Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill: Child Rights and Wellbeing Impact Assessment
Child Rights and Wellbeing Impact Assessment for the Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill 2026
Child Rights and Wellbeing Impact Assessment
1. Brief Summary
Council Tax in Scotland is a local tax on domestic properties set by the 32 local authorities to help fund public services like rubbish collection, road maintenance and street lighting. All households pay council tax unless exempt.
All domestic properties are placed into one of eight valuation bands (A to H) based on what it was estimated to be worth on 1 April 1991. Local authorities set a specific rate for a Band D property each year, and the other bands are charged as a fixed proportion of that amount.
Individual local authorities are responsible for:
- setting council tax rates in their area
- collecting council tax
- applying any discounts
- deciding how to spend the money raised in their area.
The Scottish Government is responsible for making decisions about the overall Council Tax system, including Council Tax discounts. A discount, reduction or an exemption may apply to those who are:
- care Leavers
- students
- disabled (Disabled Persons Reduction)
- have low income (Council Tax Reduction Scheme)
- live alone (Single Person-Discount)
Type of proposal
Bill
Name the proposal and describe its overall aims and intended purpose.
Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill
The Council Tax Bill is planned for introduction in mid-November 2026. The Bill consists of three parts.
Two Additional Valuation Bands
Band I will apply to dwellings with an open market capital value of more than £1 million but no more than £2 million at 1 April 2026. Band J will apply to dwellings worth more than £2 million at that date.
Existing discounts and exemptions will continue to apply. The Bill provides automatic transitional protection for eligible sole or main residences moving from Bands A to H into Band I or J. This will limit annual increases while the dwelling moves towards its full Band I or J liability.
Separate amendments to the Council Tax Reduction scheme are intended to be made by regulations. These are intended to provide additional support to lower- to middle-income households moving into Bands I or J.
Significant Cognitive Impairment provisions
The Bill makes two targeted changes to the existing Council Tax provisions relating to people currently described as severely mentally impaired. It replaces that terminology with “significant cognitive impairment” and modernises the statutory definition.
The Bill also provides that, where a person has been medically certified as having significant cognitive impairment, entitlement to the relevant Council Tax disregard or exemption may be determined by reference to the period covered by the medical certificate, even where the other qualifying conditions are fulfilled later during that period. This is intended to prevent households losing out on support solely because confirmation of qualifying benefit entitlement occurs after medical certification.
The underlying eligibility conditions, including the requirements for medical certification and satisfaction of the prescribed qualifying conditions, otherwise remain unchanged.
Local Discretionary Reductions
The Bill gives each local authority a discretionary power to reduce Council Tax liability, including reducing it to nil, through locally determined arrangements. This is intended to allow authorities to respond to local circumstances, such as flooding, fire, subsidence or a household crisis, where existing national discounts, exemptions and reductions do not provide an appropriate outcome.
A local authority may determine the circumstances, persons or dwellings covered and the amount and duration of support. In doing so, it must have regard to its income and expenditure and to the interests of people liable to pay Council Tax.
Start date of proposal’s development: 01.04.26
Start date of CRWIA process: 01.08.26
2. With reference given to the requirements of the UNCRC (Incorporation) (Scotland) Act 2024 which aspects of the proposal are relevant to/impact upon children’s rights?
None. Council Tax aims to provide fairness to all taxpayers.
The Bill will only affect those with a Council Tax liability. Children, and anyone under the age of 18 years old, does not fall within the definition of resident and is therefore not liable for Council Tax.
The Bill is accordingly unlikely to relate to children and young people’s rights directly, in any capacity as taxpayers. There is also no requirement that revenue generated through council tax be spent on services that directly benefit children. Any effects on children’s rights are therefore indirect and arise because children share the income and living circumstances of their household.
Furthermore, the existing Council Tax Reduction (CTR) Scheme seeks to mitigate against individuals having to meet a council tax liability they cannot be expected to afford. The CTR Scheme is a targeted measure and reduces a household’s council tax liability based on an assessment of their income, capital, and other circumstances. Therefore, eligible households will be protected through introduction of an income threshold in CTR for those moving into either of the new bands.
There is limited data on the number and circumstances of children who how may be indirectly impacted by the Bill. Certain elements of the Bill may have an indirect negative, neutral or positive impact on some children whose households have a Council Tax liability as explained below. Though, overall, the impact is considered to be Neutral.
Two Additional Valuation Bands
The introduction of Council Tax Bands I and J may have an indirect negative/neutral impact on children living in a household which are placed in one of those bands. This is relevant principally to Article 27; the Scottish Government recognises the right of every child to a standard of living adequate for their development.
The new bands are expected to affect fewer than 1% of domestic properties in Scotland. Property value may provide some indication of household resources, but it is not a direct measure of disposable income or ability to meet a higher recurring liability. Some affected households may therefore have lower or irregular incomes despite occupying a high-value dwelling.
Automatic transitional protection will limit annual increases for eligible sole or main residences moving from Bands A to H into Band I or J. Existing discounts and exemptions will continue to apply, and separate changes to Council Tax Reduction are intended to provide additional support to lower- to middle-income households. These safeguards are expected to reduce the risk of financial hardship, although an indirect negative effect cannot be ruled out in every individual case.
Both these measures are intended to reduce the risk that an increase in Council Tax would cause financial hardship and will look to ensure that children living within an impacted household continue to have an adequate standard of living in compliance with article 27.
Significant cognitive impairment provisions
Children living in a household with a parent or guardian who has been medically certified as having significant cognitive impairment (SCI) may be indirectly positively affected where backdating a Council Tax discount or exemption protects household income. The discount may reach back to the date of medical certification where entitlement to the associated qualifying benefit is confirmed at a later date. This approach will help ensure that a household is not delayed in seeing the benefit of Council Tax Discount solely because confirmation of benefit entitlement occurred after medical certification. Similarly, it will help ensure that a household is not delayed in receiving the benefit of an exemption, where relevant.
The change in terminology is expected to have no negative impact on children’s rights and may have a small positive indirect effect by improving dignity, clarity and understanding. The underlying eligibility conditions otherwise remain unchanged.
Local discretionary Council Tax reductions
The Bill will give local authorities a discretionary power to reduce or remove Council Tax liability for a dwelling, a class of dwellings or a person in defined local circumstances. This could include circumstances arising from flooding, fire, subsidence or another household or local crisis.
The power could have an indirect positive/neutral effect on children by protecting household income and housing stability at a time of crisis. It is therefore relevant to Article 27, concerning an adequate standard of living.
The discretion may also lead to different forms or levels of support being available in different local authority areas.
Overall Groups Affected:
The children most likely to be indirectly impacted by the Bill are:
- children living in a property placed in Band I or Band J, particularly where household income is low or irregular;
- children in households with limited financial flexibility, including some lone-parent, larger and kinship-care families;
- children living with a person who has a significant cognitive impairment;
- children whose household is affected by flooding, fire, subsidence or another crisis;
- children in different local authority areas who may experience differences in the availability or design of discretionary support.
While the Article most clearly engaged indirectly is 27, overall, we consider that the majority of the UNCRC articles are not expected to be engaged by the Bill.
For each of the proposals the likely effects are considered to be as follows –
- Two Additional Value bands – negative/neutral
- Significant cognitive impairment provisions – positive/neutral
- Local Discretionary Council Tax reductions – positive/neutral
3. Please provide a summary of the evidence gathered which will be used to inform your decision-making and the content of the proposal
Existing research/reports/policy expertise
The Scottish Government continues to take steps to ensure the protection of children’s rights, including the right to an adequate standard of living that meets their needs (article 27).
Two Additional Valuation Bands
This measure is estimated to affect fewer than 1% of properties in Scotland. However, no evidence is held on the number of affected households that will have children living in them.
The Council Tax Reduction (CTR) scheme is in place to help low-income families meet their Council Tax liability. Around 460,000 households in Scotland are in receipt of CTR (around a fifth of all chargeable dwellings). The table below shows that 101,310 CTR recipients with a recorded Council Tax band from A to H had one or more child dependants in March 2026. Of these, just over 22,800 households have at least three or more children in residence (5% of all CTR recipients).
|
Council Tax Band |
Child Dependents |
No Child Dependents |
Total |
|---|---|---|---|
|
A |
28,110 |
153,110 |
181,230 |
|
B |
32,230 |
110,100 |
142,320 |
|
C |
20,670 |
53,690 |
74,370 |
|
D |
11,990 |
21,410 |
33,390 |
|
E |
5,840 |
10,480 |
16,310 |
|
F |
1,790 |
3,230 |
5,010 |
|
G |
660 |
1,270 |
1,930 |
|
H |
20 |
60 |
80 |
|
Total |
101,310 |
353,350 |
454,640 |
Significant cognitive impairment provisions
Local-authority statistical returns indicate that more than 26,000 households currently fall within the existing severe-mental-impairment provisions. This is not an estimate of the number that will benefit from the Bill’s timing change. The returns do not identify how many of those households include children, how many experienced a delay between medical certification and satisfaction of the qualifying conditions, or the value of any resulting credit or refund.
Consultation and feedback from stakeholders
A public consultation on the proposed high-value property bands ran from 6 July to 24 August 2026. It asked about the thresholds and multipliers. The consultation paper is available at https://www.gov.scot/publications/consultation-council-tax-high-value-property-bands-mansion-tax/.That focused consultation on the proposed high-value property bands received 1,231 responses. The principal issue relevant to this assessment was affordability. Respondents emphasised that property value does not necessarily reflect income, liquidity or ability to meet a higher recurring liability. Concerns included the position of larger families and households with substantial mortgages, as well as long-standing occupiers whose property had increased substantially in value.
The consultation analysis did not identify a distinct theme concerning effects on children or children’s rights, although the affordability concerns raised are relevant to households containing children. The consultation was self-selecting and does not establish how prevalent those circumstances are among households expected to enter Bands I or J.
The wider Future of Council Tax consultation provides additional context. It recorded strong support for transitional protection and majority support for expanding Council Tax Reduction, alongside recurring concerns about the relationship between property value and ability to pay. These findings informed the safeguards being taken forward with the new bands.
Consultation/feedback directly from children and young people
No direct, Bill-specific consultation with children and young people has been identified in the material available for this draft. Existing child-poverty engagement is relevant contextual evidence, but it is not a substitute for asking children about this proposal.
For the 2026–31 child poverty delivery plan, the Scottish Government reports engagement events involving more than 180 children and young people and a Young Scot survey with 184 responses. Children described how family finances can affect mental health, stigma, inclusion, participation in activities, education, and future choices.[1] That evidence supports careful assessment of any reduction in disposable household income.
To mitigate against any potential impacts, the policy includes transitional arrangements which limit year-on-year increases in Council Tax liability and provide households with additional time to adjust to any higher charges, together with application of the Council Tax Reduction scheme to those in Bands I and J with income below a threshold at which they would be expected to meet the increased Further to the evidence described at ‘3’ have you identified any 'gaps' in evidence which may prevent determination of impact? If yes, please provide an explanation of how they will be addressed
The Scottish Government does not hold figures showing how many children live in dwellings expected to enter Bands I or J, or the income, tenure, disability status or family type of those households. The available statistical returns on the existing severe-mental-impairment provisions do not identify how many affected households include children or how many may benefit from the Bill’s timing change.
The effect of the local discretionary power also cannot be quantified in advance. Each local authority will decide whether to exercise the power and determine the circumstances, amount and duration of any support. This does not prevent identification of a possible positive effect for supported households or the possibility of differences between local-authority areas.
The assessment will be reviewed if material new evidence becomes available.
Should new relevant information come to light, it will be assessed for any potential impact on children and young people and acted on accordingly.,
The policy includes transitional arrangements which limit year-on-year increases in Council Tax liability and provide households with additional time to adjust to any higher charges, together with application of the Council Tax Reduction scheme to those in Bands I and J with income below a threshold at which they would be expected to meet the increased liability. Monitoring will consider the operation of transitional protection, accompanying Council Tax Reduction support.
4. Analysis of Evidence
The Scottish Government continues to take steps to ensure the protection of children’s rights, including the right to an adequate standard of living (article 27) that meets their physical and social needs.
It is difficult to quantify the impact this Bill will have as we do not hold data on the number of households with children that may be indirectly affected.
The two additional valuation bands will affect fewer than 1% of properties. Most children will therefore experience no household-level change. For a child living in an affected property, a higher Council Tax bill may impact household finances. Property value may indicate an ability to pay, but it is not the same as disposable income. This is a potential indirect negative impact on Article 27, particularly for a household with low or irregular income.
The continuation of existing discounts, exemptions, and the Council Tax Reduction scheme, provide mitigation against adverse impact. Most significantly, the proposed transitional protection and extension of Council Tax Reduction for lower-income households in Bands I and J, is intended to reduce the risk of financial hardship. The residual impact of the new bands is expected to be neutral for affected children and neutral for children in households that are not affected.
The significant cognitive impairment provisions are expected to have a positive or neutral indirect impact. Updated terminology improves dignity and clarity, while backdating a disregard or exemption can prevent a household being delayed in receiving support solely because confirmation of qualifying benefit entitlement occurs after medical certification.
The local discretionary power may have a positive or neutral indirect impact by enabling a local authority to reduce liability where local circumstances justify support, thereby protecting household income or housing stability. The extent of any impact will depend on whether an authority exercises the power and the design of its arrangements. Different support may be available in different areas. That variation is inherent in a locally discretionary power.
5. What changes (if any) have been made to the proposal as a result of this assessment?
No substantive change has been made solely as a result of this assessment. The assessment has, however, reaffirmed the importance of safeguards already included in, or being developed alongside, the proposal: retaining existing discounts and exemptions; introducing transitional protection; extending Council Tax Reduction support for lower-income households in Bands I and J; potentially excluding certain classes of property from Band I and J; backdating the significant cognitive impairment disregard or exemption.
6. As a result of the evidence gathered and analysed against all UNCRC requirements, what is the potential overall impact of this proposal on children’s rights?
The Bill is expected to have limited and mainly indirect effects on children. The high-value bands may have an indirect negative or neutral effect through their impact on household disposable income. However, mitigations schemes in the form of transitional relief and a Council Tax Reduction change have been agreed.
The significant-cognitive-impairment provisions and local discretionary power may have positive or neutral indirect effects by protecting household income in particular circumstances.
Taking account of the limited number of dwellings affected and the available safeguards, the overall effect on children’s rights is assessed as neutral.
No incompatibility with the UNCRC requirements has been identified.
7. If you have identified a positive impact on children’s rights, please describe below how the proposal will protect, respect, and fulfil children’s rights in Scotland.
The significant-cognitive-impairment provisions may protect household income by allowing entitlement to be determined from the period covered by medical certification once the other qualifying conditions are met. The updated terminology may also improve dignity and clarity.
The local discretionary power may allow an authority to protect household income or housing stability where existing national provisions do not provide an appropriate response.
8. If a negative impact has been identified, please describe it below. Is there a risk this could potentially amount to an incompatibility?
The available evidence does not indicate that this would result in incompatibility with the UNCRC requirements.
Mitigation consists of automatic transitional protection, the continued application of existing discounts and exemptions, and the intended accompanying changes to Council Tax Reduction for lower- to middle-income households. The effect of these safeguards should be considered as part of post-implementation monitoring.
Mitigation Record
Not applicable
Issue or risk identified and relevant UNCRC requirement
Not applicable
Action Taken/ To Be Taken
Not applicable
9. As a result of the evidence gathered and analysed against all wellbeing indicators will the proposal contribute to the wellbeing of children and young people in Scotland?
Safe: No
Healthy: No
Achieving: No
Nurtured: No
Active: No
Respected: No
Responsible: No
Included: No
10. How will you communicate to children and young people the impact that the proposal will have on their rights
This impact assessment will be published by the Scottish Government on its website. The impact assessment as far as is possible has been written in accessible language so those reading it can understand its content and neutral impact.
The Scottish Parliament will undertake scrutiny of the Bill proposals, including a call for evidence at stage 1 before the Parliament.
11. Planning for the review of impact on children’s rights and wellbeing
The Bill team will continue to monitor the impact of the proposals during the Bill development process and as Parliament scrutinises any Bill.
Monitoring will include, where data is available and its use is lawful and proportionate, the number and location of Band I and J properties; use of transitional protection and Council Tax Reduction; applications, awards, local discretionary schemes; arrears, complaints, appeals and advice-sector evidence.
Although it is not anticipated, if new information comes to light this will be assessed for potential impact on children and young people.
12. Sign off
Policy Lead Signature & Date of Sign Off: James Messis
Deputy Director Signature & Date of Sign Off: Catriona MacKean 14.10.26
Date CRWIA team first contacted: 28.09.26
Contact
Email: LocalTax@gov.scot