Rent control assessments and periodic reports: guidance for local authorities

Guidance issued in accordance with section 6 and section 7 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2025. It is designed to support local authorities in carrying out their statutory duties under Part 1 of the act.


Section 2: report to Scottish Ministers following periodic assessment

Section 2 of the act builds on the duty established in Section 1 by setting out the requirements for the reports that the local authority must submit to the Scottish Ministers following each periodic assessment of rent conditions. The report must clearly set out the details of the local authority’s assessment of rent conditions, including the evidence the local authority has relied upon in carrying out its assessment, and should also include information on the methodology of any research undertaken. It must also include sufficient reasoning for the recommendation as to whether or not all or any part of the area of the local authority should be designated as a rent control area.

All local authorities must submit their reports to the Scottish Ministers by the end of each reporting period. The first reporting period ends on 31 May 2027, and all reports should be submitted to the Scottish Ministers in advance of that date. Subsequent reporting periods run for periods of five years from that date (31 May 2032 and so on).

Summary of assessment

The report should include a summary of the key findings of the assessment of rent conditions. This should draw together the evidence presented throughout the assessment and highlight the conclusions that the local authority considers most relevant to the question of whether all or part of the area should be designated as a rent control area.

The summary should identify any evidence that suggests the designation of a rent control area may be necessary to protect the social and economic interests of tenants. This may include evidence of sustained increases in rent levels, impacts on access to housing, difficulties securing or retaining suitable accommodation, or other factors identified through the assessment which indicate that rent conditions are having a detrimental effect on the social and economic interests of tenants. Equally, the summary should identify any evidence that suggests designation may not be necessary, including evidence that rent levels are stable, that increases are broadly in line with wider economic trends, or that there is limited evidence of adverse impacts on tenants.

The local authority should recognise that different elements of the assessment may point towards different conclusions. For example, some findings may suggest significant pressures within the private rented sector, while other evidence may indicate that those pressures are less pronounced, limited to particular localities, or not of a nature that would justify the designation of a rent control area. Where such differences arise, the report should clearly set them out and explain their significance.

The local authority should consider the significance of the evidence identified through the assessment. While no single factor is determinative, some findings may provide stronger evidence than others of the need for, or appropriateness of, the designation of a rent control area. The report should explain which findings the local authority considers to be of greatest relevance and why.

The summary may also highlight any evidence presented in the assessment that rent conditions vary across the local authority area. Where findings suggest that pressures are concentrated within particular localities rather than being present across the area as a whole, this should be clearly identified, together with an explanation of the nature and extent of those pressures.

This section is intended to provide a balanced overview of the evidence before the local authority reaches its recommendation. The conclusions presented in the summary will inform the authority’s consideration of whether the designation of a rent control area is necessary and should assist in demonstrating how the recommendation has been reached having regard to all relevant evidence.

Consideration of designation of an RCA

In forming a recommendation on whether an area should be designated as a rent control area, the local authority must carefully apply the statutory test set out in the act, namely that such a recommendation should only be made where the authority considers that controlling the rate of rent increases is necessary to protect the social and economic interests of tenants in that area.

The decision of whether or not to recommend designation of a rent control area requires the local authority to review the evidence they have collected in the course of completing their assessment, before considering the question of whether the rate at which rents payable under private residential tenancies is increasing is detrimental to the social and economic interests of tenants in the area.

A significant increase in the rate of rents payable alone would not be sufficient justification for a recommendation to designate a rent control area unless the local authority also consider that rent control is necessary to protect the interests of tenants. Similarly, evidence that the social and economic position of tenants has worsened in the area would not be sufficient justification unless the local authority considers that rent control is necessary to protect the interest of tenants in the area.

The act requires the local authority to assess how the rate of increase in rents impacts the social and economic interests of tenants and demonstrate that rent control would protect those interests. The local authority may only recommend designation where there is clear evidence to support the conclusion that controlling the rate of rent increases is necessary to protect the social and economic interests of tenants in the area.

As noted above, the local authority should particularly consider how local rent trends compare with changes in the Consumer Prices Index (CPI), noting that rent control measures cap both in tenancy and between tenancy increases at CPI +1%, up to a maximum of 6%. Where rents are rising above CPI +1%, this could indicate that the introduction of rent controls may have a meaningful effect in moderating rent increases. Conversely, if increases have been trending below CPI, this could indicate that the introduction of rent controls may have less impact on moderating rent increases and therefore may not be necessary for the protection of the social and economic interests of tenants.

In considering whether the designation of a rent control area is necessary to protect the interests of tenants, the local authority should also consider whether rent control would have a disproportionate impact on the economic interests of landlords. The local authority should have regard to any available evidence relating to the economic situation of landlords in the area. The Scottish Ministers will use information provided in local authority reports for their assessment of whether the designation of a rent control area will be a necessary and proportionate control of landlords’ use of their property. Any information local authorities can provide to support that assessment, and in particular where the available evidence indicates there is a risk of landlords being disproportionately disadvantaged by the designation of a rent control area, should be set out in the report.

The local authority should balance all relevant evidence and ensure that the recommendation on designation is clearly supported by a transparent rationale. Where designation of a rent control area is recommended, the report should set out the reasons for concluding that such measures are necessary to protect the interests of tenants.

Local authority recommendation

As part of the report, the local authority is required to state whether or not it recommends to the Scottish Ministers that they designate all or any part of the area of the local authority as a rent control area and the reasons for any such recommendation. This recommendation should be set out clearly in the report.

Defining the rent control area

Where the report includes a recommendation that an area be designated as a rent control area, the report must include a plan identifying the boundary of the area. The authority may also, where it considers it appropriate, specify the area (including its boundary) by reference to a street, all or part of an electoral ward or another appropriate existing boundary.

Further action

As part of the report, the authority should consider what action is required to monitor rent levels between five-yearly assessments, and in the lead up to the next assessment.

As part of the assessment process, the authority may have identified knowledge gaps, or further action that is required in relation to the assessment of conditions in their area. For example, during the course of the assessment, the authority might identify particular localities where, in its opinion, it is not appropriate at the present moment to designate a rent control area, but rents have been rising quickly and this would benefit from further monitoring.

Contact

Email: Housing.Legislation@gov.scot

Back to top