iMatter Health & Social Care Staff Experience Survey 2026

Independent report by Webropol providing detailed information and analysis of staff experience in health and social care across Scotland. This report contains data from the 2026 iMatter survey.


Appendix 4: Impact of Wording Change

Within the introduction to the ‘My Organisation’ section there have been changes to wording both in 2026 and previously in 2021. This section summarises the changes made and the impact they have had on the response data.

As no prior testing was done or a control group run using previous wording this year, it is not possible to categorically quantify the impact of the change on the data. The impact can be inferred by comparing within subsets of staff (Boards, Staff Groupings etc.) and by comparison to other components within the iMatter data.

Background

Between 2019 and 2021 the wording changed for:

  • ‘I have confidence and trust in senior managers responsible for the wider organisation’ changed to ‘I have confidence and trust in Board members who are responsible for my organisation’
  • ‘I feel senior managers responsible for the wider organisation are sufficiently visible’ changed to ‘I feel that Board members who are responsible for my organisation are sufficiently visible’

In 2026 two changes were made:

  • An additional sentence was added to the introduction to the ‘My Organisation’: “Senior Leaders refers to individuals at Director level or equivalent who have strategic responsibility for your work area.
  • “I feel that Board Members who are responsible for my organisation are sufficiently visible” was changed to “I feel that Senior Leaders who are responsible for my organisation are sufficiently accessible”.

Data Movements

On the two occasions that the wording within this section changed, other measures within the survey, typically either did not change or moved by plus or minus 1 pt.

  • When the wording changed from senior managers to Board Members in 2021 the rating for “I feel senior managers/Board Members responsible for the wider/my organisation are sufficiently visible” declined by 7 pts. When it changed to Senior Leaders in 2026 and with the additional introductory sentence, the component score increased by 11pts.
  • When the wording changed from senior managers to Board Members in 2021 the rating for “I have confidence and trust in senior managers/Board Members responsible for the wider/my organisation” declined by 3 pts. With the introduction of the additional sentence in the introduction to the section in 2026, this component increased by 3 pts
My Organisation I have confidence and trust in senior managers/Board Members responsible for the wider/my organisation Movement from previous iMatter survey I feel senior managers/Board Members/Senior Leaders responsible for the wider/my organisation are sufficiently visible/accessible Movement from previous iMatter survey
2017 64 - 62 -
2018 65 1 62 0
2019 64 -1 62 0
2021 61 -3 55 -7
2022 61 0 55 0
2023 61 0 56 1
2024 60 -1 55 -1
2025 60 0 56 1
2026 63 3 67 11

Board Data

At Individual Board level there is some inconsistency in the extent to which the score for “I feel that Senior Leaders who are responsible for my organisation are sufficiently accessible” has moved in 2026.

Fifteen of the Boards have moved by 10, 11 or 12 pts so are in line with the overall Health and Social Care movement. NHS Golden Jubilee has improved by 13 pts, suggesting that additional activity in that Board may be driving relative improvements as well as the increase driven by the wording change.

Of the remaining Boards:

  • NHS Borders and The State Hospital increased by 7pts
  • NHS Orkney and NHS Education for Scotland increased by 4 pts
  • Public Health Scotland increased by 2 pts
  • Healthcare Improvement Scotland increased by only 1 pt.

The reasons for these lower movements cannot be fully explained, but there are several possible influences:

  • Where Boards are smaller there may be less differentiation in understanding of ‘Senior Leaders’ and ‘Board Members’. The six Boards with much lower increases in scores are among the ten smallest Boards, with NHS Orkney, The State Hospital and Healthcare Improvement Scotland the three smallest.
  • Where Boards have flatter organisation structures, or a greater proportion of more senior staff there may be less differentiation between ‘Senior Leaders’ and ‘Board Members’.
  • There does not appear to be a link between the absolute score and the level of movement.
  • It may be that without the question wording change these Boards may have seen a decline in this component score.
Board Score Movement 2025 to 2026
Health & Social Care 67 11
NHS Ayrshire & Arran 67 10
NHS Borders 66 7
NHS Dumfries & Galloway 63 10
NHS Fife 67 12
NHS Forth Valley 66 12
NHS Grampian 67 12
NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde 67 12
NHS Highland 64 10
NHS Lanarkshire 69 11
NHS Lothian 68 12
NHS Orkney 65 4
NHS Shetland 71 10
NHS Tayside 66 11
NHS Western Isles 64 10
Healthcare Improvement Scotland 69 1
NHS Education for Scotland 79 4
NHS National Services Scotland 70 10
Public Health Scotland 73 2
NHS 24 68 11
NHS Golden Jubilee 68 13
Scottish Ambulance Service 56 12
The State Hospital 60 7

Staff Grouping Data

Within the Staff Groupings, the wording change has led to an increase of 14 points among Local Authority staff and 10 points among NHSScotland staff. This means that where the scores were the same in 2025 there are now 4 pts between Local Authority and NHSScotland staff.

I feel Board Members are responsible for the wider organisation and are sufficiently visible 2025 2026 Movement from 2025 to 2026
Local Authority 56 70 14
Adult Services 55 70 15
Business Services 61 70 9
Children's Services 56 73 17
Criminal Justice 55 71 16
Older People Services 56 69 13
Senior Managers 74 86 12
Strategic Development 64 77 13
NHSScotland 56 66 10
Admin services 59 68 9
Allied Health 55 64 9
Ambulance Services 43 55 12
Health Science Services 53 61 8
Medical and Dental 55 66 11
Medical and Dental Support 57 70 13
Nursing and Midwifery 54 66 12
Other Therapeutic 57 66 9
Personal and Social Care 60 74 14
Senior Managers 71 78 7
Support Services 59 69 10

The largest increases in scores are in Children’s Services (+17 pts) and Criminal Justice (+16 pts), both Local Authority staff groupings. The smallest increases are in Senior Managers (+7 pts) and Health Science Services (+8 pts), both NHSScotland staff groupings.

Demographics

Across the various demographic characteristics, the differences between 2025 and 2026 range from +9 pts to +13 pts.

I feel Board Members are responsible for the wider organisation and are sufficiently visible 2025 2026 Movement from 2025 to 2026
Under 25 62 74 12
25-34 56 67 11
35-44 58 68 10
45-54 57 68 11
55-64 56 68 12
65 and over 58 71 13
Female 57 68 11
Male 56 68 12
Disability Yes 52 63 11
Disabilty No 57 67 10
White 56 67 11
Mixed or multiple ethnic groups 56 67 11
Asian, Scottish Asian or British Asian 69 78 9
African, Scottish African or British African 70 79 9
Caribbean or Black 60 71 11
Other ethnic group 62 70 8

Return to Main Report

Contact

Email: nationalimatterteam@gov.scot

Back to top