Private rented sector - minimum energy efficiency standard: consultation analysis
Analysis of the responses received to the Scottish Government's consultation on proposals for a Minimum Energy Efficiency Standard in the private rented sector.
Main Findings
The Minimum Standard
The consultation paper noted that the new EPCs will provide three headline ratings:
- Heat Retention Rating (HRR) – which demonstrates the performance of the building’s fabric (i.e. how well the building retains heat due to insulation and other factors).
- Energy cost rating (ECR) – which will be similar to the Energy Efficiency Rating displayed on existing EPCs. This will be based on the annual costs of running the building to standard conditions, normalised to floor area, and how these costs could change as a result of the potential improvement options.
- Heating System Rating (HSR) – which will show whether the installed heating system is polluting, hybrid or clean, and its emissions and efficiency.
These ratings will be calculated using standard assumptions about the building’s occupancy, location and climate. This means they will reflect the performance of the building itself, not where it is located or how people use it.
Band C in the HRR will be broadly in line with the fabric performance of homes in band C of the current cost-based rating, with these homes meeting a good level of energy efficiency.To reduce the amount of energy required to maintain a comfortable temperature is most likely to be achieved by improving fabric such as wall, roof, door and floor insulation, and reducing draughts.
All respondents were asked:
Q1: Do you agree that the PRS MEES should be EPC HRR band C?
Overall, just over a third of respondents (35%) agreed the PRS MEES should be EPC HRR band C; 54% disagreed. A majority of organisations (57%) agreed the PRS MEES should be EPC HRR band C, compared to 24% of individuals. When we look at organisation sub-groups, the highest levels of dissent came from landlords / letting agents / property agents where more disagreed (12) than agreed (3) and manufacturers / suppliers / installation where just under half disagreed (6 compared to 7 who agreed).
Respondents were then given the opportunity to provide further commentary in support of their response to question 1, and 259 did so.
Welcome for PRS MEES
Of those respondents commenting, a significant minority welcomed this proposal or noted they agreed with this in principle, and that this would align with net zero goals or with the Social Housing Net Zero Standard specifically. There were differences between individuals and organisations, with the latter showing higher levels of agreement.
Linked to this, a small minority of respondents also noted the importance of ensuring PRS properties are energy efficient as this will help to reduce fuel poverty and reduce energy costs for renters. A few respondents also referred specifically to the need for PRS properties to reach a certain level of energy efficiency equivalent to EPC HRR band C.
Regardless of whether respondents agreed or disagreed with this proposal, a large minority noted concerns over some types of property. Overall, a third of respondents (a quarter of organisations and nearly half the individuals) felt that many rental properties have the wrong type of fabric and / or age and, as such, will not be able to meet the requirement for band C. For example, some responses noted that much of Scotland’s housing stock is traditional solid stone construction for which retrofitting is not perceived to be a feasible option and it would be impractical for landlords to meet band C. Across organisation types, the highest level of concern over this issue came from landlords / letting agents / property agents and local authorities.
Allied to this point, a significant minority of respondents felt it could be too costly for landlords to improve the properties, especially in older properties and tenement blocks. Tenement blocks were seen to be particularly problematic, given the need for any retrofit work to be agreed to by all property owners to achieve full benefit. As noted by an organisation in the environmental / conservation sector;
“It should also be noted that, given two thirds of private rented properties are flats/tenements, there is a need for progress on measures to enable communal works in tenements.”
A representative body noted that as a significant proportion of private rented properties are flats, the Scottish Government should progress with the recommendations of the Tenement Maintenance Group which includes legislative changes to support communal work in mixed tenure buildings.
Disagreement with PRS MEES
A few respondents noted their dislike of the proposal or that there are already too many restrictive standards in place for landlords. They cited other regulations such as rent caps, a ban on evictions or proposed rent controls in the Housing Bill.
A small minority of respondents commented that as the calculation of the HRR has not yet been published, there is no comparison with current market ratings. As such, they requested more information and clarity on the implications of any changes to EPCs.
A small number of respondents noted that fuel poverty is related to energy costs, which are not the responsibility of landlords; that the Scottish Government should work to reduce energy costs.
Negative implications and concerns
Perhaps not surprisingly, given concerns over different property types and a capacity to make changes to these properties to become more energy efficient, a significant minority of respondents noted concerns that any changes are likely to bring about a reduction in rental stock by forcing landlords to leave the rental sector. Small numbers of respondents felt that some landlords might change their properties to become short-term lets as there are currently less onerous regulations in relation to energy efficiency.
A small minority of respondents also noted the removal of properties from PRS would exacerbate the current housing crisis. It was also felt that some homes might be left deliberately vacant if landlords could not afford to make the necessary changes to energy efficiency. A few respondents commented that any upgrades required of landlords could carry significant costs, particularly in older traditional properties. Some of these respondents quoted figures of £10,000 or more. Similarly, a small number of respondents noted that the cost of making any changes would outweigh the benefits and, as such, would not be financially viable for landlords.
Another key concern, expressed by a small minority of respondents was that any changes could lead to a rise in rents as landlords try to offset the costs of any changes they have to make. A few respondents also noted rent increases would undermine fuel poverty as any savings made on the cost of running cheaper heating systems would have to be spent on increased rental costs. A small number of respondents noted the need for protections for tenants against rent increases.
Another concern noted by a small minority of respondents related to where tenants would stay if their rental property could not be inhabited while any energy efficiency work was being undertaken. There were a small number of suggestions that work requiring tenants to move out of a property should only be carried at the end of a tenancy.
Other concerns noted by respondents included:
- A need to consider any unintended consequences; for example, there is a need for adequate levels of ventilation to prevent damp or mould in properties but some energy efficiency measures do not allow for adequate levels of ventilation.
- Damage to the environment caused by property upgrades.
- The proposal will not encourage landlords to move from gas heating systems to less carbon intensive fuel sources such as heat pumps, given the cost of installing a new system and the subsequent cost of using the system. A respondent attending a workshop session noted that some real examples in local authority housing have shown that replacing condenser gas boilers with electric heating increases fuel costs and fuel poverty.
- The potential for conflicts between planning authorities and what energy efficiency measures they are prepared to allow, and any energy efficiency changes required under PRS MEES.
Alternative approaches
In order to counteract some of the concerns noted, some respondents made suggestions for alternative approaches that could be adopted by the Scottish Government.
A significant minority of respondents suggested the introduction of additional metrics, as fabric efficiency is only one component of a home’s energy performance. They commented that the HRR metric does not reflect the full range of measures available to improve energy performance and provides an incomplete picture of the efficiency of a home. Furthermore, this does not prevent landlords from installing carbon-intensive heating systems which are a threat to net zero ambitions. As such, this could lead to unsuitable upgrades in a property.
There were suggestions for a heat retention metric that considers secondary metrics such as heating system efficiency or that will adopt a technology-neutral approach. For example, a representative body suggested the use of a dual metric approach using an HRR which addresses fabric performance, combined with a similar requirement for a Heating System Type Rating (HSTR). These together would give a more complete picture of the efficiency of a home.
A significant minority of respondents suggested that exemptions should be offered, so that a property can be assessed on a set of criteria based on its potential. A smaller number of respondents also suggested each property should be assessed on a case-by-case basis and be dependent on the age of the property. They felt that a more flexible approach would allow landlords to select an appropriate combination of measures, including the EPC metrics of heat retention, energy costs and the heating system.
Linked to these issues, a small minority of respondents suggested that EPC band D would be more appropriate and realistic for older properties. A similar number of respondents called for a wider range of heating alternatives to be considered. These included solar panels and storage technologies. These were felt to be of particular relevance to properties in rural and remote areas where approaches to energy efficiency can be restricted by availability.
Other possible alternative approaches suggested by smaller numbers of respondents included allowing:
- An E rating for more traditional older properties and tenements.
- A longer timeframe than that suggested in the consultation.
Some respondents referred to roles that should be adopted by the Scottish Government if PRS MEES is to be introduced. Concerns over the cost of implementation were noted by some respondents, and some of these suggested that the Scottish Government should provide grants or financial help to landlords, adopting a ‘carrot’ rather than a ‘stick’ approach. While a few respondents referred to the provision of loans, more noted a preference for grants that are easy to access and action. This was because the likely payback time of a loan is too long, particularly if rent controls are put in place.
Alongside the provision of financial help, there were some calls for the Scottish Government to provide other forms of support and guidance that is clear and comprehensive. For example, guidance so landlords are fully aware of what is required of them, to provide answers to frequently asked questions or about unusual situations. Guidance could also signpost landlords to make them aware of what alternatives are available and to ensure packages of measures are designed to prevent unintended consequences, and deliver good indoor air quality.
A small number of respondents felt PRS MEES needs to be considered in conjunction with other upcoming legislative changes such as the Scottish Government’s forthcoming Energy Strategy or Just Transition Plan.
Other comments
Other issues raised by relatively small numbers of respondents included:
- The PRS sector should not be singled out for changes; this should apply to all properties including social, private, new build and commercial, so that standards are aligned across all property types.
- Criticism of EPCs for providing inaccurate information. These were felt to provide useful information when purchasing a property but not be appropriate for use as an enforcement mechanism. They were perceived to be unreliable, lacking in documentation, using standardised assumptions that cannot be applied across the board and taking no account of a property’s thermal envelope.
- Linked to the criticism of EPCs, some respondents criticised the quality of current EPC assessors, for example, some noted that assessors provide inconsistent information or do not always provide documented proof of work that has been undertaken.
- Concerns over capacity within existing supply chains.
- A preference to align this legislation with that of England and Wales to ensure consistency.
- Link this to a HEETSA approach[2].
Demonstrating compliance with existing or reformed EPCs
The consultation paper explained that the Scottish Government is proposing that landlords will be required to meet new EPC HRR band C only, and that a property with an existing EPC band C may not be deemed compliant. It is felt this approach will ensure that the fabric upgrades that need to be made in the PRS will be prioritised. It will also ensure that properties are bought up to a good standard of energy efficiency that future proofs against changes in fuel prices by actually reducing energy demand. It will also ensure that different properties, potentially in the same building, are not able to meet the standard in different ways using the old and new EPC system. It should also allow for simpler monitoring and compliance. Respondents were asked:
Q2: Do you agree that only the new reformed EPCs should be used as a basis for the proposed MEES?
Views were split as to whether the new reformed EPCs should be used as a basis for the proposed MEES; 41% agreed and 41% disagreed. There were higher levels of support from organisations than individuals, with 75 organisations (70%) answering ‘yes’ compared to 55 individuals (26%). Conversely, 113 individuals disagreed (54%), compared to 16 organisations (15%). In terms of organisation sub-groups, highest levels of support came from local authorities and manufacturers / suppliers / installation.
Respondents were then given the opportunity to provide further commentary in support of their response to question 2; 190 did so. To an extent, many of the comments echoed those made at question 1.
Support for new reformed EPCs to be used
The single largest comment, from a significant minority of respondents was support for this proposal, with comments such as it makes sense to consider the structure of a building, that it is essential to drive fabric upgrades to reduce energy demand or this will contribute to reducing fuel poverty and greenhouse gas emissions. A small minority also felt this approach would ensure consistency, accuracy and relevance in assessing building performance.
Concerns with using new reformed EPCs
A key concern, cited by a significant minority of respondents, related to the amount of additional work, expense and bureaucracy this would incur for landlords, with some comments that the costs could be prohibitive. Additionally, there were comments from a small minority of respondents, that some landlords have already made improvements to their properties to bring them up to EPC band C but that these goalposts will now change. This could mean that work already undertaken will be disregarded, effectively penalising these landlords.
Once again, there were some comments related to type of property, with a small minority suggesting there will be some properties that will not be able to reach band C. These included older stone properties and listed properties. There were also references to tenements and communal blocks where it can be difficult to ensure energy efficiency within a single dwelling if neighbouring properties are not also taking energy efficiency measures.
Linked to these issues, there were also some comments that this could exacerbate the current housing crisis as landlords will exit the PRS, or that rents will increase as landlords try to recoup their outgoings.
A few respondents also noted concerns over the quality of staff or assessors who would be responsible for undertaking EPCs and for the inconsistency applied in this at present. It was suggested by some that there is a need to be realistic about the number of rented properties that would require an additional assessment and whether the industry has the capacity and / or skills to meet this. Allied to this, a small minority of respondents felt it would be impractical for all landlords to obtain reformed EPCs in the proposed timescale as this would place too much pressure on the system.
Alternative approaches to using new reformed EPCs
A number of alternative approaches were suggested by respondents that could help to overcome their concerns.
A significant minority of respondents suggested that existing EPCs should be acceptable and remain in place until their expiry date. Similarly, there were some comments that landlords with a current valid EPC band C rating should be considered as being compliant under the new standard, or that the reprofiling of properties should focus on those which do not currently achieve EPC band C.
Allied to this, there were some suggestions for an appropriate transition period as some respondents felt the proposed timescale is too short to cope with the impact of any changes.
Some respondents referred to the metrics it is proposed will be used with the EPC HRR format and outlined some others they would like to see included. For example, there were preferences for a metric that recognises carbon emissions associated with different heating systems; or a metric that can provide actual readings of heat loss through walls. It was felt this would offer a more nuanced approach and more accurately reflect the actual situation in different properties. A few respondents also suggested that alternative technologies should be included, or a higher score should be given to alternative technologies that can help a property to be more energy efficient. Overall, it was felt that what is proposed in the consultation paper will not incentivise adoption of low carbon technologies or protect tenants from volatile energy prices.
A small minority of respondents felt further information is needed on how the current EPC rating will change and compare to the new standard.
There were some calls for the Scottish Government to provide grants or loans to landlords to enable them to undertake the required work. Also, that the Scottish Government should provide guidance and information and ensure there is full understanding and clarity over the proposed system and how it will operate.
Other comments on using new reformed EPCs
Smaller numbers of respondents made other comments. These included:
- Suggestions for a requirement for a new assessment when a tenancy changes hands, particularly as it could be problematic finding alternative accommodation for sitting tenants who are unable to remain in their rented property while work is being undertaken.
- Queries on how this will be monitored and enforced; with a small number of local authorities noting they would need additional resources and capacity if they are to be responsible for enforcement.
- A need for a clear date as to when implementation will be required. Alternatively, a need for flexibility in timelines because if the Home Energy Model, which underpins the reformed EPC, to be introduced by the UK Government is delayed, this would have a direct impact on the workability of the PRS MEES regulations in Scotland.
Backstop date: 2033
The consultation paper noted the need for sufficient time to be provided for the sector to adapt and take necessary action to comply with the new regulations. It proposed that the PRS MEES will apply to all tenancies, unless exempt, by the end of 2033. That means that by the end of 2033, the MEES will apply to all domestic private rented properties, even if there has been no change in tenancy. Respondents were asked:
Q3: Do you agree that the backstop date for all PRS homes to comply with MEES should be 2033?
Overall, a majority (56%) did not agree with this proposal, compared to 29% who did. Responses to this question echoed those seen at question 2 in that higher proportions of organisations (40%) supporting this proposal, than individuals (24%). Conversely, higher proportions (63%) of individuals did not support this proposal, compared to 43% of organisations.
A total of 209 respondents, across all sub-groups, provided commentary in support of their initial response to this question. Most responses cited a variety of caveats and concerns in relation to their initial answer.
Support for the backstop date
A significant minority of respondents, almost all organisations, reiterated their support of 2033 as the backstop, mainly viewing this date as providing enough time for complying and the necessary improvements to be planned and implemented, as well as for local authorities to plan enforcement procedures. Smaller numbers of organisations said the backstop should be no later in order to ensure emissions reduction targets (e.g. 2045 net zero) were met, and to protect tenant wellbeing by erasing fuel poverty.
A small number of organisations added that the PRS has been aware of forthcoming higher MEES for some time, noting that the deadline has already been pushed back from 2028. However, a few organisations viewed 2033 as ambitious and that the deadline should be no earlier than this.
Disagreement with the backstop date
There were a number of calls, mainly from organisations, for the backstop date to be brought forward from 2033, particularly from large majorities of manufacturers, suppliers and installers, environment / conservation groups, renters’ representative bodies and charity / third sector organisations. These respondents felt that the timetable had already slipped and that a target as far away as 2033 would carry the risk of inaction. A sooner date would also put Scotland into line with England and Wales, and align with other initiatives, in particular the Clean Power 2030 target and the Scottish Government’s commitment to ensure that no more than 15% of households are fuel poor by 2030. Additionally, this would align with the new tenancies deadline, and 2030 would directly support progress toward reaching the first Carbon Budget (2026–2030). To this end, most of these respondents recommended a backstop date of 2030.
Among those wanting a delay to the 2033 deadline, the largest numbers (a small minority overall) said more time was needed to prepare for and undertake the necessary works. In particular, it was thought there was not enough time for landlords to save up to fund the necessary alterations; and a very small number said they had too many properties to retrofit in the 8 years allowed.
Slightly smaller numbers wanted a later date for regulatory or legislative reasons. It was pointed out that an EPC given by the expected date for the new EPC target of 2026 lasts 10 years. Additionally, HEETSAs would not be available until 2028 and there was also a dependency on the consultation timings for the forthcoming Housing Bill. Furthermore, allowances need to be made for the time for legislation to be implemented. A similar number of respondents felt there was too much uncertainty for landlords and the supply chain about the requirements and standards needed; for instance changes in RdSAP software assumptions may drop properties by an EPC band.
A variety of later deadlines were suggested, each by very small numbers of respondents, namely 2035, 2036, 2037, 2039, 2040 and 2050. It was felt that some of these later dates would synchronise with net zero targets.
A small minority were against a hard deadline. They had a preference for gradual changes which were seen as being better for managing costs, allowing for flexibility in certain circumstances and preventing a last minute surge in demand which could cause supply chain problems.
Similar numbers were in favour of having a consistent date across all housing tenures, seeing the current proposals as being discriminatory against landlords. Additionally consistency would help to target the scaling up of the supply chain.
Concerns about the backstop date
Around half of the respondents noted issues with the proposals overall. A small minority were concerned that landlords would be driven to sell their properties, amplifying housing shortages due to a lack of rental accommodation. Smaller numbers thought rents would have to increase to pay for retrofits of housing, causing affordability problems for tenants.
Similar numbers were worried about the retrofitting costs themselves. Amid concerns that these would be unaffordable, there were anxieties about costs being driven higher through supply chain shortages and inflation, while rents would be capped at the same time.
A small minority cited concerns over how older homes would be able to comply, with some calls for exemptions. Properties in conservation areas, stone buildings, historic buildings and tenements were quoted as among those types of building where the necessary upgrades were perceived to be impractical. In the case of listed buildings, it was mentioned that regulations may prohibit the work needed.
Around a third of respondents cited provisos regarding the timetable. Chief among these a significant minority of organisations had concerns about the capacity of the supply chain to cope. These respondents were concerned about the availability of accredited and skilled installers and tradesmen and a sufficient supply of materials. There were also particular issues related to landlords leaving changes until the last minute.
In connection with this, a smaller but still significant minority of organisations said that complying by the backstop date depended on the amount and availability of support. This included training needs for the supply chain (with a suggestion to renew the MCS Certification Fund beyond March 2026), and financial support for landlords with the costs of alterations, as well as for local authorities with resources for enforcement. Awareness raising and advice were also cited, as well as the introduction of a Heat & Energy Efficiency Technical Suitability Assessment (HEETSA) to give clarity about the measures needed.
Other possible time constraints were identified as follows, each by a small minority of respondents:
- The length of time for legislation / regulations to be implemented, which could have a knock-on effect on the length of time available for changes to be made between their introduction and the backstop date. For example, regarding the EPC reforms process, the introduction of HEETSA, and the timings of the Home Energy Model (HEM) consultation. One workshop attendee asked how much work had been done to ensure the new SAP Home Energy Model (HEM) does not differ too significantly with Scottish EPCs.
- The speed with which monitoring and enforcement mechanisms are put in place regarding compliance (e.g. training of sufficient numbers of assessors regarding the reformed EPCs).
- The amount of work needed on a property.
- The time needed for landlords to source funds for retrofit work.
Other problems raised by smaller numbers of respondents were as follows:
- Concerns over disturbing tenants, or a need to evict tenants, so that invasive works can be carried out.
- Concerns over unintended retrofit or fabric improvement consequences, such as damp and mould (e.g. through use of insulating foam), poor air quality, and materials having shorter lifespans than those of original materials; and also regarding the quality of work and abilities of tradesmen.
- Concerns over the availability of the required technology, with requests for the government to broaden the list of technologies landlords can use to improve energy efficiency; in particular to recognise the value and efficiency of cost-effective, low-carbon technologies.
- Concerns over the ability of multi–occupancy buildings to comply (i.e. getting all owner occupiers & tenants to agree in mixed tenure flats and other communal blocks).
- Concerns over the ability of rural and island properties to comply, due for instance to a lack of available specialists.
Additionally there were a few calls to scrap the PRS MEES plans, with some comments that the PRS is already overregulated.
In force date and earlier phased action: 2028
The Scottish Government proposed that the PRS MEES will apply to new tenancies from 2028, unless they are exempt. This will mean that from 2028, before any property can be rented to a new tenant, the landlord must have carried out the required energy efficiency improvements which apply to the property, unless exempt, to meet EPC HRR band C. This should help to enable a phased approach to the works that will be required, supporting the gradual development of supply chains and avoid potential last-minute bottlenecks ahead of the proposed backstop date. Respondents were asked:
Q4: Do you agree that the MEES should apply to properties being let to new tenants from 2028?
A majority of respondents (59%) did not agree that the MEES should apply to properties being let to new tenants from 2028 (76% of individuals and 25% of organisations). Within organisations, the highest levels of disagreement came from representative bodies (landlords), those in the landlord / letting agent / property agent sector and finance / banking groups.
Conversely, a higher proportion of organisations were supportive of this proposal (53% compared to 17% of individuals).
227 respondents then provided additional comments in support of their initial response. Most points were very similar to those made at the preceding question.
General support for the 2028 PRS MEES date for new tenancies
A small minority (almost entirely organisations) supported the PRS MEES applying to properties being let to new tenants from 2028 because this would result in a staged approach. It was agreed that a phased rollout would help spread the work and ease bottlenecks for capacity, thereby resulting in a smoother transition. A couple of energy / utility organisations noted this would align with the proposed approach in England and Wales.
A small minority of respondents viewed a change in tenancy as being a convenient time to act, providing an opportunity to undertake other non-energy efficiency related property improvements at the same time.
Other remarks, each made by a few respondents, reflected the same reasons given in support at the previous question: that the 2028 date was a long enough time for improvements to be implemented and enforcement to be planned, that it was needed to help erase fuel poverty and that it was needed to ensure emissions reduction targets were met.
Some respondents offered caveats over this date; and there were four main caveats expressed regarding support for the 2028 date. As before, a small minority, including a majority of representative bodies, had supply chain capacity concerns.
Similar numbers (mostly organisations) felt the ability to meet the date depended on the support provided in terms of training needs, financial support for installation costs, advice services and awareness raising activities.
Thirdly, respondents (including a majority of manufacturers, suppliers and installers), stated that the speed with which the regulations will be implemented would affect the time available for landlords to act prior to 2028. To this end, several respondents urged clarity over the requirements as soon as possible.
Finally, it would depend on how quickly monitoring and enforcement mechanisms could be put in place, including training of assessors regarding the reformed EPC regime so that assessments could be promptly given.
A few respondents saw a need for flexibility in time allowed, for instance in order to make exemption decisions and to raise snags.
Disagreement with the 2028 PRS MEES date for new tenancies
The main reason for disagreeing with the time frame, and cited by a large minority including significant proportions of finance / banking institutions, landlords / letting agents / property agents and local authorities, was that it did not give a long enough period to prepare and do the works needed to comply with the MEES. Respondents noted 2028 was only 3 years away, or that the window for alterations would only be two years if the regulations come into force in 2026.
Fewer respondents (again including significant proportions of finance / banking institutions, landlords / letting agents / property agents and local authorities) thought a later date was required because of the time needed for regulatory implementation before action could be taken. A few respondents specified that there would be insufficient time for landlords to save up to fund the necessary alterations. Related to this, a small minority saw too much uncertainty regarding requirements and measurements for landlords to make decisions.
“We don't even have the new EPCs, how are we to plan and arrange substantial upgrading works around existing tenancies and void periods? It seems very likely that my C rated gas heated tenements will all fail the new EPC requirements, but how can I know?” (Individual)
A small minority of respondents suggested later dates. These included 2030, 2031, 2033 or 2035. Very small numbers were in favour of bringing the date forward from 2028 as they felt urgent action was needed to reduce emissions. Small numbers reiterated their opinions that they did not want a hard deadline, or were in favour of having a consistent date across all PRS properties (whether the tenancy was new or not), or having a consistent date across all properties regardless of tenure.
Concerns over the 2028 PRS MEES date for new tenancies
Around half of the comments cited general concerns about the effects of the proposals. The most frequently mentioned of these, mostly by individuals, was a prediction that landlords would sell their properties in response to the regulations, thereby reducing PRS stock and amplifying housing shortages. Linked to this were concerns of rent increases in response to the predicted PRS shortage and the need to fund works.
A small minority again raised concerns over the affordability of retrofitting costs. There were also a few concerns about properties being empty while works were being undertaken, for instance adding to worries about a reduction in rental housing availability and affecting landlords’ income with which to fund alterations. A couple of individuals made a point about the PRS notice to leave period given by tenants to landlords being only 28 days, giving little time for them to react and plan works.
A small minority repeated concerns over the ability of older properties to comply with PRS MEES, in particular citing consent issues regarding windows and insulation in listed buildings. Small numbers also referred to difficulties in getting multi-occupancy buildings and rural properties to comply. Concerns were also repeated about unintended fabric improvement consequences and work quality.
Tenancies in scope
The consultation paper proposed that some types of property would be excluded from the PRS MEES requirements. This is because the regulations will introduce a prohibition on the letting of a property where the standard is not met and meeting this standard would not be appropriate for the nature of many of these tenancy agreements, which can be lifelong, intergenerational or legally required.
Q5: Do you agree that, regardless of changes to the repairing standard, that crofters, small landholders and agricultural holdings should be excluded from PRS MEES?
Almost half (46%) of all respondents agreed and nearly a quarter (22%) disagreed with this proposal. Similar proportions of organisations and individuals disagreed (20% and 23% respectively). Just over a quarter (27%) gave a ‘don’t know’ response. Views differed between organisations and individuals, with lower proportions of the former agreeing with this proposal (34% compared to 52%).
141 respondents then commented at this question.
Support for excluding crofters, small landholders and agricultural holdings
The most cited reason (given by a small minority including substantial proportions of local authorities and representative bodies) for excluding the above categories from PRS MEES was because of the length, nature and legal framework of their tenancy agreements. These were seen to differ from those in the mainstream rental sector, with tenancies being continuous, lifelong, intergenerational or legally required. Allied to this were a small number of concerns as to how these tenancies would be defined in legislation. It was also noted that subletting takes place and this would add complications. There was also some question as to who would be responsible for the costs of improvements.
A small minority of respondents perceived that some rural properties would be too difficult to improve to the repairing standard from a practical point of view, noting unsuitable and not easily classified building structures. Similar numbers thought that small farmers and crofters would be unable to afford the necessary alterations, referring to the expense of building costs and materials and low rents being insufficient to provide the necessary funds. A couple of organisations expressed concerns over supply chain limitations in rural areas.
Concerns were also raised by small numbers about the possibility of tenants being evicted or forced off the land to enable works to be undertaken (amid queries as to where they would go); and about rural buildings lying empty if they were prohibited from tenancies due to the standard not having been met.
However, a small minority cited caveats to the extent that these tenancies might be included if sufficient support and incentives were available for improvements.
A few respondents agreed with exclusion for now but thought these entities should come into legislation at a future point as they should have some sort of standard to adhere to where feasible. A small number agreed with exclusions for some, but not all, of the tenancies in question.
Very small numbers again raised concerns over the ability of older buildings to comply with the standard.
Disagreement with exclusion for crofters, small landholders and agricultural holdings
A small minority, including a high proportion of third sector / advocacy / charitable organisations said the tenancies in question would benefit from improved energy efficiency standards, noting these have some of the worst ratings and some of the worst fuel poverty. As an environment / conservation organisation stated:
“A blanket exclusion without alternative plans risks deepening inequality and undermine Scotland’s statutory duty to eradicate fuel poverty “as far as reasonably practicable” by 2040.”
An energy / utility organisation suggested including these properties in the standard for owner-occupiers when the HiBs Bill is published later this year. An academic / research organisation and a manufacturer / supplier / installer foresaw that HEETSA would provide solutions to these types of tenancies’ improvement problems.
A further small minority wanted to ensure all tenants had warm and efficient homes in line with the Just Transition.
A significant minority (mainly individuals against exclusion) reiterated views that all housing should meet the same standard, so that social housing, council housing and housing associations were treated in the same way as the PRS. It was felt this would increase the effectiveness of the proposals and ensure consistency with the repairing standard. Conversely, a small number considered that other tenancies such as old housing and that of small landlords should also be excluded if exclusion for crofters, small landholders and agricultural holdings was agreed.
A small minority, including several local authorities, argued for exclusions or exemptions from PRS MEES to be decided on a case-by-case basis, taking into account individual circumstances.
“…targeted exemptions could apply only to properties that genuinely meet the specific criteria behind the proposed exclusions, such as those with legal or structural constraints that make compliance impractical. This approach would balance fairness for tenants with recognition of the unique nature of certain rural tenancies.” Local Authority
Points were also made about all sectors needing to contribute to achieving climate or sustainability goals, and the risk of landlords converting tenancy type to qualify for exclusions or exemptions.
Short-term holiday lets
The consultation paper proposed that short-term holiday lets would be excluded from PRS MEES because they do not have the same interaction with fuel poverty as properties in the PRS.
Q6: Do you agree that the regulations should exclude short-term holiday lets from the PRS MEES?
Just over half the respondents (52%) felt that short-term lets should not be excluded from the PRS MEES, compared to around a third (35%) who felt they should. Higher numbers of individuals agreed they should be excluded (41%) than organisations (24%).
A total of 182 respondents made comments.
Support for excluding short-term holiday lets from the PRS MEES
There were two main themes cited by respondents which supported the exclusion of short-term holiday lets (STHL) from the PRS MEES. Firstly, a small minority noted that such properties were not permanent residences, often not used and therefore not running heating in winter, so that the imperative or benefit from energy efficiency improvements is less than for other tenures. And secondly, it is the landlord who pays the energy bills rather than the tenants, so fuel poverty does not apply to these homes. A small number claimed that short-term holiday let hosts already undertake work to attain high energy efficiency standards, arguing that it is in their self-interest to do so and that sustainable approaches are in demand from holidaymakers.
Smaller numbers of respondents thought the costs of complying with the regulations would impact on the short-term letting business, possibly leading hosts to sell their properties. A small number also said the impact would put up rents for holidaymakers, firstly from a need for hosts to pay improvement costs and secondly due to fewer short-term holiday lets being available.
A few respondents (particularly energy / utility organisations) thought these tenancies should have some sort of standard at some future point; a couple of respondents pointed out that the upcoming HiBs Bill will give ministers powers to regulate across wider sectors in future.
Very small numbers agreed with exclusions for some types of STHL, specifying lodge type lets / log cabins, pods, yurts, wigwams, other glamping types and caravans, but not others. Allied to this, a few respondents thought decisions on exclusions or exemptions should be made on a case-by-case basis, given the many different types of short-term holiday lets.
Disagreement with excluding short-term holiday lets from the PRS MEES
There were many more comments against this proposal than in support of it. The most quoted theme, mentioned by a large minority of respondents (and a majority of organisations) was a perceived risk of landlords converting tenancy type to short-term holiday letting from PRS to avoid the new regulations. This in turn was perceived as leading to less PRS availability and a resulting exacerbation of the housing crisis.
A significant number of respondents expressed a belief that all sectors including STHL should contribute to climate goals including net zero and decarbonisation. A few of these noted the sector encompasses a considerable number of properties and that these properties have emissions regardless of who pays the energy bills.
Similarly, it was felt that all tenancies would benefit from improved energy efficiency or reduced energy demands. It was noted this could also benefit landlords through lower energy bills, given their tenants have no incentive to use energy efficiently.
The nature of tenancy (e.g. length of tenure) should not preclude the standard being met, according to a small minority. It was pointed out there could be disincentives for other owners from investing in improvements in cases where STHL is part of a mixed tenure block, but the STHL owners do not have to share the cost. A few individuals simply noted that they could see no reason why STHL should be treated differently.
Smaller number of respondents made the following points in support of inclusion in PRS MEES:
- Landlords to the STHL sector make high incomes and therefore should help towards the costs of the system, as they have a greater source of funding to draw upon.
- Large amounts of STHL causes difficulties elsewhere (e.g. in rural locations taking homes out of PRS).
- STHL can become long term homes in the future; inclusion would mean properties would meet the standard on a change of use, whereas if they were excluded then this would act as a barrier to reversion to long term use.
- It would help ensure all holidaymakers are well looked after in suitable lodging.
As with previous questions, a significant minority of mainly individuals reiterated that they were in favour of consistency across all housing so that all types of housing meet the same repairing standard, and that it was unfair for landlords to be treated differently.
Exemptions and cost cap
The Scottish Government is keen to provide flexibility and exemptions where these are needed. This will ensure that regulations are fair, affordable and achievable. Flexibility would be offered so that landlords are not required to install any measures which are not suitable or feasible. To ensure the proposed regulations provide the necessary support and accommodate individual circumstances, it is proposed that exemptions will be available to landlords. These will cover consent, negative impacts on the fabric or structure of a property, temporary exemptions and a cost cap. The first question in this section of the consultation paper asked:
Q7: Do you agree with the proposed exemptions covering consent, the fabric requirements of the home and temporary exemptions?
There were relatively high levels of support for the proposed exemptions, with a majority (58%) supporting these, and just under a quarter (23%) disagreeing with them. There were some differences between organisations and individuals, with higher numbers of organisations supporting these exemptions and higher numbers of individuals not supporting them.
A total of 172 respondents provided additional commentary in support of their initial response to this question.
Support for the proposed exemptions
A significant minority of respondents who provided comments noted their support for the proposed exemptions, noting these were fair or reasonable. A few respondents also felt that there is no sense in offering temporary exemptions but that these should be permanent. A similar number of respondents also felt that landlords should be able to make a reasonable financial return on their rental properties.
Lack of support for the proposed exemptions
Conversely, smaller numbers of respondents felt these exemptions should not be introduced on the grounds that they are unrealistic and disregard the practical reality of upgrading buildings. A small minority also felt there should be no exemptions or that exemptions should only be offered on rare occasions. Some of these respondents felt that exemptions would lead to further inequalities for tenants.
A significant minority of respondents also disagreed with these exemptions on the basis that this would offer a loophole that would be exploited by landlords, for example, they might put pressure on tenants to withhold consent for work to be undertaken.
Concerns over the proposed exemptions
A small minority of respondents felt that the proposed temporary exemption of a 6 month timeframe, for example, in circumstances where there are changes to the landlord of the property or changes to the circumstances which exist between the landlord and tenants in which to undertake work, should be extended and requested an extension to the compliance period. For example, some of these respondents pointed out that probate can take a considerable amount of time to be resolved, during which time it would not be possible to undertake any work on the property.
A lack of skilled professionals to undertake assessments was noted by a few respondents, with some also noting the need for fully trained professionals who can undertake assessments. There were also some concerns about undertaking the necessary work due to a lack of capacity within the sector.
As at previous questions, there were some concerns that rental properties would be removed from the market, that any changes would lead to rent increases for tenants or that this would be too costly for landlords to undertake. A few respondents also noted concerns over the potential bureaucracy that would be involved in offering temporary exemptions.
Alternative approaches to the proposed exemptions
Approaching each property on a case-by-case basis and offering flexibility to accommodate specific circumstances was suggested by a significant minority of respondents. Some of these respondents felt the regulations need to be flexible and nuanced to accommodate different properties. Examples given included listed properties, older buildings over a certain age and off-grid properties that rely on using calor gas, oil or wood. A small number of these respondents also called for blanket exemptions for listed and older properties.
References to the proposed timescale were cited by a small minority of respondents, with suggestions for an unspecified longer time period. There were some suggestions for 10 years or more, particularly for landlords with only a single property or a small number of properties.
There were some suggestions that where a property is exempt, a landlord should still be encouraged to consider all available options and make other suitable upgrades, including heating system upgrades.
A small minority of respondents felt that fabric exemptions should be supported by a HEETSA assessment; and exemptions should only be granted where a HEETSA assessment has been conducted and shown that no safe fabric solution is possible.
Other suggestions for exemptions included:
- Reduce the cost cap from £10,000 to £5,000 as the former is too high an amount to expect landlords to pay.
- Reduce the EPC HRR band to D as band C is not suitable for many properties.
- Tenants should not be able to refuse to let work be undertaken.
- Exemptions for landlords with five or less properties, particularly as many small landlords do not have access to the necessary finance to be able to undertake expensive work to their properties.
There were calls from a significant minority of respondents for some form of review and oversight to be put in place, with a requirement for landlords to provide clear evidence of consent having been sought. A system of oversight would not only check or verify whether exemptions should be allowed but also monitor any innovative or new approaches to energy efficiency that could be used in future energy efficiency improvements and upgrades.
Once again, there were a number of calls from a significant minority of respondents for the Scottish Government to provide robust guidance for both landlords and tenants. This would help to increase awareness of what is required, although there were some comments on the need for any guidance to be clear and easy to understand and based on practical suggestions. Allied to comments on the need for guidance, there were a few comments on the need for greater clarity on the proposed regulations and clear processes and transparency throughout. For example, there were queries over what constitutes ‘reasonable efforts with third parties’.
The provision of financial help in the form of loans or grants was also mentioned by a small minority of respondents. Some noted it would not be possible for many landlords – particularly those with a single or small number of properties, or in rural and remote areas where rents tend to be relatively low – to undertake the necessary work without funding being provided. A small number of respondents – mostly local authorities – noted that additional resources will need to be provided to local authorities if they have responsibility for approving exemptions or monitoring any new regulations.
Heat and Energy Efficiency Technical Suitability Assessment (HEETSA)
The consultation paper noted that HEETSA could be used to support building owners in understanding which potential energy efficiency improvement measures would be technically suitable. This would provide an additional level of safeguard for consumers, particularly those in more complex to decarbonise buildings such as traditional or protected buildings, those in rural areas or those in tenements.
The next question in the consultation asked:
Q8: Do you agree that HEETSA should be available as an option to evidence potential negative impacts on the fabric of a property and to support an exemption?
There was a high level of support (68%) for HEETSA to be available as an option to evidence potential negative impacts, compared to 10% who did not support this proposal. When we examine sub-group differences, these show higher levels of support from organisations (76% compared to 64% of individuals).
A total of 135 respondents went on to provide further commentary.
Support for HEETSA to be available as an option
The key reason offered by around a quarter of respondents (24%) for support of this proposal was that it would help landlords and tenants understanding and thus their ability to make informed decisions. It was seen as a valuable tool that would be specific to each property, based on expert advice and not based on modelled assumptions. As such, HEETSA assessments can avoid damaging or innappropriate interventions to a property; this would help landlords ensure they were carrying out appropriate work and improvements to their properties and avoid making what could be costly mistakes. A few respondents also commented that this would offer consistency and a standardised assessment across the PRS in Scotland, as well as allowing transparency for exemptions that are applied for.
The smaller numbers of respondents who disagreed with this proposal argued that this would create unecessary work or that it would be overly complicated and introduce more complex bureaucracy.
Concerns over HEETSA to be available as an option
The key concern expressed by a significant minority of respondents, related to the costs of undertaking any work, with some suggestions that this would impact disproprtionately on landlords with single properties, those with a small number of properties or those in more remote and rural areas or island communities.
While there was support for conducting an individual bespoke assessment for each property, some respondents cited the need for properly qualified professionals who could undertake HEETSA assessments to ensure integrity in the process. Not surprisingly, a key concern was of a possible shortage of skilled professionals to undertake HEETSA assessments. Allied to this, there were a few comments that unqualified individuals (scammers) could recommend unsuitable and inappropriate improvements that could damage the fabric of some buildings and lead to further costly repair work.
The timescales were cited by a small number of respondents who commented that this should not have to be repeated every five years.
Alternative approaches to HEETSA being available as an option
While there was generally a positive view of HEETSA assessments, a few respondents felt that HEETSA should be up and running before any initial PRS MEES date or that both should be aligned fully. There were also a few calls for more information to be provided on HEETSA assessments. These included assessment costs and the processes that would be involved in obtaining a HEETSA assessment.
There were a few suggestions that rather than using a HEETSA assessment, this could align with a Retrofit Assessment and Medium-Term Improvement Plan in line with PAS 2035 as these are used across the UK and take account of ventilation and building fabric.
A few respondents also felt this proposal is overly reliant on focusing on exemptions rather than finding solutions to overcome barriers; rather that there should be a broad framework aimed at minimising exemptions.
Other comments made by relatively small numbers of respondents echoed points made at earlier questions.
Cost cap
The consultation paper proposed a cost cap exemption that would provide a ceiling on the maximum investment that a landlord would be required to invest in a single property through making energy efficiency improvements with the aim of reaching the minimum standard. This would mean that if a landlord was unable to improve their property to the minimum standard without spending more than the cost cap, they would instead be required to make all the relevant improvements that can be made up to the amount of the cap and then register for an exemption. All actual costs would be included towards reaching the cost cap, including the cost of obtaining a new EPC. The cost cap would remain in place until the property next changed ownership to a new landlord. It is also proposed that expenditure made on energy efficiency improvements which are intended to meet the standard will be countable towards the cumulative cost cap within a period of 12 months in advance of the regulations coming into force.
Q9: Do you agree that the cost cap level should be £10,000?
Overall, there was limited support for the cost cap level to be £10,000; 24% supported this compared to 59% who did not. A higher proportion of individuals (63%) did not support this, compared to 50% of organisations.
A total of 238 respondents then went on to provide comments in support of their initial response to this question.
Disagreement with the cost cap
The key comment – cited by a large minority of respondents – was that this cap is too high, and some respondents commented that many landlords make little profit from renting out properties, particularly in low rent areas. There were also comments from a small minority that landlords cannot afford the cost of energy efficiency improvements, and that many are dependent on any rental income perhaps as part of their pension.
Alternative approaches for the cost cap
A significant number of respondents made suggestions for alternative cost caps that could be applied but there was little consistency in the amount suggested. These ranged from a low as £1,000 up to £7,500, although the highest number of respondents cited a cost cap of £5,000 as being a more realistic level.
Conversely, a small minority suggested the cost cap should be set at a level of £20,000 as £10,000 would be insufficient to carry out necessary improvements. Some respondents noted that this cap was initially suggested in 2020 and that it is too low a level for 2025. A representative body noted:
“Based on current average installation costs, the cap as currently proposed at £10,000 would mean most lower-cost insulation measures could be installed. However, this level of cap would limit, or potentially prevent entirely, external wall insulation going into privately rented solid wall homes. Following inflation over recent years the average installation cost for EWI is now closer to £17,000 to £18,000.”
Other suggestions for the cost cap included:
- Make the cost cap a percentage of a Home Evaluation Report or market price or council tax band; this could be tiered depending on the house value.
- Make the cost cap proportional to rental income or a fixed percentage of income made on renting out the property.
- There should be different tiered cap levels for different types of property or by geographical area.
- A cost cap that rises with inflation.
- A cost cap that fits with the likely costs suggested in the consultation paper (between £1,400-£2,700); although a few respondents considered that the figures quoted in the consultation paper seemed very out of date and significantly underestimate likely costs). There were also some queries as to how these figures were reached.
- The cost cap should be linked to expected cost efficiency gains achievable from improvements made.
- Link the cost cap to the payback period.
- The cost cap should only include measures directly related to MEES.
- The cost cap should exclude any measures funded via grants directly to tenants through fuel poverty programmes.
- The cost cap should be for a limited time period and reviewed regularly.
- Align the cost cap to that set in England and Wales (£15,000).
- Link the cost cap to a minimum set of requirements, depending on property type.
- The cost cap should be informed by a HEETSA assessment.
A number of other themes were cited, many echoing those seen at earlier questions. These included a need for financial assistance in the form of grants, loans or subsidies to be provided to landlords. Some of these respondents felt that grants would be preferable to loans as some landlords would struggle to repay a loan. Alongside this, a small minority suggested that costs should be tax deductible or linked to council tax reductions.
There were also some calls for guidance to be provided so that landlords can be aware of the choices available to them and understand the implications of these options.
Suggestions for regular reviews and monitoring of the scheme was mentioned by a few respondents, with suggestions that the cost cap could change in line with market conditions and technical developments.
A significant minority of respondents had concerns that this policy could be undermined by allowing landlords to gain exemptions from technically suitable measures due to their cost. Linked to this, there were some concerns that the least energy efficient properties will be exempt as the costs of upgrading will be higher than the cost cap. This would mean that the most disadvantaged tenants continue to suffer the most from a lack of energy efficient properties. Again, there were also concerns that the introduction of this policy could take properties away from the rental market, thereby reducing tenant choice in where to live and exacerbating the current housing crisis; or that this would lead to rent increases, which would impact most on those on low incomes.
Finally, there were some requests for additional information. As a representative body commented:
“We believe that further guidance is needed on how the cost cap would work in practice. For example, if a property required loft insulation at a cost of £1000, double glazing at a cost of £8000 and floor insulation at a cost of £5000, the total cost exceeds £10,000 so not all these measures need to be installed. The landlord could install the loft insulation and double glazing for £9000, or the loft insulation and floor insulation for £6000. In this situation would it be acceptable for the landlord to choose the £6000 options, thereby “saving” themselves £3000?”
12 month lead in time period
The consultation paper noted that landlords may seek to implement improvements earlier than the enforcement dates and the Scottish Government are keen to ensure these costs are included in achieving the minimum standard. It was proposed that expenditure made on energy efficiency improvements which are intended to meet the standard are countable towards the cumulative cost cap within a period of 12 months in advance of the Regulations coming into force.
The next question asked:
Q10: Do you agree with the proposed 12 month lead in time period for works to contribute to the total cost cap?
Views on the proposed 12 month lead in period for works to contribute to the total cost cap were relatively mixed; with 42% in agreement and 39% not in agreement. When we look at sub-groups, a higher proportion of organisations supported this proposal.
A total of 153 respondents provided supplementary comments.
Agreement with the proposed 12 month lead in time
Some of those in agreement with this proposal simply reiterated their agreement with the proposal or noted that it seems reasonable, sensible and / or proportionate. Some other advantages were attributed to this, each by a few respondents. These included that this approach recognises early adoption and investment and avoids penalising proactive landlords while supporting implementation of MEES and offering a capacity for landlords to plan ahead. A few respondents noted that this would help to reduce pressure on the retrofit supply chain by spreading demand more evenly, as well as easing demand close to the enforcement date.
Concerns with the proposed lead in time
A key concern cited by a significant minority of respondents related to the accessing of professionally skilled staff to carry out energy efficiency improvements. They noted there is already a shortage of skilled staff, so there would be high levels of demand on a restricted number of contractors. They felt this could lead to capacity constraints. Additionally, if landlords wait until close to the deadline, this could create a bottleneck. There were some specific references to landlords in rural and remote locations and island communities where there are very few skilled staff and materials and labour can cost considerably more than in other areas in Scotland.
With this in mind, a significant minority of respondents felt a longer time period is needed for works to contribute to the total cost cap. They felt a longer time period would make it easier to phase in any necessary work and obtain any necessary building warrants. A small minority of respondents specifically commented that a 12 month limit on eligibility is too restrictive and risks undermining the policy intent to encourage early investment in energy efficiency. They also felt this could discourage early upgrades, lead to extended void periods and cause delay to improvement works. Additionally, some felt this would disincentivise landlords from undertaking any work until dates are firmly in place.
Alternative approaches
Alternatives timescales, ranging from over 12 months up to five years were suggested by some respondents, although the most frequency cited period was for 2 years. As noted by an organisation in the third sector / advocacy / charity sector:
“We are concerned that this approach may unintentionally discourage landlords from taking early steps to improve energy efficiency. If landlords are aware that regulations are forthcoming and understand what is required, they should be encouraged to act sooner. However, restricting eligible expenditure to the final 12 months (i.e. to the 12 months before the regulations come into force) could lead landlords to delay planned improvements until they are certain that the work will “count” towards the cost cap. This could result in a surge of activity at the start of the 12-month lead in period, putting unnecessary pressure on supply chains, installers and the wider support infrastructure and could lead to delays, increased costs and difficulty accessing necessary support services. We therefore recommend that the Scottish Government consider a longer lead in period. A more extended timeframe would encourage earlier investment, support smoother delivery and help avoid unnecessary delays.”
A significant minority of respondents felt that landlords should not be penalised for work that has been carried out in the last three years to upgrade properties. Alternatively, exemptions should be offered to any major upgrade works that have taken place, for example, installation of wall, loft or floor insulation or double glazing. One respondent noted that the suggested approach would benefit landlords who have not invested in upgrades to their properties in recent years.
A number of other issues were raised by respondents at this question and reflected points raised in earlier questions.
Costs counting towards the cost cap
The consultation paper noted that there is an intention to include all actual costs to be included towards reaching the cost cap. This is because some landlords may be required to comply with the regulations before their existing EPC has expired, and this would result in them having to commission a new EPC assessment. To accommodate the additional expense of carrying out a new EPC assessment, it is proposed that the cost of obtaining a new EPC will be within the scope of the cost cap exemption and can contribute to the cumulative costs of reaching the minimum standard.
The next question asked:
Q11: Do you agree that all actual costs, and the cost of an EPC, should count towards the cost cap?
Views on whether all actual costs, and the cost of an EPC, should count towards the cost cap, were positive; a large majority (81%) agreed compared to 11% who disagreed. The views of organisations and individuals were broadly similar.
A total of 101 respondents provided additional commentary to support their initial response.
Agreement for including all actual costs towards the cost cap
Among those who agreed that all actual costs, and the cost of an EPC, should count towards the cost cap, a number of reasons were given. It was felt this approach would be fair, pragmatic and reasonable; encouraging transparency and fairness and helping to encourage landlords to plan and invest in energy efficiency improvements. Covering the cost of an EPC was thought to encourage landlords to obtain up-to-date assessments for the property. Some respondents noted that an EPC is a valid expense as part of this process and ensures the cap reflects the true cost of compliance. A small minority of respondents also felt that the cost of obtaining an EPC is minimal compared to the cost of any remedial works and including this in the cost cap would not cause a significant reduction in money available for energy performance upgrades. As noted by an organisation in the landlord / letting agent / property agent sector:
“We believe that including EPC assessment costs in the overall cost cap will be particularly important if a new certificate becomes mandatory before undertaking measures to comply with MEES. Including all relevant costs, including labour, materials, EPC assessment, and post-improvement, if required, will also improve transparency for landlords. This will be hugely beneficial for policymakers in the Scottish Government, allowing for more accurate modelling of MEES affordability and policy impact moving forward.”
A few respondents suggested that the cost of obtaining an EPC should only be included in the cost cap in cases where an existing EPC has not expired.
A significant minority of respondents also made suggestions for other costs that should be covered by the cost cap. The key cost was for any professional fees, including architect fees, retrofit assessments, property agents and obtaining advice. Other suggestions, made by small numbers of respondents included:
- Costs for redecorating, reinstallation of flooring and other remedial works.
- HEETSA assessment.
- Alternative accommodation for tenants who cannot remain in a property while work is being undertaken.
- Council tax.
- Utilities.
- Increased insurance premium.
- Costs associated with any work undertaken prior to PRS MEES that could contribute towards energy efficiency improvements.
- Loss of rental income.
Disagreement with including all actual costs towards the cost cap
For the minority opposed to this proposal, there were comments that the cost of obtaining an EPC should be the responsibility of a landlord, given that EPCs are a standard cost associated with letting properties. They felt the cost cap should only include the cost of any retrofit work undertaken; some noted the purpose of the cost cap is to reflect money spent on upgrades to the energy performance of a property. If the cost of an EPC is excluded from the cost cap, it ensures the maximum positive benefit for tenants. There were also some comments that only costs directly related to compliance should be included, rather than any routine repair or maintenance work, including an EPC assessment.
Other comments
A small minority of respondents reiterated concerns that a cap of £10,000 is too low, that it will be difficult to achieve some energy efficiency upgrades on this amount; and that this level of cap will restrict opportunities to upgrade properties.
Other concerns, reiterated by small numbers of respondents included a need for:
- Guidance to be provided.
- Clarity on what costs will be included in a cost cap.
- Grants and other forms of financial support to be made available; including tax incentives.
- The cost cap to be linked to inflation.
- The cost cap to be reduced.
- Monitoring and review of the scheme.
- Likely increases to the cost of obtaining an EPC.
Support
The consultation paper noted that the Scottish Government is keen to avoid any instances where landlords are compelled to sell their properties, or change their use from offering secure tenancies, because they are unable to undertake works to meet the PRS MEES. The Scottish Government established the PRS Landlord Loan Scheme in 2020 to support the now withdrawn regulations. Landlords with up to five properties in their portfolio can borrow a maximum of £100,000 which is not subject to interest. Applicants with more than five properties can borrow a maximum of £250,000 and are subject to an interest rate of 3.5% per annum. The next question asked:
Q12: Do you agree that landlords should receive Scottish Government support to make the required changes?
There was widespread support for this proposal, with a large majority of respondents (83%) agreeing, and only 9% disagreeing. There was little difference between organisations (80% agreement) and individuals (85% agreement).
A total of 182 respondents also made comments. Reflecting the first part of the question, almost all answers were positive with relatively few caveats. There was however considerable discussion about preferred types of support.
Agreement that landlords should receive Scottish Government support
Significant minorities of respondents from across all sub-groups referred to the expense of changes without government support, with some commenting that landlords had only limited resources and that other financial support options were limited.
Smaller numbers (mostly organisations) thought support would help accelerate, encourage and incentivise the changes needed and generally increase the likelihood of compliance. Similar numbers, mostly individuals, felt it was only fair that the government supports changes since it is they who are introducing the legislation at no benefit to landlords.
A risk of landlords selling properties or changing their use to avoid complying with the new regulations was seen as a consequence of lack of support by significant numbers of respondents. This was perceived as leading to reduced PRS availability, increased rents and other knock-on issues. Some comments referred to support being seen as a protection for tenants, by insulating them from higher costs. It was also felt that this would offer an improved standard of living to tenants. Other positive knock-on effects of government support included the creation of local jobs and helping to drive innovation in energy efficient technologies.
A small number of respondents cited each of the following caveats to getting support:
- Only as long as financial support is easy and straightforward to access, amid concerns about application processing times and high demand.
- Only as long as support represents value for money for the public, with a need for control over public financing.
- Only as long as support aligns with other regulatory areas and support sources (e.g. rent caps, the Renewable Heat Initiative (RHI), the Housing (Scotland) Bill, and landlords’ additional duties under the HiBs Bill).
Disagreement that landlords should receive Scottish Government support
A small number of respondents wanted landlords to pay for works themselves, claiming either that they make high incomes and therefore can put aside sufficient funds to cover this, or simply because it is their responsibility being a business.
A very small number of respondents voiced concerns over possible abuse of a loan support system.
Alternative types of Scottish Government support
Grants were seen by significant numbers of respondents as a preferred means of support. These were seen as helping landlords avoid getting into debt, given perceived difficulties in repaying loans if rent controls were in place, and acting as an incentive to carry out alterations. However, a small number said support should not include grant funding; it was thought that landlords should have a sound knowledge of business costs and risks, and should pay back any money received or borrowed.
Particularly among organisations, slightly smaller numbers of respondents commented positively about interest free or low interest loans rather than grants. These were seen as a good way to spread costs over time. A small number advocated altering the tier system for the PRS Landlord Loan Scheme, reasoning that in certain circumstances this might not produce fair outcomes. A landlord / letting agent / property agent commented that “5 large houses could produce far more rental income than 6 small flats. Should the tiering be by a rental income threshold?”.
A need for other (non-Scottish Government) financial support was suggested by a small minority, including several local authorities, manufacturers / suppliers / installers and representative bodies. To this end, a number of options were suggested. These included: a UK Government subsidised loan scheme, green finance options, grant support through Warmer Homes Scotland, funding to lenders to subsidise a wide range of products to meet landlords’ needs, and top up support for fabric measures. Other possible measures included the reintroduction of the Landlord Energy Saving Allowance (LESA) by the UK Government (where landlords could offset energy efficiency spending and low carbon heating measures against taxable profits) and redirecting Energy Company Obligation (ECO) funding towards the PRS.
A large minority of organisations felt landlords would also need non-financial support. Recommendations included awareness-raising about PRS MEES, advisory services (including tailored rather than generic advice). Support for the wider supply chain was also advocated.
A further large minority (in particular a number of local authorities and manufacturers / suppliers / installers) advocated that support should depend on the type of landlord. Some suggestions included targeting support towards:
- Landlords with the lowest rents (as they are likely to need more help).
- Rural property owners.
- PRS properties in mixed tenure blocks.
- Properties with the largest alteration costs or most extensive fabric upgrades.
- The worst performing homes.
- Non company structure rentals.
Loans
The consultation paper noted that the Scottish Government established the PRS Landlord Loan Scheme in 2020 to support the now withdrawn regulations. This provides financial support through loans. Landlords with up to 5 properties in their portfolio can borrow a maximum of £100,000 and will not be subject to interest. Landlords with more than 5 properties in their porfolio can borrow a maximum of £250,000 and will be subject to interest at a rate of 3.5% APR.
The next question asked:
Q13: Do you agree that this should be in the form of a loan?
Views were less positive over this being in the form of a loan. Overall, just under half (49%) disagreed with this, while 31% agreed. The views of organisations and individuals differed, with higher levels of support for this proposal from organisations (47%) than individuals (22%).
212 respondents made comments at the second part of the question. Many comments alluded to themes already discussed at the previous question.
Agreement with loan support
Significant minorities of respondents, including large proportions of manufacturers / suppliers / installers, representative bodies and third sector / advocacy / charities, reiterated their support for loans, mainly as an aid to accelerate improvements. Loans were seen as better value for money than grants for the taxpayer. A few respondents added that they would like to see the continuation of the PRS Landlord Loan Scheme. There were a small number of queries as to how this loan intersects with the £10,000 cost cap; and also advocating for the repayment term to be extended (e.g. from 8 to 15 years) or to be more flexible.
A small minority voiced support for loans being interest free, particularly for smaller landlords; a similar number said that low interest loans were most appropriate for larger landlords. A local authority mentioned:
“Suggest considering German loan scheme where the interest rate charged varies depending on the level of carbon reduction achieved in the retrofit, resulting in net zero retrofits paying zero interest on the loan.”
A few respondents cited support for loans subject to conditions, with several stating that landlords should not be able to increase the rent. Other single mentions included having clear indicative costs so that people are not ‘ripped off’ by rogue traders, not being limited to employing specific companies, being banned from renting a property if standards were unmet, the loan being secured against the property, and the loan being tied to a recognised advice stream. Other proposed conditions related to tenant security (e.g. being disallowed from evicting tenants or from selling the property for 5 years after receipt of funding, or retention of the property in the PRS for a minimum period).
There were several queries over the terms, conditions, eligibility for and enforcement of loans; for instance, what the penalties for non-repayment might be.
Disagreement with loan support
The main comments disagreeing with loan support, from a small minority, centred on concerns that rents would have to increase to cover costs, including interest on the loan. Small numbers doubted how loans would ever be repaid, citing statutory burdens and rent controls in the PRS.
Alternative approaches for financial support
Large minorities of individuals and landlords / letting agents / property agents favoured grant support rather than loans. These were cited as a better incentive for landlords to make improvements, amid fears that landlords do not want to get into further (i.e. non mortgage-related) debt. There was also a comment that loans were an unsuitable business for the Scottish Government to be involved in.
That said, nearly as many respondents (across all sub-groups) favoured a mix of financial support comprising partial grants and partial loans, with for instance one suggestion of a £5000 grant towards costs with the balance provided by a loan.
A significant minority (mostly organisations including a number of local authorities and public sector / NDPBs) favoured at least some grant support in some specified circumstances; for instance where the changes needed are significant (e.g. where the costs are greater than the £10,000 cost cap, or for heat pump or roof / wall insulation works). Other qualifying situations which were put forward included tenancies in deprived / low rent / rural areas, in mixed tenure blocks, in harder to treat properties, or for protecting a building’s heritage.
Similarly to the comments above regarding loans, a small minority advocated that grant eligibility should be dependent on the type of landlord. Those on the lowest rents, rural landlords and charity / not for profit landlords were recommended as being eligible. A couple of respondents made a point that elderly landlords would be unlikely to be able to pay loans back and hence should also be eligible for grant assistance.
Very small numbers mentioned attaching conditionality to grants; i.e. that grants must be repayable on sale of property, subject to an undertaking by the landlord to do the work, and subject to no raise in rent.
There were widespread suggestions about other possible financial or fiscal support, mainly made by organisations. These included:
- Renewable Heat Initiative (RHI) type grants or loans.
- VAT free or VAT reduced renovation.
- Tax exemptions / incentives / rebates / cost offset / tax relief against rental income / green allowances.
- Eco schemes.
- Government subsidies.
- Extending the HES grant for heat pumps to landlords (as in England).
- Additional Dwellings Supplement (ADS) relief.
- Private sector finance provision of low cost secured and unsecured lending to complement existing schemes for homeowners across the tenures.
- Offering finance towards the replacement of inefficient circulator pumps as with the Green Deal Loan Scheme.
- Favourable mortgage rates for energy efficient homes if equity release is used to fund the relevant works.
- Energy Performance Contracting / ESCO Models, helping to reduce upfront costs for landlords.
- Grants through the UK Government’s Warm Homes Plan.
- Redirecting Energy Company Obligation (ECO) funding to the PRS.
Other comments on financial support
A small minority of respondents reiterated the risks of landlords leaving the PRS market if there was a lack of support for complying with the new regulations.
There were a few reiterations of calls for landlords to pay for the work themselves given perceived high incomes which would enable them to cover this cost without support. It was also pointed out that loans should be available in the market generally; and that improvements would benefit landlords over time by increasing property values and reducing running costs.
A small minority of individuals reiterated that it was only fair that the Scottish Government pays for or otherwise supports the changes.
Monitoring and enforcement
The consultation outlined a proposal that these regulations have similar monitoring and enforcement provisions to those in the draft 2020 regulations. This involves understanding which properties comply and issuing penalty notices to landlords whose properties are non-compliant. It is proposed that local authorities will be designated as the enforcement bodies. Each local authority could take a targeted approach to enforcement of these regulations which would reflect local needs and drivers. Question 14 asked:
Q14: Do you agree that local authorities should be responsible for monitoring and compliance of these regulations? If no, please provide details of an alternative with your reason(s) as to how this would support the delivery of these regulations
Just over half (56%) of respondents supported this proposal, compared to just over a quarter (27%) who did not. Organisations were more supportive (68%) than individuals (49%).
173 respondents made comments at the second part of the question. It should be noted that more responses were received from respondents who agreed than disagreed at the first part of the question. Although in agreement, most of these answers cited multiple caveats about local authorities being responsible for monitoring and compliance.
Agreement that local authorities should be responsible for monitoring and compliance
A large minority of respondents (including nearly half of responding organisations at this question, and half of all local authorities) said in broad terms that local authorities were the most suitable option or were best placed to have responsibility for monitoring and compliance. This would align with their existing responsibilities in the area, such as housing standards, local housing stock, enforcing landlord registration, the Repairing Standard and Local Heat and Energy Efficiency Strategies (LHEES). Furthermore, they had access to EPC data and were responsible for EPC regulations enforcement and the delivery of Area Based Schemes (ABS). Additionally, they knew local issues and have local oversight more generally.
Disagreement that local authorities should be responsible for monitoring and compliance
Of those comments largely disagreeing that local authorities should be responsible for monitoring and compliance, most repeated the theme that they were already overburdened and underfunded.
A small minority (almost entirely individuals and landlords / agents) gave a variety of other reasons why local authorities should not be responsible. Trust and competence issues were foremost among these. Examples included a perceived lack of consistency between local authorities, negative views about the licencing system for short-term lets, a lack of enforcement for the Intolerable Housing Standard when Tolerable Homes legislation is breached, and no actioning of Rent Pressure Zones despite soaring rents. Respondents also alluded to a perceived lack of skill and knowledge within local authorities regarding energy efficiency.
Concerns over whether local authorities should be responsible for monitoring and compliance
A large minority (and a large majority of organisations and local authorities) voiced concerns over local authorities’ resources and capacity. There was widespread agreement that local authorities needed to be adequately resourced to carry out monitoring and compliance. It was pointed out that landlord enforcement teams are already stretched, especially where there are high levels of PRS homes and in smaller authorities. Additionally, there were a couple of warnings about English councils struggling to enforce the MEES.
A significant minority specified a need for local authority funding, such as grants to cover costs. Slightly smaller numbers saw a need for sufficient numbers of adequately trained staff. Training needs included knowledge and skills for handling the necessary data and tools, and to evaluate proposed exemptions. A need for local coordinators and local enforcement officers was also identified.
Further caveats were each noted by small minorities. Local authorities were deemed the most suitable option for monitoring and compliance as long as:
- There is a consistent approach across the country and across authorities (e.g. support for local authorities via a national framework and guidance providing for standardised processes). There were a couple of comments that this would make things easier for landlords with properties in multiple council areas.
- They have sufficient authority to act upon findings (e.g. levying fines).
- They have clear monitoring and enforcement guidance.
Alternative approaches for monitoring and compliance
A small minority of respondents, including several local authorities, wanted to see a mechanism for sharing data and information, such as a centralised digital tool or database. This central support model was envisaged as an enabler for coordination or integration with the Scottish Landlord Register, and would help with tracking non-compliant properties and exemptions, thereby simplifying processes. It would also enable coordination with the Scottish Government to inform future policy. An attendee at a workshop suggested the Scottish Government needs to engage with the Scottish Housing Network to ascertain effective implementation.
There were also a few mentions about a need for the involvement of other bodies in monitoring and compliance as well as local authorities. For instance, letting agents, in order that they do not advertise non-compliant properties, but who would need access to the PRS exemption register. It was also stated that there should be an independent assessor of compliance. A couple of respondents cited a need for the Housing and Property Chamber of the First-tier Tribunal for Scotland to deal with disputes.
A small number of mainly individuals voiced fears about the cost burden of monitoring and enforcement ultimately falling upon landlords, for instance through an increase in landlord registration fees.
Only a few alternatives to local authority responsibility were suggested, each by only small numbers of respondents. These were as follows:
- Monitoring and compliance to be run as a centralised system by a central agency (e.g. to enable a national PRS database, enable consistency across the country and have wide expertise).
- Scottish Government run (as it is a government scheme).
- Run by an independent body (e.g. a national NDPB, a national body for enforcement, a standalone department not run by local authorities or a third party private sector company).
- First Tier Tribunal (as they already enforce the repairing standard for landlords).
- Self-regulation by landlords (e.g. demonstrating compliance to tenants with an option for tenants to raise a complaint).
A small number suggested shared responsibility; for example, local authorities sharing responsibility with housing associations or letting agents.
Finally, a small minority of mainly individual respondents advocated for no monitoring or enforcement of the regulations, arguing against perceived extra costs and bureaucracy.
Penalties
The consultation paper explained that The Energy Act 2011 provides powers to impose sanctions on landlords for non-compliance with the regulations. In 2020, the proposed level of financial penalty for acts of non-compliance was developed through multiple consultations and through extensive stakeholder engagement. The consultation proposed that a similar level of financial penalties should be adopted, with slight adjustments to allow for inflation. The next question asked:
Q15: Do you agree with the proposed level of financial penalties to support compliance with the regulations? If no, please provide detail on suggested amendments that should be made, outlining how the changes would increase the impact of penalties to achieving compliance with the regulations
Only around a quarter of respondents (23%) agreed with this proposal, compared to just over half (54%) who disagreed. Again, the views of organisations and individuals differed, with higher levels of support from organisations (34%) compared to individuals (18%).
A total of 188 respondents made comments at the second part of the question. It should be noted that some responses were received from respondents who agreed at the first part of the question.
Agreement with the proposed level of financial penalties
Among those tending to agree at the first part of the question, a large minority of organisations viewed the level of penalties as appropriate. Smaller numbers said there was a need for meaningful financial penalties to incentivise compliance and act as a deterrent. However, it was also percieved that this needed to be combined with an assurance that landlords can access support, advice and the supply chain to help enable compliance. It was also mentioned that there was the potential to increase the penalties over time should the effects of rising costs and inflation on attaining compliance have an impact.
Disagreement with the proposed level of financial penalties
A significant minority, mainly individuals, regarded the stated levels of penalties as being too high. In particular, respondents commented that the leap from £600 to £3,000 where there has been a breach of 6 months or more represents too steep a jump. There was also some comment that £600 for a first breach was also too high, with a couple of suggestions to at least halve this.
Similar numbers of respondents – again mainly individuals – were against financial penalties altogether. These respondents perceived that landlords cannot afford the changes or that financial penalties would only make affordability harder. That said, there was some mention of financial penalties being used in cases of protracted non-compliance. Similar numbers across all sub-groups advocated that using a carrot rather than a stick approach would be more effective in encouraging improvements to be made, or that first transgressions should only merit a warning.
A significant minority, mainly comprising organisations and including several representative bodies and organisations in the third sector / advocacy / charity sector viewed the financial penalties as being too low. There were some comments that they needed to be higher, to the extent that they should exceed the cost of improvement measures. Otherwise it was predicted that landlords may just accept the penalties rather than spend money to upgrade their properties. A couple of respondents noted the penalties were lower than those for similar breaches in England and Wales.
Specifically, a few respondents thought that a £600 fine for providing false or misleading information appeared very low compared to the impact this could cause. There was a mention that this level should be at least equivalent to that for a person in known breach of the regulations for six months or more (£3000). Also, that this was less than penalties for landlords who are non-compliant in other ways, e.g. for non-registration.
A few respondents intimated that the maximum penalty should be at least equal to, or more than, the £10,000 cost cap, in order that landlords were not incentivised to be non-compliant.
Suggested alternatives for structuring financial penalties
A small minority wanted to see a more tiered penalty structure. A sliding scale or a more flexible or individualised approach was recommended. A variety of ways to do this were suggested. These included basing the structure on the severity by which the current EPC underperforms the standard (e.g. Band G should get a higher penalty than Band D), basing it on regional adjustments, or by linking this to rental incomes, or to tenant welfare. A couple of respondents suggested a staggered introduction of penalty amounts. And a couple of local authorities and a public sector / NDPB organisation advocated making penalties rent-based: for example, letting a tenant live rent free until improvements are made, or staggering rent penalty notices up to and including abatement of the whole rent.
More flexibility in timescales was required, according to slightly smaller numbers of respondents. This was thought necessary to allow for non-availability of tradesmen, health or family issues, to cover accidental non-compliance, or to cover other mitigating circumstances. A couple of respondents thought the 6 month period was too short, suggesting the grace period should be extended to 9-12 months or up to 24 months.
Treatment of financial penalties by landlord type was also suggested by a few respondents. There were some views that penalties should be tougher on companies and landlords with many properties, perhaps by giving a fine per property. Conversely, small or rural landlords should have an extended time frame in which to act. A small number including several local authorities suggested making compliance with the regulations a condition of registration as a landlord, with the removal or suspension of registration from the rental sector the final penalty in extreme cases.
A few individuals maintained that penalties should be the same for all types of property owner, with one voicing a fear of unjust penalties for landlords if non-landlord owners in multi-tenure blocks of flats were guilty of non-compliance.
Concerns with the proposed level of financial penalties
A significant minority, mostly individuals, reiterated the risks of landlords leaving the rental market, citing the threat of or level of penalties as adding to these risks.
Nearly as many respondents, including a majority of local authorities, voiced concerns over difficulties in enforcement. Several took the view that a lot of contexts would have to be accounted for in individual cases of non-compliance. These included the availability of materials and/or contractors, whether the owner had proper information and correct assessments, and process consistency. There were fears that non-compliance could continue unchecked because of local authority resourcing and staffing issues. Examples of this were given of local authorities being unable to answer how many PRS properties lack a valid EPC despite this being a legal requirement, and how many properties might be exempt from the MEES regulations. There were also a couple of predictions that overseas or absentee landlords would be particularly unwilling to pay any penalties.
Further worries (from a small minority) revolved around how rogue landlords (such as those who avoid registration or ratchet up multiple breaches of compliance) may not be punished at the expense of good, conscientious landlords.
A very small number of mainly local authorities said the penalty system must have a clear and robust appeals process.
Amendment to primary legislation: Energy Act 2011
The consultation paper explained that Chapter 3 of the Energy Act 2011 provides the powers for Scottish Ministers to introduce energy efficiency regulations for domestic PRS properties. The Scottish Government is seeking views on proposals to align with UKG[3] and amend the primary legislation. This would provide Scottish Ministers with the powers to amend secondary legislation in the future if a need arose. If current proposals for change are implemented by UKG, this would increase the maximum financial penalty that could be introduced through regulation to £30,000. The next question asked:
Q16: Do you agree that the Scottish Government should amend the Energy Act 2011 to increase in maximum financial penalties that could be imposed up to £30,000 in future, should this be deemed necessary?
Around a quarter (26%) of respondents supported this proposal, compared to a majority (59%) who did not. Views between organisations and individuals differed, with higher levels of support from organisations (50%) compared to individuals (13%). Conversely, 79% of individuals opposed this proposal, compared to 21% organisations.
165 respondents made comments at the second part of the question.
Agreement with amendment of the Energy Act 2011 to increase maximum financial penalties
Among the minority agreeing with this proposal, the most quoted reason (by a small minority of respondents overall) was that there is a place for high penalties, particularly in that a larger penalty would mean that it no longer makes financial sense for landlords to opt to pay a fine rather than undertake improvements. £5000 was thought by a couple of respondents to be an insufficient amount for this. Furthermore, this was regarded as a useful tool for repeated non-compliance, and it would act as a stronger deterrent.
A few organisations were in favour of alignment with the UK Government approach, pointing out advantages, given that landlords may own properties across regions.
Similar numbers simply saw this as a useful option to have, providing flexibility to respond to future enforcement challenges and if current penalties proved insufficient to deter non-compliance. There were also a few respondents who were in favour as long as landlords had access to support, advice and a robust supply chain in combination with the threat of penalties.
Disagreement with amendment of the Energy Act 2011 to increase maximum financial penalties
The dominant reason for disagreement, expressed by a large minority (including a majority of individuals), was that £30,000 was far too high a penalty. ‘Punitive’, ‘excessive’, ‘disproportionate’, ‘unrealistic’ and ‘draconian’ were some of the adjectives used to describe this amount. Respondents argued the figure was likely to be a big proportion of what properties were worth, was the equivalent of many years rent, and that if landlords cannot afford the upgrade, they also cannot afford that level of fine. Further conclusions were that this level of penalty was counterproductive and would not improve MEES attainment. A representative body for landlords pointed out that this level of penalty was not in accordance with other fines applicable in Scottish PRS legislation. A small number of individuals added that it had already been agreed by the Scottish Government that £5,000 was the maximum penalty, and that this was still a huge amount for small landlords.
Other themes mentioned by a few respondents reiterated their disagreement with the use of any penalties as expressed at the previous question. Points were again made that it was more effective to use a carrot than a stick approach to encourage change, and that financial penalties only made it harder for landlords to afford the works.
There were also repeats of requests made at the previous question to change the way penalties are imposed to reflect the type or size of landlord, or for a more tiered and proportionate penalty structure.
A significant minority again reiterated the dangers of landlords selling their properties or changing their usage as a response to this level of penalty, leading to the previously mentioned detrimental effects on the rental housing market.
Other comments on amendment of the Energy Act 2011 to increase maximum financial penalties
A few respondents who otherwise agreed with the proposal cautioned about difficulties with enforcement. A couple of comments mentioned current difficulties getting results through the court system.
Requests were made for more details and clarification over this proposal by a small number of respondents, saying there needed to be further scrutiny, and that there needed to be reconciliation with other policy issues such as a lack of housing.
A very small number advocated for money raised through financial penalties to be used for the enforcement or support systems for MEES.
A few respondents repeated fears over good landlords being punished rather than rogue landlords.
Fears of an abuse of power were expressed by a small number of respondents. In particular there were perceptions of local authorities and government going after landlords as a predominately money-making exercise.
Small numbers repeated the idea of making compliance a condition of being fit to practice as a landlord.
Impact assessments
The consultation paper explained that the Scottish Government is required to consider the impacts of proposed policies, plans or strategic decisions in relation to equalities, various societal groups and sectors, data protection and the environment, under a range of legislation and commitments. The Scottish Government is proposing to refresh an earlier suite of impact assessments, carried out in 2020, to support the delivery of these regulations. In addition to those previously conducted, the Scottish Government is also considering the need for a Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA), a Data Protection Impact Assessment, and a Consumer Duty Impact Assessment. Respondents were asked:
Q17: In what way could these regulations have a specific or different impact, positive or negative, on a particular group of people? This could be based on protected characteristics, such as age or disability, or geography, such as island communities
A significant minority of respondents felt that this should have a positive impact on everyone, in theory. However, a few of these respondents were concerned that this could result in unintended consequences for tenants, landlords and / or local authorities if not properly implemented. The following paragraphs outline positive and negative impacts on various groups of people.
Impact on protected characteristics: positive impacts
Respondents cited a number of positive impacts upon the protected characteristics. The most frequently mentioned was a positive impact on individuals with long term conditions, including physical and mental disabilities, as energy efficiency improvements would provide them with improved health outcomes. For those on lower incomes and in fuel poverty, it was felt there would be better health and wellbeing outcomes; houses that are cheaper to heat with increased thermal comfort and increased levels of disposable income (so long as there are no rent increases). It was also felt that those living in rural, remote and island communities would benefit as they suffer from relatively high levels of fuel poverty.
As well as benefitting individuals with different protected characteristics, this approach was also perceived to support the net zero agenda.
Impact on protected characteristics: negative impacts
The potential for a negative impact across a range of different protected characteristics was noted, particularly for older individuals or those with disabilities. There were also a small number of comments that improvements made could have a negative impact if not carried out properly e.g. damage to health through inadequate ventilation leading to mould or damp in a property. Individuals with a disability or living with a health condition were also singled out by some respondents. Negative impacts could be having to find alternative accommodation while improvements are being carried out, or damage to health in an over-insulated property once improvements have been made. Those on lower incomes were also mentioned due to the potential for rents being increased by landlords to help pay for improvements and / or having less choice in the rental marketplace. It was also felt that there could be negative impacts on any tenants whose landlord receives exemptions as any improvement works undertaken could be limited in nature and not beneficial to the tenants.
Aside from older people, those with disabilities and those on a low income, a wide range of other protected characteristics were cited, each by small numbers of respondents. These included, individuals from an ethnic minority, migrant communities, young people, single parent families.
Tenants: positive impacts
A potential positive impact for tenants was improved protection in the form of rent controls or evictions. There were a small number of suggestions to link this consultation to the one on private rent controls as this would be beneficial to tenants.
Tenants: negative impacts
A signficant number of respondents felt there could be negative impacts on tenants. A key negative impact identified by respondents was a reduction in the supply of properties to rent, and a reduced supply and lack of choice for tenants, potentially exacerbating the housing crisis in Scotland. Linked to this, there were also concerns over accelerating rent prices, which could be higher than any savings for tenants on energy bills. There were some comments that these issues could actually undermine the fuel poverty objectives of this policy.
Another negative impact identified was the disruption to tenants who need to find temporary accommodation while energy efficiency improvements are under way. While this was a potential negative impact across all types of tenant, it was felt this could particularly impact on tenants with mobility issues who rely on adaptations in a property, older tenants and those in rural communities where there may be little choice in alternative accommodation.
Rural / remote / island communities: negative impacts
While many of the issues identified by respondents would impact on tenants regardless of where they live, a number of respondents felt that tenants living in rural, remote and island communities would face specific negative impacts. These included fewer properties available for rent, increased rents for tenants and less choice in available energy efficiency improvements.
There were also some comments that many properties in these communities are older, traditional stone built and, as such, will find it harder to reach EPC HRR band C. It was suggested that landlords of these types of property will face disproportionately high retrofit costs. Indeed, a small number of respondents reiterated that these types of property should be given exemptions as it will never be possible for them to reach band C. Another knock on impact was that some properties in the private rental sector might be lost to the short-term lets sector as this operates under a different set of regulations which are perceived to be easier to reach. Finally, there were also a number of comments regarding a skills shortage of professionals to provide retrofit services and the increased costs of travel and materials needed to make any energy efficiency improvements.
Landlords: negative impacts
A significant number of respondents identified potential negative impacts on landlords. These related primarily to financial implications in terms of the cost of making energy efficiency improvements, particularly in rural areas where costs are likely to be higher than elsewhere. There were also some comments on a lack of available ready cash to landlords to pay for energy efficiency improvements. Some comments related specifically to landlords who have five or fewer properties who are reliant on rental income to supplement their pensions and who do not have access to the necessary funding to carry out improvements. Likewise, respondents referred to higher costs for landlords with older or listed properties, or with flats in tenement blocks or HMOs[4].
Contact
Email: PRSMEESConsultation@gov.scot