Water services - investing in and paying from 2027-2033: equality impact assessment

Equality impact assessment prepared to support the Scottish Government’s development of its statutory inputs into the strategic review of charges for the 2027 to 2033 regulatory period. Namely, the Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging.


Key Findings

The assessment found that no direct differential treatment was identified with regards to two of the PSED’s three needs - eliminating unlawful discrimination and promoting good relations.

Therefore the below summary outlines the impacts with regards to Advancing equality of opportunity.

1. Age

The Water Charges Reduction Scheme (as proxied by CTR recipients) appears to benefit older people disproportionately when compared with the general population. Households where the oldest adult is aged 65 or over account for 36% of CTR recipients, compared with around 25% of the adult population. This suggests that the scheme is reaching a significant number of older households with low incomes and may help older people access financial support to meet essential household costs.

The single person discount is likely to have a positive impact on older adults, particularly those aged 75 and over, as around 65% live in single-adult households. This group is therefore more likely to qualify for and benefit from the discount.

The evidence also suggests a positive impact on younger people, particularly students. More than half (52%) of people aged 16 to 24 are students, compared with 19% of the overall adult population, making younger people more likely to qualify for student-related council tax exemption.

There is some evidence that the over-representation of older people among CTR recipients does not necessarily align with broader measures of deprivation. Consumer Scotland found that pensioners are less likely to experience water poverty, and Family Resources Survey data shows that pensioners are less likely to be in relative poverty after housing costs than the population as a whole. This could suggest that age alone is not a strong indicator of affordability pressures related to water charges.

However, the evidence does not indicate that older people are receiving support because of age itself. Rather, eligibility appears to be associated with lower incomes and entitlement to means-tested benefits. As such, the data does not demonstrate a negative age-related impact arising directly from the policy.

Overall, the evidence suggests that the policies advance equality of opportunity for both older and younger age groups by providing targeted financial support to groups that are more likely to meet eligibility criteria. No evidence has been identified that the policies disadvantage any particular age group, although the relationship between age, income, household composition and affordability is complex.

2. Disability

The available evidence suggests that disabled people are likely to benefit from the Water Charges Reduction Scheme where disability is associated with lower incomes and eligibility for Council Tax Reduction (CTR).

Adults with a limiting long-term physical or mental health condition are substantially more likely to live in single-adult households than those without a limiting condition (57% compared with 35%). This means they are more likely to qualify for and benefit from the single person discount.

No evidence has been identified to suggest that disabled people are directly excluded from, or disadvantaged by, the policy.

People with a limiting long-term physical or mental health condition are less likely to be students than the population as a whole (4% compared with 9%), which may reduce their likelihood of qualifying for student related council tax excemption.

However, disability is strongly associated with age, and younger people are both more likely to be students and less likely to report limiting health conditions. As a result, the difference in eligibility is likely to reflect age-related demographic patterns rather than a direct impact of disability.

Available data on disability amongst CTR recipients is limited to proxy indicators, such as receipt of disability-related benefits, which is noted as an evidence gap.

Overall, the evidence suggests a neutral to positive impact on advancing equality of opportunity for disabled people. Disabled adults appear more likely to benefit from the single person discount due to higher rates of single occupancy, and many disabled households are likely to benefit from income-related support schemes. No direct adverse impacts have been identified.

3. Sex

CTR data suggests that women are more likely than men to be in receipt of support. This is particularly evident among older women living alone and female-headed lone parent households, both of which are groups that may be more likely to experience lower incomes and therefore benefit from income-related support.

Women are slightly more likely than men to live in a single-adult household (44% compared with 40%), indicating that women are more likely to qualify for and benefit from the single person discount.

The evidence therefore suggests that these policies may provide particular support to women where they are disproportionately represented in household types that are more likely to qualify for assistance.

Analysis of Census data found no material difference between males and females in the likelihood of being students (8% of males and 9% of females), suggesting no significant difference in access to student-related council tax exemption.

The higher proportion of women among CTR recipients appears to reflect wider demographic and socioeconomic patterns, such as women being more likely to live alone in later life and to head lone parent households, rather than differential treatment within the scheme.

No evidence has been identified that men are disadvantaged by the policies or that either sex faces barriers to accessing support.

Overall, the evidence suggests a neutral to positive impact on advancing equality of opportunity in relation to sex. Women appear more likely to benefit from both CTR-linked support and the single person discount because they are more likely to belong to household types that meet the eligibility criteria.

4. Race

Some ethnic minority groups appear more likely to benefit from the student discount. Census data shows that 26% of individuals from certain ethnic minority groups are students, compared with 9% of the overall population aged 16 and over. This suggests that the discount may have a positive impact for these groups, as they are more likely to meet the eligibility criteria associated with student status.

However, the evidence indicates that this relationship is strongly linked to age, as these ethnic groups tend to have younger age profiles than the population as a whole. Analysis of single-adult households suggests that adults reporting their ethnic group as White: Scottish are generally more likely to receive the single person discount than adults in most other ethnic groups. This may indicate lower levels of eligibility among some ethnic minority groups. However, differences in eligibility are likely to reflect broader demographic factors, including differences in age structure and household composition, rather than ethnicity itself.

Overall, the available evidence suggests a mixed but largely neutral impact on advancing equality of opportunity in relation to race. The evidence does not indicate that the policies directly advantage or disadvantage any ethnic group. Data on the ethnicity of Council Tax Reduction recipients is incomplete which limits the ability to assess impacts fully.

5. Religion or Belief

Census evidence suggests that individuals reporting belonging to certain minority religions are more likely to be students and therefore more likely to benefit from council tax exemption. Nineteen per cent of people in these groups are students, compared with 9% of the overall population aged 16 and over. The evidence therefore indicates a potential positive impact for people belonging to these religions through higher rates of eligibility for student-related discounts. However, these groups also tend to have younger age profiles than the population as a whole. As a result, the higher likelihood of eligibility appears to be linked primarily to age rather than religion or belief itself.

Analysis of household composition indicates that adults reporting their religion as Church of Scotland are more likely than most other religious groups to live in a single-adult household and therefore more likely to receive the single person discount. This suggests that people belonging to other religious groups may be less likely to qualify for the discount through this route. However, the observed differences are likely to reflect broader demographic factors, particularly differences in age profiles and household composition, rather than any direct effect of religion or belief.

Overall, the evidence suggests a largely neutral impact on advancing equality of opportunity in relation to religion or belief. The available evidence does not indicate that the policies directly advantage or disadvantage any religious group. However, the absence of data on the religion of CTR recipients represents an evidence gap.

6. Sexual Orientation

Analysis of SSCQ data shows that around 44% of adults who report their sexual orientation as LGB+ live in a single adult household, which is similar to the corresponding proportion of heterosexuals (41%). This difference was not found to be statistically significant. Data gaps were identified with respect to this protected characteristic when reviewing CTR and Census data, so no further analysis was undertaken.

7. Gender reassignment and Pregnancy and Maternity

No available data with regards to these protected characteristics was identified to allow robust analysis and are noted as an evidence gap.

Contact

Email: waterindustry@gov.scot

Back to top