Equality Impact Assessment - Results
Title of Policy
Glasgow 2018 European Championships and Festival 2018.
Summary of aims and desired outcomes of Policy
The 2018 European Championships is a new multi-sport event to be co- hosted in its first year by Glasgow and Berlin on 2-12 August 2018. Festival 2018 is the cultural programme of the 2018 European Championships.
Directorate: Division: team
The results Equality Impact Assessment ( EQIA) for the Glasgow 2018 European Championships and Festival 2018 is a partnership document led by the Scottish Government (Directorate for Culture, Tourism and Major Events) and Glasgow 2018 with support from VisitScotland.
This document focuses on identifying the headline evidence and related opportunities to boost equality during the Glasgow 2018 European Championships and Festival 2018.
It is under-pinned by an Inclusion Strategy which is being led by Glasgow 2018 and is attached at Annex A. The Inclusion Strategy builds on the headlines in this results EQIA and outlines Glasgow 2018's on-going work towards embedding inclusion and the celebration of diversity across all its activities and build upon the progress that has already been achieved.
Partners have agreed that the Scottish Government will lead the EQIA process for the Glasgow 2018 European Championships and Festival 2018. The delivery of the opportunities that this process has identified are led by Glasgow 2018 with support from the Scottish Government, VisitScotland a range of other partners.
The EQIA process for the Glasgow 2018 European Championships and Festival 2018 has identified:
- major events (including the Glasgow 2018 European Championships and Festival 2018) have no negative impacts on any of the protected characteristics and that partner activity should therefore focus on harnessing the full potential of the key opportunities major events offer to boost inclusion and diversity;
- a lack of supporting data/evidence related to the engagement of the LGBTI, faith and minority ethnic communities in tourism and major events. However the limited evidence available- along through wider partner consultation- suggests that there are particular opportunities to further engage the LGBTI, faith and minority ethnic communities in the Championships and/or Festival 2018;
- a growing body of evidence related to the engagement of disabled and older people in tourism and events- boosted by data gathered in support of VisitScotland's Inclusive Tourism Project (accessibility strand). This evidence showcases a significant opportunity to further enhance accessibility for the Championships/Festival 2018;
- to boost equality during the Glasgow 2018 European Championships/Festival 2018 it is important to build on the successes and lessons/learning from VisitScotland's Inclusive Tourism Project (accessibility strand), the 2014 Commonwealth Games and its cultural programme (including Pride House delivered by LEAP Sports) and other recent major events (such as the 2016 Homeless World Cup) and also to link into key strategies such as the National Events Strategy 2015-2025 and the Tourism Scotland 2020: the National Tourism Strategy; and
- that significant activity to boost equality through tourism and events is already underway (for example the multi-cultural celebration of the Winter Festivals/Year of Young People- led by BEMIS Scotland- and VisitScotland's Inclusive Tourism Project- which has generated significant momentum around accessibility in particular). Where possible this existing activity should also be built on for the Glasgow 2018 European Championships/Festival 2018, in addition to exploring opportunities for new bespoke actions, with a focus on activities which leave a legacy beyond the Championships; and
- that there are particular opportunities to engage young people in the European Championships building on wider momentum around the 2018 Year of Young People.
Headline data, engagement and information:
- 79% (of respondents) believe that there is a problem with homophobia in sport. 66% (of respondents) think there is a problem with transphobia in sport. 62% (of respondents) have witnessed or experienced homophobia or transphobia in sport. 5% (of respondents) think enough is being done to tackle homophobia and transphobia in sport (Out for Sport research report- Equality Network);
- Pride House 2014 (Commonwealth Games)- 93% of volunteers reported an increase in confidence as a result of volunteering for Pride House 2014. 60% of participants stated that they were more likely to get involved with something sport, LGBT or community-related as a result of visiting Pride House 2014. 88% of participants felt that the event they attended at Pride House 2014 promoted Glasgow and Scotland (Pride House, Glasgow- Evaluation Report);
- Engagement, led by LEAP Sports, with national groups representing the LGBTI community found that there was broad support for establishing a Pride House during the 2018 European Championships; building on the success of this model at the 2014 Commonwealth Games and 2016 Homelessness World Cup;
- In 2011, the proportion of people in Scotland with a long-term activity-limiting health problem or disability was 20% (1,040,000 people) (2011 Scotland census);
- Disabled people in Scotland are less active, and are less likely to participate in sport (Equality and Sport Research- SportScotland 2016);
- In 2014, sports participation (excluding walking) for adults in Scotland without a condition was 59 per cent. This fell to a fifth (18%) for adults with a condition resulting in major limitations and a third (34%) for adults with a condition resulting in minor limitations. Disabled people are less likely to use leisure facilities. However, when disabled people do take part in sport and exercise, they are almost as likely as others to take part frequently (Equality and Sport Research- SportScotland 2016);
- 95% (of respondents) try to find disabled access information about somewhere before visiting for the first time. 61% (of respondents) say sports venues have generally good accessibility and 69% (of respondents) say cinemas and theatres have generally good accessibility (Euan's Guide- 2017 survey).
- In 2010 addressing the needs of people with autism was recognised as a national priority. Following a period of consultation, the Scottish Government and COSLA launched the Scottish Strategy for Autism in November 2011;
- Commonwealth Games 2014 - 4% of visitors (estimated 28000 people) stated that they had a particular access needs including a mobility/other physical impairment; visual impairment, hearing impairment; or learning difficulty (Glasgow Life data);
- In Scotland, Pakistani adults are least likely to participate in sport However, it is hard to identify other differences [in sport participation] based on ethnic origin, due to the demographics. (Equality and Sport Research- SportScotland 2016); and
- In Scotland, people of Muslim faith are least likely to take part in sport (Equality and Sport Research- SportScotland 2016).
Inclusion Reference Group
Glasgow 2018 has established an Inclusion Reference Group for the 2018 European Championships. The purpose of the Inclusion Reference Group is to support the delivery of agreed objectives set out in the Inclusion Strategy and act as a reference mechanism for G2018. The Group comprises organisations representing the broadest range of protected groups.
The Group's remit is attached at Annex B.
Headline feedback from the Group includes:
- broad support for establishing a Pride House for the European Championships and for engaging young people in the Championships/Festival 2018 building on the Year of Young People;
- pleased to note plans to establish autism aware quiet zones at key places during the Championships; building on the 53 venues across the city which have secured the National Autistic Society Scotland’s Autism Friendly Awards and helping achieve the ambitions set out in the Scottish Strategy for Autism;
- welcomed the mobile changing places to be provided at Go Live at Glasgow Green to boost accessibility; and
- supported the use of audio commentary at multiple venues across the Championships to assist people with visual/hearing impairments and building on the current provision which centres on premiere league football.
Other feedback from the Inclusion Reference Group, used in the design and delivery of the Championships, includes the importance of ensuring that activities at Glasgow Green and other key festival sites across the city reflect the demographics of the locality.
- The European Championships helps support the ambitions set out in the National Events Strategy- 2015-2025- Scotland the Perfect Stage and also contributes to the National Tourism Strategy- Tourism Scotland 2020;
- The first edition of the new combined European Championships will be held in partnership between Glasgow and Berlin, with 4,500 athletes set to take part;
- The event will be hosted by Glasgow from 2-12 August and its delivery is led by Glasgow 2018;
- Approximately 3,000 athletes will compete in Scotland with an overall delegation of around 8,500 including officials and media;
- The action will take place in 12 venues across Scotland, 7 within Glasgow and 5 spread across other parts of Scotland;
- The Championships will reach a potential broadcast audience of over 1 billion people and bring significant tourism benefits; and
- Alongside the sport there will be a significant cultural programme during the Championships (Festival 2018), which will include links to Berlin.
The Scope of the EQIA
The Scottish Government has prepared a full EQIA for Tourism and Events policy which aims to identify opportunities to boost equality across the tourism and events sectors (including major events like the Glasgow 2018 European Championships). This document is being continuously developed as new data and opportunities emerge.
The full EQIA for Tourism and Events is a strategy focused document which also sets out the detailed evidence and headline opportunities for the published and developing results EQIAs for a wide range of tourism/events policy and delivery actions led by the Scottish Government and other partners including Glasgow 2018 (the EQIA for the Glasgow 2018 European Championships) and also VisitScotland.
The Glasgow 2018 European Championships/Festival 2018 has the potential to make a significant contribution to the EQIA for Tourism and Events and there are two published documents which set out the related opportunity in more detail, these are:
- The results EQIA for the Glasgow 2018 European Championships- this document- which is led by the Scottish Government and Glasgow 2018 with support from VisitScotland; and
- The Inclusion Strategy for the Glasgow 2018 European Championships and Festival 2018- attached at Annex A- which is led by Glasgow 2018- and sets out how partners will deliver the best, barrier free experience to everyone who wants to participate; and takes proactive actions to ensure the event is as inclusive and accessible as possible.
The EQIA process for the Glagow 2018 European Championships and Festival 2018 has found that:
- these events have no negative impacts on any of the protected characteristics and the aim of the EQIA process for the Championships/Festival 2018 is therefore to further boost inclusion and to maximise the positive impacts for participants, audience members, volunteers, businesses/events organisers and also as a vehicle to increase the profile of Scotland's commitment to equality on the international stage;
- the key opportunities are related to boosting the participation of the LGBTI, disabled and minority ethnic/faith communities in the Championships/Festival 2018. There are also other opportunities related to people with intersecting identities and for engaging young/older people;
- the learning and lessons generated by the 2014 Commonwealth Games and 2016 Homelessness World Cup, along with on-going and wider national partner activity to boost equality in tourism and events in Glasgow and across Scotland, provides the Glagow 2018 European Championships and Festival 2018 with a sound framework on which to build its own bespoke and contributing actions and to build a legacy for the future.
Recommendations and Conclusion
To address the opportunities set out above the following actions are being delivered by partners; overseen by the Inclusion Reference Group for the Glasgow 2018 European Championships and Festival 2018 (see Annex B):
The Festival 2018 programme features a wide range of free activities which offer something for everyone.
As a key principle diversity is mainstreamed and celebrated across the entire Festival 2018 programme (in the same way as it is mainstreamed more widely across the Championships).
Many events in Festival 2018 are free and all are open to all. For example - the call for poems responding to the Beyond Boundaries initiative showcases how actions to boost equality and showcase culture and the arts are featured at the heart of Festival 2018. The poetry submitted to this initiative can be inspired by the idea of overcoming obstacles and striving towards a goal, or by the concept of uniting in our differences and celebrating our diversity. Eighteen poems will be chosen for publication in a free ebook and audiobook. A selection of these will be broadcast on community radio and some will be performed or read at Festival 2018 events during August.
In addition, Civic Canteen is a celebratory and provocative event exploring food and nourishment as one of the uniting forces in life. The Civic Canteen tent will house a series of special workshops and events, all of which have the shared goal of using delicious food as the vehicle to promote cultural exchange. Civic Canteen includes: ‘While Having Soup’ from Montreal’s award winning art activists ATSA, which brings strangers together to have thought provoking discussions over soup; and chefs Soul Food Sisters who will showcase the preparation of their favourite dishes from their multi-cultural menu.
Other highlights showcasing Scotland's diversity from the Festival 2018 programme include Michael Richardson’s creative programme at Pride House, Paragon Music, Project Ability and Indepen-dance as well as the circus programme at Go Live! At the Green
In terms of wider intersectional actions, the Scottish Government is providing VisitScotland with a funding contribution of £10,000 to deliver a diversity photography project which aims to offer partners- including Glasgow 2018- with a free to use image bank of people with protected characteristics celebrating tourism and events. This helps ensure that all of Scotland's diverse communities are showcased in promotional activities aimed at boosting Scottish tourism and events.
The volunteering programme for the 2018 European Championships and Festival 2018 has been designed to boost inclusion and celebrate diversity. The aim is that all protected groups are pro-actively invited to participate as volunteers and a set of key performance indicators have been developed by Glasgow 2018 to measure impacts. All of the Championship's performance indicators measuring volunteering by people from protected groups are being carefully monitored to ensure they remain on target.
Equalities lies at the heart of the procurement process for the Championships and Glasgow 2018. Businesses from, and representing, Scotland's diverse communities will be central to the celebration at sites across the city such as Glasgow Green.
LEAP Sports are being provided with funding of £20,000 from the Scottish Government and £10,000 from Glasgow 2018 to engage the LGBTI community in the Glasgow 2018 European Championships through the delivery of Pride House 2018 which will:
- engage LGBTI people with the European Championships;
- engage harder to reach LGBTI people including those with intersecting identities; and
- showcase LGBTI life in Scotland
Disabled and Older People
Glasgow 2018 is working closely with a range of other partners, including many local businesses, to boost accessibility during the European Championships/Festival 2018.
For example: in partnership with Autism Network Scotland and Glasgow Autism Resource Centre, autism aware quiet zones are featured across the event - building on the 53 venues across the city which have achieved the National Autistic Society Scotland’s Autism Friendly Award. This initiative makes the Championships the first multi-sport event to provide a dedicated space for people with autism. Sites with autism aware quiet zones include: GO LIVE! at Glasgow Green; Cathkin Braes Mountain Bike trails; Glasgow’s BMX Centre; and George Square (activities planned to celebrate the Championships/Festival 2018). A document, showcasing the sites offering autism aware quiet zones, was issued to all national autism organisations- by Glasgow 2018- in July 2018.
Other headline actions around accessibility include:
- accessibility audits are being undertaken to help boost acccessibility at key sites across the Championships;
- an inclusion design checklist- to highlight opportunities such as wheelchair spaces, induction loops and audio commentary- was used as part of the integrated design process for the Championships;
- in partnership with REX Blind Parties (a registered charity providing live commentary for visually impaired people), audio commentary will be provided at key events during the Championships- for example at Sir Chris Hoy Velodrome, Tollcross International Swimming Centre and Knightswood Park (Glasgow’s BMX Centre). In July 2018 a flyer detailing where audio commentary will be taking place was cascaded to partners for onwards circulation to their networks;
- there are accessible areas and seating at all the Championship ticketed events and sessions. Three types of accessible tickets are being provided- "wheelchair", "accessible" and "easy access". A dedicated accessible booking telephone line is also being provided to help people choose the right type of ticket for their particular needs and also to answer any related questions around accessibility during the Championships; and
- in advance of the Championships all holders of accessible tickets will receive a specific communication highlighting the accessible facilities on site.
Disabled people are also at the heart of Festival 2018 with shows such as "What am I worth" by Extraordinary Bodies- a company which creates large scale creative performances which raise awareness of the integration of D/deaf, disabled and non-disabled artists working equally together.
Minority Ethnic/Faith Communities
Glasgow's Mela event- one of the biggest free multi-cultural events in Scotland- will pop-up during the Championships on 9 August to promote Scotland's diversity and build on the momentum of the Mela taking place at Kelvingrove Park on 24 June. The Mela’s Championships programme begins with a new dance piece by Project X - developed with young people from across the city.
In addition, Africeilidh is a family-oriented 3-day arts and culture festival celebrating diversity in Glasgow. The festival will infuse Scottish and African arts, showcasing performances by local artists from a range of disciplines.
More widely, the Festival 2018 programme also features a wealth of other activity which showcases a multi-cultural Scotland including the vibrant Festival 2018 Carnival Procession, the Glasgow Kite Festival, Hear our Voice, and Kushe- a Scottish/Pakistani Food collaboration.
In addition, the Championships is delighted to welcome 14 traders who will showcases how Scotland's excellent local produce can be used in the preparation of delicious and healthy food and drink from around the world at the Kitchen Garden, Glasgow Green (which also includes contributions from a range of leading celebrity chefs including TV personality and winner of celebrity MasterChef Hardeep Singh Kohli).
The celebration of the 2018 Year of Young People features across the 2018 European Championships and Glasgow 2018. For example the Year of Young People is one of 5 zones featured at Glasgow Green. The Year of Young People zone features an exciting line-up of activity created by young people themselves that showcases their incredible talents to visitors.
Festival 2018 includes a wealth of events and activities with young people at their centre. For example:
- Ignite Theatre's ‘What Gives Me Strength’ brings together an incredible cast mixing experienced performers with inspiring young people from challenging backgrounds who have made Glasgow their home; and
- "Hear our voice" features a new ensemble of Scottish-Asian musicians who will create a new piece of music, exploring a theme of acceptance. They will draw on creative-writing, sound art and visual art output created by young people through workshops in East Dunbartonshire where the young people explore their own stories of seeking acceptance. This music will be showcased alongside footage of the workshops.
Monitoring and Review
Diversity related impacts from the Glasgow 2018 European Championships and Festival 2018 will be featured in the wider programme level evaluation activity for these events and will be published in due course by the Scottish Government/Glasgow 2018.