National Child Sexual Abuse and Exploitation Strategic Group: September 2026

Minutes from the meeting of the group on 16 September 2026.


Attendees and apologies

Chair

  • Iona Colvin

Group members in attendance

  • Alison Wales, Senior Policy Officer, National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children (NSPCC) Scotland
  • Angela Latta, Deputy Chief Social Work Advisor, National Social Work Agency
  • Anna O'Reilly, Assistant Director, Children First
  • Catriona Scobbie, Education Scotland
  • DCS Sarah Taylor, Police Scotland
  • Deirdre McCormick, Chief Nurse and Head of Public Protection, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
  • Doug Marshall, Senior Impact Lead, Childlight
  • DSU Brian Manchester, Police Scotland
  • Emma Thomson, Crown Office & Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS)
  • Fiona Dyer, Director, Children and Young People’s Centre for Justice (CYCJ)
  • Jane Scott, Head of Early Help and Protection, Centre for Excellence for Children's Care and Protection (CELCIS)
  • Joanne Smith, Policy and Public Affairs Manager, National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children (NSPCC) Scotland
  • Jennifer Crocket, Association of Directors of Education in Scotland (ADES)
  • Kathryn Lindsay, Chief Executive of Angus Council, representing The Society of Local Authority Chief Executives and Senior Managers (SOLACE)
  • Kirsty-Louise McNally, Senior Policy and Public Affairs Lead, Barnardos
  • Michelle McCargo, Strategic Manager Children and Justice, Social Work Scotland
  • Moira McKinnon, Vice Chair, Child Protection Committee (CPC) Scotland
  • Nicola Dickie, Director of People Policy, Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (COSLA)
  • Rosie McNee, Acting Consultant in Child Health, Public Health Scotland
  • Stefan Webster, Ofcom
  • Stuart Allardyce, Director, Lucy Faithfull Foundation Scotland 
  • Tam Baillie, Chair, Child Protection Committee (CPC) Scotland

Apologies

  • Brian Taylor, Deputy Director for Children’s Rights, Protection and Justice, Scottish Government
  • Caroline McDonald, Children and Families Policy and Practice Lead, Social Work Scotland
  • Dr Jennifer McGill, Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, Child Protection Sub-Committee
  • Glenn Preston, Director, Ofcom Scotland
  • Jillian Taylor, Child Health Commissioner & Chief Nurse, NHS Forth Valley
  • Joanna Macdonald, Chief Social Work Adviser, National Social Work Agency
  • Lesley Gordon, Director for Criminal Exploitation UK, Action for Children
  • Lorna Aitken, Senior Education Officer, Education Scotland
  • Lucy Coleman, National Organisation for the Treatment of Abuse (NOTA) Scotland
  • Mary Glasgow, Chief Executive, Children First
  • Mhairi Grant, Vice Chair, Child Protection Committees (CPC) Scotland
  • Rhona Robb, Scottish Nursing Child Protection Leadership Group
  • Roma Bruce Davies, Head of Practice and Policy, Scottish Children’s Reporter Administration (SCRA)

Also in attendance

  • Alastair McAlpine, Chief Statistician, Scottish Government
  • Dr Ariane Critchley, University of Stirling
  • Màiri McAllan, Cabinet Secretary for Education, Culture and Gaelic
  • Ruth Sills, Centre for Excellence for Children's Care and Protection (CELCIS)
  • Scottish Government officials
  • Yasmin Rehman, CEO, Lucy Faithfull Foundation Scotland

Secretariat

  • Child Protection Unit, Scottish Government
     

Items and actions

Welcome, introductions and apologies

The Chair welcomed members to the meeting, noted apologies and introduced the Cabinet Secretary for Education, Culture and Gaelic.

Minutes of previous meeting and actions arising

The minutes from the previous meeting on 16 June 2026 were agreed and published on the Scottish Government’s website.

Scene setting

The Chair reflected on recent engagement with members to further clarify the Group’s role and priorities. It was noted that, while current inquiries into historical child sexual abuse will provide valuable learning, the Group should maintain a clear focus on improving current and future approaches to preventing and responding to child sexual abuse and exploitation (CSAE).

The Chair invited the Cabinet Secretary to address the Group.

The Cabinet Secretary reaffirmed the Scottish Government’s commitment to strengthening child protection and highlighted the importance of leadership, early intervention, effective information sharing and adapting responses to the changing nature of harm, including online abuse and exploitation.

Members were thanked for their work to date. The Cabinet Secretary invited the Group to consider the implications of Public Service Reform and provide views on how reform proposals could support stronger prevention of and responses to child sexual abuse and exploitation. Members were encouraged to focus on practical actions and advice that could support children and families now.

Discussion and review of strategic priorities

The Chair noted that work is already underway through the Group’s Data, Mandatory Reporting and Workforce subgroups and invited the subgroup chairs to provide updates on progress since the previous meeting.

Data Subgroup

The Data Subgroup Chair noted ongoing work to strengthen understanding of the scale and nature of CSAE in Scotland. This work includes improving data quality, developing common definitions, understanding prevalence and strengthening the evidence base to support prevention and early intervention.

It was noted that an interim report would be presented at the next meeting in November to help inform future strategic priorities.

Mandatory Reporting Subgroup

The Mandatory Reporting Subgroup Chair advised there is ongoing work examining national and international approaches to Mandatory Reporting, including consideration of survivor and young people's experiences.

The update noted that the subgroup is moving towards developing recommendations on the forms of abuse that should fall within Mandatory Reporting. Consideration is also being given to the conditions required to ensure any future reporting duty improves the identification and reporting of concerns. The importance of ensuring that any future arrangements improve outcomes for children was also highlighted.

The subgroup expects to report its findings to the Group in early 2027 to inform future advice to Ministers.

Workforce Subgroup

The Workforce Subgroup Chair provided an update on recent engagement activity and the development of recommendations aimed at strengthening workforce capability and supporting wider system improvement.

The update outlined priorities including the development of a national CSAE skills framework, strengthening the voice of the child, improving reflective supervision, increasing leadership visibility and supporting a shift towards recognising indicators of abuse rather than relying primarily on disclosure.

The importance of supporting practitioners to identify and respond to multiple and overlapping forms of harm was also highlighted.

Discussion on current challenges and opportunities

Members discussed a range of current challenges and opportunities in relation to preventing and responding to CSAE.

There was broad agreement that CSAE should not be considered in isolation from other harms. Members emphasised the interconnected nature of child sexual abuse, neglect, child criminal exploitation, online harm and other forms of vulnerability, highlighting the importance of adopting a whole-system and public health approach. The need to avoid siloed responses and maintain a focus on the child’s overall journey through services was also emphasised.

Discussion highlighted the importance of strong leadership, clear accountability and effective multi-agency working. Members reflected on examples of integrated approaches elsewhere and noted the potential benefits of greater coordination and collaboration across services.

Members agreed that strengthening the evidence base remains an important priority. Discussion focused on the need for improved data, shared definitions and a better understanding of the prevalence and nature of CSAE to support prevention, early intervention and future improvement activity.

There was significant discussion on emerging and evolving forms of harm, including online abuse, contextual safeguarding and Child Criminal Exploitation (CCE). Members highlighted the need to better understand existing activity in these areas, identify gaps and ensure future work is coordinated and aligned with wider child protection arrangements.

Members also discussed the importance of raising public awareness and improving understanding of the scale and nature of CSAE. Consideration was given to how communication and engagement activity could support prevention, identification and improved public understanding.

The Group reflected on the potential implications of Public Service Reform for children's services and child protection, including both opportunities and risks, and highlighted the importance of maintaining visibility of child protection within wider reform activity. Members expressed interest in learning from developments elsewhere, including work to establish a Child Protection Authority in England, and agreed that further consideration of these developments would be beneficial.

Finally, members highlighted the importance of ensuring that the voices and experiences of children, young people and survivors continue to inform the Group’s future work and priorities.

Prioritisation and sequencing

In break-out groups members considered the Group's future strategic priorities, including their relative importance, sequencing and any dependencies between areas of work. Discussions also considered opportunities for improvement and impact, barriers to delivery, and how national activity could best support local implementation.

Feedback from each group was subsequently shared with the wider Group, with common themes including the need to focus activity on a manageable number of strategic priorities capable of delivering meaningful impact.

Leadership and workforce development were consistently identified as critical foundations for improvement. Members highlighted the importance of visible leadership, workforce confidence and capability, and ensuring that future developments are supported by adequate training, supervision and organisational commitment.

There was broad agreement on the importance of establishing shared definitions and language to support consistency across policy, practice, workforce development and data collection. Members noted the need to map existing activity across Scotland to identify effective practice, avoid duplication and ensure future work is aligned with ongoing improvement programmes.

Discussion also highlighted the importance of data and evidence in informing national and local decision-making, identifying emerging harms and supporting early intervention.

Online abuse, contextual safeguarding and child criminal exploitation were identified as areas requiring continued focus, recognising the evolving nature of risk and the need for coordinated responses across local and national systems.

Members also discussed the potential implications of Public Service Reform for children's services and child protection, including opportunities and risks, and highlighted the importance of ensuring that children's services and child protection remain visible within wider reform activity.

Strategic planning

In break-out groups members considered what the Group should seek to achieve over the next 12 to 24 months and what success would look like. Discussions also explored the Group's future direction, including desired outcomes, areas requiring direct oversight and how leadership, expertise, learning and evidence could be more effectively shared across Scotland.

Feedback from the smaller groups highlighted broad agreement on the need for a clear vision, supported by a delivery-focused workplan and measurable outcomes.

Members agreed that the Group should position itself as a forward-looking body focused on improving outcomes for children now and in the future, while continuing to learn from historical reviews and inquiries.

Discussion highlighted the importance of establishing baseline data and measures of success. Members noted that increases in identification and reporting may reflect improved awareness and safeguarding arrangements and should be understood within that context.

There was support for improving public understanding of CSAE, including clearer communications about prevalence, risk, identification and access to support.

Members highlighted opportunities to identify and share effective practice from across Scotland, strengthen multi-agency approaches and improve consistency in responses to emerging harms.

Discussion also focused on the need for stronger information sharing, improved access to data and evidence, and better alignment between subgroup activity and the Group's overarching objectives.

Members agreed that early areas of focus could include shared definitions, improved understanding of current activity and greater coordination across existing structures.

Delivery and governance

Members discussed whether existing subgroup arrangements and wider national structures provide the most effective mechanisms for delivery, coordination and improvement activity.

There was agreement that governance arrangements should continue while further work is undertaken to develop the Group’s vision, priorities and workplan.

Discussion highlighted the importance of clear accountability, oversight and coordination across the child protection landscape. Members reflected on how the Group’s work aligns with wider public protection, child protection and violence against women and girls structures.

Members noted the importance of ensuring that future governance arrangements remain focused on preventing harm, protecting children and supporting implementation.

Chair's summary and close

The Chair summarised the key themes arising from the meeting and noted the broad agreement that the Group should increasingly focus on delivery and implementation, supported by a manageable number of strategic priorities.

The Chair highlighted the value of learning from developments elsewhere and noted that a webinar on the Child Protection Authority would support consideration of whether any aspects of the model may be relevant to Scotland.

The need for greater clarity regarding CCE and for further work to understand existing activity and gaps relating to online harms was also highlighted. Members were encouraged to build on existing work and ensure future activity is aligned with wider child protection arrangements.

The Chair also noted the importance of considering the role of adult services, including justice social work, and ensuring that the voices and experiences of survivors, children and young people continue to inform the Group's work.

The Chair thanked members for their contributions and closed the meeting.

Actions

⦁    Secretariat to explore options with members for mapping current child protection improvement activity and examples of effective practice across Scotland
⦁    Secretariat to coordinate engagement with members to inform Public Service Reform proposals relevant to child protection and CSAE
⦁    Secretariat to arrange a webinar on developments relating to the Child Protection Authority in England
⦁    Catriona Scobbie to coordinate consideration of current online safety activity, identify gaps and review relevant governance arrangements, reporting back to a future meeting
⦁    Fiona Dyer to lead consideration of current child criminal exploitation activity, governance arrangements and emerging priorities, reporting back to the Group
⦁    Members to consider how survivor voices and the experiences of children and young people can continue to inform the Group’s work
⦁    Data Subgroup to present interim findings and evidence to inform future strategic priorities at the next meeting
⦁    Secretariat to share the Chair's updated contact details with members

Back to top