The impacts of migrants and migration into Scotland

Aims to summarise and evaluate the recent literature on the impacts of migrants and migration into Scotland.


Ager, A and Strang, A (2004) Indicators of integration: final report, London: Home Office

Anderson, B and Blinder, S (2015) Who counts as a migrant? Definitions and their consequences, Migration Observatory, Briefing, 25/08/15

Bell, D, Findlay, A McCollum, D, and Wright, R (2014) Labour migration policy and constitutional change in Scotland, Oxford Review of Economic Policy, Volume 30, no 2, 2014, 310-324

Bell, B and Machin, S (2013) Immigration and crime: evidence for the UK and other countries, Migration Observatory, Briefing, 13/11/13

Bell, B, Fasani, F and Machin, S (2013) Crime and immigration: evidence from large immigrant waves, The Review of Economics and Statistics, 95 (4) 1278-1290

Bell, B and Machin, S (2011) The impact of migration on crime and victimisation, LSE consulting, December 2011

Blinder, S (2014) Immigration and Independence: Public Opinion on Immigration in Scotland in the Context of the Referendum Debate, Migration Observatory, Briefing, 10/2/2014

Blinder, S, Ruhs, M and Vargas-Silva, C (2011) Top ten problems in the evidence base for public debate and policy-making on immigration in the UK, Migration Observatory Report, 5/4/2011

Boswell, C, Stiller, S and Straubhaar, T (2004) Forecasting labour and skills shortages: how can projections better inform labour migration policies? Paper prepared for the European Commission, DG Employment and Social Affairs, July 2004

Bray, J, Gorman, D, Dundas, K, and Sim, J (2010) Obstetric care of new European migrants in Scotland: an audit of antenatal care, obstetric outcomes and communication, Scottish Medical Journal, 55:3, 26-31

Chappell, L, Sriskandarajah, D and Swinburn, T (2008) Building a new home: migration in the UK construction sector, Institute for Public Policy Research, December 2008

De Lima, P (2012) Boundary crossings: migration, belonging/'un-belonging' in rural Scotland, in Hedberg, C and do Carmo, R (eds) Translocal ruralism: mobility and connectivity in European rural space, New York, Springer

De Lima, P and Wright, S (2009) Welcoming migrants? Migrant labour in rural Scotland, Social Policy and Society, 8:3, 391-404

Department for Business Innovation and Skills (2015) The impacts of migrant workers on UK businesses, BIS Research Paper No. 217, February 2015

Department for Work and Pensions (2015) Benefit claims by EEA nationals, November 2015

Devlin, C, Bolt, O, Patel, D, Harding, D and Hussain, I (2014) Impacts of migration on UK native employment: an analytical review of the evidence, Home Office, Department for Business Innovation and Skills, March 2014

Drinkwater, S and Robinson, C (2013) Welfare participation by immigrants in the UK, International Journal of Manpower, Vol 34, Issue 2, 100-112

Duffy, B and Frere-Smith, T (2014) Perceptions and reality: public attitudes to immigration, Ipsos Mori Social Research Institute, January 2014

Dustmann, C and Frattini, T (2014) The fiscal effects of immigration to the UK, The Economic Journal, Vol 124, Issue 580, F593-F643

Dustmann, C and Frattini, T (2013) The fiscal effects of immigration to the UK, Centre for the Research and Analysis of Migration, Discussion Paper Series, CDP 22/13.

Dustmann, C and Frattini, T (2011) The impact of migration on the provision of UK public services, Migration Advisory Committee, December 2011

Dustmann, C, Frattini, T and Halls, C (2010) Assessing the fiscal costs and benefits of A8 migration to the UK, Fiscal Studies, Volume 31, no 1, 1-41

Dustmann, C, Frattini, T and Preston, I (2008) The effect of immigration along the distribution of wages, CReAM discussion paper series 0803, Centre for Research and Analysis of Migration ( CReAM), Department of Economics, University College London.

Dustmann, C, Fabbri, F and Preston I (2005) The impact of immigration on the UK labour market, CReAM discussion paper series 01/05, Centre for Research and Analysis of Migration ( CReAM), Department of Economics, University College London.

Findlay, A, Geddes, A and McCollum, D (2010) International migration and recession, Scottish Geographical Journal, 126:4, 299-320

George, A, Meadows, P, Metcalf, H and Rolfe, H (2011) Impact of migration on the consumption of education and children's services and the consumption of health services, social care and social services, NIESR, December 2011

Goodhart, D (2004) Is Britain becoming too diverse to sustain the mutual obligations behind a good society and the welfare state? Prospect Magazine, February 2004

HM Revenue and Customs (2016) Statistics on recently arrived non- UK EEA nationals subject to income tax and National Insurance contributions or receiving HMRC administered benefits, May 2016

Institute for Public Policy Research (2014) A fair deal on migration for the UK, March 2014

Kay, R and Morrison, A (2012) Evidencing the Social and Cultural Benefits and Costs of Migration in Scotland, University of Glasgow, Centre for Russian, Central and East European Studies, COSLA Strategic Migration Partnership

Kearns, A and Whitley, E (2015) Getting there? The effects of functional factors, time and place on the social integration of migrants, Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 41:13, 2015-2129

Lemos, S and Portes, J (2008) New labour? The impact of migration from Central and Eastern European Countries on the UK labour market, Discussion Paper no. 3756, University of Leicester.

Lisenkova, K and Sanchez-Martinez, M (2016) The long-term macroeconomic effects of lower migration to the UK, NIESR Discussion Paper No. 460, 24 May 2016.

Lucchino, P, Rosazza-Bondibene, C and Portes, J (2012) Examining the relationship between immigration and unemployment using national insurance registration data, NIESR Discussion Paper No 386

Manacorda, M, Manning, A and Wadsworth, J (2012) The impact of immigration on the structure of wages: theory and evidence from Britain, Journal of the European Economic Association, 10 (1) 120-151

McCollum, D, Tindal, S and Findlay, A (2015) The political economy of immigration policy: the example of Scotland, Centre for Population Change, Working paper 58, January 2015.

McCollum, D, Nowok, B and Tindal, S (2014) Public attitudes towards migration in Scotland: exceptionality and possible policy implications, Scottish Affairs, 23:1, 79-102

McGhee, D, Heath, S and Trevena, P (2013) Post-accession migrants - their experiences of living in 'low demand' social housing areas in Glasgow, Environment and Planning, 2013, 45, 329-343

Metcalf, D (2016) Work immigration and the labour market: incorporating the role of the Migration Advisory Committee, July 2016

Migration Advisory Committee (2014) Migrants in low-skilled work, Summary Report, July 2014

Migration Advisory Committee (2012) Analysis of the Impacts of Migration, January 2012

Migration Watch UK (2014) An assessment of the fiscal effects of immigration to the UK, 13 March 2014

Moskal, M (2016a) Language and cultural capital in school experience of Polish children in Scotland, Race, Ethnicity and Education, 19:1, 141-160

Moskal, M (2016b) Spaces of not belonging: inclusive nationalism and education in Scotland, Scottish Geographical Journal, 132:1, 85-102

Moskal, M (2014) Polish migrant youth in Scottish schools: conflicted identity and family capital, Journal of Youth Studies, Vol 17, No 2, 279-291

Moskal, M (2013) Circulating capitals between Poland and Scotland: a transnational perspective on European labour mobility, International Migration and Integration, 14: 363-379

NatCen (2015) The benefits of random sampling: lessons from the 2015 UK general election

Nathan, M (2011) The long term impacts of migration in British cities: diversity, wages, employment and prices, SERC Discussion Paper 67

Nickell, S and Saleheen, J (2008) The impact of immigration on occupational wages: evidence from Britain. Working Paper No 08-6, Federal Reserve Bank of Boston

OECD Policy Brief, Matching economic migration with labour market needs in Europe, September 2014

OECD Policy Brief, The fiscal and economic impact of migration, May 2014

OECD Migration Policy Debates, Is migration good for the economy? May 2014

Office for National Statistics (2010) Standard Occupational Classification 2010, Volume 1: structure and descriptions of unit groups, Palgrave Macmillan

Portes, A and Vickstrom, E (2011) Diversity, social capital, and cohesion, Annual Review of Sociology, Vol 37, 461-479, August 2011

Portes, A and Zhou, M (1993) The new second generation: segmented assimilation and its variants, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, Vol 530, Interminority Affairs in the US: Pluralism at the Crossroads, November 1993, 74-96

Pouliakas, K, Roberts, D, Balamou, E and Psaltopoulos, D (2012) Modelling the effects of immigration on regional economic performance and wage distribution: a computable general equilibrium ( CGE) analysis of three European Union regions, Regional Studies, 48:2, 318-338

Putnam, R (2007) E Pluribus unum: diversity and community in the twenty-first century, Scandinavian Political Studies, Vol 30, Issue 2, 137-174, June 2007

Reed, H and Latorre, M (2009) The economic impacts of migration on the UK labour market, IPPR Economics of Migration Working Paper 3, Institute for Public Policy Research, London

Rienzo, C (2015) Migrants in the UK labour market: an overview, Migration Observatory, Briefing, 9/11/2015

Rolfe, H and Metcalf, H (2009) Recent migration into Scotland: the evidence base, Scottish Government

Rowthorn, R (2014) Large-scale immigration: its economic and demographic consequences for the UK, Civitas, August 2014

Rudiger, A and Spencer, S (2003) Social integration of migrants and ethnic minorities: policies to combat discrimination, OECD

Ruhs, M and Vargas-Silva, C (2015) The labour market effects of immigration, Migration Observatory Briefing, 22/05/2015

Saggar, S, Somerville, W, Ford, R and Sobolewska, M (2012) The impacts of migration on social cohesion and integration, Final report to the Migration Advisory Committee, January 2012

Saleheen, J and Shadforth, C (2006) The economic characteristics of immigrants and their impact on supply, Quarterly Bulletin Research and Analysis, 2006, Q4

Scottish Government (2016a) Characteristics of migrants in Scotland: analysis of the 2011 Census (forthcoming)

Scottish Government (2016b) Scottish Social Attitudes 2015: attitudes to discrimination and positive action, September 2016

Scottish Government (2015a) Scotland's Economic Strategy, March 2015

Scottish Government (2013) Scotland's Future, November 2013

Scottish Parliament Equal Opportunities Committee (2010) Fifth official report: Inquiry into migration and trafficking

Shubin, S (2012) Living on the move: mobility, religion and exclusion of Eastern European migrants in rural Scotland, Population, Space and Place, 18, 615-627

Shubin, S and Dickey, H (2013) Integration and mobility of Eastern European migrants in Scotland, Environment and Planning, 45, 2959-2979

Sime, D (2014) 'I think that Polish doctors are better': newly arrived migrant children & their parents' experiences and views of health services in Scotland, Health and Place, 30, 86-93

Sime, D and Fox, R (2015) Migrant children, social capital and access to services post migration: transitions, negotiations ad complex agencies, Children and Society, 29:6, 524-534, November 2015

Spencer, S (2006) Social integration of migrants in Europe: a review of the European literature 2000-2006, COMPAS, 28 September 2006

Spreckelsen, T and Seeleib-Kaiser, M (2016) Dimensions of labour market integration among young EU migrant citizens in the UK, Barnett Papers in Social Research, Department of Social Policy and Intervention, University of Oxford, Working Paper 16-01, February 2016

Springford, J (2013) Is immigration a reason for Britain to leave the EU? Centre for European Reform, October 2013

Sumption, M and Altorjai, S (2016) EU migration, welfare benefits and EU membership, Migration Observatory Report, 04/05/16

The Question Bank (2007) Methods of data collection in social surveys, Factsheet 2, Department of Sociology, University of Surrey

Tindal, S, Findlay, A and Wright, R (2014) The changing significance of EU and international students' participation in Scottish higher education, Centre for Population Change, Working paper 49, May 2014

Tindal, S, McCollum D and Bell, D (2014) Immigration policy and constitutional change: the perspectives of Scottish employers and industry representatives, Centre for Population Change, Working paper 44, February 2014

Trzebiatowska, M (2010) The advent of the 'EasyJet Priest': dilemmas of Polish Catholic integration in the UK, Sociology, Volume 44(6): 1055-1072

TUC (2007) The economics of migration: managing the impacts, Economic and Social Affairs, June 2007

Vargas-Silva, C (2015a) The Fiscal Impact of Immigration in the UK, Migration Observatory, Briefing, 27/03/15

Vargas-Silva, C (2015b) Migrants and Housing in the UK: Experiences and Impacts, Migration Observatory, Briefing, 21/09/15

Vargas-Silva, C (2013) Migrants in the Scottish Labour Market, Migration Observatory, Briefing, 18/09/13

Vergunst, P (2009) Whose socialisation? Exploring the social interaction between migrants and communities-of-place in rural areas, Population, Space, Place, 15, 253-266

Wadsworth, J, Dhingra, S, Ottaviano, G and Van Reenen, J (2016) Brexit and the impact of immigration on the UK, Centre for Economic Performance, Paper BREXIT05.

Wadsworth, J (2015) Immigration and the UK labour market, Centre for Economic Performance Election Analyses Series, Paper EA019, February 2015

Weishaar, H (2008) Consequences of international migration: a qualitative study on stress among Polish migrant workers in Scotland, Public Health, 122, 1250-56

Whitehead, C, Edge, A, Gordon, I, Scanlon, K and Travers, T (2011) The impact of migration on access to housing and the housing market, LSE London, December 2011

Xie, Y and Greenman, E (2005) Segmented assimilation theory: a reformulation and empirical test, Population Studies Centre, Research Report No. 05-581, August 2005


Back to top