Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill: Strategic Environmental Assessment
Strategic Environmental Assessment for the Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill 2026
Strategic Environmental Assessment
Responsible Authority:
Scottish Ministers (Scottish Government)
Title of the plan:
Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill
What prompted the plan:
The Bill is being prepared as primary legislation to implement Scottish Ministers’ decisions on targeted Council Tax reform. It responds to concerns about fairness and proportionality at the upper end of Council Tax, modernises the statutory treatment of people with significant cognitive impairment and gives local authorities a discretionary power to reduce Council Tax liability in locally determined circumstances.
Primary legislation is required to create Bands I and J using 2026 market values while Bands A to H remain based on 1991 values, and to make the related provision for transitional protection, significant cognitive impairment and local discretionary reductions.
Plan subject:
Local government finance; domestic property taxation; Council Tax valuation, administration and reductions.
Brief summary of the plan:
The Bill applies throughout Scotland. It would:
-
create Band I for dwellings worth more than £1 million and up to £2 million, and Band J for dwellings worth more than £2 million, using market conditions at 1 April 2026. Properties that remain in Bands A to H would continue to use 1 April 1991 values. The multipliers would be 2.886 for Band I and 4.628 for Band J;
-
provide for a targeted valuation exercise before implementation, automatic transitional protection for eligible sole or main residences moving from Bands A to H into Band I or J, and a power to exclude specified descriptions of dwelling from the new bands where necessary to avoid unintended treatment;
-
replace the term “severe mental impairment” with “significant cognitive impairment”, modernise the definition and enable entitlement to a relevant Council Tax discount or exemption to be determined by reference to the certified period even where another prescribed condition is fulfilled later during that period; and
-
give each local authority a permissive power to reduce Council Tax liability, including to nil, for locally determined persons, dwellings or circumstances. The Bill does not impose new statutory consultation, publication or review requirements; existing legal, financial and governance duties would continue to apply.
Current modelling estimates around 12,940 Band I dwellings and 660 Band J dwellings, about 13,600 in total and fewer than 1% of Scotland’s domestic stock. The final number and distribution will depend on the targeted valuation exercise. The principal provisions are intended to take effect from 1 April 2028.
Brief summary of the likely environmental consequences:
Conclusion. The Scottish Ministers have applied the criteria in Schedule 2 of the Environmental Assessment (Scotland) Act 2005 and consider that the Bill is likely to have no or minimal environmental effects, whether directly or indirectly. Pre-screening under section 7 of that Act is therefore appropriate.
Section 5 route. The proposal is not within section 5(3): it is not prepared for one of the listed sectors in a way that sets the framework for future development consent, and it does not require an appropriate assessment under habitats legislation. It is therefore considered, for SEA purposes, under section 5(4).
Characteristics of the proposal
-
The Bill establishes rules for Council Tax valuation, liability, transition and reductions. It does not authorise development, allocate land or resources, direct construction, demolition or property improvements, or set the location, nature, size or operating conditions of projects requiring development consent.
-
Its influence on other plans and programmes is limited to Council Tax implementation. Additional receipts are retained locally but are not earmarked by the Bill, which does not direct local authority spending or future projects. Any later spending, development or physical works remain subject to their own assessment and consent requirements.
-
The Bill is relevant to social and fiscal aspects of sustainable development, but it does not constrain the integration of environmental considerations into other decisions. It neither creates an environmental problem nor implements environmental legislation. A local discretionary reduction may respond to circumstances such as flooding, fire, subsidence or another crisis, but provides financial relief only and does not authorise remedial works.
Characteristics of the effects and of the area likely to be affected
-
No direct effects have been identified for biodiversity, flora or fauna, population or human health in the SEA sense, soil, water, air, climatic factors, material assets, cultural heritage, landscape or the relationships between those topics.
-
Changes in household property choices, property values or local authority receipts are conceivable indirect consequences of taxation, but any environmental consequence would be remote, uncertain and dependent on separate decisions. The targeted bands affect a very small share of dwellings, and the Bill creates no incentive or requirement for a particular physical or land-use response.
-
Although the legal framework applies throughout Scotland, it is not spatially targeted and does not alter the protection or management of any designated site, sensitive landscape or area of environmental value. No cumulative, transboundary or material risks to human health or the environment have been identified.
-
The conclusion does not depend on mitigation. It follows from the fiscal and administrative character of the Bill and the absence of a credible pathway to significant environmental effects. The SEA position should be revisited if the Bill’s scope changes materially, or if later regulations or schemes introduce provisions with a distinct environmental pathway.
Brief summary of how environmental principles have been considered:
The five guiding principles in section 13 of the UK Withdrawal from the European Union (Continuity) (Scotland) Act 2021 have been considered. The proposal principally concerns local taxation and finance. Without relying on whether the finance or budget exclusion in section 14(3)(b) applies, the assessment records the following consideration:
-
Integration. Environmental consequences were considered alongside fiscal fairness, equality, local government and sustainable-development impacts. The Bill does not prevent environmental factors being integrated into later decisions.
-
Precautionary principle. Plausible direct and indirect pathways were considered despite uncertainty about behavioural and revenue effects. None provides a credible risk of serious or irreversible environmental damage. A material change in scope would trigger reconsideration.
-
Preventative action and rectification at source. The Bill does not cause or authorise pollution or environmental damage, so no specific preventative or source-control measure is required. Existing planning, building and environmental controls continue to apply to any physical activity.
-
Polluter pays. The principle is not engaged because the Bill neither authorises pollution nor allocates the cost of environmental damage to public authorities or others.
Contact details:
James Messis, Policy Team/Bill Leader Local Government Division Local Government and Housing Directorate Scottish Government
Date of opinion:
28 October 2026
When completed send to: SEA.gateway@gov.scot or to SEA Gateway, Scottish Government, Area 2F (South), Victoria Quay, Edinburgh, EH6 6QQ
Contact
Email: LocalTax@gov.scot