as co-Chair. LB also welcomed GF and GFr as new members to the Group.

  • TA stated his pleasure to return as co-Chair and have Retail in his portfolio again. He noted Scot Gov’s desire to work with retailers, e.g. if regulations are not fully considered or don’t align with vision of sector.

  • TA noted the ambition of the ILG for Scotland to be the best place in the UK to grow a retail business. He emphasised that economic growth underpins SG’s goals, and how Scotland needs a thriving Retail sector. 

  • TA welcomed Kirsten Oswald, noted her attendance reflects how much interest SG has in the sector, then highlighted that the Retail Crime Taskforce (RCTF) has been a real achievement in recent years and demonstrates SG’s commitment to the tackling the issue of retail crime.

  • TA acknowledged that a major topic for the sector currently is the proposed policy on capping food prices. The Minister noted he has made himself available through the process and SG is now gathering feedback via the consultation, as well as having brought stakeholders together at a food summit earlier in the month. No decisions have been taken yet, open to ideas and proposals. TA informed members that the timeline post-consultation is based on the range and volume of responses, imagines a significant amount of commentary will come. Stressed that there is already a lot of work done being done by SG to prepare. TA noted that while there are clear differences of opinions on policy, we all recognise that the goal to reduce price of weekly shop for people is worth striving for.

  • TA still committed to ongoing engagement but agreed with LB that the policy is kept separate from the ILG, as there are so many other areas to use this forum for. TA acknowledged it is ultimately up to the ILG what they would like to discuss. 

  • TA addressed the topic of AI, a matter that is escalating rapidly in both public consciousness and Government agendas. TA noted that projections about AI can be encouraging but also have serious downsides. Opportunities for growth, job creation, and making sure the Retail sector can compete - worth considering for a future conversation.

  • DL echoed LB’s warm remarks about TA coming back as co-Chair, always attentive and gone out to bat for the sector. DL noted that the Programme for Government had several positive aspects and no unwanted surprises, though flagged his disagreement with the proposed food price cap. Wondered what is coming after PfG? Review of rates system, methodology?

  • TA noted that the Non-Domestic Rates (NDR) sub group had a lot of discussions but there was no consensus on what could replace NDR. Would need to consider type of reliefs and distribution of these. TA highlighted that these schemes are generally very popular and are defended vocally, no suggestion that Small Business Bonus Scheme should be reduced.

  • TA stated that NDR reform would need to align with public service reform, as per the proposals in the SG’s document set out earlier in the week. No firm position or set in stone, recognising this needs to happen with consensus, not in a vacuum, and building support in Parliament is key.

Update from Police Scotland

ACC PD and DCI JL provided an update on the Retail Crime Taskforce and then a presentation on Direct Reporting:

  • PD expressed he was pleased to take over as lead on RCTF, had a handover with previous lead Tim Mairs, and is looking forward to working with the Group.
  • PD stated that he recently chaired a SPAACE (Scottish Partnership Against Acquisitive Crime) meeting, noted significant cross partner working.
  • PD noted there have been increases in Retail crime statistics due to significant increases in reporting, though the gap is closing between Police Scotland reports and what retailers have captured, detection rates rising also. Advised the average in Scotland is around 180 incidents of shoplifting per day, with 3% of offenders representing 26% of all detected TSL (theft by shoplifting) retail crime (over 2600 offences)
  • JL introduced himself, as he has recently taken over from Jackie Knight.
  • JL advised members that the RCTF will be publishing an 18 month snapshot, with both internal and front facing pieces. Noted theft by shoplifting stats - up 26.1% on previous years, additional 5000 shoplifting crimes.
  • LB expressed that she believes no one is surprised by the figures, but that there is rising confidence in the sector about reporting and crimes being dealt with, and that these figures are the recording of crimes that were happening anyway.
  • JL informed members that the detection rate has been stable, despite uptick in recorded crimes, which is encouraging and they are hopeful that figures are reaching a plateau point. Closing gap between what was previous norm and what is the new normal for detection.
  • JL noted stats showing threatening and abusive behaviour towards staff, as well as assault stats, have risen, but detection rate for assaults has risen too. Due to 18 months deep dive work with the RCTF, they are confident they have identified the prolific offenders. Repeat offenders are those who have committed more than 1 retail crime in the past year. 58.3% of all offences by repeat offenders. Prolific offenders are those who have committed 16 or more offences.
  • JL also identified decreases in a number of areas of Scotland, with some areas showing drops in assaults of retail workers.
  • DL queried if it was like a ‘Whack-A-Mole’ situation. Do these people tend to pop up in other areas once detected? JL acknowledged that some prolific offenders move across divisional Police Scotland boundaries.
  • JL noted that the force is trying to increase ASBOs and knowledge of ASBOs, to stop offenders going into towns and busy areas. This requires an anti-social element too, with victim statements going into the reports to request ASBO
  • JL stated that some drivers of retail crime are outwith police control, e.g. cost of living crisis, justice pinch points.
  • JL flagged that there are a number of positive outcomes since the RCTF began. Ability to be more pro-active and to track repeat offenders. RCTF contributed to hundreds of arrests and prevention engagements. There has also been increased engagement via SG funding. PS act as single point of contact and have set up retailer forums, while also attending national and local events, to show the work being done and listen to hear if they’re getting it right. Retail bulletin also published
  • JL looked ahead, to 2029, and stressed PS’s aim to focus on prolific offenders, and work with crown to get better outcomes. Also, how best to engage with released offenders to stop them going back to that behaviour? Local stations can bid into the RCTF funding for local solutions. Some funding going towards prevention and de-escalation courses to train officers.

Direct Reporting

  • MM noted that because reporting systems are not fully integrated, he suspects that crime is still underreported. His Boots teams are encouraged to report on AUROR but this is not integrated with PS system.

  • JL informed members about Direct Reporting Retail Crime (DRRC), the aim being that this will provide a solution to retailers to provide equity for those who might not have a system like AUROR. DRRC will be online and stores can report non-ongoing or violent incidents. PS are looking to eliminate the need for officers having to arrange dates and times with retail staff for obtaining statements, CCTV, summary of events etc. The automation aspect makes the process much quicker than current processes.

  • JL went on to note they are working with all platforms (AUROR, SentraSIS etc) to integrate with PS platform. Retailer will log on to their system, or if they don’t have one, can log on to the PS free system, then upload info and photos from CCTV. PS system will create a pre-populated report and streamline process.

  • JL explained benefits for retailers (ease of reporting crime, store productivity) and for PS (streamlines work, makes it easier to see big picture and trends). PS are expecting a rise in reporting with this system in place, but better quality submissions. JL stated that PS will be encouraging retailers to report as it happens, rather than saving up evidence.

  • JL went through a proposed timeline for DRRC. The online reporting is live, automation is live, third party reporting looking at April 2027 onwards. Pilot of each third party provider in April 2027 then will decide afterwards if DRRC is the solution or if more work is required.

  • KO thanked PS for their presentation, then expressed that she hopes her presence, in addition to TA, shows how seriously SG takes Retail issues. Glad to see the practical work of the RCTF, which is worth its weight in gold, and agrees with the vision of the ILG. Noted how partnership working is key and pleased to see how strong the will of the retailers around the table is in tackling this.

  • TA acknowledged impact from organised crime and queried if PS can predict organised crime trends developing and evolving, and how criminality could evolve in response to the work of the RCTF?

  • PD advised that PS view organised crime like an ecosystem, and that there are often complex and varied lines of criminal activity to tackle. PS therefore take a holistic approach to tackling organised crime, undertaking prevention and protect activities around victims and vulnerable people, while pursuing offenders from the lowest to the highest levels of organised crime groups. Within the targeting of organised crime, focused activity within thematic areas, such as retail crime are important and there have been some successes disrupting organised crime across this crime type.  

  • PD acknowledged that PS do however recognise a ‘Whack-A-Mole’ effect as referenced earlier, that a disruption of organised shoplifting, could for example lead to organised crime gangs seeking other opportunities across online crime or drug trade, or conversely significant arrests relative to drug production and supply can lead to drugs taken off the streets, increasing commodity prices, which can consequently prompt more acquisitive crimes. It is because of such complexities that trends and activities of organised crime groups are tackled holistically as well as thematically.

  • MM noted it is great to hear about offenders being caught and punished, would like to see the full process of what happens from arrest to sentencing

  • GF told members of reporting over 5000 offences, the top 10% of those accounting for about half of losses. Not hearing much about what happens after reporting. Reluctance to report if stores don’t hear what’s happening.

  • KO flagged that PS does put up some good info on social media, although there are restrictions on what can be posted. How do we make that info more accessible to the staff facing these threats?

  • PD acknowledged that there is a desire from all parties, including SG, to see the Justice process, but once case begins, there is a lot of complexity about what can be revealed. Very difficult to have individual assessments.

  • PD confirmed that once a case begins, particularly once a suspect has been charged, that there is a lot of complexity about what can be revealed/published until justice outcome is then subsequently achieved. He acknowledged a desire from all parties, including SG, towards improvements across wider Justice processes to afford greater sight and access to case information - from point of reporting to position of justice conclusion but there was still work to do on that. PD acknowledged that whilst every case is individual and will have individual outcomes, there may be more that can be done proactively to highlight retail crime outcomes and have these shared across platforms.

  • LB asked how ILG members can help with the storytelling element?

  • DL stated he was pleased to see evidence that the RCTF is working well, is hoping for more funding for the RCTF in budget, offered to support PS where appropriate

  • GO pondered what strategies and actions are actually successful in deterring people from committing crime? Could be for a future discussion

  • PD noted that prevention is the keyword. Want to address how to change behaviours, but this is linked to complex societal aspects. PD informed members that there are examples of offenders becoming role models

  • KO noted her support of preventative examples, like ex-offenders who have been diverted away from retail crime, being brought to a future meeting

Discussion on Illicit Trading

KO apologised for needing to leave early, though noted the ingenuity of the people who are committing these crimes is evident, so we need to have the same levels of ingenuity to stop it. We don’t want these illicit traders on our high streets.

  • GP introduced himself and told members of his role as lead of the Trading Standards team in Aberdeen City. GP also leads on illegal tobacco and Operation CeCe for SCOTSS.
  • KD also introduced himself and noted his role: to manage the operations within SCOTSS and other enforcement agencies across UK, and he also produces stats and figures on e.g. local underage sales
  • GP noted dwindling numbers of Trading Standards employees. 50% drop since 2002. Audit Scotland classified services with under 8 staff as small and at higher risk of underperformance. By 2025, 22 of TS services fell into this category. 60% of officers are over 50, only 11% under 40.
  • GP informed members about Operation CeCe – created by UK Gov, to address overlap in what HMRC and TS are doing, looking for illegal tobacco and cigarettes. Trading Standards focus on Tier 3, which is retail selling of illegal tobacco and cigarettes. Their work is all intelligence led. Over 6000 intel logs added in 5 years on retail level criminality. His Majesty’s Government fund this work, and have committed to 4 years. GP highlighted good relationships with HMRC, Home Office, Police Scotland.
  • KD flagged that 5 years ago, pre Op CeCe, there would be almost zero tobacco seized at retail level. Last year over 2 million cigarettes and 500kg of hand rolling tobacco were seized.
  • GP noted that through a change in legislation, TS have access to HMRC technology to tell if tobacco products are genuine or fake. The same legislation allows TS to refer cases to HMRC for tax  penalty purposes. though acknowledged there is no visibility, it is a quick and effective process. 
  • GP highlighted the creation of Scottish Illicit Tobacco Team (SITT), after recent funding from HMRC. Funding secured until April 2029, results already very positive
  • GP raised that illicit businesses are adapting, complex mechanical, magnetic, hydraulic technology to hide the goods, as well as making scents to confuse detection dogs. They also use stash cars, neighbouring buildings, delivery runners. Detection dogs were deployed over 70 times last year, though unless there is a police car outside, hard to publicise visits to public/other stores
  • KD stated that in Scotland, TS don’t have the same powers to apply for Closure Orders as TS does in England and Wales under anti-social behaviour legislation.  KD requested TA to give powers to Trading Standards to allow closure orders like England and Wales. 
  • In Scotland, in cases of under-age sales of tobacco and vapes, banning orders are available but they are able to just remove a named person, who can then ask a friend or spouse to run the shop instead, so limiting the impact. 
  • GP stressed that these illicit traders are putting legitimate shops out of business.
  • LMcG expressed how important it is that TS get more resource. LMcG met with KO recently, brought up ideas like an illicit crime taskforce, similar to RCTF. SGF agree that TS should be given power to enforce closure orders. LMcG also raised giving landlords powers to have a clear and effective route to evict leaseholders it they’re trading illegally. Also raised potential for withdrawal or suspension of alcohol licences for retailers found guilty of illicit trading
  • TA thanked KD and GP for coming and for the work that they do. Noted the impact on legitimate businesses, local jobs and the economy, also the undermining of public health initiatives. TA keen to pick up what more we can do in Government, recognising overlapping responsibilities in SG, UK gov.
  • DL raised the social acceptability of these crimes and those buying from them – people not aware of the criminal elements linked to their cheaper products. DL also noted new restrictions could be coming down the tracks and could affect TS work, not tooled up to do any of this.
  • GP expressed that while the funding is welcome, TS still lack resource. They could carry out visit in the morning and the store will be up and running by the afternoon. Not a viable use of resource to check on these stores multiple times. No visibility unless it goes to court and is reported in the press. In England and Wales, local council can apply for closure orders, in Scotland only Police Scotland can do this.
  • KO’s raised that Tesco had good experience working with TS and gave an example of a local team working with them to tackle the sale of illegal products, which led to an arrest. She highlighted the frustrations for colleagues when stores selling illegal products reopen soon after action has been taken against them.
  • GP stated that TS have to use their limited resource on what they feel is the biggest public concern, with targets chosen on intelligence and previous results
  • DM then presented some slides, as illicit trading is in his portfolio. Noted Operation Machinize, which carried out 135 premises visits and is fully intel led. Expects to exceed that figure this year. The information gathered will inform who will lead on further work, e.g. immigration, Trading Standards
  • LB raised how we can better show the consequences of these traders, and how do we inform the public about the deeper criminality. Perhaps for a future discussion
  • GP agreed that it is about which messages strike a chord, and which change behaviours. Perhaps some people don’t care about government losing out on tax money, but these people do care about people trafficking. GP confirmed again that closure orders are a key ask for TS, but they are also open to ideas from retailers
  • CS queried what ILG members can do to support the work of TS. Could be a future agenda item, mapping out what ILG members can do going forward?
  • LB noted how many substantial items have been raised for future agendas. Agreed with Colin about gathering info from retailers on how to support TS, and noted that Secretariat will reach out to members
Back to top