Data Access Panel: terms of reference
- Published
- 3 February 2026
- Directorate
- Digital Directorate
- Topic
- Public sector
Terms of reference for the Scottish Government and National Records of Scotland Data Access Panel.
Introduction
The Scottish Government (SG) and National Records of Scotland (NRS) Data Access Panel is a governance structure of the Scottish Government.
The Panel has a formal mandate to scrutinise the information governance (IG) relating to requests for access to:
- Scottish Government datasets
- published National Records of Scotland (NRS) Census data
- linkage to Scottish Government datasets and published NRS Census data
- research and other well-defined and bona fide purposes
The SG and NRS Data Access Panel has delegated authority to approve requests that fall within its remit – specifically, those involving data with potential for identifying individual or creating new linkages regardless of consent. This authority excludes requests involving published NRS Census data. For such cases, The Panel will provide recommendations to the Registrar General, who retains final decision-making authority.
This process does not replace any existing or future requirements for ethical review or approval.
The Panel’s focus on public awareness, concern and benefit demonstrates a commitment to the protection and promotion of privacy as a public good and in the public interest.
The Panel aims to:
- provide a single, consistent, open and transparent scrutiny process allowing Scottish Government data and published National Records of Scotland Census data to be used for a range of purposes including research and statistics,
- ensure balance is struck between safeguarding the privacy of all people in Scotland and the fiduciary duty of Scottish public bodies to make the best possible use of the data collected
- provide leadership across a range of complex privacy and information governance issues, so that the people of Scotland gain the benefits from research and wider use of data, while managing emerging information risks, addressing public concern around privacy, and promoting the protection of privacy as in the public interest
Panel Membership and Composition
The Panel membership is as follows:
- Tier 1 Panel:
- Panel Manager (permanent member)
- Information Governance practitioners from Scottish Government and National Records of Scotland
- Panel members from Scottish Government and National Records of Scotland
- Independent Practitioners
- Tier 2 Panel:
- Panel Chair (permanent member)
- Chief Statistician
- Register General or representative
- Independent members
Panel members must hold a dedicated Information Governance role and be suitably qualified to contribute to decision-making. They are expected to exercise impartial judgement, communicate decisions clearly, understand complex proposals, be familiar with relevant legislation, participate electronically, respond promptly to panel activities, and undertake any necessary training as determined by the Panel Chair.
Panel Meetings and Process
Tier 0 - Applications being reviewed by Analytical Division Heads
Applications requesting single Scottish Government datasets without linkage will be sent directly to the relevant Analytical Division Head. Analytical Division Head’s will assess the risk associated with the application using agreed risk criteria. If the agreed risk criteria score is over a threshold value, the application will be reviewed by Tier 1 of the SG & NRS Data Access Panel.
Tier 1 - Applications going through the process
Where an application requires SG & NRS Data Access Panel review, it will be circulated to at least three Tier 1 panel members for review by correspondence, as and when an application is received by the Panel Manager.
Panel members require two weeks to review the application, each conducting an independent assessment using agreed proportionate governance criteria, to agree an outcome for the application.
An application requesting published Census data, will be reviewed by the NRS Privacy Group and SG & NRS Data Access Panel in parallel.
Applications requesting access to published Census data will also be reviewed by the Register General or assigned deputy.
For an application requesting Education data, the Panel will also include at least one member from Education.
If no consensus is met, all panel members will meet to discuss the outcome of the application, or the application will be escalated to the Tier 2 panel.
Tier 2 - Applications not concluded at Tier 1
Where no consensus is met at Tier 1 review, or an application is flagged as containing a large volume of data, or highly sensitive data, a Tier 2 Review will be requested.
Documentation will be circulated to Tier 2 panel members, followed by a meeting to discuss outcomes.
All applications
For approved applications, the Panel Manager issues the agreed communication to either the applicant or the research coordinator.
Where the Panel decides not to approve an application, it may request timely clarification or additional information from the applicant, in any format it considers appropriate, to support further deliberation. This process is facilitated by the Panel Manager, with the aim of enabling panel members to reach a decision once the requested information is received.
The Panel will only seek clarification on an application which has a realistic chance of receiving approval upon receipt of the necessary clarification or additional information.
Where an application clearly has little or no chance of approval, such as when data requested is not consider suitable for the proposal, the Panel Manager or Panel Secretariat will advise the applicant of this on behalf of the Panel, with a recommendation to re-submit the application.
All application outcomes will be issued to applicants by the Panel Manager within an agreed timescale of the determination being reached.
The Panel Manager, on behalf of the Panel Chair, maintains a register of approved applications, which is made available on the Panel website.
Expected Performance (Applications)
For the purpose of monitoring performance, the Panel Manager logs the key events in the application process by date. Time elapsed whilst awaiting clarification or additional information from the applicant will not be included within the recorded turnaround time (see below) for the application (i.e. the ‘clock’ will be deemed ‘paused’ whilst the applicant is responding).
Applicants are informed of the Panel decisions to approve (with or without conditions) applications within an agreed timescale after the Panel’s decision. It is the normal expectation that such applications will be concluded within 30 working days of receipt of an administratively complete application. Where clarification is required, this will be longer.
The following documents can be made available upon request to the SG & NRS Data Access Panel team:
- risk matrix
- information governance assessment criteria
- process maps
Contact
Email: dataaccesspanel@scot.gov