Overview of Evidence on Land Reform in Scotland

The purpose of this paper is to provide an overview of the evidence available on the implementation and progress of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003 to date, and to highlight some of the key issues that may be worth considering in its forthcoming review.


Annex

Additional Information on Community Right to Buy

List of tables

Table 1

Applications to register a community interest in land, number of approvals of these applications and approvals for CRtB applications by calendar year, 2004 to 1 May 2012 (Scottish Government, May 2012)

Table 2

Applications to register a community interest in land submitted

Table 3

Areas of land purchased by each community group who were successful at purchasing land

Table 4

Rights to Buy that are currently proceeding

Table 5

Details of the communities that have received approval for their Right to Buy but have so far failed to make a purchase (as of 1 May 2012)

Table 6

Reasons given for Ministerial rejection of applications to register a community interest in land

Table 7

Community Bodies that withdrew their applications (as of 1 May 2012)

Table 8

Community Bodies that have Right to Buy application rejected / extinguished at the Right to Buy stage (as of 1 May 2012)

Table 9

Time between community bodies receiving their Section 34(4) letter and applying to register an interest in land

Table 10

Types of projects proposed by community bodies in their applications to register a community interest in land

Table 11

Proposed uses of land by community bodies registering a community interest in land

Table 12

Outcomes of the CRtB ballots undertaken between January 2005 and 1 May 2012

Table 1 Applications to register a community interest in land, number of approvals of these applications and approvals for CRtB applications by calendar year, 2004 to 1 May 2012 (Scottish Government, May 2012)

Calendar Year

No. of Applications to Register a Community Interest in land

No. of Applications to Register a Community Interest in Land Approved

No. of RtB applications Approved

2004 (from 14 June)

13

7

1

2005

17

8

5

2006

36

12

5

2007

16

29

6

2008

24

15

3

2009

6

6

0

2010

15

6

6

2011

12

11

4

2012 (to 1 May 2012)

3

1

1

Total

142

95

31

Table 2 Applications to register a community interest in land submitted between June 2004 and 1 May 2012

Year

No of Applications

No. that were 'late'

No. that were 'timeous'

14/6/04 - 13/6/05

20

16 (80%)

4 (20%)

14/6/05 - 13/6/06

19

5 (26%)

14 (74%)

14/6/06 - 13/6/07

35

4 (11%)

31 (89%)

14/6/07 - 13/6/08

20

3 (15%)

17 (85%)

14/6/08 - 13/6/09

13

0

13 (100%)

14/6/09 - 13/6/10

8

4 (50%)

4 (50%)

14/6/10 -

13/6/11

16

4 (25%)

12 (75%)

14/6/11-1/5/12

11

2 (18%)

9 (82%)

Total

142

38

(27% overall)

104

(73% overall)

The number of timeous applications to register a community interest in land has generally been high, averaging 70% over the past seven years. It is now more than 5 years since the first registered interest was approved by Ministers, and community bodies are now able to re-register their community interest in land. A total of 10 Community Bodies with 12 applications have been able to apply to re-register their community interest in land. Some four of them have re-registered their interest while a further three were unable to submit their applications before their registrations expired and consequently submit them as new registrations. Some five of them did not apply, and their registrations have expired. One re-registration application is currently pending a decision by Ministers.

Table 3 Areas of land purchased by each community group who were successful in purchasing land

Community Body

Date when Right to Buy Approved by Ministers

Area of Land Purchased (ha)

Crossgates

28/02/2005

14.87

Assynt

18/03/2005

4861.8

Assynt

18/03/2005

41.07

Assynt

18/03/2005

14909.3

Silverburn

05/07/2005

0.08

Neilston

29/08/2006

0.081

Comrie

11/07/2007

35.78

Camuscross

26/1/2010

12.1

Benbecula S&L

17/3/2010

701.7

Bute

22/3/2010

1.05

Catrine

19/10/2010

0.2

In addition, there have been two cases where a community received approval for their Right to Buy from Ministers and concluded their purchase outwith the Act. These were: Newburgh - Robertson's Quay (purchased on 20/6/07) and Newburgh 3 Piers (purchased on 20/6/07).

Table 4 Rights to Buy that are currently proceeding

Community Body

Case Number

Date when Right to Buy Approved by Ministers

Area of Land Purchased (ha)

Machrihanish

CB00112

17/3/11

409

Eshiels

CB00125

15/9/11

0.15

Seton Fields (East)

CB00133

29/3/12

44.32

Table 5 Details of the communities that have received Ministerial approval for their Right to Buy but have so far failed to make a purchase (as of 1 May 2012)

Case Number

Community Body

Date Right to Buy Approved by Ministers

Reason for Failure to Purchase

CB00001

Boddam

31/08/2004

CB00007

Newtonhill

28/02/2005

CB withdrew. Could not raise funds.

CB00012

Mundole

09/02/2006

CB failed to purchase. Could not raise funds.

CB00042

Benbecula

02/10/2007

CB failed to purchase after lengthy extension to purchase date. Could not raise funds.

CB00044

LCBG

22/08/2007

Land was valued but landowner decided to withdraw. Registration still in place.

CB00045

LCBG

22/08/2007

Land was valued but landowner decided to withdraw. Registration still in place.

CB00046

LCBG

22/08/2007

Land was valued but landowner decided to withdraw. Registration still in place.

CB00047

LCBG

22/08/2007

Land was valued but landowner decided to withdraw. Registration still in place.

CB00073

Willow Wood

30/9/10

CB withdrew. Could not raise funds

CB00079

Salen

10/01/2008

CB failed to purchase. Could not raise funds.

CB00086

Coldingham

11/11/2008

CB failed to purchase. Could not raise funds.

CB00089

Urras Bhaile Na Cille

12/11/2008

CB failed to purchase. Could not raise funds.

CB00109

South Lochaber

16/2/10

CB failed to purchase. Could not raise funds

CB00032

Bridge Castle

15/9/11

CB failed to purchase. Could not raise funds

Table 6 Reasons given for Ministerial rejection of applications to register a community interest in land

Case Number

Community Body

Reason for Ministers rejecting a CB's CRtB application

Details

CB00005

Ballater

Failed basic/legislative requirement

Failed to meet section 34 criteria.

CB00027

Seton Fields Community Company (no. 1)

Failed basic/legislative requirement

No reference in application to shaded part of map and only one grid reference given in application. (Ministers had no option but to reject)

CB00024

Newburgh Community Trust (Robertson's Quay)

Failed basic/legislative requirement

Owner wrongly identified on application form.

CB00026

Sprouston Community Trust (39(5))

No option but to reject

Missives concluded before receipt of application.

CB00030

Seton Fields Community Company (No. 3)

No option but to reject

Missives concluded before receipt of application.

CB00031

Pro Market Crieff Ltd (rejection under section 39(5))

No option but to reject

(2 owners) Missives were concluded before prohibition letter was received.

CB00016

Holmehill

Not in the public interest

Reasons for being late - not in public interest - NIMBY

CB00019

Park of Keir

Not in the public interest

Not in public interest - NIMBY

CB00021

Houston

Not in the public interest

Not in public interest to dissect community - the land is covered by h1 policy in local plan - not good reason given for late application.

CB00022

Newburgh (Midshore)

Not in the public interest

There had been ongoing negotiations for 8 months with the owner. Not considered to be in the public interest to give a further 6 months to secure funding

CB00035

Killearn

Ministers have no option other than to reject.

39(5) - option agreement in place prior to application.

CB00055

Kinghorn (K8)

Failed basic/legislative requirement

Court decision to delete registered interest

CB00057

Kinghorn (K9)

Failed basic/legislative requirement

Court decision to delete registered interest

CB00060

Kinghorn (K12)

Failed basic/legislative requirement

Court decision to delete registered interest

CB00072

Holmehill

Ministers have no option other than to reject.

39(5) - option agreement in place prior to application.

CB00081

Tarbert & Skipness

Failed basic/legislative requirement

Application fatally flawed i.e. Memo and Arts and Community support problems

CB00083

Tweedsmuir

Failed basic/legislative requirement

Rejected as CB reasons for being Late were not good. CB re-applied timeously and are now registered.

CB00093

Isle of Cumbrae

Ministers have no option other than to reject.

39(5) - option agreement in place prior to application.

CB00101

Edenshead

Failed basic/legislative requirement

CB indentified the wrong landowner.

CB00102

Prestoungrange

Ministers have no option other than to reject.

39(5) - option agreement in place prior to application.

CB00104

Edenshead

Rejected under public interest criteria.

Division within the community

CB00110

Walkerburn

Rejected as CB reasons for being Late were not good.

Application submitted Timeously but found to be Late.

CB00113

Heriot

Ministers have no option other than to reject.

39(5) - option agreement in place prior to application.

CB00118

Drumoig (Area 1)

Ministers have no option but to decline to consider application

37(11) - CB did not indicate a heritable creditor.

CB00119

Drumoig (Area 2)

Ministers have no option but to decline to consider application

37(11) - CB did not indicate a heritable creditor.

CB00120

Drumoig (Area 3)

Ministers have no option but to decline to consider application

37(11) - CB did not indicate a heritable creditor.

CB00121

Drumoig (Area 1)

Failed basic/legislative requirement

Rejected for no good reason for being late

CB00122

Drumoig (Area 2)

Failed basic/legislative requirement

Rejected for no good reason for being late

CB00123

Drumoig (Area 3)

Failed basic/legislative requirement

Rejected for no good reason for being late

CB00129

Bargrennan

Failed basic/legislative requirement

Rejected under public interest criteria and division within the community

CB00128

South Cowal

Failed basic/legislative requirement

Rejected for no good reason for being late

CB00141

Findhorn

Failed basic/legislative requirement

CB indentified the wrong landowner.

Table 7 Community Bodies that withdrew their applications (as of 1 May 2012)

Case Number

Community Body

Reasons for Withdrawal of Application

CB00002

Assynt

Problem with mapping. CB withdrew, re-applied and was successfully registered.

CB00003

Assynt

Problem with mapping. CB withdrew, re-applied and was successfully registered.

CB00004

Assynt

Problem with mapping. CB withdrew, re-applied and was successfully registered.

CB00013

Braemar

Problems with company Memo and Arts. CB withdrew to avoid rejection and possible court action. Did not re-apply.

CB00029

Portpatrick

Problems with company Memo and Arts. CB withdrew, re-applied and successfully registered.

CB00040

Brookfield

CB identified incorrect owner. CB withdrew, re-applied successfully registered.

CB00068

Langstruther

Problem with mapping and did not notify heritable creditor. CB withdrew, re-applied and successfully registered.

CB00069

DCDT

Owner in receivership. CB withdrew to negotiate outwith the Act.

CB00084

Bridgend

CB withdrew. No reason given.

CB00087

Lairg & District

Withdrew as owner was in negotiations with third party.

CB00095

Knockman (BLW)

CB identified incorrect owner. CB withdrew, re-applied and successfully registered.

CB00113

Heriot

Discovered that some of the land had been compulsory purchased. CB withdrew and planned to apply for lane with plans to re-apply minus compulsory purchased area.

CB00130

Walkerburn

CB did not want to have an effect on the business

Table 8 Community Bodies that have Right to Buy application rejected / extinguished at the Right to Buy stage (as of 1 May 2012)

Case number Community Body Right to Buy Rejected/Extinguished Details
CB00011 Coigeach 18/03/2005 Applied for the same land as Assynt. Assynt was chosen to proceed with the right to buy.
CB00020 Fairlie 23/02/2006 Discovered that there was an option agreement over the land.
CB00112 Machrihanish 11/08/2010 Extinguished due to ballot. CB undertook a further ballot and successfully secured Ministerial approval for its second Right to Buy 'application'

Table 9 Time between community bodies receiving their Section 34(4) letter and applying to register a community interest in land

Community Body Date 34(4) Letter Issued Date(s) Application(s) to Register an Interest In Land Submitted
Boddam Development Trust Ltd 22/10/04 30/7/04*
Assynt Foundation 2/10/04 1/9/04*
Ballater (RD) Ltd 22/10/04 13/9/04*
Crossgates Community Woodland 22/10/04 27/9/04*
Newtonhill Trust 22/10/04 7/10/04*
Coigeach Community Company Ltd 25/11/04 19/11/04*
Mundole Futures Ltd 10/12/04 21/12/04
Breamar Community Ltd 30/12/04 21/12/05
Eilean Glas Heritage Trust 30/12/04 25/02/05
Holmehill Ltd 22/2/05 24/2/05; 01/3/05; 29/3/07
Silverburn Community Ltd 24/2/05 24/2/05
Kinghorn Community Land Association 2005 21/3/05 23/3/05; 30/10/06; 28/6/10
The Kipp 23/3/05 05/4/05
Park of Keir Friends Ltd 28/4/05 10/5/05
Fairlie Land Acqusition Company Ltd 18/5/05 25/5/05
Bridge Castle Community Woodland Company 23/5/05 13/1/06
Pro Market Park (Crieff) Ltd 10/6/05 21/12/05
Ford Community Project Ltd 07/7/05 08/9/05
Newburgh Community Trust 25/7/05 17/8/05; 17/5/06; 21/11/07
Durness Development Group Ltd 25/7/05 01/11/05; 04/3/08
Houston Amenity Land Ltd 10/8/05 16/8/05
Sprouston Community Trust 26/10/05 19/10/05
Seton Fields Community Company 26/10/05 18/10/05; 30/12/05; 12/5/06; 27/7/11
Brookfield Village Trust 26/9/05 23/6/06; 09/8/06
Borthwick Water Community Development Trust 12/10/05 05/02/08
Portpatrick Trust 25/10/05 04/1/06; 07/3/06
Willow Wood (West Lothian) Community Company 29/11/05 24/4/07; 1/5/12
Neilston Development Trust 04/4/06 04/4/06
Killearn Community Land Company 04/4/06 03/5/06
Abernyte Community Company 03/4/06 27/2/07
Gifford Community Land Company 13/6/06 06/10/06
Comrie Development Trust 13/6/06 01/9/2006
Benbecula Golf Course Community Interest Company 18/7/06 22/8/06
Salen Development Community Company 29/8/06 20/8/07
LCBG 07/9/06 12/9/06
Balloch Village Trust Community Company 12/10/06 19/2/07
Tarbert & Skipness Community Trust 24/10/06 09/11/07
DCDT Enterprise Company 23/11/06 07/2/07
Darnick Village Trust 04/12/06 29/1/07
Langstruther Community Enterprise Ltd 06/12/06 02/2/07; 21/5/07
Benbecula Sport and Leisure Community Company 21/12/06 20/7/07
Heriot Community Company 22/12/06 24/2/10; 24/6/10
Machrie Improvements 12/1/07 23/7/07
Walkerburn Community Development Trust 07/2/07 09/6/08; 03/9/09; 15/3/11
Carty Port Community Company 01/8/07 03/10/07
Dunblane Development Trust 06/9/07 21/11/08
Evanton Wood Communtiy Company 05/10/07 11/9/08
The Tweedsmuir Community Company 07/11/07 14/1/08; 16/4/08
Bridgend Community Centre Company 22/11/07 15/1/08
The Embo Trust (Urras Euraboil) 16/11/08 05/11/08
Coldingham Sands Community Company 17/1/08 05/2/08
Lairg & District Community Initiatives 28/1/08 20/2/08; 15/10/08
Urras Bhaile Na Cille 04/2/08 25/3/08
Friends of Midmar Inn Community Company 13/2/08 07/5/08
Isle of Cumbrae Initiative Community Company 28/2/08 22/5/08
Grandtully & Strathtay Conservation Trust 20/3/08 28/3/08
Druids Park Community Company Limited 02/4/08 13/10/10
Prestoungrange Arts Festival (2006) 16/5/08 24/9/08
Knockman Community Company 22/5/08 19/6/08; 28/7/08
Glenelg & Arnisdale Development Trust 22/5/08 16/6/09
Grantshouse Community Company 16/6/08 01/7/08
Colintraive and Glendaruel Development Trust 19/6/08 26/10/10
Machrihanish Airbase Community Company 21/8/08 22/12/09
Catrine Community Trust 26/8/08 08/6/10
Edenshead Friends 2007 Community Company 03/10/08 25/9/08; 23/10/08
Camuscross Community Initiative 12/11/08 06/5/09
South Lochaber Community Company 29/12/08 0/8/09
Bute Community Land Company 14/10/09 16/10/09
Coigach Community Development Company 19/2/10 24/3/10; 16/3/12
Drumoig Community Trust 09/6/10 08/7/10; 09/8/10
Eshiels Community Company 23/7/10 08/10/10
North West Mull Community Woodland Company Limited 12/8/10 20/12/10
South Cowal Community Development Company 04/11/10 20/1/11
Bargrennan Community Trust 08/11/10 24/2/11
Findhorn Village Conservation Company 17/2/11 08/7/11; 3/4/12
Am Fasgadh Regeneration Company (Kingussie) Limited 6/5/11 8/9/11
Dunnichen Community Company 2/8/11 13/10/11

Table 10 Types of projects proposed by community bodies in their applications to register a community interest in land

(cases where applications have been approved by Ministers as of 1 May 2012)

CB Number CB Name Business use Leisure Housing Amenity Tourism
CB00001 Boddam
CB00006 Crossgates
CB00007 Newtonhill
CB00008 Assynt
CB00009 Assynt
CB00010 Assynt
CB00011 Coigeach
CB00012 Mundole
CB00014 Silverburn
CB00015 Eilean Glas
CB00017 Kinghorn
CB00018 The Kipp
CB00020 Fairlie
CB00023 Newburgh (dry)
CB00025 Ford
CB00028 Durness
CB00032 Bridge Castle
CB00033 Portpatrick
CB00034 Neilston
CB00036 Newburgh (RQ)
CB00037 Newburgh (3 Piers)
CB00038 Seton Fields (East)
CB00039 Seton Fields (West)
CB00041 Brookfield
CB00042 Benbecula
CB00043 Comrie
CB00044 LCBG
CB00045 LCBG
CB00046 LCBG
CB00047 LCBG
CB00048 Gifford
CB00049 Kinghorn (K2)
CB00050 Kinghorn (K4)
CB00051 Kinghorn (K5)
CB00052 Kinghorn (K6)
CB00053 Kinghorn (K6A)
CB00054 Kinghorn (K7)
CB00056 Kinghorn (K3)
CB00058 Kinghorn (K10)
CB00059 Kinghorn (K11)
CB00061 Kinghorn (K13) 1
CB00062 Kinghorn K(14)
CB00063 Kinghorn K(15)
CB00064 Kinghorn (K16)
CB00065 Kinghorn (K17)
CB00066 Kinghorn (K18)
CB00067 Darnick
CB00070 Balloch
CB00071 Abernyte
CB00073 Willow Wood
CB00074 Langstruther
CB00075 Benbecula S&L
CB00076 Machrie (Golf Course)
CB00077 Machrie (V Hall)
CB00078 Machrie (Field)
CB00079 Salen
CB00080 Carty Port
CB00082 Newburgh (Lochmill)
CB00085 Borthwick Water
CB00086 Coldingham
CB00088 Durness
CB00089 Urras Bhaile Na Cille
CB00090 Strathtay
CB00091 Tweedsmuir
CB00092 Midmar
CB00094 Walkerburn
CB00096 Knockman (BF)
CB00097 Knockman (FH)
CB00098 Grantshouse
CB00099 Knockman (BLW)
CB00100 Evanton Wood
CB00103 Lairg & District
CB00105 Embo
CB00106 Dunblane
CB00107 Camuscross
CB00108 Glenelg
CB00109 South Lochaber
CB00111 Bute
CB00112 Machrihanish
CB00114 Coigach
CB00115 Catrine
CB00117 Kinghorn
CB00124 Druids Park
CB00125 Eshiels
CB00126 Colintraive
CB00127 North West Mull
CB00131 Walkerburn
CB00132 Findhorn
CB00133 Seton Fields (East)
CB00134 Seton Fields (West)
CB00135 Kingussie
CB00136 Kingussie
CB00138 Kingussie
CB00140 Coigach
CB00141 Findhorn
CB00142 Willow Wood

Table 11 Proposed uses of land by community bodies registering a community interest in land

Application Number Name of Community Body Existing use of Land Proposed use of Land
CB00001 Boddam MoD base Business units and local services
CB00002 Assynt Deer Forest Deer Forest
CB00003 Assynt Lodge Lodge
CB00004 Assynt Deer Forest Deer Forest
CB00005 Ballater Arable land and trees Community woodland/amenity
CB00006 Crossgates Wasteland Community woodland/amenity
CB00007 Newtonhill Forestry Forestry, amenity land business creation
CB00008 Assynt Deer Forest Deer Forest
CB00009 Assynt Lodge Lodge
CB00010 Assynt Deer Forest Deer Forest
CB00011 Coigeach Deer Forest Deer Forest
CB00012 Mundole Caravan Park Caravan Park, social housing environmental improvements
CB00013 Braemar Woodland Bio-mass
CB00014 Silverburn Old water tank Community hub
CB00015 Eilean Glas Lighthouse Tourist attraction and café etc
CB00016 Holmehill Woodland Woodland
CB00017 Kinghorn Grazing land Amenity land, home for Ecology Centre
CB00018 The Kipp Rough grazing Gardens, landscaping etc
CB00019 Park of Keir Farmland, grazing Amenity land
CB00020 Fairlie Open ground Amenity
CB00021 Houston Open ground Play areas/amenity
CB00022 Newburgh (mid) Waterfront Amenity
CB00023 Newburgh (dry) Waterfront Amenity
CB00024 Newburgh (RQ) Waterfront Waterfront/amenity
CB00025 Ford Old quarry Community hub
CB00026 Sprouston Pasture land Amenity, tree palnting
CB00027 Seton Fields Open ground Environmental/ amenity
CB00028 Durness Outbuildings Café and craft areas
CB00029 Portpatrick Harbour Harbour and business units
CB00030 Seton Fields Open ground Environmental/ amenity
CB00031 Pro Market Park Park
CB00032 Bridge Castle Open ground/grazing Open ground/grazing, amenity
CB00033 Portpatrick Harbour Harbour and business units
CB00034 Neilston Old bank Community hub
CB00035 Killearn Tennis club Open tennis club, meeting venue
CB00036 Newburgh (RQ) Waterfront Waterfront/amenity
CB00037 Newburgh (3 Piers) Waterfront Waterfront/amenity
CB00038 Seton Fields (East) open ground Environmental/ amenity
CB00039 Seton Fields (West) Open ground Environmental/ amenity
CB00040 Brookfield Open ground Amenity
CB00041 Brookfield Open ground Amenity
CB00042 Benbecula Golf course Environmental/golf course
CB00043 Comrie PoW camp Business units/ allotments, heritage
CB00044 LCBG Former factory site Community hub
CB00045 LCBG Former factory site Community hub
CB00046 LCBG Former factory site Community hub
CB00047 LCBG Former factory site Community hub
CB00048 Gifford Park area Amenity
CB00049 Kinghorn (K2) Fallow land Cemetary
CB00050 Kinghorn (K4) Old train line, trees, open land Wildlife corridor/access
CB00051 Kinghorn (K5) Dense undergrowth and open land Wildlife corridor/access
CB00052 Kinghorn (K6) Open ground trees and paths Wildlife corridor/access
CB00053 Kinghorn (K6A) Open ground trees and paths Wildlife corridor/access
CB00054 Kinghorn (K7) Cultivated land and grazing Access, bunkhouse, biodiversity, Woodland, wildlife
CB00055 Kinghorn (K8) Grass field Woodland habitat for wildlife
CB00056 Kinghorn (K3) Bone building and bare land Bunkhouse, garden, access
CB00057 Kinghorn (K9) Grassland Woodland habitat for wildlife
CB00058 Kinghorn (K10) Grass field Woodland habitat for wildlife
CB00059 Kinghorn (K11) Grass field Woodland habitat for wildlife
CB00060 Kinghorn (K12) Grass field Bio-mass and habitat
CB00061 Kinghorn (K13) House and woodland Respite care
CB00062 Kinghorn K(14) Wetland, woodland and loch Lease to ecology centre, access and education
CB00063 Kinghorn K(15) Gas station Woodland habitat for wildlife
CB00064 Kinghorn (K16) Farm and buildings Lease to ecology centre, access and education
CB00065 Kinghorn (K17) Grass field Woodland habitat for wildlife and possible bio-mass
CB00066 Kinghorn (K18) Reclaimed land from loch Access and lease to Ecology Centre
CB00067 Darnick Open ground Amenity
CB00068 Langstruther Chicken farm, open ground, grazing Amenity, business units
CB00069 DCDT Open ground Car park, garden housing
CB00070 Balloch Agri. field Amenity and recreational use
CB00071 Abernyte Field Amenity and recreational use
CB00072 Holmehill LA building Community centre/hub
CB00073 Willow Wood Residential park Residential park with community hub
CB00074 Langstruther Chicken farm, open ground, grazing Amenity, business units
CB00075 Benbecula S&L Rough areas Sports facilities
CB00076 Machrie (Golf Course) Golf course Golf course, environmental
CB00077 Machrie (V Hall) Village hall Community hub
CB00078 Machrie (Field) Amenity Amenity, tourism enhancement
CB00079 Salen House and jetty Social housing and jetty development
CB00080 Carty Port Old factory site Environmental/ amenity
CB00081 Tarbert & Skipness Boat yard Redevelopment
CB00082 Newburgh (Lochmill) Old reservoir Amenity, boat lake etc
CB00083 Tweedsmuir Hotel, outbuildings and land Hotel, hub, sports facilities
CB00084 Bridgend Walled garden Market garden
CB00085 Borthwick Water Open ground Social housing
CB00086 Coldingham Former Youth Hostel Tourist accomodation
CB00087 Lairg & District Former hotel site Tourist accommodation
CB00088 Durness Visitor centre Business units
CB00089 Urras Bhaile na Cille Former church Community hub, tourist accommodation
CB00090 Strathtay Buildings and woodland Improve woodland, wildlife and upgrade buildings
CB00091 Tweedsmuir Hotel, outbuildings and land Hotel, hub, sports facilities
CB00092 Midmar Former pub Community hub
CB00093 Isle of Cumbrae Open ground at cathedral Gardens, landscaping etc
CB00094 Walkerburn Church Social housing, hub
CB00095 Knockman (BLW) Forestry Forestry, amenity
CB00096 Knockman (BF) Forestry Forestry, amenity
CB00097 Knockman (FH) Forestry Forestry, amenity
CB00098 Grantshouse Former school Amenity and community hub
CB00099 Knockman (BLW) Forestry Forestry, amenity
CB00100 Evanton Wood Forestry Woodland habitat for wildlife
CB00101 Edenshead Former church Recreation facilities
CB00102 Prestoungrange Former factory/office Arts studios etc
CB00103 Lairg & District Former hotel site Tourist accommodation
CB00104 Edenshead Former church Recreation facilities
CB00105 Embo Woodland and arable land, buildings Forest croft creation, business units
CB00106 Dunblane Braeport Centre Maintenence of buildings
CB00107 Camuscross Former reservoir Feed for hydro plant
CB00108 Glenelg Business premisis and fields Crofting, allotments, hydro and business
CB00109 South Lochaber Former hospital Museums, community facilities
CB00110 Walkerburn Rugby club and Pitch Renovate rugby club, sports and fishing
CB00111 Bute Forestry Amenity, forestry
CB00112 Machrihanish Formar airbase Factory sites, business units, meeting facilities
CB00113 Heriot Open ground Amenity land
CB00114 Coigach Former hydroponicum Business units, other community services
CB00115 Catrine Former church house & hall Community facilities, business spaces
CB00116 Heriot Open ground Amenity land
CB00117 Kinghorn Grazing land Amenity land, home for Ecology Centre
CB00118 Drumoig (area 1) Open Ground Amenity
CB00119 Drumoig (area 2) Former golf practice area Redevelopment of practice area
CB00120 Drumoig (area 3) Open ground and trees Amenity land
CB00121 Drumoig (area 1) Open Ground Amenity
CB00122 Drumoig (area 2) Former golf practice area Redevelopment of practice area
CB00123 Drumoig (area 3) Open ground and trees Amenity land
CB00124 Druids Park Open amenity area Amenity improvements
CB00125 Eshiels Recreation hall Community facilities
CB00126 Colintraive Hotel, outbuildings and land Hub, tourist accomodation
CB00127 North West Mull Strip of land in woodland Road creation
CB00128 South Cowal Former outdoor education centre Outdoor education centre, café, tourist accommodation
CB00129 Bargrennan Former village hall Community hub
CB00130 Walkerburn Warehouse and ground Business units
CB00131 Walkerburn Unused building area Redevelopment site, shop, storage etc
CB00132 Findhorn Garages Business units/garages
CB00133 Seton Fields (East) Open ground Environmental/ amenity
CB00134 Seton Fields (West) Open ground Environmental/ amenity
CB00135 Kingussie (allot) Former folk museum, land, carpark and buldings Allotments
CB00136 Kingussie (amf) Former folk museum, land, carpark and buldings Retail space, bistro, heritage, community space
CB00137 Kingussie (LC) Former folk museum, land, carpark and buldings Learning resource centre
CB00138 Kingussie (manse) Former folk museum, land, carpark and buldings Craft centre and community space
CB00139 Dunnichen Former church Heritage Centre
CB00140 Coigach Former Smokehouse Business units
CB00141 Findhorn Drying green area and boat slip Boat storage, repair shop, changing facilities
CB00142 Willow Wood Residential park Residential park with community hub

Table 12 Outcomes of the CRtB ballots undertaken between January 2005 and 1 May 2012

CB number CB name Ballot date Total number of eligible voters Total Number that voted (inc proxy votes) Percentage that voted Number voted in favour (YES) Number voted against (NO) inc spoiled Percentage that voted in favour
CB00005 Crossgates 31 January 2005 1672 1079 64.53% 1002 77 92.86%
CB00007 Newtonhill 07 January 2005 91 84 92.31% 49 35 58.33%
CB00008 Assynt 17 November 2007 818 441 53.91% 276 165 62.59%
CB00009 Assynt 17 November 2007 818 441 53.91% 276 165 62.59%
CB00010 Assynt 17 November 2007 818 441 53.91% 276 165 62.59%
CB00011 Coigeach 28 February 2005 401 204 50.87% 127 77 62.25%
CB00012 Mundole 17 January 2005 136 103 75.74% 94 9 91.26%
CB00014 Silverburn 10 June 2005 43 33 76.74% 32 1 96.97%
CB00034 Neilston 05 August 2006 4165 1156 27.76% 1122 34 97.06%
CB00036 Newburgh (RQ) 09 October 2006 2011 1246 61.96% 1190 53 95.51%
CB00037 Newburgh (3 piers) 09 October 2006 2011 1246 61.96% 1190 53 95.51%
CB00042 Benbecula 06 September 2007 997 331 33.20% 323 8 97.58%
CB00043 Comrie 13 May 2007 1946 1404 72.15% 1362 42 97.01%
CB00044 LCBG 28 July 2007 2646 1088 41.12% 991 97 91.08%
CB00045 LCBG 28 July 2007 2646 1088 41.12% 991 97 91.08%
CB00046 LCBG 28 July 2007 2646 1088 41.12% 991 97 91.08%
CB00047 LCBG 28 July 2007 2646 1088 41.12% 991 97 91.08%
CB00075 Benbecula S&L 20 February 2010 976 492 50.41% 469 23 95.33%
CB00079 Salen 15 December 2007 65 43 66.15% 43 0 100.00%
CB00086 Coldingham 20 October 2008 790 433 54.81% 411 22 94.92%
CB00089 Urras Bhaile Na Cille 16 October 2008 319 238 74.61% 141 95 59.24%
CB00107 Camuscross 22 December 2009 152 93 61.18% 89 4 95.70%
CB00109 South Lochaber 05 March 2010 2089 1182 56.58% 689 492 58.29%
CB00111 Bute 11 February 2010 5220 2739 52.47% 2557 182 93.36%
CB00112 Machrihanish 25 May 2010 5949 4007 67.36% 3903 104 97.40%
CB00073 Willow Wood 01 September 2010 69 64 92.75% 60 4 93.75%
CB00115 Catrine 22 September 2010 1828 915 50.05% 793 122 86.67%
CB00112 Machrihanish 17 December 2010 5817 2789 47.95% 2642 147 94.73%
CB00032 Bridge Castle 01 August 2011 58 37 63.79% 37 0 100.00%
CB00114 Coigach 01 August 2011 220 161 73.18% 148 13 91.93%
CB00125 Eshiels 26 August 2011 128 105 82.03% 99 6 94.29%
CB00133 Seton Fields 14 March 2012 6634 3747 56.48% 3599 148 96.05%

Contact

Email: Angela Morgan

Back to top