Publication - Consultation analysis
Digital Scotland – Reaching 100% Programme: public consultation report
Scottish Government responses to the consultation into the eligible intervention area for investment of public funds into NGA broadband infrastructure.
Appendix A – Public Consultation Response
| Response | Responder | Comment | Resultant Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Charlie Anderson | Query re whether R100 will address slow speeds in Ky8 5NZ and surrounding postcodes | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 2 | Balquhidder Community Broadband CIC | Actively engaged in a project to deliver hyper-fast broadband to several NGA White post code areas | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – intervention area changed |
| 3 | Fibrecast Ltd | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 4 | Sianna MacDonald | Superfast Broadband query on individual premises | Advice provided –intervention area changed |
| 5 | GreySky Consulting Ltd | Working with Stirling Council to identify un-served 'white' premises | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 6 | Angus Council | Angus Council are currently considering a submission to the consultation | Advice provided and follow up stakeholder meeting offered – no change to intervention area |
| 7 | Gigaclear | Request to share the draft intervention area | Draft NGA White premise information shared – no change to intervention area |
| 8 | Marykirk.com | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 9 | Applecross Community Company | Request for OS maps for the area served by AppleNet | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 10 | Donnchadh Kennedy | Concern about countryside coverage near Kilbrinie | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 11 | Tree of Life Enterprises | Feedback that data on basic broadband map is incorrect for PA28 6QR | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 12 | Charlie Anderson | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 13 | Alvah and Forglen Community Council | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 14 | Badenoch Broadband & Comms. | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 15 | Highland Community Broadband CIC | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 16 | HUBS | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 17 | CMNet CIC | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 18 | Len Chapman | Raised query on classification for the village of Cousland, Midlothian | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 19 | Confidential Response 1 | Confidential Response 1 | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 20 | Sleat Community Trust | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 21 | Loch Tay Internet | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 22 | Heather Hill | Highlighting issue of slow speeds in the Lowther Hills area | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 23 | Scottish Borders Council | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 24 | Fife Voluntary Action | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 25 | Scotnet | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – intervention area changed |
| 26 | Ardvourlie Castle | Highlighting slow speeds on the Isle of Harris | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 27 | RCGP Scotland | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 28 | Confidential Response 2 | Confidential Response 2 | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 29 | Colin Jenkins | Looking for clarity on how individual property is affected | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 30 | Scaladale Activity Centre | Concerned that postcode is not on the intervention list | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 31 | Lothian Broadband | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – intervention area changed |
| 32 | Broadway Partners | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 33 | Bob Alexander Landscaping Ltd | Concerned about poor broadband impacting business | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 34 | Penny Cousins | Concerned about poor broadband in area | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 35 | RFCom | Company with Wireless Tech looking to be involved | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 36 | Confidential Response 3 | Confidential Response 3 | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 37 | East Lothian Council | Provided comment on consultation | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 38 | Andrew Dodds | Provided comment on consultation | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 39 | CloudNet | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 40 | South of Scotland Alliance | Provided written response to consultation | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 41 | Tiree Community Development Trust | Raised concern around access to affordable backhaul | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 42 | Independent Networks Co-operative Association | Provided written response to consultation | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 43 | Perth and Kinross Council | Provided written response to consultation | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 44 | Lothian Broadband | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – intervention area changed |
| 45 | Paul & Amanda Russ | Looking for clarity on how property is affected | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 46 | Patricia Tucker | Concern over slow speeds around ML11 8LH | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 47 | Confidential Response 4 | Confidential Response 4 | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – intervention area changed |
| 48 | Andrew Walker | Provided comments on consultation | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 49 | Dick Barbor-Might | Provided written response to consultation | Advice provided – no change to intervention area |
| 50 | Linlithgow Mill Road BID | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – no change to intervention area |
| 51 | Cromarty Firth Wireless Networks | Confirm intention to respond to the Public Consultation | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – intervention area changed |
| 52 | Confidential Response 5 | Confidential Response 5 | Invited to submit information for ' NGA Assessment' – intervention area changed |