Water services - investing in and paying from 2027-2033: child rights and wellbeing impact assessment
Child rights and wellbeing impact assessment prepared to support the Scottish Government’s development of its statutory inputs into the strategic review of charges for the 2027 to 2033 regulatory period. Namely, the Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging.
Child Rights and Wellbeing Impact Assessment Template
1. Brief Summary
-
Decision of a strategic nature relating to the rights and wellbeing of children
Name the proposal, and describe its overall aims and intended purpose.
The policy proposals aim to ensure the water industry:
-
Supports inclusive economic growth and resilient infrastructure.
-
Maintains high levels of service and customer trust.
-
Keeps charges affordable and fair for households and businesses.
-
Responds effectively to the challenges of climate change and net zero targets.
Scottish Ministers set objectives for Scottish Water (SW) as to the standard of services it provides in its core functions. Scottish Water develops a Business Plan for delivering the Ministerial Objectives for the regulatory period. The Water Industry Commission for Scotland (WICS) then determines the maximum by which SW can increase customer charges over the regulatory period.
The Strategic Review of Charges (SRC) sets the framework for how Scottish Water will deliver services throughout the country and invest in infrastructure over the next regulatory period. The Ministerial Objectives (MO) establish specific outcomes Scottish Water must deliver in the regulatory period 2027-33 and the type of investment activity Scottish Water should be undertaking to enable it to play its part in achieving the long-term Water Sector Vision[1]. These include maintaining the standard of services currently enjoyed by customers, supporting economic growth, and adapting to the challenges of climate change.
The Principles of Charging (PoC) sets out Ministers’ policy approach to how to charge for water and wastewater services, aiming to ensure fairness, transparency, and financial sustainability for customers and Scottish Water alike.
Scottish Water is a publicly owned company accountable to the Scottish Ministers. It is regulated to ensure services are efficient, meet mandatory standards and operate in an environmentally sustainable way. Customers fund the vast majority of these services and ongoing investment through charges collected alongside council tax or through wholesale charges for non-household customers. Plans for water and wastewater services are set in six-year regulatory cycles.
The Scottish Government’s proposed Principles of Charging for the next regulatory period (2027-33) are an evolution of those in the current period. The draft Principles of Charging Statement states that charging should continue to reflect the following five core Principles:
-
Be stable
-
Cover the full costs of providing services to customers
-
Be harmonised across Scotland – i.e. charges are not to vary for similar services to similar people
-
Be cost-reflective – i.e. the charge for water services is limited to the cost of providing the services
-
Be fair, equitable and affordable
The Principles of Charging Statement also sets out detail on implementation including how charges should be levied, that it should cover the costs of drainage, what discounts exist for householders, the presumption that non-households should be metered, and exemption scheme for charitable organisations.
It is important to note that this CRWIA is of Ministers’ policies for the water industry as set out in the Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charges only. As Scottish Ministers are responsible for setting the overall direction through these policies it is pertinent to carry out such an assessment, however is it noted that this assessment does not extend to Scottish Water’s financial business plan nor of WICS’ final determination of the charge cap.
Start date of proposal’s development: April 2024
Start date of CRWIA process: February 2026
2. With reference given to the requirements of the UNCRC (Incorporation) (Scotland) Act 2024, which aspects of
Not all aspects of the proposal are considered to be of relevance to the requirements of the UNCRC and therefore are anticipated to have an overall neutral impact on all other requirements of the convention not listed below.
Those which are considered relevant are outlined below alongside the UNCRC Articles. The full detailed proposals can be found in the main consultation document[2].
The UNCRC Articles and relevant aspects of the proposal are:
Article 24 (Health and Health Services) – Objective 5, Objective 8 and Objective 10
Article 27 (Adequate Standard of Living) – Objective 8 and Objective 10 and Principles of Charging
Article 26 (Social Security) – Principles of Charging
Article 31 (Leisure, play and culture) – Objective 8
Summary of relevant Ministerial Objectives
Objective 5
Drinking Water Quality: Scottish Water must address risks to water quality through investment and operational improvements, conduct system-wide risk assessments, and support efforts to eliminate lead piping.
Objective 8
Environment: Scottish Water must publish and deliver an Improving Urban Waters Routemap, maintain transparency on unsatisfactory discharges, and invest to improve bathing water quality in collaboration with SEPA.
Objective 10
Management of Rainwater and Flood Resilience: Scottish Water must collaborate to implement integrated urban catchment management, reduce sewer flooding and pollution, and create flood-resilient, nature-inclusive communities
Summary of Principles of Charging (PoC)
The PoC is deemed relevant to Article 26 (Social Security) because it affects the affordability measures provided to households needing support with their water charges. The PoC sets out that discounts will be linked to a household’s council tax benefits – including those with low incomes, disability, or a single adult. Whilst these discounts are available to households irrespective of whether there are children, they do ensure that the household’s circumstances are taken into account (Art 26(1)).
The PoC is deemed relevant to Article 27 because the affordability measures set out in the PoC seek to target support to households on low income, which could include children. This is relevant to the primary responsibility that parents have towards securing the conditions of living within their financial capabilities (Art 27(2) & (3)).
3. Please provide a summary of the evidence gathered which will be used to inform your decision-making and the content of the proposal
Evidence from:
Anderson, H.K., Bradley Duthie, A., McDougall, C.W., Quilliam, R.S. and Price, H. (2025) ‘The impact of the cost-of-living crisis on water poverty in Scotland: A lived-experience analysis’, Utilities Policy, 96.
Children & Nature Network (2026) Research Digest: Blue spaces.
Consumer Scotland (2025) Affordability of water and sewerage charges. Available at: https://consumer.scot/publications/affordability-of-water-and-sewerage-charges-html/ (Accessed: 1 July 2026).
Currie, M., Philip, L. and Dowds, G. (2020) Long-term impacts of flooding following the winter 2015/16 flooding in North East Scotland: Summary report. Glasgow: Centre of Expertise for Waters (CREW).
Gascon, M., Zijlema, W., Vert, C., White, M.P. and Nieuwenhuijsen, M.J. (2017) Urban blue spaces and human health: A systematic review and meta-analysis of quantitative studies. International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health, 220(8), pp.1207–1221.
Scottish Government (2015) Mapping flood disadvantage in Scotland: Main report.
Scottish Government (2025) Council tax reduction in Scotland 2024–2025: Supporting documents.
Scottish Government (2025) Poverty and income inequality in Scotland 2022–25: Child poverty summary.
Thomas, R. and Niedzwiedz, C. (2024) Building public health resilience to fluvial flooding in Scotland: Policy brief (CSPF2023_01). Centre of Expertise for Waters (CREW).
Werrity, A., Houston, D., Ball, T., Tavendale, A. and Black, A. (2007) Exploring the social impacts of flood risk and flooding in Scotland. Edinburgh: Scottish Executive Social Research.
World Health Organization (2010) Childhood lead poisoning. Geneva: WHO.
World Health Organization (2021) WHO guideline for clinical management of exposure to lead: Executive summary. Geneva: WHO.
Scottish Government (2026) Water services: investing in and paying from 2027: analysis of consultation responses.
4. Further to the evidence described at ‘3’ have you identified any 'gaps' in evidence which may prevent determination of impact?
N/A
5. Analysis of Evidence
Consultation analysis
It is noted that a consultation was carried out and an analysis of consultation results produced[3]. Due to the nature of the proposal children were not directly invited to respond to the consultation. No respondents directly highlighted a risk to children’s rights. With regards to the principles of charging The Poverty and Inequality Commission highlighted impacts on low income families with respect to the Council Tax method of charging, which may be of relevance. Further evidence with regards to the MOs and PoCs are discussed below.
Objective 5 - Drinking Water Quality
Drinking water may be contaminated by lead through lead pipes or lead fittings in people’s homes (this is the private distribution network that is the responsibility of the property owner) or from the supply pipe/communications pipe that connects to the water main in the street. Houses built before 1970 have a higher chance of having lead pipework.[4]
Children are particularly vulnerable to the adverse effects of lead poisoning[5]. Infants and young children absorb a greater proportion of ingested lead than adults as well as being particularly vulnerable to the neurotoxic effects of lead, which include impaired cognitive and behavioural development that can have life-long impacts[6].
Under Objective 5, Scottish Water must support efforts to eliminate lead piping, therefore given the above evidence this is anticipated to have a positive impact in relation to Article 24.
Objective 8 - Environment
Bathing waters designation by Scottish Ministers aims to protect human health[7]. SEPA are responsible for monitoring bathing water sites in Scotland during the bathing season and annually will classify each site as excellent, good, sufficient or poor. This helps people make informed choices on where and when to bathe, including families.
The classifications used by SEPA defined in The Bathing Waters (Scotland) Regulations 2008[8] and are based on the presence and concentration of Faecal Indicator Organisms which can cause gastro-intestinal illness. Improving bathing water quality means there is a lesser chance of becoming ill from bathing water and better protection of public health. This in turn may improve public confidence and children's access to the outdoors and opportunity to enjoy blue spaces. Access to blue spaces in some studies for both adults and children has shown beneficial effects on obesity, all-cause mortality, general health, and self-reported mental health and well-being[9]. A number of studies focussed on children summarise the well-being and social benefits of blue space recreation specifically, including bathing[10].
Under Objective 8, Scottish Water must implement measures to prevent deterioration in bathing water quality due to its assets, or improve this where minimum standards are not met due to its assets. Therefore given the above evidence this is anticipated to have a positive impact for children in relation to Articles 24 and 31.
Objective 10 - Management of Rainwater and Flood Resilience
Research identifies children and young people as among the groups most vulnerable to flooding, alongside elderly people, those living alone, and those dealing with pre existing stressful life events or medical conditions[11]. In the UK, the greatest impact from flooding is on mental health, though it can have a wide range of impacts, including short, medium and long-term effects on wellbeing, relationships and physical and mental health[12]. A small number of Scottish-based studies have investigated the impacts of flooding on people and communities. One of the earliest studies found that flooding impacts directly on both physical and psychological health, with a strong interaction between the two[13].
The Scottish Government’s 2015 report, Mapping Flood Disadvantage in Scotland, highlighted research indicating that flooding has been associated with increased mental health and behavioural problems in children, that cold or damp houses can increase the incidence of minor illnesses and exacerbate the severity of others in children, and that both older people and children have been found to suffer considerable psychological trauma following flood events[14].
Under Objective 10 Scottish Water must collaborate to implement integrated urban catchment management, reduce sewer flooding and pollution, and create flood-resilient, nature-inclusive communities which, given the above evidence, is anticipated to have a positive impact in relation to Articles 24 and 27.
Ministerial Objectives as a whole
Scottish Government published statistics on poverty and income inequality informed by data from the Family Resources Survey shows that 21% of children (210,000 children each year) were living in relative poverty after housing costs (2022-25). Before housing costs, the rate was 19% of children (180,000 children each year).[15]
Key takeaways from the report note that:
‘While the risk of being in poverty is much lower for children where someone in the household is in paid work compared to those in workless households, not all work pays enough to ensure the household income is above the poverty line. Three quarters of children in relative poverty live in a household with someone in paid work.’ and
‘Eleven per cent of children were living in combined low income and material deprivation. This measure is an additional way of measuring living standards and identifies households who cannot afford basic goods and activities that are seen as necessities in society.’
The cost‑of‑living crisis has made it harder for people in Scotland to afford their water bills. Lived-experience analysis using a definition of water poverty as ‘occurring when a household self-reported that they struggled to afford their water bill over the last year’ found that that 18% of respondents said they had struggled to afford their water bill. The survey also showed that while people often keep paying their water bill it may cause financial pressures to be shifted to other household expenses and that younger adults (especially 18–25) were more likely to struggle[16].
While the Scottish Ministers are not directly responsible for setting charges, it is recognised that they are responsible for setting the overall direction through the Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charges. This process sets the direction on which ultimately Scottish Water develops their business plan, and is on the basis which WICS determine how much customer charges may increase by. WICS published the draft determination on Tuesday 30 June 2026 which would allow Scottish Water to increase customer charges by on average two percentage points above inflation (CPI + 2%) in each of the next six years (CPI + 12.6% over the period).[17]
Consumer Scotland have highlighted that the projected rate of water poverty is proportional to the extent of the charge increases and in their 2025 report, noted that ‘...by 2029-2030 we estimate water poverty to reach between 12% and almost 15%, depending on whether charges increase by 2% or 5% per annum in real terms, respectively’. This is an increase from 2025-2026 where estimates are 10.1% of households.[18]
It is therefore reasonable to consider that the expectations set within the Ministerial Objectives as a whole and resultant investment required by Scottish Water may have a negative impact on children in households whose water and wastewater charges will increase, particularly those living in relative poverty and water poverty. While there is a negative impact identified with respect to the MOs, the proposal must be considered as a whole package and therefore the mitigations contained within the principles of charging are set out below in order to assess the overall impact.
Principles of Charging – Principle 3 and Affordability Support
The Scottish Government recognises that a number of customers face difficulty in paying their water bills and proposes to continue the range of support measures which have been part of the charging framework for many years. This includes the Water Charges Reduction Scheme (WCRS) which remains the means by which the water industry supports those customers least able to pay water and sewerage charges. The WCRS applies an up to 35% discount to low income households, passported on and proportionate to their Council Tax Reduction.
Scottish Government published statistics on Council Tax Reduction in Scotland provide a breakdown of CTR recipients by age group, family type and gender[19]. Statistics from March 2025 identify 101,240 households (single and couples) who are in receipt of CTR and have child dependents.
Furthermore, the Water Industry (Scotland) Act 2002 s29D requires harmonisation of charges for the same service. This is embodied in the PoC principle 3 that ensures that charges apply uniformly across all of Scotland, such that the charges do not vary by location. While the cost to Scottish Water to provide services in rural areas is higher, Principle 3 ensures that families living in rural areas are not disproportionally disadvantaged by higher chargers for the same service. Scottish Water produces a Scheme of Charges that sets out the charges with reference to council tax bandings that apply across the whole of Scotland.
By maintaining the amount of support given to families with children via entitlement to WCRS through Council Tax Reduction, the overall income of the household will be maintained more effectively than if there were no affordability support measures, thereby having a positive impact in relation to Article 26 and 27.
In summary the resultant draft charge determination by WICS, although not the direct responsibility of the Scottish Ministers, is derived from the proposals and is likely to increase water poverty rates, as evidenced by Consumer Scotland. The proposals therefore may have a negative impact on children living in households experiencing water poverty. This is however, considered in combination with the positive impact of the harmonised charging principle and affordability support measures, which work to target low income households as defined by CTR eligibility.
Therefore on balance and when considering the proposal as a whole package, the impact of both the MOs and PoCs on Article 26 and 27 is deemed to be neutral.
6. What changes (if any) have been made to the proposal as a result of this assessment?
No changes have been made as a result of this assessment. The Ministerial Objectives and Principles of Charging are an evolution of existing policy and will be reviewed for the next regulatory period.
Contact
Email: waterindustry@gov.scot